Don't Trust Pinkie

by Holocron

Rating: mature
Tags: Alternate Universe, Porn, Sex, Fetish, Profanity, Random, Rumble, Pinkie Pie, Anthro, Pound Cake, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Button Mash
Length: 1010

Sweetie Belle, Scootaloo, and Pumpkin Cake have a conversation about Pinkie Pie, while the pink mare take their special somepony on a beach date.

Pinkie Pie is among one of the most friendly and cheerful pony in all of Ponyville, if not all of Equestria. But ever since she gave birth to her son, Lil Cheese, she's been a little "too friendly" with many stallion, both younger and older. At Sugarcube Corners, Sweetie Belle, Scootaloo, and Pumpkin Cake talk about these "issues", while Pinkie herself have take these three mare's special someponies out on a beach date.

This is part of my 1K Challenge.
Derpibooru: 2900285

Published 2023-07-08 00:50:02 UTC
Last updated 2023-07-08 00:50:02 UTC

That Stallion Stealing Pinkie

The doors of Sugarcube Corners burst open on as Sweetie Belle and Scootaloo storm the place. Inside, Pumpkin Cake was alone, cleaning up some tables, but with an annoyed look on her face. One look at these two, and she knew all too well, that these two were facing the same problems she must've been going through. Setting up a table, she sat, waiting for the others to join her. Sitting with the mare, Sweetie and Scootaloo huffed and panted, as if they had ran to get here.

"Where is she?" They asked together. "Where's that whore?"

"Gone. With Button and Rumble already." Pumpkin replied with a sigh. "Even took Pound with her."

"Where'd they go?" Sweetie asked, frustration fueling her words. "I wanna know where that slut took my Button!"

At a beach, somewhere far from the three mares, Pinkie was busy enjoying herself, with the three stallions she had snagged with her. Pound Cake, Button Mash, and Rumble were all not only in their swim trunks, but she was showing off her own naughty bikini. Though she had barely had it on for a half hour before deciding it was time to have her fun. Flashing her fat, pink tits, Pinkie lured in the three with ease. She had known these stallions since they were little colts, and now she was gonna fuck their adorable brains out. All while their marefriends fumed angrily about it back home.

"Heyya boys!" Pinkie giggled, smiling seductively at the three stallions. The three of them all having huge boners over the sight of the mare's massive tits. "Wanna help Pinkie have some fun?"

"Look, I know it sucks." Pumpkin groaned, trying to remain calm, but was just as frustrated as the other two. "Since giving birth to Lil Cheese, Pinkie's been a bigger slut than normal. Not only have I caught her sucking off dad, but she's been seducing my Pound."

"Isn't Pound your brother?" Scootaloo asked, to which Pumpkin blushed. Shaking her head, she looked back to Sweetie. "Not the point. Pinkie's been doing that to Rumble!"

"I've seen her showing little flashes to Button on occasion too." Sweetie added. "He barely looks at me now. He's been lured in by that bimbo's fat tits, and we gotta know where they went!"

"Mmm...oh yeah...right there..." Pinkie moaned, feeling as both Button and Pound were suckling on her bare chest. "Don't get...greedy..." She moaned whorishly as the two indulged themselves. "There's plenty of Pinkie for everypony."

As the two stallions enjoyed Pinkie's tits, Rumble was on his knees in front of her. His face was buried in the mare's pussy, savoring her sweet nectar as he was carefully tonguefucking her. The mare only moaned on, placing her hands on the back of Button and Pound's heads as she held them close to her tits. Even months after giving birth to her son, she's still leaking out creamy milk. And these stallions couldn't get enough of it.

"Look, girls. Clearly we can't stop them now." Pumpkin commented, crossing her arms as she stared at the two of them. "They're going to have to return eventually. So wouldn't it be better to come up with what those three are gonna do to make up for this."

"I was just gonna dump Button for this." Sweetie commented, huffing a little. "If he's gonna cheat on me, with Pinkie, then I was just gonna smack him and be done with it."

"I wanted to hear from Rumble why he would do it first." Scootaloo added in. "Then I was going to break up with him."

"Yes, yes, I understand how you both feel." Pumpkin nodded, still keeping her composure. "But at the same time. Look at us." Gesturing along her own body, as well as Sweetie's and Scootaloo's. "How could we compete with Pinkie's figure? She's a walking sex toy, and she knows it."

"That's not an excuse!" Sweetie snapped, only to calm down with an frustrated sigh. "But...what exactly did you have in mind?"

"I was thinking, when the four of them get back, we should give them a taste of their own cheating." Pumpkin suggested, her lips curled into a sinister smile. "And I know just the stallion."

"Who?" Both Sweetie and Scootaloo asked. "Who could possibly help us?"

"Pinkie's husband, Cheese Sandwich." Pumpkin answered, confidence in her voice. "I'm sure he can help us."

"How are you so sure?" Sweetie asked, curious as to the mare's idea. "I doubt he'll just cheat on Pinkie just because we tell him about her."

"Don't worry, I have an idea." Pumpkin replied. "While Pinkie was pregnant, I saw how he would look at me when he thought I wasn't looking. So trust me, I know what I'm doing."

"We're in!" Sweetie and Scootaloo replied. "Where do we start."

"Don't worry about it." Pumpkin replied. "I'll let you know."

Pinkie's body was spasming out in pleasure. While Pound was literally pounding his cock in her slutty hole, both Rumble and Button were shoving both their lengths in her mouth. The mare was gagging and moaning muffled, whorish sounds as she eagerly took in these cocks. Her body was soaked in both sweat and passion, while both pussy and mouth were being fucked like living sex holes. The stallions were close to cumming, feeling their orgasms bubbling up inside them. Pinkie was already cumming, making Pound's dick slip in and out of her pussy with ease.

Grunting, the three stallions groaned together, gritting their teeth as they could feel themselves cumming. All at once, the three of them pulled back, only to push forward. There, they bottomed out in the mare's mouth and pussy, stuffing her with their combined, thick loads. Pinkie swallowed all the cum, from both ends, while the three stallions savored this moment. Even as their post nut clarity hit them, the though of their marefriends finding out didn't even register, while Pinkie was moaning and shivering, ready to be fucked again, in another round.