The Girls of My Life 2: Old Flames and New Flames

by Wildcard25

Harem Orgy

Previous ChapterNext Chapter

After getting some advice from Stellar Flare, Spike had skateboarded his way to the hotel in which the Canterlot Cuties were staying during their visit. He put his board in his bag and walked into the building. As he entered the lobby he saw Rarity who had been waiting for him.

“Rarity!” he called.

The sight of him made Rarity's face light up with joy, “Spikey-Wikey!”

“Sorry I took so long. I had some things to do.” Spike explained making sure to cover up his true reason.

“Well, better now then never,” Rarity giggled, “Come along, everyone's waiting for us.” And so Rarity took Spike by the hand and dragged him to the elevator where they would head up a few floors.


When they reached the right floor, Rarity knocked on one of the room doors, and Pinkie Pie answered it, “Come on in, guys!” she cheered, as they entered before Rarity put the 'Do Not Disturb' sign on the door handle.

Spike looked around the room seeing it was quite big like most hotels. He saw there were two bed set up, and thought, 'Guess they share them three a piece.' he then noticed in between the two beds were luggage stacked up along with an extra few blankets to make it look like one bed, 'Clever, Twilight.' he smiled to himself.

The rest of the girls got up and went to Spike, “Glad ya made it, Sugarcube.” Applejack greeted.

“We were worried you weren't coming.” Sunshine said in worry.

“But we're glad you did.” Fluttershy added.

“Like I'd miss it.” Spike answered.

“We already have something for you to wear before we begin.” Moondancer said.

“So pardon us while we go get ready.” Sunset Shimmer said, as the girls headed for the spacious bathroom.

Spike was curious to what they meant, before he saw folded neatly on one of the room chairs was a white bathrobe. The sight of it brought back memories of his first time with the Cuties after their prom the night they officially became a harem. He smiled, as he started removing his clothes before putting the robe on and tied the sash.

“I remember how snug I felt when I wore this thing before my first time. Feeling never goes away.” Spike said to himself.

Soon enough the door to the bathroom opened, and out stepped each of the girls wearing a white bathrobe like Spike wore. Spike looked at them all while blushing as how sexy they looked, and how much their breasts stuck out. He then thought to himself, 'They must've lifted most of those robes from the laundry room or something.'

“This takes you back doesn't it, Spike?” Rainbow asked with a grin.

“It sure does.” he confirmed.

“It takes us back as well to that night.” Twilight added.

“It was so magical.” Pinkie said heavenly.

“And now we'll get to experience it with you as well.” Ember noted.

“Even if it's during the daytime.” Moonlight sighed.

Spike nodded, and spoke, “So let's get started.”

The girls nodded, as all of them undid their sashes of their robes, before slipping them off their shoulders as they dropped to the floor. The girls smiled and blushed at the sight of their beloved Spike standing before them all natural with his erection nice and hard. Spike himself stared in awe at the dozen buxom beauties whose hearts have been captured by him.

“Girls, you're all so beautiful. I don't think I'm worthy of any of you.” Spike declared.

“Always the humble one, Spike.” Applejack smiled.

“And that makes you all the more attractive.” Rarity put in.

“And sweet.” Starlight finished.

“Come over here, Spike.” Ember beckoned him, as did the others.

Spike went over to the girls who surrounded him. Spike eventually found himself smothered from all sides by the busty racks of his entire harem, who made sure to cover every inch of him, “It's like being hugged by clouds.” he said while relaxing.

Each girl took a turn to nuzzle against Spike's cheek while also claiming his lips with a kiss. After Moondancer had her kiss with Spike she felt a pair of hands grab her breasts from behind, “Hey!” she gasped.

As it turned out, it was Pinkie who was groping Moondancer from behind, “Ooh, Moondancer, you've really got some good ones here.” she massaged them.

“Pinkie, please.” Moondancer moaned.

“I can't believe you'd hide these babies underneath a sweater,” Pinkie continued to fondle the bookworm from behind, “Guess that's why they're called sweater puppies.”

“Pinkie, you really shouldn't do that.” Twilight scolded her, only to be groped from behind by Sunset Shimmer.

“Actually, I think she's got the right idea.” Sunset teased Twilight.

“Sunset Shimmer!” Twilight moaned.

“Boob grope!” Rainbow announced, as the girls started groping each other and moaning in enjoyment.

Spike could only watch with a flustered face as all the girls kept groping at one another like an erotic cat fight, 'Well, at least this is keeping my boner up.' he thought.

