Choices

by Michael Hudson

Rating: mature
Tags: Random, Sex, Sunset Shimmer, Drama, Equestria Girls
Length: 8281

X, O, V, or Y. Which will the current player choose, and what will happen because of it?

X, O, V, or Y. Which will the current player choose, and what will happen because of it?

A story about taking choose your own adventure to a ludicrous level, one is the story teller, usually myself, while another the player. Their decisions dictate what happens as the tales progress in this anthoology about choices.

Sunset: Her choices caused so much trouble, so much pain, and have left her isolated in the school that she calls home. Even after the sirens, she doesn't know what will happen, or what to do. There are too many options, so, a helpful... blessing gives her only up to four. Now if only it would stop being a total pervert. (Storyteller: Jumbled Thought. Decision Maker: Foals Errand. Please go support her here!)

Art done by Marenlicious.

All characters are 18+

Published 2016-07-04 20:50:01 UTC
Last updated 2016-08-17 17:43:38 UTC

Sunset Pt. 1

Sunset Shimmer awakens in her bed with a shuddering breath. The night was.. Rough, though that isn’t too strange for her at this point. An old gymnasium storage room that nobody had come into in Celestia only knows didn’t really keep out the noises of the storms, or the chill of an oncoming fall.

No, what left her chilled was the dream. It wasn’t new either, just her imagining everything going right at Canterlot High. People loved her, instead of feared her, she had been forgiven for her actions, and she was popular. At least, right up until the fake world broke, and became a nightmare. What stuck in her mind was the last part though.

“What if you gave up control? You still make the decisions, but they’re fewer, and less complex. Wouldn’t that be nice?”

And she had said yes. She knew it was silly to wish something like that, but maybe if she didn’t make the choices, they could actually be right for once.

As of the moment though, groggy, bleary eyes, and still doubtful, she found herself looking at a message in front of her.

X: Stay naked

O: Get Dressed

Sunset scoffed as she thought about how stupid it would be to not get dressed, and thought she saw the other option, O, glow for a moment, and disappear. Of course, it had to be her imagination. Or, didn’t matter, as her alarm clock blared again, reminding her that she needed to get ready for school.

She pushed back the thin blanket and stretched, before pulling her clothes on. She’d been able to find enough change to use the washer and dryer at the local laundromat so at least they smelled nice. “Maybe I should try to be nice to someone today. Couldn’t hurt to try.”

As she grabbed her shirt, her modest breasts shaking slightly in her black bra, another screen appeared before her eyes. This one was almost just as bad as the last one, though it did have a little more text… text she may have put there herself.

X:Put the shirt on: You need to still be decent, even if everyone knows your cutie mark usually means a pounding.

O:Leave the shirt. Bikini tops are technically allowed at school, and guys would at least be more willing to spend time with me than, even if they’re just hoping for a nipple slip.

Sunset rolled her eyes, thinking about how her and her… friends, would look if they all took the bikini look, before blushing at the thought of her ex finding her in just her bra. The thought wasn’t all bad though, and before she knew it, she found herself folding her shirt back up, and putting it into the closet, letting the black bra still be all that covered her top half. She didn’t even really think about it being wrong, though a small part in the back of her mind did wonder why.

She shook her head and grabbed her backpack, glancing at the time. “Fluttershy would probably be by the statue… maybe I could help her pass out those flyers she always had.”

X:Go help Fluttershy. I might be hungry later, but it’ll help me get in closer with her, while doing something good.

O:Go steal some food from the cafeteria. It sucks that I have to, but a girl does need to eat.

V:Go out and help Fluttershy with the flyers, but in a more… special way. It’s not like I’m dressed wrong to make sure people pay particular attention to what I care about.

Sunset shakes the thoughts of her head, blushing brightly as she thinks for another moment of unclasping her bra. She couldn’t dare do that, but she does want to help Fluttershy, and smiles as the X option glows for a moment, and fades away.

She pulled her backpack on and poked her head out, making sure there was no one around before heading over to the statue. The yellow skinned teenager was already there, her arms full of flyers for the animal shelter. Sunset took a steadying breath, before smiling. “Morning Fluttershy.”

“Morning Sunse-” Fluttershy seemed to stop midsentence, her eyes almost popping out of her skull as she stared at Sunset. The shy girl usually wished she could survive the heat of a burqa, so the idea of just showing off her breasts like Sunset practically was made her face turn bright red. “Wh-why are y-you d-dre-dre…” She squeaked, hiding her face in the flyers as she can’t keep staring at the exposed flesh.

“I uh, i’m not really sure… just seemed like a good idea to wear this today. I was hoping I’d be able to help you hand out flyers today?” Sunset smiled, hopeful Fluttershy wouldn’t run.

Fluttershy looked down, her foot dragging at the ground as she thought. “I… don’t know.”

X:Tell her off. I can wear whatever you want, and she shouldn’t be trying to shame me because I decided to show a little skin. Hell, I’m not even the one of the two of us usually asked to show some skin!

