Sunscreen
Chapter Five: An Enchanting Refreshment
-by Drace Domino

Sunset Shimmer hadn’t missed a shot so far, and she wasn’t about to start now. Every girl that she targeted with her dark machinations had fallen loyally under her thumb, convinced that she was the best friend they ever had and capable of giving them the sort of wild pleasure their young teenage minds had never imagined. The latter part was certainly true, but the former was...debatable, to say the least. Even if she did enjoy their company from time to time - Rarity, for example, certainly came in handy when she was shopping for clothes - the four young women that had become her harem were little more than a means to an end. Her first steps in conquering not just Canterlot High, but so, so much more. She might even one day parade them straight through the portal back to Equestria and force Princess Celestia herself to bow, but before she tackled the final boss of her pursuit of vengeance, there was one major roadblock that she needed to get over.

The most dangerous of the quintet of friends that she had first targeted. The most impulsive, the boldest, and the one least likely to let her get close enough to utilize her power of subtle manipulation. The small-chested, athletic young woman that was by all accounts a superstar at CHS - a champion on the soccer field, a paragon of coolness, and easily the most confident teenager to ever live.

Rainbow Dash.

There was no true way for Sunset Shimmer to bend Dash to her will in the same manner she did the others, the former pony knew that much. Her ability to gently twist the thoughts of people she made delicate contact with had its limits, and a particularly strong-willed person would have no problem pushing aside the magical compulsion to trust her. Sunset Shimmer knew as much from her old days back in Equestria, where a simple brush of her hoof across Celestia’s leg had utterly failed - and even worse, alerted the high ruler of Equestria that she was trying to use sinister magic against her. With Rainbow Dash, Sunset couldn’t take such a risk - it was unlikely that the brat would really understand just what was going on, but she wouldn’t put it past her to throw a few angry fists. That was to say nothing of the social cost of having Rainbow Dash against her - when it came to being beloved by the student body, only Pinkie Pie could best her reputation.

No...the usual path towards domination wouldn’t be good enough. If Sunset Shimmer was going to break through the barriers of Rainbow Dash’s obstinate and stubborn mind, she’d need to first weaken them. And thankfully, she had just the thing to enable her to do so: a magical amulet capable of generating the most potent mind control potion known in all of Equestria.

“Hnn...c’mon...almost…” Sunset Shimmer was alone in the locker room that night after school, after having snuck in after she saw Rainbow Dash leave. The girl left her belongings behind and was most likely planning on doing a few laps around the soccer field - some evening exercise that served as the perfect opportunity for a sinister bitch to execute her plan. Now, Sunset was bracing herself with bent knees and her skirt lifted around her waist, furiously pumping at her smooth, amber cock in a desperate attempt to get herself off. Her free hand was holding something else Rainbow Dash left behind: a bottle of sports drink for after her workout. With sweat lining her brow and her heart beating faster, Sunset continued to jerk herself off with vigorous strokes, grunting softly as she did so. It was...tricky having to settle for masturbation after she had gotten so accustomed to having willing sluts suck her off or bend over for her cock, and in order to push herself towards climax Sunset had to let her mind focus on the end goal of the evening. Once she managed to squirt her load right into Rainbow Dash’s waiting drink, it was only a matter of time before she’d have that tight blue pussy squeezing her rod to as many explosions as she wanted that night.

She managed to get herself there eventually, and shuddered in excitement as she leveled her cocktip towards the open mouth of the drink. With a few spasming twitches her cock began to unload as pleasure washed through her, and jets of warm, white nectar fired straight down into the lemon-lime flavored drink, swirling within it once they landed. It was a heavy climax and Sunset realized as much when the drink started to reach the point where it might overflow, and she hastily had to pull her skirt down and over the tip of her still-squirting cock to avoid making a suspicious mess. With her hands free and her sensitive rod still plastering the fabric dangling in front of it, the sinister former pony scrambled for the nearby cap of Dash’s drink. After screwing it in place she gave it a hearty shake to help her cum blend within it, and once she gave it a scrutinizing glance, Sunset offered a wicked little chuckle.

Rainbow Dash might’ve posed more of a challenge than the others, but with a little ingenuity and some underhanded deceit, she’d fall in line just as quickly.

***

Quick was...an overstatement, unfortunately. Once Sunset Shimmer shot her load into Rainbow Dash’s drink, she went to hide amidst the lockers, sitting down on one of the benches and waiting for Dash to finally return. An hour passed. Then two. Then almost a third while Sunset steadily watched the battery on her phone continue to dwindle, and her heart started to sink. Was it possible that Dash had just left her stuff in the locker room? Did she get distracted and go home for the evening? Was she so stupid she forgot how to get back down there?! Sunset Shimmer would’ve believed any of those options, and it made her start to wonder if she really was just wasting her time that evening. With her phone threatening her with a blinking one percent charge and her shoulders lifting and falling in a heavy sigh, the young woman slowly lifted to her feet and gave an irate, huffing grumble.

