The Girls of My Life 2: Old Flames and New Flames

One night in Spike's room, the boy was at his laptop scrolling through new memes while laughing at the funnier ones, "Oh, how did I miss these ones? I mean they're so simple," he heard his laptop ring, "Video chat." he pulled up the video chat to reveal Pinkie Pie and her sister Marble Pie.

"Hi, Spikey!" Pinkie waved.

"Pinkie, hey!" Spike smiled, and turned to the sister, "Hi, Marble."

Marble smiled and shyly waved at Spike, "Marble wasn't really doing anything so I decided to let her join in my video chat."

"That's nice. So how're your other sisters doing?"

"Well, you know Limestone, always about work," Pinkie answered, "And Maud's on a date with her boyfriend Mud Briar."

"Wait. Maude's got a boyfriend?" Spike asked in surprise.

"I know. Shocked me when she first told me."

"Since when?"

"A few weeks now." she answered.

"What's he like?" Spike wondered. From all the times he's met Maud she wasn't the easiest person to understand with her unusual quirks.

"He's really bizarre," Pinkie began, "I mean he's always pointing out technicalities in stuff, even when someone says a simple goodbye. Plus he's also into sticks."

"Sticks?" Spike asked, "A rock lover and a stick lover?"

"I know. I don't get it. But if he makes Maud happy then I'm happy too." Pinkie admitted.

"Good to hear." Spike smiled, until he saw Pinkie batting her eyes at him.

"But really, Spike. The real reason I messaged you here is I wanted to see your sweet face," Spike's face turned pink, as the girl continued, "And I wanted to see your reaction."

"Reaction to what?" he wondered.

"Oh, nothing," Pinkie answered, as she crossed her arms under her big breasts and started jiggling them, causing Spike to gasp as his eyes were glued to his screen, "Spike...I know you miss my girls," to Spike's shock, Pinkie removed her blouse to reveal she wasn't wearing a bra underneath, "And you know something? I think they've gotten bigger since last time, don't you?' she asked, while hefting her breasts up for Spike, while Marble gasped at what her sister was doing.

"Pinkie," Spike began speaking like a lustful zombie, before shaking his head and came back to his senses, "Your sister's there! Don't you think-" Pinkie cut him off.

"Oh, it's okay, Spikey-Wikey. It's just us here," she turned to Marble and spoke wickedly with a glint in her eyes, "Besides...I think Marble wants to show hers to you, too."

Marble let out another gasp and shook her head while blushing, "Uh-uh!" she denied.

Pinkie wasn't done teasing her yet, "C'mon, Marble. Ever since I showed you Spike's picture, you can't help but think about him. I even heard some sweet sounds coming from your room the other night."

Spike hearing her third sister may still think about him that way gulped, while Marble turned away to hide her embarrassment. Pinkie whispered into Marble's ear, which was loud enough for Spike to hear, "Show him your goods, sis. Then he can show you his." Marble and Spike's faces turned red, as Spike spoke up.

"Pinkie! You really think I'm just going to whip out my package just like that?"

"You could," she replied, before looking back at Marble who was too sheepish to do anything, "Well, Marble, if you won't do it, then I'll do it for you." she reached for the bottom of her sisters shirt and lifted it up and over her head to reveal like Pinkie Marble was also without a bra.

'Her too?' Spike thought, as he felt like he was on the verge of a nosebleed.

Pinkie began fondling Marble's bust, making her moan, "Ooh, I think you've been growing here too lately, Marble." Spike just watched the monitor, as the sight of Pinkie's breasts jiggling and Marble's getting fondled was making his heart run a marathon. Suddenly Spike fell backwards and hit the floor.

Pinkie seeing Spike vanish from her monitor, gasped and released Marble's rack as the girl panted, "Spike, are you ok?" Pinkie asked, "Where'd you go?" Spike laid on his bedroom floor laughing like a goofball, as a drop of blood came out of his nostril.