O:Sympathize. I am in a bit of an odd outfit, especially for a sheltered girl like Flutters. There’s no real reason to be a bitch about this anyways.

V: Challenge: All it is is a little skin, and Fluttershy is constantly being afraid of doing anything. Maybe if I can get her to take that stupid sweater of hers off, she might start having some confidence.

Y: Run. There’s no reason I need to stay here, and be reminded of how much the other girls still distrust me.

Sunset bites her lip, and shakes her head as she places a hand on Fluttershy’s shoulder. “Hey, look, I’m just trying something out today. I’m not gonna make any progress if I don’t try anything new, right? I do understand that you don’t really like this stuff though, so if you want me to go, I understand.”

Fluttershy lowered her flyers a little, pursing her own lips before she let out a sigh. “N-no, Sunset, you don’t need to. Wh-what you do with your body is your choice, and I could honestly use the help.” She then extends the flyers like a peace offering, with a soft, though very red, smile.

Sunset smiles back, taking the stack of flyers, though her stomach would be complaining until lunch. The sight of Fluttershy’s smile was worth it. “Volunteer to help the humane society!”

For a while, the two of you merely chat and offer in front of the statue, watching the first few students come onto the schoolgrounds. Fluttershy is normally early for school for this purpose, but no one ever knows why Sunset is always early. Before the massive crowd hits, one boy, in a white t-shirt with a recycle symbol on it, and dreadlocks, walks by, and then stops. He turns, staring at Sunset, but not in the same way as the other boys.

He steps forward, his smile growing as he takes a flyer. “Hey, Sunset, are you trying to cut back on your wardrobe? Because I approve. I’ve thought of trying to do it myself, but my mom keeps telling me that I’m not allowed. If I could, I would go completely natural. How about you?”

X: Agree. There’s no reason to shoot him down, and the idea of actually going naked would be like being at home, even if I have no tail to cover myself.

O:Partially Agree. I might be able to live with the embarrassment of being in my undies, but never completely naked.

V: Disagree. I’m not doing this to save on how many loads of laundry I need to do, just to, you know,... I don’t know actually.

Sunset tapped her chin, before letting her cheeks come to life with their own blush as she realized what she was about to admit. Still, she had heard about Green Peace, and knew he was a pretty good guy, so she didn’t want to leave him wondering. “Well, I don’t think I could deal with letting everything show, but having something over them wouldn’t be too bad. It’s not like I don’t already wear bikinis anyways.” She did note though, that that was more so because those were easier to ‘borrow’ than full swimsuits.

Green grinned at the answer, before he started pulling off his shirt, and Fluttershy let out squeak. “Yeah, I think you’re totally right there. Not everyone is going to be okay letting everything hang out, but,” he finally got it off with a grunt, and grinned as his smooth stomach showed itself, “I am happy to hear a girl admit what a bikini really is. And hey, since you’re being brave, so will I. How about you, Fluttershy? We’ll be like an alliance of support today!”

Sunset raised an eyebrow, before gently smacking him on the back of the head. “Hey, calm down there, Captain Planet. Fluttershy doesn’t even wear a swimsuit as far as I know.”

This time, it was his turn to blush, and nod, before turning away and taking off. As his goodbye faded in their ears, Fluttershy turned to Sunset, and squeaked, “Thanks.”

Sunset nodded with a smile “Don’t worry Fluttershy, I have your back.”

As the main rush of the crowd began to come in, more of the meatheads came with it, and more whistles and taunts at Fluttershy and Sunset, though, for possibly the first time in Fluttershy’s life, there were less aimed at her.

One such taunt, brought back up the options. “Flash me, and I promise to come by tonight to get something. You can kick me in the dick if I don’t.”

X: Flash the idiot. It’ll help the shelter, and probably be the first time that Fluttershy’s work has actually gotten someone to come to the shelter.

O: Tell him to fuck off. Not only would Fluttershy probably freeze up and think I’m a total slut, but why the hell should I have to bribe him to get a goddamn pet!

Sunset tensed for a moment, before letting out a sigh. It might piss Fluttershy off, but she had heard the girl lament so many times about how she thought about no longer doing the flyers. At least she would be able to call this a success.

The guy, and the couple others looking in the right direction at the time, let their jaws drop as she lowered her bra. Sunset could feel every eye on her, and her spine shivered in both embarrassment, and excitement at the thought of having all of theirs attention. If her breasts were bigger, she bet this would have been as successful as using the elements.

After about maybe three or five seconds of this, and worrying about one or two conspicuous bulges, she glared at the main one, and said, “So, deal?”

He hummed for a moment, before licking his lips. “Well, I mean, it’s just a…” He became very quiet as her eyes turned to ice, and he nodded furiously. “Yep, yep, they’re awesome!”

Sunset nodded, and pulled up her bra again, covering the hard, pink nipples with the nice, black satin. As she let her arms fall again, and tried to get the heat in her cheeks to do the same, she felt a hand slip into hers.