“...fine, you bitch, I’ll get you next ti--”

“Annnnd the crowd goes wild for Rainbow ‘Daring’ Dash!” It was the voice of Dash herself coming from the hall leading to the locker room, the self-congratulatory sound of a brat that was absolutely stuck on herself. Sunset immediately fell quiet and darted back to her hiding space, pressing her back against the line of lockers and keeping her lips completely sealed. She even held her breath so she could listen as Dash continued to approach, her muscles going tight and her cock naturally started to spring to life once more below her skirt. “Here she is, ladies and gentlemen! The greatest, the best, the awesomest superstar celebrity soccer player wrestler kickboxer adventurer! Everyone loves her, and she loves everyone!”

Sunset Shimmer rolled her eyes, but her cock only twitched again. This was going to be one sweet conquest. Dash seemed pretty pleased with herself that evening after a good workout, heading straight past the lockers and into the adjoining showers. At first, the increasingly-pouty, irate Sunset was furious that she’d have to wait even longer for her conquest, but...it was better than the brat would be nice and fresh and clean for her eventual domination. Sunset would much rather she pick up sweat and filth as she rolled around on the floor getting fucked like a whore, rather than whatever foolish exercises she was doing. To that end, Sunset Shimmer remained patient and quiet for an entire twenty extra minutes while Rainbow Dash showered and sang - quite offkey - to herself. Mostly songs about how great she was.

“...oh, I cannot fucking wait to shut this bitch up,” Sunset Shimmer murmured to herself while Dash showered, pinching the bridge of her nose.

Eventually, Rainbow Dash slipped out of the shower, and as Sunset confirmed by peeking from around the corner of the lockers, she was still in the buff as she did so. She was naked save for the towel draped over her soaking wet hair, and she padded to the spot where her things were waiting, still humming songs about herself as she did so. Although Sunset Shimmer’s plan had involved much more waiting around than first anticipated, once the moment finally arrived, it all went off without a hitch. Rainbow Dash reached for her lemon lime sports drink, twisted off the cap, and helped herself to one big, chugging gulp.

Sunset kept watching from the corner, her sadistic smile growing as Dash pulled her lips from the mouth of the bottle and gave a satisfied sigh. The effects were almost instantaneous as Dash lowered the bottle and gave it a wide-eyed look, clearly realizing that something was going on, but completely unable to determine what.

“...woah,” she whispered in a state of awe, and licked her lips of the excess flavor. “This is...really, really good. Did they change the recipe?”

She gave herself another few gulps. Then a few more. Before long, Rainbow Dash was sitting down on the locker room bench as she finished the bottle of sports drink, and then whipped it down to the floor below as soon as it was drained. From the sidelines Sunset Shimmer continued to lurk - studying not just the effects of the blended cum beverage, but the sight of Dash herself. Her tight little body was truly something impressive and tempting to behold. She didn’t have the fantastic tits of Applejack or Rarity or the plump, spankable ass of Pinkie Pie, or even the silky hair of Fluttershy that was so wickedly fun to cum on, but still...her tight figure was built for fucking. Athletic, well-toned, and obviously so sturdy and strong that she could ride all night if it was demanded of her.

“W-Wow, this...this is crazy, but...mmm, just feel so hot…” Rainbow Dash was whispering to herself by that point, looking around from side to side to make sure that she was alone. Sunset Shimmer just barely managed to dip out of sight, only leaning forward again when she heard Dash’s voice continue with a predictable path of thought. “F-Fuck, I probably can’t drive home like this. Maybe I’ll just...hell, it’s just me here…”

Sure enough, by the time Sunset looked around the corner, Rainbow Dash had already begun. She had one leg up with her foot braced on the other side of the locker room bench, one hand against a single tiny tit while the other had lowered to her lap. She wasn’t one for foreplay, that much was apparent - from what Sunset could tell, she already had two fingers hooked inside that tight blue pussy, and she was pinching her surprisingly thick, puffy nipple with quite a bit of force. Her hips were rocking back and forth and her eyes were fully closed by that point, clearly pushing herself right into the stream of pleasure that the taste of magical cum compelled her towards. From singing songs of her own praises to shamefully fingering herself in a public place - that was the power of Equestrian magic, but moreover...the power of Sunset Shimmer.

Sunset was quite proud of herself just then - perhaps even more proud than Rainbow Dash was of herself for running fast or catching a ball or whatever. The battle with Rainbow Dash was over before it had even truly begun, and now Sunset finally came around the corner of the lockers, knowing that she had absolutely nothing to fear. She was dressed in her favorite outfit that evening, starting with knee-high cowgirl boots that Rarity had hand-embroidered with a flame motif, her typical pink dress with an exposed back, a metal ring collar, and a short skirt that ended just above her knees. Over it was her typical leather jacket with the spikes and studs all perfectly polished, giving her a look of badass authority that she so thoroughly lived up to. She walked across the locker room floor towards Rainbow Dash who was still so very much distracted, and Sunset didn’t bother to announce herself until the other girl was firmly underneath her shadow.

“Ahem.”

