Out for a Pack

by Shakespearicles

Rating: mature
Tags: Sex, Argyle Starshine, Dark, Porn, My Little Pony: A New Generation, Non-consensual, Sunny Starscout
Length: 1963

One day, Argyle goes out for a pack of cigarettes and never comes home.

One day, Argyle Starshine went out for a pack of cigarettes,
and never came home.

That's Sunny Starscout's story,
and she's sticking to it.

Published 2024-05-31 23:00:04 UTC
Last updated 2024-05-31 23:00:04 UTC

A Mare Has Her Secrets

"Thanks for helping me carry this stuff back from the store, Hitch," Sunny Starscout said as she approached the door to her lighthouse home.

"Of course! But I gotta say, Sunny, you sure do go through a lot of groceries for one pony. How do you stay so fit?"

"A mare has her secrets," she said with a coy wink before opening the door.

"Well, anyway I'm happy to help," Hitch said before stepping inside. He closed the door behind him and the framed photo beside it tilted. Hitch watched Sunny set down her bags and trot over to fix the photo of her with her father. "What with you being on your own now, and all."

"Oh, I'm alright," she insisted. Once the photo was set right, she looked back at Hitch with a small smile and started unpacking the bags.

"So... did you ever find out what happened to him?" Hitch asked.

She shook her head. "He just went out for a pack of smokes one day and never came back."

"Something must have happened." Hitch said. "He wouldn't just leave you like that. He was a good stallion." Sunny just nodded. Hitch wanted to say something more. But he didn't want to give her false hope of her father ever being found if he hadn't by now. And as much as Hitch wanted to offer his help to try to find Argyle himself, he wouldn't even know where to begin. "Sorry. I didn't mean to ruin the mood."

"No worries," Sunny said. What might have been a lack of closure for anypony else, she had long since made her peace. "I've got you around to help out," she said with a smile. "I'll be fine." As she worked, her hips swayed and bobbed in time with whatever song was playing in her head, and her tailed followed suit, waving just a bit higher. This did not escape Hitch's notice.

Hitch cleared his throat and tried to change the subject, "Well, speaking of being helpful... the spring equinox is coming up, you know."

"Thank you, Hitch. I do own a calendar."

"Well, yeah, I know, I just, what I mean is..." He rubbed the back of his neck. "I know what a difficult time that can be. For mares."

"Uh huh..."

"That certain itch, that needs a special scratching?"

"Uh huh..."

"A certain... massage? Of the penis-in-vagina variety," he said.

"Wow. That was smooth. How are you still single?" she asked.

"I'm just saying."

"And I suppose you want to help me with that? How magnanimous."

"I mean... if you're asking..."

"I'm not."

"No?"

"I have my own solution," she said.

"Oh?"

She nodded.

"So do you use like, a potion or something?" he asked.

She smirked. "A mare has her secrets," she said as she walked him to the door.

"Hmph. So I'll still see you at the Flower Dance tomorrow?" he asked.

"It's a date!"

"Alright. See you then."

Sunny closed the door and watched him walk down the path until he was out of sight. She locked the door and then the deadbolt before trotting upstairs to the top of the lighthouse. She angled a couple of mirrors to send the sunlight down through the middle of the tower to the crystal shape at the bottom. She trotted back downstairs and grabbed a few items from the grocery bags on the table to start cooking.

In not time at all she had prepared a sumptuous banquet. She plated the food onto a tray along with a few other things and brought it over to the lighthouse lift. She unlocked the lift and climbed on to go down to the basement. She checked the refraction of the light going through the crystal and set the tray on her workbench.

"Wakey wakey," she sang. "Time for breakfast!"

Argyle Starshine blinked awake where he sat in the reflected beam of sunshine. "Oh. Good morning, sweetheart." He sat on the edge of the cot and waited while Sunny refreshed the roll of toilet paper next to the commode. The shackles on his hooves and collar chaining him to the stone wall gave him limited movement. "What's for breakfast?"

"Potato hash browns, and pancakes with this really nice baked apple topping I'm trying out," she said.

"Ooh, that sounds delicious, dear!" he said, licking his lips. "You always did have a creative aptitude for cooking!" His chains jingled as he reached for the plate.

"Ah, ah," she chided. "You know the rules, Daddy. If you want your meal, you have to eat your dessert, first." She pointed at the cot, instructing him to lay down.

He smiled. "Of course, sweetie." He laid down on the cot and she climbed on top, straddling his face. He wasted no time licking deeply into her marehood.

She smiled down at his eyes as she ran her hoof through his mane. "I love you, Daddy."

"My uv oo, hoo," he mumbled into his daughter's vagina.

Sunny rolled her hips slowly, grinding her winking clitoris against his nose as he continued licking. He was very good at this. He knew her so well. He always knew just what to do to get her off. "D-Daddy!" she moaned. Her legs tensed and squeezed his head between her thighs. He held his breath and closed his eyes. He knew what was coming next. Her whole body shivered on top of him as she came, gushing her marecum on his face, getting most of it unto his mouth. She held his head with her hooves until she could feel him swallowing. She relaxed and leaned back to let him catch his breath, clearing her squirt out his nose.