As the girls kept groping each other, Twilight finally spoke up, “Girls, stop!” the girls ceased their groping, with Rainbow giving Starlight one last squeeze of her breast, “Remember we should focus most of our energy on Spike.”


The girls got themselves together and turned their attention back to Spike. They surrounded Spike again, as Twilight, Sunset Shimmer, Fluttershy, Ember, Rainbow Dash, and Starlight got down to his crotch and each took turns giving Spike a handjob, massaging his man jewels, and kissing his shaft. Rarity, Sunshine Smiles, Pinkie Pie, Moonlight Raven, Applejack, and Moondancer were making Spike grope each of their breasts, while Rarity was rubbing her boobs against Spike's back to further pleasure him.

“How is this, Spike?” Rarity cooed.

“I feel extreme relaxation.” Spike replied, as he enjoyed himself.

“Good. Because we like it too.” Moonlight noted.

The girls brought Spike onto the two combined beds, as they all got on. Spike laid back, as Twilight and Moondancer took the first shot, with Twilight laying down allowing Spike to slide himself inside her, “Oh, Twilight. I missed this.” Spike said.

“So have I.” Twilight smiled happily.

Moondancer draped herself on Spike from behind to rub her breasts against his back, “Ok, you two, let's get started.”

And so Spike started screwing around with Twilight, as Moondancer rubbed herself against his back, “Oh, yes, Spike!” Twilight moaned.

“Having wet dreams about this with you isn't as good as doing it in person.” Spike moaned, as he rode her.

“I know!” Twilight cried, as Spike picked up the pace.

Moondancer continued to rub her breasts against Spike's back to keep his body enticed so he could continued to pleasure Twilight.

“Twilight, I'm gonna explode!”

“Do it!” she cried, as Spike released inside her.

“Oh, Spike. Oh, I've missed that.” she panted.

“I'll bet.” Spike replied.

“Ok, Spike, my turn.” Moondancer said.

And so they swapped positions, with Spike laying down, and Moondancer getting into the reverse cowgirl position. Twilight made things hotter as she face sat on Spike. As Moondancer started riding him, Spike started licking at Twilight's pussy.

“Oh, yes, Moondancer. That's it.” Spike panted.

“Oh, I you got me feeling so horny, Spike.” Moondancer moaned.

“Spike, lick it! Lick it!” Twilight moaned, as Spike's tongue covered her pussy.

“Moondancer, I'm almost there!”

“Don't hold back on me.” Moondancer ordered.

“I'm gonna to!” Twilight moaned, as she squirted on Spike who licked it up, while at the same time Spike released inside Moondancer.

“Oh, yes.” Moondancer moaned, as Spike's cum filled her up.

“You two were great.” Spike said, as he sat up and hugged both Twilight and Moondancer giving them both a kiss, followed up by a playful breast grope.

“You were great to, Spike.” Twilight said.

“The best.” Moondancer agreed.

“Alright, eggheads, make some space.” Rainbow said, as she and Ember pulled the two girls away.

“Now it's our turn.” Ember said, as she and Rainbow got ready.

“Hope you're ready, big boy.” Rainbow said, as she started giving Spike a blowjob.

“Oh, Dashie.” Spike panted.

Ember took Spike's hands and placed them on her breasts, “You've got the best touch ever.” she said.

“They work best when feeling something soft.” Spike replied, as he fondled her.

Spike moaned, as Rainbow blew him, while massaging his man jewels, “Oh, Rainbow. Work it!” he moaned, as she picked up the pace before making him release in her mouth. She swallowed it, and spoke.

“Nice load, Spike. Still got more?”

“Always.”

“Then let me have some of that.” Ember said, as she swapped positions with Rainbow, and rode him like a cowgirl.

Rainbow meanwhile lowered her breasts down on Spike's face and smothered him with them.

Spike motorboated Rainbow's breasts, while enjoying Ember's riding. Eventually he released his load into her.

Ember panted, “Oh, Spike, your cum is amazing.

“Yeah, almost as great as Sweet Apple Cider. No offense.” Rainbow said.

“None taken.”

“Alright, ya'll, make some room because we want our piece of the action.” Applejack said, as she, Sunset Shimmer, Starlight, and Rarity swapped with the two.

“Four at a time? Oh, sweet.” Spike panted in enjoyment.

Sunset and Starlight got on both sides of Spike, and both each took a hand and made him grope the two. Down by his crotch, Applejack and Rarity were rubbing their breasts all around his manhood.

“Gosh, I never thought we'd be seeing this sweet thing again.” Applejack marveled at Spike's erection.

“I know what you mean, darling. It's been ages.” Rarity agreed.