“Wha-woah-ahhhh!” The reaction from Rainbow Dash was priceless, so much so that Sunset was silently furious her phone didn’t have enough charge to record it. The masturbating blue brat gave a squawk as she looked up to see who was looming over her, and the immediate blush and panicked look on her face made it clear that Sunset was at the very bottom of the list of people she expected. It all led to her tumbling right off the bench and collapsing into a heap - her legs hooked around the top rim of it while her back was flat on the floor. Sunset leaned forward and arched a brow, naturally stealing not only a glimpse of Rainbow Dash’s ashamed face, but that lovely blue pussy that was glistening with a copious amount of nectar. Dash looked up with near-tears in her eyes, her heart racing in surprise and shame, but moreover - a desperation she couldn’t begin to process. “S-Sunset Shimmer! W...Wh...What are you...what are you doi--”

“Rainbow Dash.” Sunset Shimmer simply offered a condescending, venomous smile as she approached, and made it a point to bring one boot up, sitting it atop the bench. “Do you want...a hand?”

Everything Sunset Shimmer did was calculated, and that moment was no different. She held an outstretched hand towards Rainbow Dash with the full intention of using her magic the second the two made contact, although she already knew...that wasn’t going to be necessary. The look on Rainbow Dash’s face said it all and completely confirmed to Sunset that the scales had truly been tipped, with her eyes large and wide and staring straight towards where Sunset’s boot was perched on the bench. It was there that she was offering a glimpse up her skirt towards the naked, quivering, enchanted brat - and along with it, the sight of a magnificent amber dick that was stiffened thanks to the show Dash herself had just put on. When Rainbow Dash reached up and pressed her palm into Sunset’s own, the brief kiss of magic from one to the other was little more than an afterthought.

Rainbow Dash belonged to her, now, and the school’s coolest athlete confirmed it with a pitiful, needy whimper.

“P-Please, Sunset…” she gasped, still staring straight up at that magnificent amber dick as Sunset pulled her upward. “Please help me…”

She’d leave that evening the same as all the others, with the knowledge that she had never had a kinder, more benevolent, and more helpful friend than Sunset Shimmer.

It was time for the center of Rainbow Dash’s universe to be someone else for a change.

***

“That’s it...you look good with a dick in your mouth, Rainbow Dash.” Sunset Shimmer couldn’t help but tease the blushing athlete, watching as the inches slowly pushed past those plump blue lips. She offered one small thrust forward with enough momentum to clap her balls against Dash’s chin, and chuckled in the aftermath with a smug, satisfied smile plastered across her face. “See? No reason that we can’t be good friends just like I am with all the others. I’m sure you’ve heard them talk about me by now. And weren’t you just a little bit curious if all those stories were true?”

She allowed Rainbow Dash to pull her mouth off of that twitching cock just long enough to respond, and while Dash did so with a heavy blush on her cheeks, Sunset was keen to grab her member by the base, continuing to slap it softly back and forth over her rival’s face. It made for a series of light noises as flesh struck flesh again and again, and only further intensified the mild shame and humiliation Rainbow Dash was experiencing - all blended with building trust.

“I...I guess maybe, just a little.” She was lying about the last part, as evidenced by the hand that had snuck down between her thighs. Once more Rainbow Dash was fingering herself, though this time it was much more gentle than before, simply keeping herself to a wet simmer rather than ferociously fingerfucking that sopping slit. There was no reason to rush anymore, not with a perfect amber dick in the locker room to satisfy her, and not with the promise of a load of hot, white cum to gobble down. She wasn’t sure why, but such a thought made her burn with an even greater desire than she already felt. “I...I guess it’s a pretty nice dick. I mean, I can see why Fluttershy or Rarity might be crazy about it. I just don’t know if it’s really gonna...y’know. Do the job for a girl like me.”

Sunset Shimmer couldn’t help but laugh, as assured in her dominance as she was the fact that Rainbow Dash would be a stubborn brat until the very end. Not that it mattered. Rainbow Dash could puff out her chest and posture as much as she wanted, so long as she did it naked underneath her. With a fluid gesture Sunset let her fingers slip into Dash’s rainbow-colored hair once more, locking her grip against the very base of her skull to maximize the level of control she had. Holding the other girl on a short, short leash made it easy to pull Dash back to the true focus of the evening - that glistening amber cockhead that was already covered in spit and a light glaze of precum.

“Guess we’ll see.” Sunset Shimmer simply shrugged, and her grin intensified once she felt Dash’s tongue underneath her anew. It was flicking wildly back and forth and was indicative of just how hungry the girl was for more glances of flavor - from the taste of dick dancing across her lips to the dots of precum that Sunset was constantly wedging into the back of her throat. After she allowed Rainbow to take her up and down with a few wet strokes of her mouth, she pulled Dash’s face down all the way, compressing her there until she felt the girl’s nose wedged against her lap and could hear her struggle with an enormous dick near the very center of her throat. “C’mon, Rainbow Dash...show me how well you can take it. If Applejack can deepthroat my cock, I’m sure you can, too.”

