A Lesson in Freezing

by Michael Hudson

Rating: mature
Tags: Sex, Twilight Sparkle, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Dark, Alternate Universe, Sad, Starlight Glimmer
Length: 2515

I watched my life be torn away. She wanted to see me break, but now that I have her, I will break her. I don't care what it does to me, Starlight Glimmer will know my pain.

I don't care if it hurts, or I take no pleasure from the act. All that matters to me now, before I may move on, is that Starlight Glimmer know some of my pain.

-Twilight Sparkle

Thank you to Mondai Shunketsu for prereading.

Published 2015-11-29 21:10:01 UTC
Last updated 2015-11-29 21:10:01 UTC

Stopping Starlight

Twilight bit into her cheek as she stood on the map, taking a moment before she ran back to Starlight. The other mare would be waiting for her, and would probably even try to freeze her again. She was fairly certain that she could shoot off a spell before Starlight when she came out, but the right one would need to be used if she didn’t want to betray Zecora, and set things right. Countless pages of spellbooks zoomed through her mind, before a fairly new favorite of hers came to mind.

Spike notice the sick grin on her face, and smiled himself. “Do you have an idea?”

She nodded, picking up the scroll, and setting up the magic she needed for the second spell while she activated the scroll’s magic. It was a good thing that she by no means had to activate it, but that the magic Starlight had left in it triggered the activation. Otherwise, she would have had needed a lot more time to learn its intricacies, and after two uses like this, she doubt she would have been able to continue to stand.

The portal above her ripped open, and she smiled, releasing the spell only a moment after slipping in.

======+++++======

Starlight slammed into the cloud as she came out of the portal, resting her hooves on the fluff as she spotted Twilight’s portal in the sky. She doubted that another crystallization spell would be all she would need for this time, but she was intrigued as to what Twilight’s response was. She could try slinking away with the few seconds she had, but doubted she could really do much. Besides, seeing Twilight all flustered was nice,

It wasn’t Twilight she first saw exit the portal though. Instead, a field of magic exploded from within, and caught her before she could throw up her barriers. Immediately, she felt her body stop. She couldn’t move, she couldn’t act, she couldn’t even get her magic to go. The only part of her that did work was her mouth and insides, which was a blessing in and of itself.

Her eyes next fell upon her captor as Twilight flew down from the portal, her horn glowing as she glared down Starlight. Starlight swallowed hard, and tried focusing her magic so as to break out, but it was of no use. A bit more focus on her horn brought a splitting headache to her skull, and stopped her channeling. “Wh-what are you doing? What is this?”

Twilight put a hoof to Starlight’s chin. “Well, you see, when you’re the student to the most powerful alicorn in the world, and one of the greatest leaders of all time, you learn some good tricks. This one here is meant for crowd control, but works just fine to stop one pony, as it limits all function except for the most vital. Good if you need to escape even.”

Starlight tried to strain against the bonds, while doing anything to look away from those piercing, purple pupils. They had no kindness, no innocence, and no mercy. Her body chilled, and tears brimmed to the edges of her eyes. “No! This wasn’t how it was supposed to be!”

Twilight raised a hoof, and didn’t even blink as it drew across Starlight’s face, a loud smack echoing into the air. Starlight herself had felt the spell loosen for a moment, but only to allow her to feel the full impact that now cause tears to come to her eyes. She swivelled her eyes back to Twilight, before clearing her throat. “Don’t you want to at least give me a fair chance? This seems like a very boring way-” She was stopped as she was forced to not even move as Twilight’s rear hooves crashed into the side of Starlight’s jaw. She could hear her molars splinter, before blood filled her mouth. She coughed blood onto the cloud as Twilight towered over her.

“You attempted to destroy my world twice. No matter what you had hoped to do, you should have known there would be drastic consequences. Consequences I can’t allow, and that you will pay for them. We merely must wait another few minutes first.” Twilight sat beside Starlight, her horn flaring even brighter as her magic intensified, almost trying to crush the limbs of her adversary. She would not do that though, not yet at least.

