Sunscreen
Chapter Three: An Enchanting Pet
-by Drace Domino

Sunset Shimmer squeezed her cock one last time, milking the last few drops of cum from the tip. Once she’d finished, she swung her member up and down, tapping it against the rim of the glass to make sure she’d salvage everything she possibly could. The end result was a glass stolen from the cafeteria that was half-filled with warm, rich, white magical cum, and as Sunset lifted it up the eyes of her current companion widened all the further.

“Oh...my...goodness, darling!” Rarity whispered breathlessly, keeping her voice low so they weren’t discovered. She and Sunset had snuck off during lunch to have themselves a bit of fun, and now the two were hiding in one of the storage closets of CHS. As Sunset swung the glass of cum from side to side, Rarity’s eyes tracked it like a cat watching a laser pointer, her thighs squeezing together and the excitement apparent in her tone. “May...may I drink it now, Sunset? Please?!”

“Well, I don’t know…” Sunset Shimmer teased, her free hand moving to half-tuck her cock back into her panties. It was a lackluster job, and even now the top edge of the garment was threatening to allow her to tumble out once more. As she leaned back with her glass of magical cum still warm in her palm, Sunset arched a brow and looked at Rarity with a playful smile - watching her friend squirm was always a rewarding experience. “Are you gonna let me fuck you before lunch is over?”

Rarity, nodding so fast and so hard that it messed up her hair, practically yelped in glee at the proposal. A hard cock and a warm glass of cum? It was a win/win situation for the fashionista, and she shook with delight when Sunset Shimmer handed her the glass. Without hesitation and with her eyes burning in an intense hunger, Rarity dipped the edge of the glass to her lips, tilting her head back and allowing that creamy white nectar to slowly, stickily, slide ever-closer to her waiting mouth.

“Slow, Rarity. Drink it slow,” Sunset Shimmer cooed, and gave the back of her pet’s head a sweet, gentle stroke. Once she did, the sinister young woman dropped down to her knees behind the other girl, lifting Rarity’s skirt and pulling aside her panties, ready to help herself to that warm, ivory pussy. “I want to watch you enjoy it while I pound your hot little cunt.”

Rarity, with a blush on her cheeks that was fueled not only by the magical arousal rushing through her but the shameful, scandalous delight of the moment, gave a tiny swallow before nodding with an eager bob of her head.

“Y-Yes, Sunset!” She shivered, and eased her hips back when the first glancing touch of a cockhead moved across her folds. “Ohh, you’re absolutely spoiling me, darling!”

The bell rang no more than ten minutes later, and Sunset Shimmer slithered from the storage closet looking as sleazy as possible. The halls were already filled with students transitioning to their next class, but she knew one girl that’d be late - the well-fucked, cum-filled fashionista that was currently in the room behind her recovering from a surprisingly rough fuck. When she stepped out into the hall Rarity was still braced on her knees with her shoulders and cheek to the ground, cum dripping from her overflowing pussy in a thick line the same color as her flawless skin. Naturally, Sunset Shimmer opted to lean against the storage closet door while the students all walked to their next class, standing guard for her favored pet while she recovered. It was, after all, the nice thing to do. The friendly thing to do.

“Sunset Shimmer! Oh, hello, Sunset Shimmer!” A sweet voice filled the air no more than two minutes after Sunset emerged, and it was enough to draw the girl’s attention to a rapidly-approaching figure in the hallway. A trail of beautifully soft pink hair framed pale yellow features sporting a genuine kindness - one of the prettiest girls at CHS to be certain, but also among the most humble. Fluttershy stepped up to Sunset looking as if she had something to say, but as soon as she stood a foot away from the other girl she immediately fell into a position of blushing shyness. “Oh! Uhm...uh...h-hello. Uh...Sunset, I...I wanted to...ask...if y--”

“Fuck’s sakes, spit it out, Fluttershy.” Sunset Shimmer rolled her eyes, and tightened her arms against her chest. As she leaned against the storage closet door Sunset couldn’t help but feel like the top stud of the whole damned school - the scent of Rarity’s sweat and hunger clinging to her body, the satisfying feel of a spent cock nestled within her panties, and the knowledge that Rarity’s cum-dripping slit was as close to her as Fluttershy was enough to make any girl preen with confidence. “Don’t have all day to listen to you ramble.”

“I’m...I’m sorry!” Fluttershy squeaked, and half-recoiled from Sunset’s harsh words. Harsh, but by the same token, much, much kinder than how she used to speak to CHS’s top sweetheart. “I was just wondering, if...if uh, you knew where Rarity was? I saw the two of you leave the cafeteria during lunch, and...and uh, well, Rarity promised she’d come help me take care of some animals after school, and…”

“Rarity’s busy after school,” Sunset Shimmer responded simply, and shrugged. At least, she planned for Rarity to be busy. Though as she leaned back on the door and pondered her plans, Sunset couldn’t help but study the offering that was right there in front of her. Fluttershy was drop dead gorgeous, and when it came to girls that were naive and easy to take advantage of, she was at the very meek head of the pack. It was enough to draw Sunset’s attention, and she allowed her look to soften for the moment - long enough to ease Fluttershy further. “Hey. I like animals.” She was, after all, partial to ponies. “Maybe I can help you out instead? Rarity has to make a...uh...dress.”