“Th-thank you. You didn’t need to, but…” Fluttershy hung her head, and squeezed Sunset’s hand again.

Sunset frowned for a moment, before stepping slightly closer to the other woman and giving her a light hug. “Hey, I bet you hear that all the time, and it can’t be easy to not give into it, can it? I’m stronger though, so if it means getting what we wanted, I was willing to do it, especially for a good friend.”

Fluttershy lowered her eyes, and faintly whispered, ‘Yeah…”

X: Press. She is hiding something, and I want to know about it.

O: Give her space. Fluttershy has been pretty flustered this morning, so pushing her might just make her cry, and I don’t want that.

Sunset set her jaw. Fluttershy didn’t seem just scared, but like she was hiding something, which was entirely unlike her. “Hey, if something’s wrong, let me know. If you don’t want me to do that anymore, I won’t. It’s not like I actually wanted to show that creep my boobs.”

Fluttershy shook her head, before looking up, a tear coming down her face. “H-how many times do you think I’ve heard that same offer, but done nothing, despite the fact that I’m the one that actually comes out here in a constantly failed attempt to help?”

Sunset wiped the tear away, “It’s okay, Fluttershy, you and I are just different. You are much shyer, but that’s not a bad thing! I think between the two of us, we make a good team!”

Fluttershy smiled, another tear coming down her face as she looked into the other girl’s dazzling eyes. Those eyes that were always so confident, and strong. For a moment, Fluttershy glanced around, and saw that, with how close it was getting to school starting, there was no one looking there way, and very few anyways.

And she was not about to let Sunset not know how much this mattered to her.

“I… I might not be able to do this normally, b-but for you,” she paused, lifting her sweater up. The soft, pink cotton was to go with the colder weather, but now it let her skin show, quickly being raised in a very hurried fashion. This only led to more bounce as it cleared her chest, and Fluttershy’s whole body tensed.

And in front of Sunset were the biggest tits in school. The soft, yellow mounds sagged slightly, but youth kept them from going too far. With each almost being the size of Sunset’s head though, they were still very impressive, and drew her in, just as they had in the past.

X: Squeeze them. Feel those soft mounds in her hands for once, and enjoy all that she could of her friend’s bravery.

O: Hug her. It’ll get those tits hidden, but still acknowledge how sweet of a gesture it was.

V: Kiss her. Let the shy girl know the fact that Sunset had a reason to make her an old favorite for teasing because she is simply so beautiful, and this… but it could be too much as well.

Sunset took a deep breath, staring at Fluttershy for a long moment longer, her brain not quite being able to process the choice, before she stepped forward, and wrapped her arms around the other girl. She could feel the massive mammaries against her own, more diminutive chest, but for the moment, she didn’t care.

Fluttershy hugged back, nuzzling her face into Sunset’s neck, and whispering, “Y-you’re a good friend, y-you know that, right?”

Sunset smiled, laying her cheek on the top of Fluttershy’s head. “Thank you, I-I’m trying to be better than I have.”

Fluttershy stepped away, letting the sweater settle back on it’s own as she looked Sunset in the eye. She was relieved for a moment that the brave girl hadn’t realized that she wore nothing underneath it, but pushed it away, wanting to say one more thing. To extend her bravery just a little farther.

Ding, dong.

Both girls turned towards the sound of the warning bell, and Fluttershy forced herself not to sigh in defeat. The moment was gone, and they had to go. “Well, I’ll see you at lunch than?”

“Yeah! Sounds good. I’ll see you then, Fluttershy!” Sunset picked up her bag and raced off to her first period. A small blush still on her cheeks.

Author's Note

As an early warning, Foals is very much so trying to have her act in character, so don't expect a ton of smut from her, at least early on.

Sunset Pt. 2

X: Focus on the class. It may be history, something I looked into way too hard when I first came here, and so know all of this stuff, but I still can’t just brush it off.

O: Fantasize. I know all of this, so why not relax, think of other things, and not let boredom kill me?

Sunset takes a deep breath, and lets her mind wander, while pretending to be very interested in the material, a skill she mastered while working with Snips and Snails. She quickly went to a normal one, where she was coming to a meadow, where all of her friends awaited her, smiling, and overjoyed that the one they cared about was there.

X: It was a clearing, a normal picnic as always, and we were all dressed for a hike.

O: A small change for the day, to go with my outfit; we’re at a beach, all in bikinis, even… my Fluttershy.

A small hum escaped Sunset as she saw the bouncing boobs of Fluttershy’s again, looking at her with a bright smile, before she looked away. Applejack merely smiled at her, her own, perky apples jiggling a bit as she began to climb over the picnic blanket. As always, she had brought the food, and Sunset couldn’t be happier. She had so little ‘home cooking’, even in Equestria, that she welcomed it every time.