Meanwhile in the home of Sunshine and Moonlight, the two sisters were asleep in their beds. Sunshine had begun moaning in her sleep while muttering, "Oh, Spike."

As it turned out she was dreaming about Spike and the situation they were in was the two of them were naked, with Spike on top of Sunshine while fondling her breasts, "Oh, Spike! Please be gentle." she pleaded.

"Don't worry, baby. I'm all about gentle." Spike said, as he continued to fondle Sunshine causing her to moan some more.

"Mm, Spike."

It started feeling too real to Sunshine and her body, and she woke up from her fantasy to see her sister Moonlight was on top of her and massaging her breasts, while her pajama top was unbuttoned courtesy of her dark sister.

"Moonlight... What're you-"

"You looked very lonely, sis. I just wanted to comfort you," she smiled, "Were you having a nice dream?"

"Moonlight...no..." Sunshine pleaded for her to stop, but kept on moaning.

"I bet I know what it was about. Was Spike doing what I'm doing to you in your dream?" Moonlight guessed.

"Mm-hmm."

"I thought so. I don't blame you. I actually dreamed about him as well two nights ago." the dark sister admitted.

"Was he doing to you what you're doing to me?" the brighter twin asked.

"All that and more," Moonlight answered, as she continued to massage her sister's rack, "Sunshine, you really are beautiful. And sometimes I envy you for that." she sighed.

"You envy me?" Sunshine asked in shock, "Moonlight, you've got nothing to be envious about," she took control and reversed positions with her sister so Moonlight was on bottom and Sunshine was on top. The brighter sister unbuttoned her sister's pajama top exposing her own breasts and began massaging them, "You're beautiful in your own way. You always have been, and you always will be."

Moonlight smiled, as she sat up next to her sister, "I'm glad I have you for a sister, Sunshine."

Sunshine pecked Moonlight on the cheek and answered, "I feel the same way about you." To Sunshine's surprise, Moonlight pecked her on her lips. The two sisters smiled and fell asleep in each others embrace.

The next day at the pub, Spike and Ember had just finished their shift. As they walked outside the pub, Ember spoke, "I'll catch ya later, Spike. Gotta pick up groceries for my dad."

"If you're the one that does most of the cooking how did he survive when you left?" Spike asked curiously.

"He ate nothing but microwave dinners for the most part." she answered.

"Well, that can't be good for him."

"I know. Well, see ya around, Spike." Ember went to her car and drove off.

"Well, day's still young and I got plenty of time." Spike said to himself, as he grabbed his skateboard and headed off.

As he boarded around town, he noticed Sunshine and Moonlight up ahead. He rolled closer and called out, "Sunshine! Moonlight!"

The twins hearing Spike turned around and smiled upon who it was, "Hi, Spike!" Sunshine greeted.

"How's it going?" Moonlight asked.

"All good. I just got done with my shift at the pub. How about you girls?"

"We were just on our way to the cafe." Sunshine explained.

"If you're not doing anything, you're welcomed to join us." Moonlight offered.

"I think I'll take you up on that offer."

"Well, then let's go." Sunshine said, as the three went together.

Later on the three had gone to the cafe. They were sitting in a booth sharing a large ice cream sundae. Spike dipped his spoon into the sundae and took a bite, "Mm, delicious. Any of you girls tried to eat one of these by yourselves?"

"If we did that we'd get total brain freeze." Moonlight replied.

"And that would hurt." Sunshine shivered.

"True, but hey, sometimes it can be worth it." Spike said.

"Did you ever?" Sunshine inquired.

"Once, though I didn't get through the whole thing."

"Why's that?" Moonlight asked.

"My stomach couldn't handle it." the boy confessed.

Sunshine giggled, "That'll happen."

"And when did you do that exactly?" Moonlight wondered.

"Last year when me and my boys went out for a guys night to celebrate our high school finals coming to an end."

"That must've been fun." Sunshine said.