“Well, that does sound like Rarity,” Fluttershy murmured, but judging by the look on her face, couldn’t have been any more put off by the suggestion of her replacement. She took a half-step back and recoiled further, nibbling her bottom lip and hiding half of her face behind a long curtain of pink hair. “That’s...that’s okay, Sunset. It’s nice of you to offer, but, but, but...I don’t...I don’t think you’d have fun.”

Oh, how wrong she was. Sunset Shimmer would definitely have fun...and so would Fluttershy, if she played along. Sunset Shimmer was quick to reach out, her bare hand flexing its Rarity-scented fingers before casually stretching forward. She teased the tips of her fingers across Fluttershy’s exposed arm from her shoulder all the way down to the elbow, drawing across her flesh a long, friendly, flirty line while her magic started to take effect. It was almost instantaneous in bringing her results - as soon as her digits stroked over Fluttershy’s skin, the timid young woman’s back straightened and her head lifted, her hair falling to the side to reveal a face that was already wearing trust and friendliness. She even started to smile with a tiny tug at the corner of her lips, and Sunset Shimmer encouraged that behavior with her voice sliding forward with a surprisingly gentle coo.

“C’mon, Fluttershy, I know I haven’t always been nice to you.” Specifically, never. She had never been nice to her. But in her defense, it was before she had the idea to fuck her. “But I’m friends with Rarity and Pinkie Pie now. Maybe we can be friends, too…? I know I’m a little rough around the edges, but I’m all soft and fuzzy beneath that. Like...like a…” she leaned back, rubbing her chin in pondering fashion. “Like some kind of...big animal that everyone thinks is mean, but is really, really cute…”

“A bear?! You’re like a bear?!” Fluttershy’s eyes widened and she giggled, rocking back and forth on her heels. It was the sort of cheesy leading that would almost certainly never have worked if it wasn’t for Sunset’s magic, but everything that afternoon was leading towards Sunset getting another new lover. Fluttershy’s trusting nature and her vulnerable position, her eagerness for comfort and consolation, a bit of Equestrian magic...oh yes, she’d be all too easy for Sunset to claim within her grasp. “Oh, you’re right, Sunset! I’m sorry if I was being fussy! I’d love to have you help out!”

“Wonderful, I’d love to have you, too.” Sunset Shimmer smiled, before squinting and correcting herself. “I mean I’d love to help, too. I’ll meet you after school. Now run along, okay? I’m trying to look like a cool loner here.”

Fluttershy giggled and waved as she left, moving with the crowd and heading off to her next class once more. Sunset Shimmer just grinned - a smug look of self-satisfaction plastered on her face and her magical cock twitching underneath the edge of her panties. Another pussy. Another pet. Another lover to keep her more primal instincts in check while they edged ever-closer to the Fall Formal. It was still a few months away and with it, the opening of the portal back to Equestria - and Sunset Shimmer was going to need plenty of warm teenage pussies to keep her from getting too bored by then. And speaking of…

The sinister young woman waited until everyone had moved around the corner, and only then did she slink back into the storage closet. As the door closed behind her she saw Rarity just finishing getting dressed - pulling her panties back up along her thighs, and wearing a look of glistening pleasure across her lips. Considering how little cum there was on the floor, it was a safe bet the fashionista couldn’t bear to waste such a delicious snack. As Sunset slipped inside Rarity tilted her head, looking curiously at Sunset while the other girl hitched her hands to her jeans and started to once more undo her belt.

“Gonna have to cancel our after-school plans, Rarity, something came up,” she remarked, just as that thick amber length flopped out and into her open palm. “Looks like we’re gonna miss Social Studies if you really want to get fucked again today.”

Rarity, with her throat tightening in a nervous swallow and her thighs subtly pressing together, weighed her options for all of two seconds before responding.

“...Ms. Harshwhinny gives such boring lectures, darling,” she remarked, just as she dropped again to her knees, ready to suck the dick of the best friend she’d ever, ever, ever have.

Or so Sunset would have her believe.

***

It was hours later before Sunset Shimmer finally got her chance. Hours. Hours spent feeding cats, walking dogs, and touching snakes and lizards so they “got used to it,” whatever the hell that was supposed to mean. When she offered to help out Fluttershy with her volunteer work, she never expected that it’d be such a long endeavor, and on more than one occasion she thought about saying to hell with it and ditching. Unfortunately, doing so would almost certainly shatter the work she’d already put in getting Fluttershy to trust her, and while she was sure that she could earn it back with a few affectionate touches, an upset Fluttershy could do a lot of harm to her public image. The last thing she needed was Fluttershy sniffling and sobbing about how Sunset drove her out to the shelter, got bored, and then left her stranded and having to walk home.

Besides, the drive back offered Sunset certain...opportunities, and she was confident that by the time the evening was over, Fluttershy’s pussy would be worth the cat bites and dog slobber.

“Gosh, Sunset Shimmer, you sure were great with all those animals.” Fluttershy smiled from the passenger’s seat, her hands folded neatly in her lap and her eyes shining. In truth, Sunset was awful with them - but that certainly wasn’t the perception the magic-addled young woman had. “All of those adorable puppies and kittens sure liked you! Oh, and that great big iguana just couldn’t get enough of your hair!”