She couldn’t help but continue to focus on Fluttershy though, and what she had just seen of her friend. It wouldn’t be hard…

X:Push it away. They may be fantastic without covering, but I don’t need Flutterboobs.

O: It won’t hurt to indulge a little, right? Just a small snap of strings, and I could make her show me them again, even if just in my mind.

With a sharp breath, Sunset reminded herself that she was still in school, and pushed the thought out of her mind. Instead, she began to simply chat and hang out with her friends. It was as she always hoped friends interacted. Natural, fun, and especially funny, with things like Pinkie pretending to be from Jaws.

While she day dreamed though, another set of choices popped into her view, and it said,

X: Ignore him

O: Glare at him

V: Smile and subtly wave

And she found herself unable to glance over and see whatever the hell it was talking about.

Sunset turned to spot the person looking at her, and saw that one of the nerds she had teased a good while ago, a Button Mash, if she called right, was staring at backwards at her. A smile crossed her lips, and she waved to him, and his cheeks got became much brighter as he turned away. It was also at this time that the teacher said that his lecture was done, and that they could work on the assignment for the day.

“Hi Button, would you like to work on the assignment together?” Sunset smiled softly as she opened her book to the page written on the board.

Button obviously wasn’t expecting anything like this as his pupils almost disappeared from his eyes, and he swallowed hard. He tried speaking, but the only thing that came out was a strangled squeak.

“I’ll take that as a yes, so move your chair over here, and we can use my desk.” Sunset patted the top of her desk.

Button began to fumble and move, but before he could get very far, he slammed himself back into his chair. This wasn’t before she had seen a rather… impressive, bulge in his pants. She than got to watch the poor boy put his hands over it, while blushing like a tomato.

X: Compliment him, and thank him for the compliment

O: Say nothing. It’s way too embarrassing for both of you.

Sunset stood up, the book in one hand as she moved her chair with the other one. Once she was down next to him, certain she was just going to thank him for the compliment, she blurted out, “Well, nice to see I have enough charm to get your broadsword all the way up.” Her mind screamed as she realized what she said, but her body didn’t blush, unlike Button, who looked like he might die. No, she instead winked, and felt a shiver of excitement run down her spine.

Sunset covered her mouth with her hand. Did I really say that? She quickly moved her hand down, realizing that it probably wasn’t the best to stay like that after winking like she did. “Ah, so...so the assignment is on the Battle of Pearl Harbor…”

Button Mash nodded, his own hands fumbling with the textbook, and he tried to focus on the words in front of him. He still didn’t speak though, afraid that his voice would shatter if he did. His eyes weren’t so easy to control though, and Sunset could easily see when he was looking back at her, his gaze fixed on her exposed chest.

“I-I’m really sorry about what I said. I mean, I...I do see it as a compliment, but I didn’t mean to say something like that. I hope you aren’t too… upset?” Sunset played with her pencil between her fingertips.

For a moment, Button simply stared at her like she was completely insane, before whispering, “A-aren’t you the one that’s supposed to be smacking me here? Because as far as I’m concerned, one of the-” Buttons caught himself just in time, and slammed a hand over his mouth as he paled.

“One of the?” Sunset encourages him.

Button swallowed hard, before sighing. If she wanted the truth out of him, she would be able to get it out of him one way or another probably. “O-one of the prettiest girls in school isn’t hurting me for staring at her chest.”

Sunset blushed. “I… N-no, like I said, I’m flattered by it. I know I’ve been pretty rotten… i’m trying to change.”

Button tried for a weak, nervous smile. “Well, I believe you, I… I promise. It’s not like people can’t change after all.”

X: Offer the young lad a show of how much I appreciate the compliments

O: Simply blush, and focus on the assignment. He is still a nerd, and we’re at school. To do anything like those things would be super inappropriate.

Sunset reached over, squeezing his hand and mouthing thank you, before she turned back to the book, and began to discuss the chapter. As the class progressed, Button became more comfortable around her, and by the end, they agreed to talk more some time, and parted with tears at the very edge of Sunset’s eyes as he smiled genuinely at her face, and not just her breasts.

Sunset Pt. 3

With food in hand, Sunset sees two options pop up before her.

X: Wander the halls, and see who might be doing what around the school.

O: Just head to the table with her friends, and hang out with them, like most lunches nowadays.

As Sunset moved across the cafeteria, and tried to ignore the catcalls she got, she spotted the small table that her friends usually sat at. Of course, with how busy the other five were, it was pretty rare for all of them to be there, and today, it looked like Applejack and Fluttershy were the only ones that had been able to make it.

Once she got into earshot, Applejack shook her head. “Well, Fluttershy had told me that you had decided to dress… differently today, but I hadn’t actually expected it to be true.” She than smiled. “Guess it’s that rocker side of you then, isn’t it?”

Sunset blushed, “I guess so. Today has just been really weird if I’m honest though.” She picked up her cheese burger and took a big bite.

Fluttershy smiled, and placed a hand on the one Sunset had on the bench. “Well, I know you’re still acting like yourself, so I wouldn’t worry about it personally.”