"It sure was. I still have the selfies. Wanna see?" Spike offered, as he pulled out his cellphone.

He began showing the twins some of the pictures on his phone of him along with his pals, Snips, Snails, Pipsqueak, and Featherweight going on a guys night out on the town.. Several pictures included one of the group posing in front of a horse statue, Snips and Snails on the grass playfully wrestling, at a cafe, Featherweight was holding a nacho dipped in cheese over his mouth allowing the cheese to drip right into his open mouth, Pip and Spike were hanging off one another on a bench looking happy, and another shot was of all five of them sitting around a circular table each taking a shot to commemorate that night.

"You seem to have a nice bunch of friends." Sunshine noted.

"Yeah. Despite their own wacky quirks they're the best pals a guy like me could ever ask for." Spike admitted.

"Do you still keep in touch?" Moonlight asked.

"Oh, yeah. We'd be crazy to not keep in touch. And we are a team on one of our favorite online RPG games. In fact I'm really gonna have to look ahead and see if there's any free time where I can get together with them."

The twins smiled, until Sunshine spoke, "Spike, Moonlight and I were wondering if you'd like to come back to our place later?"

Spike looked up at the two, "Really? What about your peeps?"

"Mom and dad won't be back till much later so it'll be just us." Moonlight explained.

"We really want to take this as a chance to get to know each other even better." Sunshine added.

"Know each other even better?" Spike asked, as he processed everything, before realizing what they were hinting at. He thought to himself, 'Yes! My first threesome in a long time!' he answered the two, "Well, girls. I'll take you up on that offer."

The twins smiled, as Sunshine cheered, "Wonderful!" Moonlight smiled and nodded in agreement.

Later on, the twins brought Spike back to their place and into their bedroom. Spike looked around the bedroom seeing it was two sided and one side reflected either of them. He spotted each of their beds, "So which one are we doing it on?"

"Both." Moonlight answered.

"Let's push them together." Sunshine said, as the three pushed both beds together to give them more room.

"Perfect." Moonlight nodded in approval.

"So how do we start?" Spike asked the two.

"Let's start by getting comfortable." Sunshine suggested, as she and Moonlight began taking off their clothes.

Spike watched with joy, as the twins undressed themselves and were suddenly in their undergarments. Sunshine's was colored pink, and Moonlight's was a bluish black color. The girls noticed Spike unable to take his eyes off them, and Sunshine spoke, "This is just a small sample of what's in store for you, Spike."

"I can't wait to see the full stuff." he answered.

And so the twins removed their undergarments and stood before Spike totally naked. Spike looked them over knowing despite looking like polar opposites, they both had the same body shape, size, and curvaceous figure.

The girls seeing Spike was still smitten, knew it was time to flaunt their charm, "Let's see your hands." Moonlight said, as she and Sunshine each took one of Spike hands and make him cope a feel at one of their breasts each.

"How does it feel?" Sunshine asked.

"Feels awesome." Spike answered.

"Yeah. We think it feels great too." Moonlight agreed, as Spike fondled them some more.

The girls released Spike's hands and proceeded to remove his clothes for him. Soon enough, Spike stood in his birthday suit with his erection in full view. The twins looked at it in delight, "Whoa. You're even bigger than some of the boys I screwed during college." Moonlight confessed.

"I'll take that as a compliment." Spike replied, before seeing Sunshine lower herself down to Spike's waist, and began giving him a hand job.

"Mm, I can't believe you've been hiding this from us." Sunshine said, as she massaged his twig and berries.

Spike couldn't say anything as he was too busy enjoying himself. Moonlight got down and Sunshine allowed her to take a shot at giving Spike a hand job as well, "Mm, yeah. Even smoother than any other guys I've done." Moonlight added.

When Spike was hard enough for the two, the twins brought Spike down on the two beds, before climbing up to join him. The threw dropped their bodies down on Spike's torso rubbing their bodies together, "Does this feel good?" Sunshine asked.