With his eyes still shut, his hooves rattled the chains. "Dear?" he asked.

"Oh, right." Sunny grabbed a napkin to wipe her marecum out of his eyes.

He blinked them open and looked up at her. "Thank you."

"No. Thank you, Daddy!" She adjusted herself on shaky legs into a more comfortable position.

"It must be getting to be about spring time," he said.

Sunny blushed and rubbed her pussy with her hoof right over his face. "You can tell, huh? Do you think it tastes even better?"

"I can definitely tell the difference when you go into estrus," he said. "Not just the taste, but your scent. And you've been down here a lot more often in the past few days."

"Well, you obviously like it!" she said, looking behind her at his stiff erection.

"Well, sweetie, that's an entirely biological response. I can hardly help it."

Sunny's smile faltered. "Because you like it. Because your daughter has the best pussy you've ever had!"

"... Of course, sweetie."

"Daddy... Say the words."

"My daughter has the best, tastiest, tightest pussy I've ever had!"

Sunny's smile returned. She shifted herself back to straddle his waist. She held his dick with her hoof and angled it up to aim it at her marehood. She slowly lowered herself down with a practiced motion, and she moaned as she felt her father's dick slide inside her in one smooth motion. Once her hips met his, she sat there for a moment, enjoying the feeling of him filling her. "Right where it belongs. A perfect fit. Like lock and key," she purred, wiggling herself a bit in place. "Just like it's meant to be." She started to slowly ride him.

"Did I hear Hitch upstairs earlier?" Argyle asked.

Sunny's pleasant expression soured slightly. "He was helping me bring home our groceries."

"He seems like a really nice stallion. Maybe you should see about-"

"I don't want to talk about Hitch!" she said. "Sheesh! I thought dads were supposed to try to scare away stallions trying to take advantage of their daughters!"

"Do you really think he would-"

"Yes! He obviously wants to have sex with me!"

"Well- well, who can blame him? You're such a s-sexy mare! Right?" he asked.

"Only for you, Daddy!" she said, moaning as she rode up and down on the length of his shaft. "You're the only stallion I need! Besides, it's completely normal! You think Spout isn't doing this with his Mom, too?"

"I don't think Phyllis would-"

"Oh, please! I've seen they way they look at each other!" she said. "It's pretty clear what's going on. I'm sure lots of ponies do it. There's nothing wrong with this. It's completely normal! Right?"

"... Yes dear. Perfectly normal."

She pulled the wheeled tray closer to feed him while they had sex. No sense in letting it go cold, after all. He enjoyed the meal immensely. She really was a talented cook. She held the cup and aimed the straw for him to drink the smoothie she made. He felt his body tingle. Sunny moaned as she felt his shaft throb just a bit bigger inside her from the combination of Neighagra and the virility elixir, making his balls swell even fuller, sure to make him cum even more.

The increase in pressure was too much for him to be able to hold out any longer. He winced and grunted. Sunny could read his signs like a book and she planted her hips down against his as firmly as she could, keeping him as deep inside her as she could. His tip swelled and flared, pressing squarely against her cervix as his shaft started to twitch and throb. She could feeling his shaft pulsing inside her as he pumped load after load of his seed up inside her, straight though the entrance of her cervix, flooding her womb.

Argyle panted and chewed his lip as he came inside his daughter. "Did you at least try to start taking Moon Tea?" he asked. A common birth control option for mares.

"Of course not, Daddy! Where would be the fun in that!?" She pointed at her trophy shelf with all of her old, positive pregnancy tests from their many previous sessions. Once she got a fresh positive result from this coupling to show him in a few days, it would be off to the apothecary for her in the next town over for another Oopsie Daisy potion. As much as she loved him getting her pregnant over and over, she didn't want to actually raise a foal.

She looked down at where his shaft was buried inside her and purred. "I can feel you pumping so much cum inside me, Daddy! You're going to get me so pregnant again! I'll need to head to the next town over and get a test to make sure! Aren't you excited!?"

"... Of course, sweetie. I love getting my daughter pregnant."

Still sitting on his lap with him hilted inside her, she grinned touched his nose with her hoof. "But as much as I know you want grandfoals you know we can't keep it! We aren't even married. What would the neighbors think!?"

"I know, dear."

"Maybe someday though," she said as she rubbed her hooves over her belly. "I bet you'd love to see my push out our beautiful foal right here! But then I wouldn't be your tight little filly anymore! And we can't have that. I know you love how snug my little pussy is, just for you, Daddy!"

"Of course, sweetie."

She slowly lifted herself off of him and stood beside the cot. She quickly checked her behind to make sure none of him was leaking out before she swayed her hips. "Mmm! I can feel your cum sloshing around inside me!" She walked back over to the lift to head upstairs. "I'm going to head out to the Apothecary. I'll see you soon when I get home. Love you, Daddy!"

"... Love you too, dear."