Applejack bit into her cheek, before shrugging herself, and leaning forward to get some of her own grub. “I suppose that’s really what matters. It isn’t the clothes that make the girl, it’s her own actions. As long as those aren’t changing too much, we don’t have anything to fear.”

“Well I’m trying to be a nicer person I want to be a good person.” Sunset blushed nervously.

Applejack reached over and squeezed her hand as she smiled. ‘I know sugarcube. Just don’t think a more open person means a nicer person, okay?”

“Alright, today has just been very weird… Oh! Button! Button Mash over here!” Sunset stood up to get Button’s attention.

Button didn’t hear her though, and Sunset got to see as one of the quarterbacks, Thunderlane, smiled down at the poor nerd. Just from the posturing, how Button looked, and the hand on the wall that stopped him from going anywhere, she knew what was going on. She’d used the same tactics too many times not to.

X: Leave him be. I would just make more enemies trying to help him, and they are the jocks. I didn’t mess with them for a reason.

O: Confront them. I can still hold some level of fear over most people, and bullying is just wrong… or so I now think.

V: Act oblivious, and pretend to be his girlfriend. It’s underhanded, and Button might pass out, but bullies don’t like to do it when there are witnesses. Celestia knows I used plenty of dark corners for my business.

Sunset stepped over, her heels making an extra bit of noise as she approached. She wanted to make sure she was heard, and heard she was, as Thunderlane jumped at first at the sight of her. What she didn’t notice was his eyes flicking over her body, and the grin that barely hid in his scowl. Instead, she felt complete control as she crossed her arms and said, “Let him go.”

Thunderlane gestured for her to go away, his scowl becoming more realized as he glared at her. “Look, you aren’t queen of this school anymore, and I’m just talking to Button about an arrangement we had, that’s all. A friendly deal. So, since you aren’t even ready to do this, why don’t you just move along?”

X: Confront

O: Backoff

Sunset stepped forward, her eyes glaring into his as she growled, “And what will you do if I don’t?”

It was too late when she realized the smile in his eyes, and that she had walked right into what she wanted. “This.” His hand, the same one that had been stretched out before, now reached forward, grabbing the front of her bra, and pulling it down, hard. She heard the clasp in the back undo itself, and the fresh air caressed her bosom as Thunderlane held her bra.

It was about this point, as Button froze in place and a small bit of blood left his nose, that Sunset realized that they were lucky to be in a corner.

Sunset gritted her teeth and cried out, swinging at Thunderlane’s nose. “You… you Gelding!”

Thunderlane stepped back, his teeth grit as he recoiled from the pain. Glancing to the room though, he saw that their noise had made sure that his actions were still unseen, even with Sunset’s shout, and now he was angry. He pushed forward, his hands grabbing ahold of her bosom and forcing her against the wall as he scowled. “Alright, you bitch, let’s see how tough you real-”

Crack!

A brown fist slammed into Thunderlane’s cheek, and this time sent him sprawling onto the floor. Button then stood before her, holding his wrist. His eyes were darting from place to place, unable to stay in one point, before they landed on Sunset. He reached out, grabbing her hand, and tried to pull her away, and out of the cafeteria.

X: Follow Button. That punch didn’t sound good, but if Thunderlane isn’t out cold, he is going to be mad, and I may need to protect Button.

O: Stay, as Thunderlane still has my bra, and I want to make sure the jackass gets what he deserves.

Sunset let Button take her away as a groan came from Thunderlane. Even if she bothered to stay, it’s doubtful she would get much done. There was a bit of a reason that her empire lasted as long as it did. Besides, she had come over to make sure Button was okay, and now she was even more curious.

And, as she found out when Button’s adrenaline stopped, it was a good thing, as the poor boy hit his knees with a cry of pain. Kneeling beside him, Sunset saw him clutching at his hand, and whimpering.

Sunset kneeled down “Let me see. My, uh, old mentor taught me about wounds, and how to heal them.” She was, admittedly, bluffing a bit, but as she pressed into his palm, and felt one of the bones move a bit, she knew she would need to be pretty dumb not to realize that the poor boy broke his hand on the idiot’s thick skull.

Button tried to take his hand away, an open sweat coming down his face at this point. “It’s… It’s nothing, I-I promise. What’s more important is that you’re okay, and that we,” he paused, still somehow able to blush, even like this, “find you something to cover up with.”

“Y-yeah. Hopefully AJ comes soon. I know she was watching…” Sunset blushed. “Thunderlane is going to owe me a new bra… gelding bastard.”

Button nodded, breathing heavily as he leaned back against the wall. His hand now grasped at his wrist, his arm shaking as he tried to keep it still. She could hear him muttering, worried about what this might do to him, and about the pain.

X: Kiss Button Mash. He deserves that much.

O: Let him touch me with his good hand. He stood up for me, seems pretty sweet, and god knows he could use a distraction.