The two watched as the foals set themselves to the track, and soon were taking off. Twilight hummed to herself as Rainbow made her turns, having already figured out just what she wanted to do to her little slave, and so was focusing on if she could see any holes in Rainbow’s story from when she first heard it. Starlight meanwhile,kept having her head turned to watch the race, whimpering from not only the pain in her mouth, but also the sight of her dreams being crushed. She was supposed to have won here, with Twilight breaking from seeing her future being torn away right in front of her, not the other way around.

The Rainboom went off without a hitch, and soon the portal was back open, and the three of them were sucked in.

======+++++======

Twilight and Spike set down on the map, before Starlight simply appeared in the air, still floating there. The princess hadn’t been able to deny the magic’s pull, even if she had wanted to, and with a quick check on her captive turned to around her. There they saw the familiar blues and purples of the castle that she called, and Twilight was able to let out a sigh of relief. Spike himself ran off the map, and kissed the ground, before turning around to look at Twilight, who still did not share in his joy. “Twilight, we’re home!”

She nodded, before moving Starlight to the ground, where she didn’t have to keep the statue levitated. “I know, but I can’t share in your happiness until I know this can’t happen again. That’s why I need you to send a letter to Celestia requesting that she send enforcers immediately with the highest levels of magic nullification braces, horn locks, and chains that they can.” She looked to Starlight. “That way, once she is let go, she will never know the touch of magic again. Not for a very, very long time.”

Spike nodded solemnly, tapping his claws against one another. While he too had been horrified by the futures he had seen, how Twilight was now possibly scared him more. Still, he knew she was right to make sure she couldn’t hurt them again, and this went for his quill and ink.

“And once you’re done, go to your room. I want to be alone with Starlight.”

Spike stopped, standing there with quill in hand. “A-are you sure?”

“Spike, don’t question me on this.”

“I just want to make sure there is something for the enforcers to collect.” He shrank back as Twilight turned her gaze to him, fury undying within her eyes.

“Death is too simple a punishment for her. A lifetime without the magic that she and I hold so dear is all I wish for her. What I do here though is so that I may personally vent my frustration. However,” she took in a deep breath and put a shaking hoof to her eye, “I will Pinkie promise to do no more permanent damage. Okay, Spike?”

Spike gripped the paper, before shutting his eyes and imagining Rarity being forced to make drab army outfits, or being consumed by changelings, and nodded, furiously penning the letter to explain to Celestia what occurred. One fire breath later, and he stomped over to Starlight. He looked up into her scared eyes, ready to spit venom. Looking into the eyes that pleaded with him, and the few tears that had already escaped them, he hesitated, before deciding to say nothing. Twilight would be able to punish her, and do the right thing. She had to as a princess.

Twilight waved farewell to Spike, before leaving the room for a few minutes herself. Starlight was left alone now, still stuck, waiting for Twilight to come back. Waiting for her torture to begin. Something inside of her just knew that despite promising no permanent damage would be done, Twilight would still do all she could to make Starlight suffer.

Soon, the alicorn was back, humming to herself as she stayed out of Starlight’s sight. “Sorry that I needed to step out. I knew I could keep the spell up, but had to add the precaution of putting your spell somewhere safe, just in case something went wrong.”

Starlight would have nodded if able, but her head stayed firmly in place. “Wh-what are you going to do to me?” She jumped a bit as she felt Twilight’s face nuzzle into her rump, and the mare’s hot breath caught against her slit, sending chills of dread down her spine.

Twilight swallowed hard, trying to stop the tears that ran down her face as her own body shook. “You got me to watch them lose their lives. Everypony I had ever known, just as you had wanted. I had nothing, all because you had ripped it from me. I wish to do the same to you now, even if it’s just in this small way.”

Starlight tried to shake her head, to move, to do something, but all of it was futile against her captor. She felt hooves press down on her back, and soon had most of Twilight’s weight pressing down upon her. Her legs could not even buckle for relief, but instead simply screamed in pain. “Please Twilight. You’re already going to ruin my life, so we’ll be even. don’t add to the cycle of revenge, right? That’s one of those stu-,” she stopped for a moment, trying not to antagonize the princess any further, “friendship lessons you speak of, so you need to follow it.”