Rainbow Dash had been a challenge to conquer, but in some ways she was the easiest to manipulate of all. All of the girls had their own weaknesses - Rarity’s vanity, Pinkie Pie’s recklessness, Fluttershy’s trusting nature...but Rainbow Dash? She was as competitive as they came, especially when it came to her apple-farming rival. It was the perfect thing to push Rainbow Dash even further over the edge, to encourage her to indulge in the overwhelming delight that the magic was fueling inside of her. With her eyes barely open, there was still a clear flash within them - a moment of competitive indignation that she would not be bested by Applejack, of all people!

“Hnnnmmph…” Rainbow Dash choked herself on Sunset Shimmer’s cock, and there was little other way to describe it. She buried her face all the harder against the other girl’s lap and encouraged that throbbing dicktip to probe deeper, to bulge at her throat from within and grind against every wall spasming and attempting to force her out. She was actively holding back the desire to cough and relied on her athletic nature to keep her senses in check, even as her eyes started to water and her cheeks were overtaken by a heavy, strained blush. Despite the efforts and the struggle, Rainbow Dash continued to persevere, and Sunset Shimmer absolutely delighted in encouraging that behavior.

“Mmm, that’s pretty deep.” Sunset rubbed her chin, idly, and spoke as if she was being entirely innocent in tone, playing at trying to help the other girl. “I mean, Applejack did about the same, but she was a lot more...oh, I don’t know. There was just more to it. Her tongue was moving, her hands were in play, it was…” She gave a longing, wistful sigh, even as she savored the grip of Dash’s throat around her prick. “...oh, it was just wonderful.”

The way Rainbow Dash’s eyes flared open only for a second to show their burning fury was a clear sign to Sunset that things were about to get intense. It wasn’t long after that she felt Dash’s hands both suddenly lash forward, latching against her waist underneath her skirt and locking her digits firmly into place. Sunset quirked a brow in curiosity for the moment, but she was swiftly delivered the pleasure that she had coerced Rainbow Dash into offering as the indomitable athlete suddenly, and vigorously, started to facefuck herself with the other girl’s cock.

Sunset almost gasped, but silenced herself for fear of discouraging Rainbow Dash from the sudden onslaught she was putting herself through. With a single hand braced against the nearby lockers, Sunset locked her knees and bit down on her bottom lip, watching as the space in front of her lap was occupied by a wild rainbow blur of movement and activity. Dash’s head was pounding back and forth against her, shaking so vigorously that it was difficult for Sunset’s eyes to track. Up and down, up and down, she claimed Sunset’s rod down to the hilt with every fierce strike, nudging her nose against the girl’s lap and making sure to stretch her tongue out on every impact so she could get a taste of the girl’s amber balls. It was wet. Messy. Relentless. And even though Sunset Shimmer knew it couldn’t have been easy on her latest conquest, she wasn’t about to stop her. Hell, she might have even seen fit to further prod her to see how far Dash’s competitive streak would take her, but at that point Sunset knew it wasn’t likely that she’d be able to resist that much longer, herself.

“Guh...guh...guh!” Dash’s voice only escaped in the form of those moist grunts, riding amidst the sloppy noise of suction while her mouth remained locked on Sunset’s rod. Every time she ushered that glorious amber prick down her gullet, Rainbow Dash forced down a choking noise, though when her fingers tightened against Sunset’s waist with an intense ferocity the sinister bitch knew that she hit a particularly sensitive spot. With her hand leaving Rainbow Dash’s hair and allowing the girl herself to do as she desired, Sunset did her best to play things up as casually as she could...and not let on that Rainbow Dash was giving her one of the best, wettest blowjobs of her damn life.

She fidgeted in place. Gazed at her fingernails. Even looked down at her phone, and pretended that the battery hadn’t long since dropped to zero percent. She couldn’t stop her eyes from gazing up and over the blank screen, however, to stare at Dash’s naked figure while she sucked her cock with such enormous gusto. That perky blue ass was wiggling back and forth and her puffy, dark blue nipples were shockingly stiff, and Sunset could even see a thin line of excited nectar dangling from the other girl’s folds. Rainbow Dash was loving this - at least a very primal, hungry, lusty part of her was - and it couldn’t all be because of the magical cum still rolling through her system. Still...that seed certainly helped, and she was about to get another dose of it soon enough.

By the time Sunset Shimmer started to hit her peak, Rainbow Dash had been putting herself through a sprint of fierce facefucks that were enough to leave her dizzy and shaking. When Sunset first gave a sharp groan to announce her peak, Dash suddenly popped off of her length, immediately falling into a fit of coughing as she held her throat with one hand and Sunset’s rod with the other. The poor thing seemed absolutely torn in that moment - threads of spit connecting her face to Sunset’s twitching member before dangling all the way down to the floor, her face heavy with an ashamed blush and her eyes watering desperately. Still, despite the discomfort she was clearly struggling with, she was dutiful enough to keep pumping Sunset’s rod harder and harder and harder, taking her the last few strokes she needed to finally unleash her torrent.