V: Do what I had thought before, and undo his trousers. No work for him, and I give him what he is due, and then some.

Y: Hold his good hand, and let him know I’m here. No matter what though, I’m not leaving him alone.

Sunset moved over to his right side, gently taking ahold of his good hand, and smiling at him as she squeezed it. He tried to smile back, but it was obvious that it was forced, and hard for him to hold. Despite it only taking her another minute, by the time Applejack came around the corner, he was sobbing into her shoulder, shuddering in pain and fear.

“Sorry it took me so long. Are you two okay?”

“Button’s hand is broken, and Thunderlane took my bra. Do you have a top I can borrow?” Sunset looked up, hopeful.

Applejack frowned. “I… don’t. Sorry. I don’t even know where we would find one right now, at least before lunch ends. If I could track down Rarity, that would be a whole different story.” She then turned to Button. “As for you, first, thanks for helping out Sunset, it means a lot to me. Secondly, we either need to get you to the nurse, or at least get your hand bandaged up so it stays still.”

a moment, Button just nodded, gritting his teeth as he stepped away from Sunset and the wall, before his eyes popped open. “W-wait, I’ve played enough survival games to know that, nnf, you could just rip a piece of a shirt off for a bandage. And then, Sunset can just take my ruined one. Worst that can happen is the guys tease me.”

Applejack glanced over to Sunset and raised an eyebrow. “The thought had crossed my mind.”

X: No, as I owe him too much already.

O: Yes, as it fixes both of our problems, and I can figure out a real way to thank him other than, ‘He got to see my tits.’

Sunset slowly nodded, looking Button right in the eyes as she asked, “Are you sure?”

Button nodded with a smile. It was small, but she could tell sincere, just like the rest of the boy. It actually kind of hurt though, as she knew a large part of it had to go to the pretty girl talking to him. That did give her a good few ideas as to how to reward him though.

She couldn’t set any of them into motion yet though, as by the time they had everything taken care of, the end of lunch bell was ringing, and they had to rush towards class, with Button feeling better, unlike Sunset’s stomach.

Sunset Pt. 4

Sunset sighed as she searched her locker for anything to eat. “Oh come on… there has to be something here…”

Rainbow chuckled next to her, currently in a state of undress not unlike the way Sunset had been most of the day, which was actually kind of nice, as Rainbow was the only one of the group with a smaller chest than hers. “Hey, you know no food is allowed in the locker rooms, right? Besides, shouldn’t you be getting changed?”

“Rainbow, I haven’t eaten all day. I’m going to pass out if I don’t eat something!” Sunset spun to face her friend “Please, do you have anything?”

Rainbow sighed. While it was fun to tease, she had known too many hunger pangs to be too mean. “No, but how about I get you something from the vending machines after class, alright?”

“Thank you! Thank you, Rainbow Dash.” Sunset licked her lips at the thought of the coming food, then turned back to her own locker.

As with so often in the day, a choice popped up just then.

X:Go in shorts and panties

O: Follow the theme of the day, and ditch the shorts.

Sunset glared at the bar, and didn’t even kid about the idea of pretending her black panties were part of a bikini. Instead, she grabbed her gray shorts, and the white t-shirt that still needed to get washed someday soon before the smell killed someone, and began to get changed. There was only minor staring at her entirely exposed chest when she took off Button’s shirt.

Getting into the gymnasium, she could see everyone there, with a good number of guys looking disappointed as they looked her way. They’d probably been hoping to see her still in only her bra, though, right now, she would not have minded that too much, as her nipples ground against the rough fabric of the shirt, and it sent shivers down her spine.

She hoped it would get better by the time the supposedly perverted teacher, Soarin, came out, but it wasn’t, not that there was any reason for it to. He said they were doing just simple physical exercises today, including things like

X: Crunches

O: One Mile Run

V: Pull ups

Y: Sprints

Sunset offered to do crunches first. On a normal day, there wouldn’t be any reason to worry, but as most movements brought awkward chills to her body, she needed to be careful. Unfortunately, no matter her condition, she knew the crunches would be bad. Not because she couldn’t do them. No.

It was because, at about the half-way point, with her pushing hard enough to get an A score, her shirt was already halfway down her front. Each pull after that brought it closer to revealing herself, until, during the last ten seconds, she simply had to power through.

The person above her was luckily a girl, something she had made sure to do while her mind was clear, but both of them still turned red as her Bouncing Betties came out to play. The only consolation she really got out of it really was that a lot of the idiots became too distracted waiting for this to happen to get there amount high enough to get the grade they wanted.

It wasn’t much, but at least it was something.

X: One Mile Run

O: Pull ups

V: Sprints

Sticking to the theme of being careful, Sunset next set out for the pull up bars. She wasn’t lucky enough to get a girl to be her partner this time, but it really didn’t matter this time. Now, if she had been sweaty, aroused, or anything like that, the boy watching her might have had plenty to see, or even do that she might not object to, but as it was, he just got to grip into her thighs, and get smacked in the face for it.

