An Apple for a Diamond

YOU'RE THE APPLE IN MY EYE

“Big Macintosh's and Applejack seem so upset...how am I going to cheer them up?” Pinkie Pie thought to herself as she stirred the batter in the bowl with her mouth, poured it into a cupcakes sheet, and stuck the batch into the oven a few moments later. “If a party won't work then I’ll have to try a different approach...” Pinkie Pie thought to herself as she walked up stairs and to her room.

It was then she noticed a little green book on her bed with a letter tied to it. Curiously the pink mare undid the string and read the letter.

To Pinkie Pie,

It has come to my attention that things are not going very well in Ponyville between Big Macintosh and his sister. Between your carefree personalty and this book I’m sure you will know exactly how to help Big Macintosh out. Please return the book to me after you are finished with it to prevent it from getting into the wrong hooves. Namely, a certain purple dragon's.

Your proud ruler and mentor,

Princess Celestia

Upon reading this letter a wide grin spread onto Pinkie Pie's face. “Oh Celestia, you know me too well...which is kind of creepy! Creepy, but good!” Pinkie Pie exclaimed with a wide smile. Pinkie Pie did have one other talent besides throwing parties it was a talent she liked to keep a secret, one she wasn't too proud of, but none-the-less knew she was VERY good at.

“If a party won't cheer Big Macintosh up then maybe I can!” Pinkie Pie exclaimed with a smile putting an emphasis on the letter “I” as she spoke it, grabbed the green book and ran off towards Apple Acres...

“What the hay are you doin here Pinkie Pie? Ah thought ah made myself clear when ah said to steer clear from mah farm yesterday.” Big Macintosh said in a upset tone. He wasn't nearly as upset to see her as he was yesterday but that didn't stop him from sounding like he was willing to get that way very quickly.

“Silly Big Macintosh, I didn't come here to cause problems for you. I just wanted to make an offer that I think you might have a hard time refusing.” Pinkie Pie said in the best seductive tone she could muster.

Big Macintosh blinked several times clearly showing that he got the hint as a faint blush could be seen showing up on his face. “Ah reckon ya proposin to go hoof knockin with meh. While ah appreciate the offer, hoof knockin with y'all won't help meh feel any better. I had to disown mah sister no thanks to Rarity. And nothing can stop meh from feelin terrible for it.” Big Macintosh replied, turned around, and began to walk away.

Pinkie Pie wasn't about to give up however. She knew he had always wanted to bang her puffy pink cunt raw thanks to the little book in her hooves which was now red and she wasn't going to stop till he was balls deep inside her. After all this was her secret talent. Some ponies might call her a slut for it but Pinkie Pie knew that sex was the only way to cheer some ponies up and if it meant using her own body to put a smile on their face then that was something she was willing to give to make a pony happy. It was time to turn up the heat.

“Oh come now Big Mac. I know you want me, besides after all those nights with Applejack it's no surprise that you'd be hurt to find out she was with a mare.” Pinkie Pie said with a grin making the red stallion come to a screeching halt, whirl around and walk up to her so he was barely five inches away from her face.

“How the hay could you know that?!” Big Macintosh asked in a panicked whisper.

“I know a lot of things...” Pinkie Pie replied batting her eyes at him.

“It wasn't like that at all, ah mean...we both knew we would find someone we liked sooner or later but...ah just couldn't bare thought of losin her like that. Sides, it's not that simple.” Big Macintosh said in a whisper as his ears folded back with a guilty look on his face.

“Well maybe you can tell me while we help you release some of that tension. How long has it been?” Pinkie Pie asked in a seductive tone as she turned away from him, lifted up her tail revealing her prize to him on purpose.

“It's been nearly a year.” Big Macintosh replied not quite ready to submit to temptation yet but clearly showing signs of his weakening resolve as his erection slowly began to show.

“You poor stallion you, don't you want me to make you feel happy? After all when a party can't fix a problem, Celestia knows that there's always another way to put a smile on a stallion's face.” Pinkie Pie said still not turning around with a wide smile on her face.