A warm, flared tip pressed against Starlight’s slit, causing her eyes to widen. Twilight’s secret had been revealed, not that the unicorn cared at the moment. She instead leaned down, slowly moving her hips. The throbbing mass moved ever so slightly, teasing the dry, pink folds. Her breath now caught against Starlight’s ear, before she whispered, “the problem with that is that I know you’re not going anywhere, and am doomed already.” Her horn flared one more time, and she broke her promise to Spike as Starlight’s horn cracked, and only a silence spell stopped the pink mare’s scream from disturbing all of Ponyville.

Twilight leaned in further, her cock now pressed against both Starlight’s slit, and her clenched rear. She licked away one of the tears that ran from the other mare’s purple eyes. Satisfied, she let the spell go, almost collapsing with Starlight, but instead merely forcing her to the ground, her hooves still pressed into her victim’s shoulders.

Starlight didn’t bother fighting. She didn’t even try using her horn, knowing that the best outcome would be to blow both of them up. With the crack in the bone, it was almost useless, and would need serious medical attention before it was useful to any degree. Attention she would not receive from the other mare, who’s flared cock still pressed against her lower lips. “Please Twilight, isn’t this enough?”

Twilight stopped for only a moment to move her hips back. With a simple, “No,” uttered, she slammed forward, forcing her quivering growth deep into Starlight. While the folds were warm, they were anything but wet, so sliding wasn’t an option. Instead, slowly, steady pushes were what Twilight began to do, forcing herself in.

Of course, while her body enjoyed it to some degree, Twilight felt strangely empty. She knew that this way, pounding into the antagonist’s folds, was the best way to hurt her, it didn’t give her the pleasure she had expected. It was simply cold to her, even as her medial ring shoved itself in, and Starlight let out another silenced cry, her flanks shaking as they tried to get away from the mass that tried to rip her in two. The outcry helped Twilight’s mood a little bit, but she knew she would take no real pleasure in this, and was fine with it. She did not do this for her happiness.

Starlight shut her eyes as a hard hoof came against her ass, just before another short, forced thrust by Twilight. Her whole body hurt at this point, crying out for it all to stop. Her mind tried to curse out the mare that dominated her, but it could only return to her failure. She had known that what she did could leave her open to retaliation, but she had wanted to see Twilight break. See her pain, The cock that was almost to its base in her pussy was simply the punishment she was to have for being greedy.

And so the pounding continued. Neither mare felt much during it. Some base pleasure entered Twilight as she kept going, slamming hard against her prisoner’s slit every few moments. It was with a base rhythm though, and she couldn’t muster the energy to go faster, or do more. She knew it hurt Starlight, and that was all that mattered. Starlight herself only felt the numbing pain from each thrust while her face was shoved into the the hard crystal. Her future was so completely destroyed that she simply was ready to accept this with quiet moans and whimpers, her spirit trying to curl up and be ready for cold irons.

When her climax came, Twilight felt a tear fall down her face. She thrusted forward one last time, with barely any more pressure or ceremony than the rest, and let it go, It rushed from her in a weak burst, splattering her sperm onto the bruised folds of her adversary, and were left there as Twilight stepped away. She watched as Starlight fell, whimpering and murmuring to herself. It was almost pitiful now, to see such a powerful unicorn reduced to so little. Am I much better, so shaken simply because I tried punishing her in the worst way possible? She was going to end Equestria if I hadn’t put an end to her, but… She looked one more time at the small bits of white she could see, before sitting down on a couch. She would have sobbed, but that would have given Starlight a chance to escape, and no amount of pity or shame would allow her to let that happen.

And there the two laid, knowing that they would never forget this day in a hundred years. Shortly after Starlight was taken away, with the enforcers asking nothing about her ravaged state, Twilight went back to the spell, and burned it. She wanted no more reminders of this mess, but never wanted the temptation to go back and change her actions. She had done them for a reason, and would live with the consequences, just as Starlight now had to.