“I never want to talk about the iguana again,” Sunset Shimmer interjected, an eye twitching as her hands tightened upon the steering wheel. She guided them down the road but pointedly started to turn down a side path, one that twisted them away from the core part of the city and towards her remote apartment. While she drove, Fluttershy’s head tilted curiously, and she chimed up in her typically soft, delicate voice.

“This isn’t the way back to CHS.” Fluttershy blinked. “Where are we going, Sunset?” The fact that there wasn’t any nervousness in her voice was a testament to just how much she trusted the other girl by now. Typically, Fluttershy was defined by her social awkwardness and fear of the unknown, but now as a sinister bitch guided her down an unknown road, there was nothing but trust in her tone. Trust that Sunset would only betray in the most pleasing of fashions, of course.

“All of those animals sure were fun.” Sunset had to grit her teeth while saying it, once more remembering the creepy, painful feeling of iguana claws in her hair. “But after spending four hours there, I--” She paused, looked at the clock on the dash again, and grumbled to herself. “Really? Four fucking hours? Uh, I mean--after having so much fun, there’s one problem I need to take care of.”

Fluttershy was completely trusting and innocent, and just to make sure she stayed that way Sunset stretched a hand out and dropped it over the other girl’s, giving it a small squeeze. The fact that Fluttershy’s hand turned palm-up was a good sign, and the two shared a sweet smile as Sunset gave the trusting young woman another touch of Equestrian magic. It was more than enough to keep her complacent and stop her from asking questions until they were finally parked out front of Sunset’s apartment, at which point the redhead started to unbuckle herself while gesturing to the stairs leading up to the entrance.

“This is my place,” she began. “And...all those animals kind of left me smelling...less than pleasant.”

“Ohh, you don’t like it?” Fluttershy’s head tilted, as if she didn’t understand the statement on a basic level. “Why, I think it’s such a cute and cuddly smell!”

Once again, Sunset Shimmer’s eye twitched, and she resisted the urge to point out that smells could not, in fact, be cute and cuddly. If she didn’t get this hot young thing naked and moaning soon she was almost certainly going to snap, her frustration starting to bubble over just like the hamster that peed in her hand. She really, really, really didn’t like animals.

“...I really need to grab a shower,” Sunset Shimmer blurted out, and to make sure her upcoming offer was accepted, stretched out to grab one of Fluttershy’s hands. This time she let her fingers interlink with the timid girl’s own, squeezing palm-to-palm while she continued her thought. “How about you join me? We’ll get all nice and clean together.”

It was a bold request, considering who Fluttershy was. If she made the offer to an athlete like Rainbow Dash it could’ve easily been played off as a casual thing, or at the very least, as something Dash had almost certainly done before. But Fluttershy was a girl that actively hid after gym class so she didn’t have to shower with the other girls, and even now her cheeks were overtaken by a deep, heavy blush. She almost certainly would’ve run squeaking and whimpering into the hills if it wasn’t for Sunset Shimmer’s hand in hers, feeding her a steady, constant drip of magic that reassured her of the simple fact that she could trust her. Even though she really, really couldn’t.

“W-Well, I...I...uh...I never showered with...with any--”

“Hey, all the better.” Sunset Shimmer smiled, and squeezed the other girl’s hand a little tighter. “It’s scary showering with a bunch of girls you don’t know that well, but when it’s just someone you trust? When it’s one of your best friends?”

She was laying it on thick because she knew she needed to. It’d take every drop of Equestrian manipulation magic and every ounce of her own sinister thoughts to break through Fluttershy’s natural timid nature, but thankfully, it was enough. As she fed Fluttershy’s insecurities with the other students of CHS while reinforcing their own bond, soon she could feel Fluttershy’s hand tremble within hers, just before it slipped out to reach for the buckle of her seatbelt.

“That...that sounds...nice.” Fluttershy blushed as she admitted as much, and gave Sunset a kind smile. “Promise you won’t peek?”

“I promise,” Sunset Shimmer lied with an enormous smile on her face, knowing that before long, Fluttershy would be doing more than she ever imagined when she woke up in the morning.

***

There was a small mountain of clothes laying just outside the bathroom door of Sunset Shimmer’s apartment, and from within there was the constant, steady, heavy sound of spraying water as it crashed down upon two naked teenage bodies. Underneath the noise of beating water came an undercurrent of tiny whimpers and moans - the sounds of a pink-haired beauty with a faltering resolve, the gasps of a virginal, adorable thing that was about to be taken advantage of by a wicked girl that only cared about her holes.