“Ah....Ah...Ah swear. You are makin it a might hard to not pound the livin daylights out of ya.” Big Macintosh said as his face looked very flushed and his stallionhood fully erect now.

“You silly pony. I wouldn't be showing myself off if I wasn't wanting your pony meat.” Pinkie Pie said with a turning to look back at him with a naughty grin.

“Ya won't hold it aginst meh for goin all out?” Big Macintosh said finally giving into temptation as he aligned his stallionhood with Pinkie Pie's entrance with the tip parting now dripping pink lips ever so slightly.

“Nope-dopey! And while we're at it maybe you can fill me in on what's going ah-ah-on-AHH!” Pinkie Pie exclaimed having her sentence abruptly cut off by a high peaked squeal of pleasure as Big Macintosh rammed his full length into her rapidly hard and fast.

Pinkie Pie wasn't expecting this much force but she took it with stride as she braced herself against the barn wall at Big Macintosh plowed her puffy pink cunt like no tomorrow...

SEVERAL HOURS LATER....

“Dear Celestia! He's already came twenty times and he's not done?! I've never seen such a pent up pony before!” Pinkie Pie thought to herself dramatically as Big Macintosh continued to pound the living daylights out of her cunt which by now was dripping with Big Macintosh's cum and her own. However she had a lot to tell the others once he was done with her as he had pretty much spilled his guts to her over the course of the last several hours.

“How much frustration have you had built up there?” Pinkie Pie asked between moans having just had yet another orgasm, she had lost count after the thirtieth time but she no longer cared.

“Quite a bit. Ah'm shocked you haven't asked meh to stop yet cause ah can keep goin for a lot longer..” Big Macintosh replied as his cock slammed into her once again blowing several thick ropes of stallion spunk into her soaking wet and dripping slit which was already overflowing from cum causing even more to gush out with each thrust and trail down her hind legs.

“I can keep going all night if need be stud, so pound me as long as you want!” Pinkie Pie said with a wide smile. “God, I’m in heaven, but I know I’m going to regret this later!” Pinkie Pie thought to herself once again climaxing as her puffy pink pussy clamped down on Big Macintosh's meat inside of her...

“Have you seen Pinkie Pie?” Twilight asked Mrs. Cake as she walked in with her plan to help patch things up with Applejack and Rarity.

“Oh, she came home not to long ago, but she looked very sore. I wonder what the poor mare was up to?” Mrs. Cake remarked looking up the stairs as Twilight slowly walked up them to Pinkie Pie's room and knocked on it.

“Come in...” Pinkie Pie's voice said in a sore tone.

“Hey Pinkie Pie how are you...OH DEAR CELESTIA!” Twilight exclaimed dramatically as Pinkie Pie lay on her bed spread eagle with an ice pack between her legs. “What happened? I mean not that I’m staring or anything but you're vagina looks...” Twilight trailed off with a blush.

“Like a gaping hole? Yeah well Big Macintosh can have that effect on a pony. Give me a day or so and it'll look normal again!” Pinkie Pie said in a cheery tone even though she still sounded sore.

“He didn't rape you did he?” Twilight asked in a concerned tone.

“Oh no, I let him have his way with me...” Pinkie Pie said trailing off before her expression turned to dreamy. “For eight hours straiiiit...” Pinkie Pie said in a dreamy tone drawing out her final word in a blissful tone.

“No wonder your sore!” Twilight exclaimed in a shocked yet concerned tone then another thought occurred to her. “Umm Pinkie Pie, what about...” Twilight said trailing off as she knew what the usual result was between a mare and a stallion going at it.

“Oh don't worry about that you silly filly. I may act crazy but I’m not stupid!” Pinkie Pie exclaimed with a smirk pointing a hoof at her counter with a small box with lettering on it that read:

Wanna have a night you want to remember forever but worry about the results that will come from such a pleasurable night? Take one of our FOAL BEGONE pills and you can go at it for up to twenty-hours without any consequences!

Reading this made the Purple unicorn give a sigh of relief but she was still worried for her friend as she looked very sore. “But why would you do that though Pinkie? I mean weren't you scared that Big Macintosh might react badly to you showing up?” Twilight asked in a concerned tone.