"Yeah. As if you had to ask."

"Of course. We like it too." Moonlight agreed.

The girls began moving to Spike's face, and began making out with Sunshine for a bit before switching over to Moonlight. After parting with Moonlight for some air, Spike began thinking back to the video of Pinkie Pie and Marble Pie, and an idea popped into his head, "Hey, girls. Could I ask a fvor of you?"

"Of course." Sunshine answered.

"Could you two possibly fool around with each other?" Spike asked in a playful meek tone.

"Spike, how could you suggest such a thing?" Moonlight playfully gasped.

"She's right. We're sisters after all." Sunshine reminded him, while trying to suppress a giggle.

"Oh, pretty please? It'll help me get in an even greater mood." Spike begged them in his playful tone.

The girls finding Spike's playfulness too adorable, answered, "Ok." Spike smiled, as the girls turned to each other and and began fondling each others boobs.

"I think you're still growing, Moonlight." Sunshine told her sister.

"I think you are too." Moonlight agreed.

The twins giggled, before moving closer and began kissing each other passionately. They wrapped their arms around each others necks to keep close. Spike watched as the two began Frenching, which caused his dick to throb in excitement.

When the sisters parted, Sunshine spoke, "Moonlight, if we weren't sisters and I swung more in the opposite direction I would love to make you mine."

"And I'd do the same for you." Moonlight replied, as the sisters kissed again, before parting.

"Let's both have a great experience with Spike together." Sunshine said, as her sister nodded.

So they started getting into position as Spike laid back with his head on one of the pillows, Moonlight straddled him before moving closer so his dick was able to enter through her vagina. Sunshine knelt over his head allowing Spike to get a good look at her ass.

"Ready to eat my ass alive?" Sunshine asked him flirtatiously.

"You know it."

And so Moonlight rode Spike, while he performed oral on Sunshine. As they screwed Spike thought to himself, 'Oh, I haven't had such a good threesome since Twilight and Rarity. Awesome times.'

As Moonlight rode Spike, the boy started feeling the build up before releasing into her. The dark girl panted, as she felt his load rush through her, "Oh, Spike, that was amazing."

"I know." he replied.

"I wanna share some of that too!" Sunshine moaned, as Spike ate at her.

"Then let's fix that." Moonlight said, as they took another position.

Sunshine laid atop Moonlight putting them in Missionary position. Spike who was behind Sunshine, crouched between both their legs an inserted himself through Sunshine's anus, while the brighter twin pressed her body down on Moonlight's.

"Does this work for you?" Moonlight asked her sister.

"It does." Sunshine confirmed.

"Works for me too." Spike added.

"So let's make this worthwhile." Moonlight said, as they started again with Spike inserting himself in and out of Sunshine's anus, while Sunshine moved downward rubbing her breasts against Moonlight's.

"Yes! Oh!" Sunshine moaned, from the double pleasure of both Spike and Moonlight.

As Spike screwed Sunshine from behind, he was really enjoying the show between the two sisters who were once again getting some loving with each other, "Mm, sis, this feels great. It's like our souls have become intertwined." Moonlight moaned.

"I feel that way too. This makes us feel closer than ever." Sunshine said, as they kissed, before Spike released inside Sunshine.

"That was great." Spike panted.

"You still good for more?" Moonlight asked.

"I sure am."

"Then let's make the most of it." Sunshine said, as the two sisters got up and kissed Spike together in a three way kiss, while Spike held the two close to his body.

An hour had passed, and the three were lying atop the two beds panting while keeping each other close, "That was so intense." Sunshine gasped.

"I know. I've never felt so great in my life." Moonlight agreed.

"My thoughts exactly," Spike put in, "You two are quite the team."

Sunshine smiled with her sister, "We are, aren't we?"

"The best." Moonlight agreed.

The two girls kissed Spike before snuggling up to him to rest, as Spike thought, 'Four down and two more to go. This is truly going to stick with me for the rest of my life.'