“Fluttershy, your hair is just so pretty…” Sunset Shimmer cooed, standing behind the other girl with her fingers covered in shampoo as they worked through Fluttershy’s locks. It was an easy enough position to guide herself into, and all a part of her sinister plan - the shelter got them to the car, the car got them to the shower, the shower got her to the shampoo, and soon she’d be enjoying where the shampoo would lead. Fluttershy was already a quivering mess as she stood below the spray of the shower, her eyes closed while shampoo glazed down her face and across her bare shoulders, even rolling down over a bust that was surprisingly large considering her timid nature. It was desperately tempting for Sunset Shimmer to just grab her tits and grind forward, but Fluttershy still required patience. Besides - the young woman was so timid and eager to avert her gaze from Sunset, she still hadn’t noticed the massive cock that was hanging between her thighs or the amulet draped casually around her neck. She was little more than a responsive body packed with gasps and trembles, and Sunset Shimmer was easing Fluttershy into the moment with lilac-scented suds and a soothing, compassionate voice. And plenty of Equestrian magic, of course. “And it’s so soft. Can I tell you a secret? I’ve always been jealous of your hair.”

“Y-Y-Y-You?” Fluttershy half-squeaked out, her eyes still closed while Sunset’s fingers worked through her soft pink locks. It was the most she’d spoken since the two of them stepped into the shower, and even now sounded like she was ready to burst from nervousness and social anxiety. Sunset Shimmer kept Fluttershy’s fear-based instincts in check with a soothing voice she delivered just at the back of the other girl’s ear, making quite sure to never drift so far forward as to alert her of that stiffening cock.

“Absolutely,” Sunset cooed, and even nudged Fluttershy’s cheek with the tip of her nose. Her motions were softer and sweeter now, urging Fluttershy’s head just underneath the spray of the water. It was a motion made for two purposes - first to wash away the suds from the girl’s beautiful head of hair, and second to add a level of louder noise for her voice to penetrate, hoping to overwhelm Fluttershy’s better senses with every passing whisper. “I’m jealous of so much about you. I look at you, Fluttershy, and I see a girl I really...really...wish I could be like.

Like. Inside. What difference did it make?

Fluttershy squeaked predictably at the praise, her nerves still overwhelming her as Sunset Shimmer continued to dote on her. For a lewd conquest that was only possible with lies and magical alteration, Sunset Shimmer was treating her with true kindness - taking her time to make Fluttershy comfortable and cared for, ensuring that no one moment was too much for her to bear. Before long she had layered her hands with a dose of lather from her body wash, and from there the true fun began. Her hands passed over Fluttershy’s shoulders, arms, trembling tummy, shivering waist...every motion offered with a surprising gentleness and kindness, and every touch taken with Fluttershy’s comfort in mind. Before long, though, it became clear that she’d only have one more area to clean up on Fluttershy’s torso - the big, plump, breasts of a teenage girl that was too shy to show them off. Sunset Shimmer’s soap-covered fingers lingered at Fluttershy’s belly, one finger tracing idly around her belly button as she whispered at the back of the other girl’s neck.

“Fluttershy, I’m going to clean your chest now,” she cooed, and waited for Fluttershy’s whimper to fade before sliding her hands upward. “Don’t worry. This is just what girls do for each other in the shower.”

It absolutely, irrevocably, entirely was not what they did for each other, but considering how Fluttershy hid during gym there was no way for her to know that for certain. Not that it mattered - with so much Equestrian magic offered up through touches and caresses and doting whispers, Sunset Shimmer could’ve convinced her of anything that night. Her hands finally crossed the last few inches towards Fluttershy’s breasts and pulled up and across them, her fingers stretching out as she coated each of the young woman’s perfectly plump tits in a thick lather of suds. As soon as she did so, Fluttershy gave a sharp and sudden gasp and bucked her hips back against Sunset’s lap, swiftly informing her just what her friend was packing. It was a lot to assault the timid girl’s senses all at once, and with so much going on Fluttershy couldn’t muster up anything more than a pathetic little murmur, just before settling into place and letting it all happen. Her blush intensified and she squirmed back and forth, grinding her backside against Sunset Shimmer’s thick, twitching cock as the hot shower continued pouring over them.

“There we go...isn’t that nice? Relaxing? Feeling nice and clean?” Sunset Shimmer’s smile was slow and predatory, and she even dared to bring it close to Fluttershy’s throat while she worked. Her hands were moving with expert precision through the suds, ensuring that each of Fluttershy’s tits were completely coated - at least enough to half-obscure the attention of her hands. Fluttershy didn’t notice she was making a beeline for her nipples until it was too late, with her digits pinching them tenderly and tweaking each one under the guise of cleaning her off. “Fluttershy, you’re so tense...but don’t worry, it’s just me here. And we’re such good friends now, aren’t we?”

“W...W...We are.” Fluttershy nodded, with a sweep of soaked pink hair half-hiding her face and with her body reclining against Sunset Shimmer. She no doubt felt that enormous length pushing against her backside, wedged up against Sunset’s belly and caught between them, but for the moment she was so distracted by the hands on her breasts that she could only focus on them. She swallowed nervously and shuddered in a state of veiled arousal - the sort that not even she knew she was experiencing, and likely wouldn’t until it was too late. “Do...do you want me to clean you off, too?”

“Not if you’re too shy, I wouldn’t want to make you uncomfortable,” Sunset Shimmer lied, but even in the same moment released one of Fluttershy’s breasts, moving it up to wrap around her wrist. She was already encouraging Fluttershy to reach behind herself - purposefully sweeping the girl’s hand through a coating of sudsy lather as she did so. “But...if you wanted to try cleaning me, well...I promise I wouldn’t tease you even if you didn’t do a good job.”