Sunset Shimmer - ever the compassionate lover - actively held her peak back for a few seconds. Just enough to give Rainbow Dash a little time to collect herself, just enough to give her a moment to turn her face forward once more and receive the creamy reward she deserved. Those extra seconds certainly paid off, for as soon as Dash’s head snapped back into position with her mouth open and her tongue dangling outward, she was rewarded with an immediate blast of warm, wet, white cream squarely against her mouth. Sunset hissed between her teeth as she suddenly felt the pleasure of a well-earned climax rushing through her, and she once more dropped a hand to Dash’s hair to help keep her in place for the delivery of her treat.

“F-Fuck, keep your mouth open, slut…” Sunset shuddered, just as she watched the first jet of cum splash squarely into Dash’s mouth, leaving a streak across her tongue before shooting to the back of her throat. The rainbow-maned brat was clearly fighting the urge to choke and cough some more, and so Sunset relied on the ultimate tool to keep her in check, invoking the name of that rustic cowgirl that was a fine cocksucker in her own right. “Don’t you waste any! Applejack didn’t waste any!”

A lie, of course - Applejack’s own facials were every bit as sloppy, intense, and wet - but there was no reason that Rainbow Dash needed to know that, especially if it encouraged her to hit new heights in her new role as facefucked teenage tramp. As Rainbow Dash stared ahead with spit coating her blushing cheeks and a desperate, depraved gloss to her eyes, Sunset fired another streak, and another, and another, all of them either squirting directly into Rainbow Dash’s open mouth or plastering her face. A jet of spunk crossed her from the chin to the brow while another fired in a line across her nose, just before Sunset pressed the bottom edge of her tip to Dash’s outstretched tongue where she unloaded a particularly hefty amount square into Dash’s open mouth. The entire time Rainbow Dash knelt there sweat-licked and hungry, whimpering as she felt that cream usher down her gullet and into her belly, her excitement building with every second that the flavor rested on her tongue. She was filling herself up with both spunk and Equestrian magic alike, an intoxicating blend that would drive her to the sort of submissive glee that Dash usually would’ve expected from other people in deference to her. It was going to be a strange evening for her on that account - a night where Dash spent her time being used and toyed with, a night where she’d go to bed with the knowledge that her body was a plaything for someone else.

Specifically, for her new best friend.

“Fuck...fuck, that was good.” Sunset Shimmer shuddered as she took a half-step back, releasing Dash’s hair and stumbling until she was resting her backside against the cool steel of the locker. With sweat coating her figure, she couldn’t wait to strip out of her leather jacket, peeling it off and throwing it to the side, just before she started to repeat the process with her skirt. Soon she was standing there bare in front of Rainbow Dash save only for her cowgirl boots, while Rainbow Dash wore only cum on her face and a broad, eager smile as she slurped up the mess that had been made. “Heh. Hungry little bitch, aren’t you?”

“Mmmhmm!” Rainbow Dash didn’t hesitate to reply, nodding eagerly as she shot a glance towards the other girl. She was practically saturated with Sunset’s cream by that point, with threads of it dripping down to her tits and shivering a line across her toned belly, or soaked into her hair from a few more errant streaks. Dash was reclaiming what she could by sliding her hands across her smooth skin to usher the extra seed right into her mouth, licking her fingers and suckling at her palms, constantly trying to consume more and more. When she was able to keep her mouth clear enough that she could speak, Dash looked at Sunset with shining eyes and a tone that was clearly reserved for friends - of which, Sunset now was. “It’s even better than the cider at Sweet Apple Acres! It’s...oh wow, Sunset, your cum tastes so awesome! Can I have more?! Can I...can I get fucked?! Please?! Ohmigosh ohmigosh ohmigosh, I’m soooooo horny, Sunset!”

Sunset Shimmer just smirked, her arms folding underneath her bust as she simply appreciated the moment for what it was. Rainbow Dash - infuriatingly bold and bull-headed, the most stubborn and confident bitch she’d met outside of Equestria - now naked on her knees, desperate for another taste of cum and actively begging to get fucked. Oh, she’d have a lot of fun with this particular pet, that much was to be sure. Pinkie Pie, Fluttershy, Rarity, Applejack...they were all fine lovers in their own right and they all filled a particular role in Sunset Shimmer’s evil plan, but she’d be taking a much more intense satisfaction in dominating Rainbow Dash. The rainbow-haired brat had caught her eye from the very first second she stepped through the portal from Equestria and into the human world. It wasn’t that she had a crush on Rainbow Dash so much as she wanted to actively crush her.

But making her into a mind-addled, cum-addicted sexpet through the use of consent-denying Equestrian magic was a fine alternative.

“Bend over, slut,” Sunset Shimmer finally spoke, lifting a hand and twisting a finger through the air to suggest Dash turned around. “I want you to stick your ass up in the air and stretch your pussy out for me. You don’t get fucked until I see pink.”