“And I've really missed your tit fucks.” Spike admitted, as he relaxed.

“Whose do you prefer best?” Sunset Shimmer teased.

“Do tell, Spike.” Starlight smirked.

“Please don't make me.” Spike winced, as they continued to have their fun.

Eventually both Rarity and Applejack got Spike to cum on their faces, and they licked it off each other much to Spike's delight, 'Damn, I love seeing those two do that to each other.' he thought.

The girls started swapping positions with Starlight and Sunset going down to Spike's crotch and began licking his manhood to keep him hard.

“I'll take this one.” Starlight said, as she slid Spike's dick up inside her and started riding him, with Sunset groping Starlight from behind.

“Oh, Sunset, perfect!” Starlight moaned, while riding Spike.

“Now this is a threesome.” Spike moaned, but was cut off as Rarity leaned down and started Frenching Spike to keep his moans quiet.

“Alright, Rarity, one side.” Applejack took Rarity's place and started Frenching Spike as well.

Between the Frenching of both Rarity and Applejack along with getting ridden by Starlight, Spike having double the pleasure.

“Spike!” Starlight moaned

“Starlight!” Spike said between kissing A.J, before releasing inside Starlight.

“So good.” Starlight panted.

“I get next dibs.” Applejack said, as she got into position atop Spike and rode him like the cowgirl she was.

“Ride me, A.J!” Spike moaned.

“I'll ride ya to the heavens, partner!” Applejack cheered.

And Applejack rode Spike like crazy, before he inevitably released a load inside her, “Good enough for you, Applejack?”

“You always satisfy me.” she answered, while feeling overjoyed.

“I shall be taking my turn then.” Rarity said, before laying down and spread her legs for Spike.

Spike slid his dick into Rarity's pussy earning a gasp out of her, “You ok?” he asked in concern.

“Oh, yes. It's just been so long since you've been inside me. It caught me surprise.” she answered.

“Well, let me remind you on how good it feels to the two of us.”

“Yes, please.”

And so Spike started screwing around inside Rarity, who panted, “Oh, Spike. I remember this so well, darling.”

“That's right. Who's my dirty diva?” he teased.

“I am!”

“Yes you are.” Spike continued to screw Rarity until she released.

“Oh, Spikey. You always know how to make a lady feel good.” Rarity panted.

“I know.” Spike said, as he and Rarity kissed.

“Now it's our turn. right, Fluttershy?” Pinkie asked her timid friend.

Fluttershy giggled, “Yay.”

And so the two went to Spike and pressed themselves against his torso rubbing their breasts against him, “Every night I always dream my pillow is you, Spike.” Fluttershy cooed.

“Me too. Because every morning I always find my pillows covered in my drool.” Pinkie giggled.

“Was I any good in any of your dreams?' spike asked hopefully.

“Always the best.” Fluttershy assured him.

“Glad to hear it.” Spike smiled, as Pinkie Pie started nuzzling into Spike's chest and even licked his nipples making him moan.

“You like this, Spike?” Pinkie teased as she continued to lick his torso.

Fluttershy not wanting to be left out, started licking and kissing Spike's neck, “Oh, Fluttershy.” Spike moaned, as he held the two girls close. After plenty of cuddling, Fluttershy got on all fours and stuck her ass out giving Spike an opening.

Taking the hint, Spike inserted his dick inside Fluttershy and started screwing her, “Oh, Spike!” Fluttershy moaned, as Spike held onto her hips to keep her straight.

“How is it, Fluttershy?”

“So good. I missed this feeling so much.” she moaned.

“So have I.” Spike replied.

Spike screwed Fluttershy harder and harder before the timid girl released, “Oh, Spike. Only you could make me cum this much.”

“It's a talent.” he admitted proudly.

“Let me get some of that.” Pinkie said as she mounted Spike and rode him like a cowgirl.

“Pinkie, you almost have as much stamina as I do.” Spike panted, as he was being ridden.

“I'm just so spontaneous!” Pinkie cheered, as she rode Spike harder.

Pinkie rode Spike hard enough making him release a load inside her, “Pinkie, you never cease to amaze me.”

“I try.” she smiled.

Spike saw his last two girls were the twins who were both looking excited, “Well, girls, you're all that's left.”

“Yes!” Sunshine cheered.

“Oh, joy.” Moonlight said.

Spike smiled, as he opened his arms out, and the sisters crawled onto the bed and embraced him together. Spike took turns kissing the two individually before doing a three way kiss.

“Who's up first?” he asked.

“I am.” Sunshine cheered.

“Ok.” Spike said, as Sunshine wrapped her arms an legs around his body, while his dick went into her pussy.