Reassurances built-in with condescension. Comfort built upon exploitation. Sunset Shimmer was taking advantage of this trusting sweetheart like a shark that smelled a fresh meal, her smile intensifying the whole time. It wasn’t long before Fluttershy was slowly turning around to face her, those lovely, soap-covered breasts bouncing against Sunset’s own and her hand being guided straight to the other girl’s amber length. Sunset Shimmer shamelessly and gleefully helped Fluttershy wrap her hand around her member at the hilt, and she did it with enough gentle coercing that not only did it feel completely natural, but actually seemed like Fluttershy’s own idea. It was such a convincing and masterful piece of manipulation that Fluttershy already started to stroke her, nibbling her bottom lip as those delicate fingers went from the base to the tip again and again, keeping Sunset’s throbbing length covered in suds.

“Like...like this?” Fluttershy nibbled her bottom lip, blushing wildly and still half-hiding her face with her hair. “I’m...I’m not hurting you, am I?”

Sunset Shimmer just grinned, and let her hands stretch out to answer Fluttershy with caresses and touches rather than words. While the timid young woman gave her a gentle handjob with body wash-covered fingers, Sunset put in the work to make her more comfortable - slipping digits behind Fluttershy’s hair to sweep it away from her face, teasing her palms down the girl’s arms to soothe her, even gently caressing her backside to nudge her a little closer. When Sunset’s soap-covered tip nudged against Fluttershy’s belly the timid girl squeaked in surprise, but Sunset was quick to ease it back and forth and draw a line of glistening precum across Fluttershy’s belly, just to let her know there was nothing to be afraid of. That big, pulsing, scary dick wasn’t going to hurt her - and in fact, it seemed damn fond of her gentle gestures of affection.

“Mmm, just like that, Fluttershy.” Sunset Shimmer closed her eyes, letting herself rest in that moment. With the shower beating down against them and Fluttershy’s fingers passing up and down her shaft, the sinister manipulator was free to bask in her attention and enjoy her reward. It had been earned through a long hassle of tending animals and putting up with Fluttershy being afraid of her own shadow - a frustrating evening to be sure, but one that was leading to a fantastic end. Her hips rocked back and forth, her hands continued to tease and touch along Fluttershy’s naked figure, and when the pink-haired sweetheart dared to reach a second hand down to join the first, it was enough that Sunset herself gasped.

“Ah…!” She blushed heavily, opening her eyes and looking back at Fluttershy. “Whew...I...I didn’t expect that.”

“Is it okay?” Fluttershy blinked, her newly-added hand fondling Sunset’s sack, coating it with the same heavy lather. By that point her breasts were squished up against Sunset’s own and their faces were desperately near - so close that Sunset found herself drifting closer and closer. “Am...am I doing this ri--”

Her voice fell into a tiny, muted squeak as Sunset closed the distance between them, bringing her mouth against Fluttershy’s own for a sweet, sensitive, tender kiss. At least, one that seemed like it was all those things, even though it was really just coming from a place of profane manipulation by a twisted, deceitful bitch. In the end it didn’t matter, because Fluttershy absolutely crumbled underneath the attention, and Sunset Shimmer found her peak creeping upon her quicker than she had imagined it would. The kiss between the two was chaste compared to everything else about the evening, with Sunset’s head gently tilted and Fluttershy just barely pressing back. Their lips remained closed as they shared an intimate moment underneath the spray of the shower, so fierce and constant that it swept away all of the suds and lather that they’d coated themselves in. By that point there was nothing but water on flesh, whether it was two pairs of teenage breasts rubbing together or the quivering hand of Fluttershy as it pumped Sunset Shimmer faster and faster, the pink-haired beauty’s instincts pushing her to keep tugging on that throbbing length until--

“Hnng!” Sunset Shimmer suddenly tensed within Fluttershy’s palm, and she pulled back from the kiss just enough for the other girl to see her vulnerability in that moment. The heavy blush, the strained look of immense delight, the closed eyes...the sight of a girl that was seemingly just as swept up in the moment as Fluttershy was, and her body was serving as the proof. Her peak rumbled through her with her cocktip pointed squarely at Fluttershy’s belly, and when she started to cum it surged ahead to squirt straight across the girl’s pale yellow flesh. She shivered and twitched, but even within the thrill of her climax Sunset Shimmer shuffled a few steps to the side, interjecting her back between Fluttershy and the shower spray. After all, that cum she was firing against the timid young woman’s belly would be considered quite the precious commodity before too long, and every drop that got swept up in the water was yet another tragedy.

By the time it ended, Sunset’s member hung soft and tender in Fluttershy’s grasp - a grasp that was coated in thick white spunk, the same as her trembling tummy. The pink-haired girl released Sunset after just a few more seconds and a few more squeezes, pulling her palm slowly upward into her line of sight, her eyes growing wider and wider as she did so. She was holding a small pool of cum in the very center of her palm and gazing at it with fascination - there was something about it that was downright captivating. Sunset Shimmer’s predatory smile intensified as she let her head drift close, kissing at Fluttershy’s wrist while she whispered in a prodding, encouraging tone.

“Go ahead, Fluttershy,” she urged her, and swung her hips forward just enough to nudge Fluttershy’s cum-slickened belly with her dick. “Taste it.”