“At first I was but then I figured that if anypony could cheer him up it would be me! Besides I found out a whole lot of things. Like why the apple family is so against their own going off and being lesbian or gay!” Pinkie Pie said with a wide smile she always wore when she was very happy.

“Oh? Care to fill me in? And while I’m listening I can fill you in on my plan to help Applejack and Rarity make up.” Twilight said as she sat down on the bed next to her.

“So that's why...but why would granny smith force her entire family do abide by such a rule just because her first love went gay on her and cheated on her with another stallion?” Twilight asked curiously after Pinkie Pie's long explanation.

“Don't know, but at least we know why the apple family don't like it when one of their own go lesbian or gay. So what's your plan?” Pinkie Pie replied with a smile.

“Well you see...” Twilight began said and began to explain her plan to Pinkie Pie.

“Oh! I see! That sounds like an awesome way to help them make up! But do you think Rarity will actually sing it?” Pinkie Pie asked curiously.

“If she doesn't then I spent the last eight hours writing up lyrics for nothing.” Twilight replied with a smile even though she had a look of worry in her eyes. “So can you do it?” Twilight asked curiously after a few moments.

“Of course!” Pinkie Pie said hoping up suddenly then put both hooves over her snatch and gave a pained groan before flopping back onto her back and reapplying the icepack. “Just give me a day or so...Big Macintosh really rode this pony hard...” Pinkie Pie said in a pained tone but with a wide smile which caused the purple mare to giggle.

“Sounds like you and him had a blast.” Twilight remarked with a grin.

“Yep! By the time we were through I might as well have changed my name to Pinkie creampie!” Pinkie Pie exclaimed followed shortly by a giggle.

“Haha, well alright. I'll see you later Pinkie Pie.” Twilight said giving a cheesy evil grin as she slapped the icepack causing Pinkie Pie's eyes to water up and give a squeal of pain.

“Twilight, I swear to Celestia...do that again and I swear you'll be the secret ingredient in my next cupcakes recipe!” Pinkie Pie said doubling over in pain now however immediately broke into a laughter afterward despite the pain she was in as Twilight gave a hearty laugh of her own as she left the room.

TWO WEEKS LATER...

“You want me to sing this?” Rarity asked in a semi-shocked tone.

“If you want to. Pinkie Pie is making arrangements as we speak but she won't give them the green light unless you're okay with this.” Twilight said in a matter of fact tone.

“Well of course darling! Though...” Rarity said trailing off.

“Is something wrong with it?” Twilight asked curiously.

“No, no nothing is wrong with it at all.” Rarity said quickly even though she knew it was a lie. These lyrics while good didn't express how she truly felt but she didn't have the heart to crush Twilight's hard work after she had gone to such great lengths.

“Okay, then i'll give Pinkie Pie the green light then.” Twilight replied with an eager smile as she swiftly left the room.

THREE DAYS LATER...

“It is my pleasure to announce the first annal Ponyville fall talent concert!” Mayor mare exclaimed which was meet with cheers by everypony there including Twilight and the other five with the exception of Rarity.

“Ah still don't see how this is gonna cheer meh up.” Applejack remarked sourly as the first group of ponies stepped up on stage.

“Well, it's better than sulking in your house isn't it?” Twilight replied with a eager smile.

“Ah suppose y'all got a point thar.” Applejack replied even though she wasn't all that entertained by the ponies on stage who were performing a rock ballad as she looked around. “Have ya seen Rarity as of late?” Applejack asked curiously.

“Oh? She said she couldn't make it.” Twilight lied knowing that Rarity was one of the ponies who would be performing this evening.

Several performances later Applejack was just about to walk away when Mayor Mare announce the next performance was by Rarity which made her whirl around and stare at the stage.

Rarity stepped up on stage as a alternative style music began to play, looked about the crowd and saw Applejack. The white mare hesitated but began to sing after a few moments only to stop much to Twilight's disappointment.

“Twilight, while I appreciate the gesture darling this song does not suit my feelings.” Rarity said before stepping off stage. However just as Twilight thought her plan had failed a different kind of music began to play, this music was much similar to a classical feel but it had a tempo to it that made you feel as if it was going to be an upbeat song.

