Josh has to find a way to make it back to earth with Tail Flight and Wind Rust to preserve and restore their feline memories, possibly leaving behind all of the dreams that he's achieved in the one week he's been in Equestria.

Josh's letter takes him over to Equestria. Along the way, he reunites with Tail Flight, Wind Rust and Wiretap as well as gaining wings so he could fly, all of which would not have been possible if not for a senior prank.

Jostle Jinx comes to Manehatten only to find a nationwide disaster struck below his hooves on the way there causing him to fall unconscious.

Ponies have went missing and it's up to the four princesses to find them.

The narrator finds that every single cat he knows alive has been turned into their Equestrian counterparts as the result of a senior prank.