“I...I...oh my, I’ve never even dreamed of doing something like this before, I…” Fluttershy was clearly unsure of things, and yet the magical compulsion pushed her forward. It was a testament to Sunset Shimmer’s prowess, both in terms of her magical acumen and her gift for manipulation, that Fluttershy so smoothly pulled her palm up to her lips and allowed her tongue to slither out. With a tiny tilt backward she ushered the small mouthful of cum past her lips and across her tongue, and as soon as her mouth sealed once more the results were immediate and intense. “Mmm…!”

Fluttershy’s eyes went wide, and the shy blush was replaced with one of heady, hungry desire. Her tongue battered back and forth within her mouth as she kept sampling her first taste of heaven, and her hand was already lowering once more to where her belly was still soaked. She pooled up more cum and greedily ushered it into her mouth with a zeal that was Pinkie Pie-esque in nature, this time licking her lips and managing to squeak out a few words towards Sunset as she did so.

“This...this tastes so good, Sunset!” She rocked back and forth on her heels, squirming and shivering and serving as a wet, horny bundle of teenage bliss. With her thighs rubbing together and her eyes going desperately wide, she looked to Sunset Shimmer for answers - and of course, more of her cum. “Can I have more?! Can we do more?! I...I don’t know what I want, but I...I just...I...want!”

The poor thing had no answers, but lucky for her, Sunset Shimmer was there to guide her. With a coy smile and a flash of her sinister eyes, Sunset turned towards the showerhead and switched the faucet off, leaving them both damp and dripping in the tub. Wordlessly, she reached down to claim one of Fluttershy’s wrists in her hand as she began moving from the bathroom and back into her apartment’s living quarters - her smile growing just as rapidly as Sunset Shimmer’s hunger.

This one was more effort than her other two pets, but she was becoming increasingly certain that Fluttershy would be well worth the effort.

***

Shy, innocent pussy was the tightest of all. At least, that was Sunset’s experience so far. She still had to try cocky bitch cunt and rustic farm girl ass, but right now? Fluttershy was giving her the best grip she’d ever known. The two girls had retired to Sunset Shimmer’s bed in the loft of her apartment, with Fluttershy laying flat on her back and inviting the seemingly kind and considerate Sunset inside. They were still warm and wet from the shower ensuring that the sheets would be thoroughly damp by the time they went to bed, but neither girl seemed to mind - after all, they’d no doubt be sweaty and toasty by the time they were finished anyway. With Fluttershy’s knees up on her shoulders and her lap grinding against the other girl’s own, Sunset clenched her teeth and shuddered in delight, whispering in a barely-contained lust against Fluttershy’s throat.

“You feel so good,” she half-growled, her face buried against the crook of Fluttershy’s neck while she worked. The timid young woman’s hands had passed up and over her shoulders to cling to her, and even though Fluttershy was leaning back with her knees pressed to her chest and her pussy tightly gripping a throbbing amber cock, she looked downright innocent in that moment. A heavy blush riding her face, her voice escaping in squeaks and gasps of gentle tenderness, and her fingers tightening on Sunset’s figure as the other girl kept growling against her. “I could fuck you all night long. Think I will.”

“Y-Yes...please…” Fluttershy gasped, her nails digging in against Sunset’s flesh as she tightened every muscle of her body. The looming presence of her newest friend was nearly overwhelming for her, and with the taste of magical cum still playing on her tongue, she was all too ready to give everything to Sunset. Her whole evening could be an experience in being used as the other girl’s toy and Fluttershy would’ve been thrilled at the honor - and it certainly seemed like that was the way things were going. “Wh...whatever you want, Sunset, just...I want to feel like this some more!”

Just like Rarity, just like Pinkie Pie, behind the layers of “good girl” nonsense, Fluttershy had the potential to be just as slutty as the rest of them. Sunset Shimmer’s smile was enormous as she kept pumping forward, making sure to keep driving her cock down into the other girl’s depths. Her thrusts were short but particularly hard, always making sure to stir that quivering pussy with a greedy, downright possessive authority. Fluttershy herself was absolutely soaked and her nethers were milking Sunset for all they were worth, speaking of a particularly horny little minx underneath the layers of fidgeting embarrassment. And as fun as fucking her was, Sunset couldn’t help but keep pushing the envelope of Fluttershy’s blushing shyness - and the perfect method to make Fluttershy erupt popped into her mind in that moment. She pulled her head back just enough to gaze at Fluttershy’s eyes, their lips hovering in a near-kiss while Sunset started to whisper.

“Want to know how I made friends with Rarity and Pinkie Pie?” she asked, her brow arching with the confession teasing against her tongue. “Been a few weeks. Bet you and the others were curious why we started hanging out.”

“I...I...y-yes,” Fluttershy admitted. She was trying her best to stay focused on Sunset Shimmer’s words, but it was rather difficult to do so while she also lost her virginity, her tender pussy constantly spasming around that girthy length. “You...you seemed so mean before, we didn’t think you...you liked us…”

“I like your little group as much as I like any of the students at CHS.” Sunset smirked, and told the absolute truth in doing so. She just left out what an intensely low bar that was. With her grin growing she closed a bit of the distance between her and Fluttershy’s mouths, and in doing so ushered the heated breath of her whisper across the innocent young woman’s trembling lips. “We’re all friends now because we fuck. Me and Rarity. Me and Pinkie Pie. And now...me and you.”

