Several years ago, Berry Punch was just a teenager trying to make it through high school. She was just like any other pony with her own unique struggles and challenges. Then, once hearing that her best friend Cheerilee is going to college to become a teacher, she realizes that she won't be able to spend nearly as much time with her, so why not do something together while they still could.

Then, the best night ever takes a turn for the worst when they run into somepony who they didn't know was real...

Written before season 9. Now with alt universe tag because things happened.