“You got it, Sunset Shimmer! Ohhhhh man, this is gonna be so awesome!” Rainbow Dash was an enthusiastic submissive, that much was certain. With a giggle billowing from her throat she practically scrambled to oblige, turning around and bracing herself on her hands and knees on the bench, lifting her backside and giving it a playful wiggle. Before long she slid one hand underneath herself and braced her fingers against the outer edges of her nethers, pulling down against them to stretch herself as much as she was able. Once she was in position she looked over her shoulder with a hopeful glance, whimpering in a growing desperation. “How’s that, Sunset? Is that good enough?”

Sunset Shimmer, ever happy to force a bitch like Rainbow Dash into shaming herself even more, simply shrugged. She paced behind Rainbow Dash while she looked at the girl’s offered ass and the entire lewd display before her - from thighs that were visibly wet from Dash’s nectar to the fact that she was still dripping cum off of her big, puffy nipples down to the floor below. She spent a special moment or two studying Dash’s pussy as she had it spread, her lips pursing as she contemplated the presentation for a long, lingering few moments. Finally, she gave a huffing noise, and lifted her hand to give Dash another order.

“No, I’ve changed my mind,” she announced, dismissively. “Get on the floor and lean back on your ass, then stretch yourself out. I want to see how wet I’ve made you, Rainbow Dash.”

“You got it, Sunset Shimmer!” It was the same unbridled enthusiasm, the same absolute willingness to do anything it took if it meant getting stuffed with that perfect amber cock. The domination of Rainbow Dash wasn’t just complete, it was a smashing success, and now that Sunset had her doing tricks like a trained dog, the former pony could barely hide her joy. Thankfully, she didn’t have to, as Rainbow Dash’s eyes were utterly transfixed upon that thick amber cock as it swung back and forth, drooling a line of excess cum from a sensitive, raw tip. Before long, Dash had finally managed to oblige by dropping onto her backside and stretching her thighs out wide, showing off her impressive, athletic flexibility as she did so. With her shoulders against the nearest locker, Dash slid her hands down to her pussy and pressed her fingers against the edges, this time pulling to stretch herself out more vigorously than before. This time, when Sunset gazed down she could see visible pink past the dark blue folds of Dash’s nethers - the perfect, warm, snug hiding spot for her flawless prick.

“That’s...better,” Sunset finally observed, and slowly dropped down onto her knees in front of Rainbow Dash. “But just remember, Rainbow Dash - I’ll expect more from you next time. I have a lot of girls that want to fuck me at any given hour of the day, and you’re going to need to keep impressing me if you want a spot on my dick.”

The framing of her expectations landed perfectly on Dash’s sporty, competitive mind, and that much was clear as her eyes widened and she swiftly nodded. Her reaction was similar to that of being accepted onto some grand pro sports team, complete with a few soft whispers of “ohmigosh” underneath her breath as Sunset loomed above her. That perfect amber dick flopped forward and sat with Dash’s blue folds crowned along the edges of her, and while Sunset’s member drooled a tiny puddle of cum atop Dash’s belly, the manipulative bitch idly rubbed her chin as she studied what was presented to her.

“This is smooth as silk, Dash,” Sunset murmured, and lowered a hand to press her thumb against Dash’s pubic area. She stroked downward in a fluid motion, and lifted her brow to press the issue while Dash quivered underneath her. “You shave? I had no idea you were fucking people on the regular.”

“It’s...it’s for sports,” Dash murmured, her blush absolutely intensifying as she was called out on her personal grooming. “I wear a lot of short, tight shorts, and...and uh...well…”

“Start letting it grow.” Sunset gave her a simple command - another suggestion if Dash wanted to make the team, so to speak. “I want to see if your bush has the same ridiculous color as the rest of your hair.”

Her words were demanding, even mean-spirited, but with her cock braced upon Dash’s folds and the taste of cum still thick on the girl’s tongue, it didn’t matter. Sunset was confident that she could tell Rainbow Dash anything she wanted in that moment, and the loyal young woman would receive it all as the advice of a trusted and beloved friend. This was the sweetest moment for Sunset Shimmer - the brief few seconds before her conquest was complete, the moments in which she could test the waters and see just how obedient her newest pet would be. At the demand that Dash let her nether hair grow, the young athlete bobbed her head up and down immediately, without a single fraction of hesitation before she was ready to fulfill any request Sunset Shimmer had. So long, of course, that she got fucked.

“Y-Yes, Sunset, I promise!” She nodded, and shivered back and forth. Her hands were still stretching out her folds in a lewd display and her thighs were still swung out to the sides as much as she could muster, already trembling from the strain. It was a good thing she was in such magnificent shape and stretched regularly, otherwise there’d be no way she could hold such a position for so long while she was teased by the other girl. “Now…p-please...please, Sunset, I really...I feel like I’m going crazy, I...ahhh…!”