It was a bold statement on Sunset Shimmer’s part, soiling Fluttershy’s first time with the knowledge that she wasn’t unique. Still, the sinister bitch was sure that her control over the shy young woman would be more than enough to keep Fluttershy excited no matter what she told her, and sure enough that much was true as Fluttershy stared back at her with blushing amazement. Her cheeks were absolutely overtaken in a darker shade just as her body twitched and trembled, quite clearly inching ever closer to her first cock-stirred climax. Sunset Shimmer slid a hand to grope at one of Fluttershy’s lovely plump tits as she kept fucking her, and leaned back in all of her smug glory as she continued along that train of thought.

“That’s right, Fluttershy,” she whispered, all while her hips kept driving back and forth and her cock continued to explore Fluttershy’s nethers. She spoke in a voice that was only barely audible over the steady noise of flesh slapping on flesh, but the confidence and the self-satisfaction were still apparent in every word. “Earlier in the hall? I just got done fucking Rarity. And yesterday when Pinkie Pie rode home with me? She sucked my cock while I was driving. We have so much fun together...and now you and me? We get to have fun like that, too.”

Fluttershy still couldn’t form words beyond her nervous squeaking, her world crumbling right before her and suddenly being rebuilt into something tawdry, lewd, and naughty. The knowledge that all of the times Rarity and Pinkie Pie were hanging out with Sunset over the past few weeks was laced with a hidden desire, it was almost too scandalous for Fluttershy’s innocent mind to process, and that rush of excitement made her tighten all the more around that amber dick stirring her. With her blush sweeping from her cheeks to her chest she unleashed a sudden moan, toes curling and eyes closing as her body began to tremble. She was intensely close to her peak now, and Sunset Shimmer sought to keep her in that moment. With her arms tightening around both of Fluttershy’s legs, Sunset lunged forward and started to buck with wider thrusts, yanking back until she could feel her cockhead nearly pop out before plunging straight down to the hilt once more. The steady sound of slapping flesh filled the air around them as Sunset claimed her latest prize, and her voice picked up in volume and authority as she pushed them both towards the finale.

“Isn’t it great, Fluttershy?!” she boasted, eyes flashing with venomous delight. “Isn’t friendship wonderful?! It’s almost as great as your awesome...tight...pussy!”

She slammed forward once more, her balls slapping against Fluttershy’s backside and her tip lunging deep into the innocent girl’s entrance. With that final thrust she pushed both herself and Fluttershy completely over the brink, with Sunset’s head snapping back as she unleashed a hungry moan and Fluttershy’s whimpering gasps immediately turning into screams of orgasmic, wordless noise. The two teenagers convulsed against each other while Sunset’s member throbbed in that once-virginal valley, pouring squirt after squirt of hot, white cream directly into her tender hole. It was hardly the first climax Sunset had that day but it was easily the most thrilling, with the captivating sight of Fluttershy’s twitching body underneath her and the sounds of her moans filling the air around them. Claiming Rarity and Pinkie Pie were rewarding enough, but this? This moment when she ushered Fluttershy into corruption as well? It was the pinnacle of Sunset Shimmer’s sinister actions at CHS - the most wicked, deceitful, selfish thing she’d done.

So far.

Despite the lies and the manipulation and the magically-driven dominance, Fluttershy’s orgasm was genuine and shook the girl down to her core. While cum poured inside of her she writhed against the bed, screaming so throaty and hard that it was clear that even without Sunset’s influence, there really was something of a dirty girl underneath the blushing and the pink hair. The sheets were a little more damp by the time they finished, and when both girls stopped trembling, Sunset simply rested there on her knees, keeping her massive member stuffed inside of Fluttershy and forcing her to endure just how girthy it was within a valley that was left sensitive and raw. Before long she dropped Fluttershy’s legs to the mattress and let her hands stretch out, one moving to fondle a big, pale yellow tit while the other walked fingers down Fluttershy’s belly so she could smooth her thumb across Fluttershy’s twitching hood.

Fluttershy shivered underneath the attention, sweaty and exhausted and practically glowing. When she finally regained her senses she managed to look up at the other girl that loomed above her - wearing nothing but sweat, a smile, and a gorgeous amulet draped around her neck - and even though she’d just lost her innocence, even though she knew that she was just one of many girls that had been in that position, Fluttershy practically melted underneath the attention.

“Oh, oh Sunset, that...that was…” She squirmed back and forth, and in doing so squeezed her walls against that twitching length still inside of her. Cum was oozing out of her pussy now, escaping from between the seam of flesh connecting them, and it was easily the stickiest, messiest, and naughtiest Fluttershy ever felt in her life - a series of sensations that she was clearly enjoying. “Thank you, Sunset Shimmer! Thank you so, so much for showing me how we can be friends, too!”

She deceived them. She manipulated them. She took advantage of them. And at the end of it all, they thanked her for it. Sunset Shimmer was rapidly becoming the top bitch queen of CHS - a title that suited her just fine.