It was also one of the few times where she ever thanked the fact that she didn’t have Fluttershy’s boobs, as that would make this a hundred times harder.

X: One Mile Run

O: Sprints

Sunset stretched out for a bit, readying herself mentally for the mile run. It was gonna be a hell of an endurance test, but it was just a circle, so nothing to fear.

At least, until her ‘gift’ began to show its true power while she ran.

X: Nipples

O: The pounding of her feet.

Sunset breathed in deeply, almost not acknowledging the choice. However, as her nipples were currently grinding against the fabric of her clothes, she decided anything else was better, and so focused on the rhythm of her footsteps, and tried to keep herself calm through it.

X: Running with Button Mash.

O: Running for School Government last year.

Her mind began to wander more to the run with Button Mash from that idiot, before it went to more specifically the end of the run. She had heard of nerds doing stupid stuff for those they liked, but he really took the cake. And what had she given him in return? Let him get less of a feel of her boobs than her shirt was getting right now.

She knows, of course it was the right choice, as Applejack would have gotten entirely the wrong idea otherwise, but still, holding his hand didn’t feel like enough. What felt like enough was if she had bent down, opened wide, and taken all of his big, fat, nerdy-

She jolted awake from her daydreaming as she stumbled, a heat rising up from her nethers that made her legs tremble more. She had to stay focused though.

X: Fluttershy’s boobs.

O: Her own boobs.

As she came onto the final lap, Sunset sighed as she remembered how the day had gone. While sure, the guys of the school had enjoyed seeing her in her bra, not many reacted like Button Mash. Hers were a treat, not a banquet to be enjoyed. Now, if she’d had the bra size that Rarity boasted, but usually didn’t show, that would be a whole different story.

Than, she could go around school, only with a bra on, and all the guys would stare. She could make them listen, and probably believe her case for being a good girl. She might even get Flash to come back, so she could have another who was that close once more. One who would lay her on the ground, suckle on her bosom, and give her the tou-

No! She shut her eyes, her body trembling more as she finally passed the final line. She was starting to really get tired of these stupid thoughts, and whatever stupid thing had put this on her. And no, getting to meet Button does not make it okay.

It only put her in a worse mood as she did her final challenge, the sprints. At this point, she could feel the wetness between her thighs as she dashed from one point to the next, and back again, over and over again. Normally not a problem, but with how stiff and agitated her nipples were, along with the thoughts she couldn’t quite concentrate.

Meaning gym class for her ended with almost crashing onto the floor, her legs quivering from the amount of arousal she was under. Not that she showed it for more than a few moments. No, she couldn’t have that.

It was going to be awkward to talk to Button after school though about his reward for being her knight though while she was like this. She had an idea though, and was not about to abandon it. Not even due to… this.

Author's Note

Foals was smart about this one, as this could have ended much worse, or better, dependent upon perspective, for our dear Sunset. Just a little bit more we did today, in part to celebrate the release.

Sunset Pt. 5

Sunset raised an eyebrow as she opened her closet, and couldn’t help but think the magic was beginning to get snarky.

X: Dressed, but no underwear

O: Panties only

V: Bra only

Y: Dressed completely, you bore.

Sunset blushed as she to slid off her underwear and gym shirt. She’d luckily been able to wear it for the rest of the day, so as to not have to show everyone her tits, but it also meant that her pants and panties were slick with the arousal the course fabric caused. In fact, if she were honest, her whole body was heated.

It was because of this that her tight, wet, shaven crotch soon found itself covered not by cotton, but denim. Thick enough to absorb any remaining moisture, but also left her ready for how she slightly hoped the night would go. A blush covered her face as the softer fabric of her normal, cutie mark emblazoned shirt covered her modest chest. She’d never thought about going out with a nerd before, but now that she’d met Button, and after today, she kind of hoped it ended… pleasantly.

Of course, first she had to find him.

X: Back of the School

O: Computer Lab

V: Front of the School

Sunset tried to calmly walk through the halls of the school, ignoring the looks she got from her classmates. A lot of them had heard about her prancing about school with only a bra on, and already there was a rumor for her braless period too. However, she knew her trusty go to tee would keep her nipples hidden, and her bosom safe. Thus, she strode with purpose, as speed was key right now.

She got to the tech lab, and the adjoining computer lab, before swiftly opening the door. She had honestly never been in the place before, and could hear subtle gasps come from the boys there. She liked it, though not so much when she heard a moan of disappointment. She was a little done with almost flashing guys at the moment though.

Her eyes drifted over the room, and she tried to pick out that orange mop of Button’s. From brown, to white, to red, she saw nothing though, and frowned. With a slight sigh of annoyance, she looked out the window, and damn near cursed as she saw his stupid propellor hat walking right out the front gate. “Damnit!”