Sunset Shimmer couldn’t have one of her pets going crazy, of course. A crazy pet couldn’t be the docile, loyal, cum-addicted toy that she needed. To that end, Sunset Shimmer didn’t hesitate to pull her hips back, dragging the underside of her prick across Dash’s folds in a fluid, smooth gesture, just before allowing it to dip into place at her entrance. She pressed forward and allowed her amber cockhead to nuzzle the pink entrance that was stretched wide and inviting for her, and only once she was a half-inch pressed within did she give Dash a nod to release her hands. The athlete immediately let her palms scoop underneath her own thighs to help keep them properly held apart, and when she released the grip at the edges of her folds they crashed down against the sides of Sunset’s cock, practically enveloping her cockhead. With a predatory smile growing on Sunset’s face and her eyes scanning from the other girl’s lap all the way across a cum-covered, tiny set of tits to reach Dash’s face, she took a long, deep breath of appreciation and satisfaction. The perfect moment, and the final piece of her collection of Canterlot High friends.

“Remember,” Sunset purred, a split-second before jamming herself forward. “You’re in direct competition with the other girls. Especially Applejack.”

***

Even when made to submit by manipulation and magic, Rainbow Dash was still a harder ride than most. She could easily be called a power bottom once she got into the swing of things, which was almost immediately thanks to how excited she was by that point. Sunset Shimmer had only wedged her cock inside the other girl about halfway before Dash’s legs suddenly stretched out before locking around her, ankles hooking behind the small of Sunset’s back before suddenly pulling her forward the rest of the way. Even the sinister bitch from Equestria was surprised by the sudden surge of momentum, gasping as the rest of her impressive length was snugly gripped inside of a wet, warm cunt and instinctively bucking her hips forward against that increase in pressure. Sunset caught herself with one hand flat against the lockers and the other moving down to grip Rainbow Dash’s shoulder, and the two exchanged heated glances during which Dash freely exposed just how desperate and needy she was. Her eyes were weak and wanting - practically on the verge of tears because she wanted fucked so, so badly. Sunset Shimmer merely smirked, and with her other hand sliding down to fiercely take a fistful of Dash’s hair, started to deliver exactly what Dash wanted.

The eagerness of the blue brat was such that Sunset Shimmer felt no hesitation in opting to fuck this particular pet hard - not that she would’ve considered holding back regardless. Her hips pulled back to the point that merely an inch of perfect amber cock was still snugly fit inside of Dash before she jammed forward once more all the way to the hilt, clapping her flesh against Dash’s own and making the athlete give a loud, hungry moan that echoed within the otherwise-empty halls of the girls’ locker room. As she was fucked down to the core Dash unleashed a pathetic yet joyful whimper after her scream, and her hands moved to hook against Sunset’s shoulders close to her neck.

“Please please please please please fuck meeeeee…” she begged, keeping her legs properly hooked and grinding right back against Sunset. It didn’t take long for the girl on top to realize that Dash was matching her efforts, violently bucking her hips up to crash against every thrust and ensure it was as deep as she could go. It was a far cry from Rarity or Fluttershy who were so content to be engaged but passive - Fluttershy for lack of confidence and Rarity simply because she trusted Sunset’s aroused judgment. That look of manic desperation continued to rest on Dash’s face as she wiggled her hips from side to side and made an effort to squeeze her walls around that enormous cock, doing everything she could to earn her spot in Sunset’s good graces. “Fuck me hard, use me, pound my tight little pussy, Sunset…”

“Bratty little slut, aren’t you?” Sunset could only smirk, happier than ever at how well this particular conquest had gone. Her hand shifted from Dash’s shoulder to her throat, and as those amber fingers closed around Dash’s tense blue flesh, she offered a sharp, corrective squeeze. Oh yes...this worked for her. “Brace yourself, bitch.”

Sunset used Dash’s throat half for support and half to correct her, squeezing it a few times as she started to really pound the other girl. When Dash got too loud - or simply wasn’t loud enough - Sunset seized her fingers upon the other girl’s muscles until Dash offered a pathetic squeak. The entire time, her thrusts continued with the same vigorous velocity as before, slapping hard against the other girl’s body and jamming her deep with cock. The wet, lewd noises that filled the air only inspired Sunset to go harder and faster, with the wet sloshing sound of a stiff dick stirring a soaked, tight cunt playing like a melody for them both. With Dash’s ankles firmly digging in against her back, Sunset always slammed forward with more force and intensity than when she pulled back, and before long she timed her grips on Dash’s throat to happen every time she hilted her.

Choked and fucked right there on the locker room floor, Rainbow Dash was nonetheless caught in an uncontrollable wave of delight. Her eyes crossed before rolling back in her head, and it wasn’t long before her lips parted and her tongue dangled free, actively drooling on herself from how much she enjoyed it. Those tiny blue tits didn’t have enough meat to them to offer much of a bounce, but that was fine - the way her rainbow hair was swaying and the look of abject, orgasmic bliss was more than enough to keep Sunset entertained while she fucked her newest pet. The fact that Rainbow Dash seemed to constantly be spinning in between sharp and tiny climaxes only helped matters, since every time one of those waves struck her, she seized upon Sunset’s cock all the harder.