***

What followed was a long night of exploring what friendship really meant, at least so far as Fluttershy understood it. In reality, it was little more than training for Sunset Shimmer’s newest and shiniest slut - not to mention an opportunity to explore her holes and indulge herself in the naughty pleasure of claiming yet another member of her growing harem. Fluttershy was different from Rarity and Pinkie Pie in so many wonderful ways, from the noises she made when her ass was threaded with cock to the way she blushed when Sunset dropped her big, throbbing dick in between those perfect tits. And so far...she was impressed. Fluttershy was taking to this with a natural grace, and after her initial series of desperate whimpers and squirming nervousness were out of the way, her bravery didn’t fail her.

Granted, she stumbled a little over herself when she called her parents to let them know she was staying over at a friend’s house, but in all fairness Sunset Shimmer was eating her out at the time. Anyone would be a little nervous at that.

Late into the night, Sunset Shimmer was reclining in her bed, shoulders resting on a small mountain of pillows. It was her turn to be the one on the phone while she was serviced, with her cell held up to her face as Fluttershy was laying on the bed before her, fondly licking and slurping at her sack and the heavy balls resting underneath. The dutiful pink-haired girl was working diligently to appease her new favorite toy, teasing her tongue up and down when she wasn’t giving Sunset’s sack a nuzzling series of kisses, and the entire time her eyes were entirely focused on her new lover while she laid back casually chatting, a smug look of satisfaction on her face.

“No, Rarity, I don’t think it’s too early at all to start thinking about the Fall Formal,” Sunset murmured, one hand lowering to Fluttershy’s head. She threaded her fingers into her hair to pull her slightly upward, silently encouraging her to take the head of that throbbing cock past her innocent lips. Once she could feel Fluttershy’s mouth slide to the midpoint of her cock, Sunset Shimmer gave a satisfied grunt, and chuckled into the phone. “Honestly, I’ve been thinking about the Fall Formal all year. Like...you don’t even know how much I’m looking forward to it.”

She listened while Rarity went off on another tangent about dresses and fashion and all of the boring things she tended to focus on, rolling her eyes and even looking down to where Fluttershy was still toiling. She lifted a hand and made a chattering gesture to her newest pet, and Fluttershy just offered a blushing giggle while sweeping all the way down to the hilt. With her cock nudging the back of Fluttershy’s throat, Sunset Shimmer finally chimed up over the phone, smirking as she did so.

“Rarity, Rarity, you can show me all your designs later. But in the future, maybe don’t call me at four in the morning to tell me about them? I mean, usually I’d be asleep.” She paused, and then chuckled. “Nah, not tonight, you didn’t wake me up. Hmm? Oh, I’ve been fucking Fluttershy all night.”

There was a pronounced “WHAT?!” in Rarity’s dramatic voice that came over the other end of the phone, and Fluttershy herself squeaked in surprise with that massive cock bulging her throat. Sunset Shimmer just stretched out and gave a content sigh, knowing that after this long, she didn’t need to touch Rarity in order to charm her. After the loads she’d pumped into the fashionista and the endless orgasms she gave her over the past couple of weeks, Rarity was hers no matter what she did - magic or no.

“Yeah, I helped her out with her shelter volunteering, and one thing led to another…” Sunset was devoid of any trace of humility, savoring her alpha status as CHS’s best bitch. When Fluttershy’s lips popped off her tip Sunset ushered her right down to the spot where her cock met her balls, and even amidst her fright over having their relationship exposed, Fluttershy still kissed desperately at that sensitive, tender spot. While her tongue danced Sunset continued to boast, preening under all the attention she was receiving. “She’s hot as hell, Rarity, and a real tiger in bed. We’ve been fucking all night, and right now she’s sucking my balls.”

She paused, listened intently to Rarity’s request on the other end, and then laughed.

“Sure, I’ll prove it.” Sunset didn’t ask the faintest hint of permission from the pink-haired girl as she flipped her phone’s camera on and stole a sudden picture, tapping away before speaking up again. “There we go. Get the pic?”

It went on like that for some time, and it didn’t matter to either girl how Sunset treated them. She teased Rarity with the knowledge that her kindest, sweetest friend was sucking on her balls throughout the evening and she made Fluttershy squirm endlessly under the weight of being exposed. Through it all, both girls got flustered and squirmed and whined, but their adoration of Sunset Shimmer remained absolute. By the time the evening finished, Rarity was fawning over her own pussy while staring at pictures of a cum-blasted Fluttershy, and Sunset Shimmer hung up so she could have another run at her timid new prize. And as she fucked Fluttershy into the morning hours, as she pumped another hot load into the girl’s inexperienced pussy, she writhed not only with satisfaction, but with power.

Her plan was going better than she ever imagined, and soon...soon everything would belong to her. The crown. The magic. The school. And every hot, teenage slut she could talk or enchant her way into the pants of.

End of Chapter Three.

Author's Note

My my my, how easy Fluttershy was to seduce! Good job, Sunset!

Apologies for the lack of updates lately, it's been a bear of a year on my end. Motivation can be a real rough bitch to mount sometimes, y'know?

If you enjoyed this story, consider giving me a peep over on Twitter!