Sunset grit her teeth as footsteps came closer, and she heard behind her, in a voice she was not familiar with, and soon found belonged to a pasty, white girl with glasses, and mostly red hair, “Are you okay? People don’t normally just randomly curse. Not from what my research shows at least.”

“Yeah, I was just hoping Button Mash might be here… Unfortunately, I just watched as he walked out the front entrance. And I have no idea where he lives.” Sunset sighs rubbing her temples.

The girl frowned. She knew Sunset’s reputation, even though she was enough of a recluse to have stayed out of her radar. However, she wasn’t dumb, and used her ability to hide as well. Now that she mentioned Button Mash, the gears started to work, and she recalled something she had heard earlier that day. “Wait, didn’t you help him today?”

“Yeah, I was hoping to find him so I could thank him for defending my honor, what little of it I have at least. You know, maybe ask him to dinner… or something.”

Moondancer’s eyes narrowed at that. She had heard about Sunset’s exploits as the whispered adventures of ‘Sunslut’ as some students were calling it. How she spoke now though spoke to different reasons for it, and once more, she found herself nodding her approval. Still, she was not one to make friends, even with friends of nerds. “You also helped him out, from what I hear. Thunderlane will think twice next time he tries to hurt Button, and stop him from coming here during lunch.”

“...Moondancer, right? Do you happen to know where he lives? I’m not planning to hurt him. I mean… he’s a sweet guy.” Sunset blushed, reaching back and rubbing the back of her neck.

That finally got the white girl to smile. “I don’t. I know Button, and play with him sometimes, but I have never been to his house. I can let him know that you want to see him after school tomorrow though.”

Sunset sighed and nodded with a small smile. “Well, that’s better than nothing. Thanks Moondancer I appreciate it.”

She nodded one last time, before deciding to give one more offer of kindness. “I can give him a message from you as well. Or a gesture, if you feel so free.”

X: Tell him thank you.

O: To give him a kiss on the cheek for me.

V: To give him a kiss on the lips for me.

Y: To flash him for me.

Sunset considered for a moment what to send along, before she smiled, leaned forward, and pecked Moondancer on the cheek. She then smiled, and looked up, her gaze elsewhere than the blushing, bright red girl as she said, “Give him that, along with what I think of him. That he’s a sweet guy. Do you think you can?”

“I-I th-think I can.” Something was wrong in Moondancer’s brain, as it felt like almost every system within it simply crashed all at once.

Sunset, satisfied that she had done her job, nodded one more time, before stepping for the door. After all, if she wasn’t going to spend time on a date, she could use it for other things.

X: Wash my clothes, and myself, in the pool, since the swim team should be done soon.

O: Go dumpster diving for some dinner.

V: Turn in early, and just relax at my little place, and snack on chips.

Sunset swiftly snuck back to her little, abandoned home, for once able to put a smile on her face as she did so. Most of the time, she came back because she didn’t want to catch the eyes of her classmates, or their potential ire, but tonight, she was simply tired. It had been a long, stimulating day, and she was ready to rest.

As she watched her dvds, she couldn’t help but look around herself. Everything, and she meant everything in there was some level of stolen. From the small tv, to her wardrobe, all of it technically didn’t belong to her. She had technically paid for some of the things, but it wasn’t honest money. It was money she had extorted, or pickpocketed. Sure, it kept her alive, but for that to still be how she lived…

X: It’s fine. It’s not like I have a family to support me after all.

O: It’s not fine. I’m supposed to be a good girl now, but all I am is a petty thief.

V: It’s okay… for now. One of these days I’ll get help, or try to repair what I can, but… not yet.

Sunset laid her head down, and breathed in deeply, her body shaking as she let it out. It hurt to admit, how far she had gone down when she left Equestria. How many people she hurt that no one knew about. That all would end though. She would start looking for a job, and dumpster dive until she could get one.

One thought plagued her mind as she slept that night though. One thought as she realized that she couldn’t possibly do what she had planned if she weren’t to use her ill gotten money.

What am I going to do to thank Button Mash tomorrow?

Sonata?

Sunset raised an eyebrow as she saw the blue haired Siren from the battle of the bands bent over, and jabbing at the air with one finger, as if trying to click on something. "Sonata...what are you doing?"

Sonata scowled as the X option in front of her, 'Tell Sunset about my curse' wouldn't actually press. "I'm trying to get my button-pushing overlord to pick this one!"

Sunset just opened her mouth for a few moments, before shaking her head, and placing a hand on her temple. "...and I thought I was the one being shipped with Button Mash."

Button, standing to the side, freaking out about those two, finds himself oddly unsurprised as three options appear before his eyes.

X: Pursue romance with Sunset.

O: Pursue romance with Sonata.

V: Attempt harem ending.

He breaks into a cold sweat as he realizes the sudden turn his life has taken. "I...I need an adult," he whimpers under his breath.

A new message alert informs him that the one pulling his strings is an adult.

Author's Note

Something Tatsurou and I made up on the fly to promote the Choices story I'm working on with him, featuring our dear little Sonata.