“Hnnnng! You...obnoxious...pain...in the ass!” Sunset drove herself forward mightily every time she said a word, her amulet bouncing against her chest and her hair starting to go frizzled and untamed. With one hand still at Dash’s throat, the other dropped to the girl’s puffy dark nipples, where she pinched each one and twisted them until she felt Dash’s nethers tighten across her rod again. “Fuck, yes! You’re such a good ride, hope you’re ready for my cum!”

Sunset wasn’t prepared to rank her harem of sluts - just yet - but if she did, Rainbow Dash likely would’ve been pleased to find out that she was near the top. For now, at least. The grip of that soaking wet cunt around Sunset’s rod and the sheer eager enthusiasm Dash had for being on the bottom filled the visiting pony with a dominant glee that fed the very worst parts of her - her arrogant desire to dominate others, her righteous indignation as the real “cool girl” of CHS, and her latent mean streak. Sunset let everything go as she slammed into Dash again and again, and all the other girl could do was sit there on the locker room floor, her pussy drooling nectar as she was fucked down to the hilt each and every time. And when Sunset Shimmer finally hit her peak, she made sure to do it in such a way that Dash experienced a whole new level of defeat.

“Take it, bitch! Take every drop!” Sunset Shimmer roared suddenly, just as her hands dropped to Dash’s hips and she dug the arches of her cowgirl boots against the carpet. She suddenly surged forward and lifted Dash’s back half as she did so, leaning her entire body upward to force Dash into a breeding position. The fact that her magical amulet ensured she didn’t have to worry about any little Rainbow Dashes didn’t change the thrill of claiming a slut in said position, with her member probing particularly deep as Dash’s legs stayed latched onto her. While her cock twitched and unleashed squirt after squirt of hot, wet cum Dash’s eyes went crossed once more, and she desperately snuck her hands into Sunset’s hair to pull it, hoping she could manage to keep herself sane.

The strain of her hair suddenly serving as Dash’s lifeline was something Sunset didn’t expect, but it only made her cum all the harder. That perfect amber dick spasmed within Dash’s inviting entrance as she offered a constant assault of jets of spunk, filling Dash with even more warmth than she had already offered. Spurting noises filled the air as Dash’s pussy failed to keep it all in, and the blue teen herself was left with an almost ashamed look as she felt it plaster her thighs and drip down the back half of her rear. It was a moist affair beyond all measure, and Sunset Shimmer held herself hilted inside the other girl for a few long seconds before finally allowing herself to relent.

“F...Fuck...fuck, that was good.” Sunset practically oozed back down onto her knees, holding Dash’s hips as she did so. In a few seconds, CHS’s best athlete was still wrapped around her prick, but those toned legs were laying flat on the floor around Sunset’s knees. Both girls were breathing desperately, from Dash’s rapidly rising and falling chest to Sunset’s heaving breasts while they collected their strength. Even now, Sunset could feel her cock squirt another short burst of nectar from a still-sensitive tip, and Dash was left drooling it out onto the carpet as she struggled to stay locked around her. “Heh...good work.”

“As…” Rainbow Dash’s question was predictable, perhaps, but understandably so. “As good as Applejack?”

Sunset's slow, sinister smile spread once more, and she gently rubbed her chin in quiet contemplation of the question. She wasn’t sure if she’d give Rainbow Dash the validation she so desperately sought just yet - not when she could make her work for it all night long. Still...she didn’t necessarily want to see the other girl suffer in the waiting to find out, and so Sunset offered her a small concession by means of a shrug and a promise of a chance to prove herself.

“Hard to tell just yet,” she replied simply, and perhaps even honestly. “You’re going to come home with me tonight and we’ll figure out just how you stack up.”

Rainbow Dash’s joy upon hearing that she’d be Sunset’s bedmate for the evening said it all. She had been manipulated and coerced into that position wrapped around Sunset’s dick, but the bliss it brought her was clear to see. Shining eyes, blushing cheeks, and even a happy squeeing noise that escaped from the back of her throat showed just how delighted Rainbow Dash was at that turn of events. As Sunset pressed a palm to Dash’s belly and started to pull out, she gestured to their nearby clothes, and licked her lips as her dick left Dash’s nethers with a satisfying, wet pop.

“C’mon, get dressed, we’ve got a lot of work to do,” she demanded. “Oh, and we’re gonna stop so you can buy me a coffee along the way.”

“You’ve got it, Sunset Shimmer!”

The eager words of a willing pet, so utterly addicted to magical cum that she would’ve given Sunset Shimmer anything she wanted. Rainbow Dash wasn’t all that different from the others in that regard, but her natural tendency to go all-in with everything she did made sure that the art of submitting to her new, manipulative mistress came naturally to her.

And Sunset Shimmer was overjoyed, now that her collection was complete. At least until more toys managed to catch her eye.

End of Chapter 5.

Author's Note

Sunset Shimmer's finally collected the most present threats to her wicked plan. But where will she turn her gaze next?

Speaking of gaze, put yours on my new tumblr. Look, we all know that Twitter's going through some violent changes, and it doesn't really seem reliable right now. So I made this extra tumblr to at least get some place where folks can reach me. Gimme a follow, and stay up to date with new stories!