“Let's make some magic, Spike.” Sunshine said.

“Show time.” Spike said.

And so the two began to screw while lip locking, until Moonlight came at Spike from behind, “Just because you're screwing my sister doesn't mean I can't have my own kind of fun until my turn.” she said, while rubbing her boobs against Spike’s back, and rubbed her sisters back.

In between Spike and Sunshine's make out, Sunshine leaned over Spike's shoulder to kiss her sister, which Moonlight gladly returned.

Sunshine moaned, as Spike's dick moved around inside her, “Spike, I'm almost there!”

“Don't hold back, Sunshine.” he ordered.

Sunshine released and panted, “That felt good.”

“You did great, sis.” Moonlight smiled.

“Thanks, Moonlight. I know you'll do great to.” Sunshine smiled back.

So the sisters swapped positions with Moonlight getting in front of Spike, and Sunshine getting behind him. Spike held the goth sister closer like he did Sunshine allowing his dick to slide up into her pussy, “Spike, give me the best feeling I could hope for.” she said.

“You want it you got it.” Spike answered, as the two screwed like he did Sunshine. Sunshine herself took the time to reach from behind Spike to kiss her sister.

Soon enough Moonlight spoke, “This is it, Spike.”

“Do it.” he replied, as Moonlight released.

“Whoa. That was perfect.” she panted.

“I know,” Spike smiled, as he slid himself out of her pussy. Spike looked over and saw all the girls grinning at him, “Girls, you have that look.”

“We know.” Rainbow kept her grin up.

“If you thought that fun was wild, Spike, you haven't seen what we got coming up.” Ember said.

“Girls, it's go time.” Sunset said.

“Get him!” Twilight called, as all of them piled atop the bed and proceeded to have their humongous orgasm with Spike and each other.

In the midst of all sex, Spike was enticed by the girls making out with him, and screwing around with each other, 'If this were an online porn video it'd break the view counter.' he thought, as he enjoyed himself with his harem to the fullest.

Afterward, Spike and the girls were lying on the bed, with the girls trying to get as close to Spike as they could, “Wow. That was just... Holy shit.” Spike panted.

“I know.” Applejack agreed.

“Even better than Prom night.” Pinkie added.

“Wish we could've gotten that lucky during prom.” Sunset Shimmer sighed on behalf of herself and her group.

“Hey, what can ya do?” Moonlight asked rhetorically.

Spike and the girls sat up, as the young man spoke, “Thank you so much for all this, girls. I still feel bad about not telling you all about each other sooner.”

“What's done is done, Spike,” Twilight began as she put an arm around him, “But remember you shouldn't have to keep these kind of secrets from us.”

“And it's good that the girls you've been with are girls we got to know during college.” Starlight admitted.

“And not some group of no brained sluts.” Moondancer put in.

“We're a full on harem now. And that's how it's gonna be.” Rainbow said.

“I love you girls all so much.” Spike smiled with tears of happiness.

“And we love you to, Darling.” Rarity said. One by one each girl received a kiss from Spike, as they all cuddled up with Spike for a while longer.


That night back at Spike's home, the boy pulled out his cellphone and did a face time with Thorax. When his face appeared on Spike's screen, the boy cried, “Spike! You're still alive!”

“Of course I am.”

“What the hell happened with the girls? Did they break up with you? Don't skimp out on the details no matter how painful it may be.” Thorax demanded.

“Thorax! Relax. Everything's all good. In fact they couldn't be better.” Spike assured him.

“I don't understand.” Thorax said in confusion.

So Spike explained everything to Thorax who was more shocked than before, “Let me get this straight. They competed for you, you confessed, and now they all wanna share you?!”

“That sums it up.” Spike confirmed.

“Dammit! How can things work out this way for you?!”

“I'm damn lucky as hell.” he answered.

“No kidding. So what happens now since your cuties from Canterlot are going to be here for a few more days?” Thorax inquired.

“Actually, tomorrow we're all hitting the beach.”

“The beach? You better get plenty of pictures of them because I need to see how they look.” Thorax demanded.

Spike chuckled, “Ok, Thorax. I'll be sure to get plenty of pictures with them for you to see.”

“Thank you.” Thorax said, before they ended their chat.

Spike smiled, as he looked through his phone pictures and saw one of himself and all the girls who were fully clothed and washed up after their ogry, “Girls, I am truly lucky to have all of you in my life.” he said to himself.


Author's Note

Hope you enjoyed that, and once again I ask for any potential ideas that could happen with Spike and the girls on the beach.

Next Chapter