It was at this point Rarity stepped back up on stage. “Before I begin, I would like to say a few words. There is a very special pony in the audience tonight. A pony very close to my heart, who I would give anything for her to know just how much I love them. This song is to them from my heart.” Rarity said, took a deep breath and began to sing.

Life is not perfect, nor is it grand...

But deep within my heart I know one thing to be true,

My life is not complete without you,

Though times may be hard,

I can always take your hoof in mine and know that that even if things look bleak,

No matter what happens you're always the one I seek,

Because....

Your the apple of my eye,

Your love is my reason why,

I will never doubt you,

I will never judge you...

Rarity then paused in her song ass the music continued to play, and wiped tears from her eyes before she started singing again.

Sometimes things are said that we don't mean,

They can be hurtful as it would seem...

But if there is one thing I know to be true,

I can make through anything,

As long as I have you...

Because...

Your the apple in my eye,

Your love is my reason why,

I will never doubt you,

I will never judge you...

My life is not complete without you,

So ask you ask you now...

If you feel the same way please take a bow...

Rarity then slowly stepped backward off the stage as the lights dimmed and the crowd burst into cheers and hoofstomps of applause.

“That was great! Don't you think Applejack?” Twilight exclaimed looking over to see Applejack was no longer standing there. “Applejack?” Twilight asked looking around when she saw the farm pony barreling through the crowd towards the back of the stage and smiled. “Go get her cowpony...” Twilight remarked with quietly with a teary smile.

“That was a truly marvelous performance!” Mayor Mare remarked looking at Rarity who seemed lost in thought.

“Oh? Yes, I suppose it was. I just hope the message got through.” Rarity replied as she walked away down the steps behind the stage to see Applejack standing there and in the next moment nearly tackling her as she kisses her passionately before she broke the kiss and two a few steps back to look at Rarity.

“Rarity...ah...ah'm sorreh for what I said. I didn't mean a lick of it.” Applejack said taking her hat off and lowering her head in shame as a silent tear streaked down her cheek.

“I'm sorry as well. I was out of line for what I said.” Rarity replied with a frown.“You're still welcome to stay with me if you like.” Rarity said after a few moments only for Applejack to lock lips with her again.

The two continued to make out until a voice cleared their throat making the both of them look to see Big Macintosh standing there. “Don't start anythin, I already told ya I don't care what you think of meh. ah love her.” Applejack said moving Rarity behind her as she said this.

“Ah didn't come here to start anythin.” Big Macintosh replied in a slightly annoyed tone before his expression softened greatly.

“Then why the hay you here for?” Applejack asked curiously as Rarity stepped from behind her and stood beside her.

“Ah came to say ah'm sorreh for being such a horseapple brained twit. Ah heard your song Rarity. That kind of song could only be sung from the heart, ah see that now. Can y'all forgive meh?” Big Macintosh said giving the best comforting smile he could muster.

To this Applejack smiled. “Ah already have bro.” Applejack replied giving her brother a loving hug which he returned without hesitation.

“I forgive you as well, Big Mac. After all I can't hold a grudge for too long now can I?” Rarity said with a smile.

“Y'all are welcome on the farm anytime, and sis ya is more than welcome to come back and stay with meh on the farm.” Big Macintosh said shortly after they broke their hug.

“Ah appreciate the offer bro but ah think ah'm gonna be livin with Rarity from now on. But ah'm more than happy to help ya farm them apples.” Applejack replied with a smile.

“Sounds good to meh.” Big Macintosh replied smiling broadly now.

“Oh, Big Macintosh!” Pinkie Pie exclaimed not far from them batting her eyes with a cheesy grin.

“Oh, horseapples. Ah go at it one time with her and she's not been leavin meh alone since.” Big Macintosh said with an eyeroll.

“Well, ya do have that effect on a gal.” Applejack replied with a wink which Rarity noticed.

“What's that about?” Rarity asked with an inquiring look and a smile.

“Ah'll tell ya later. But ah think we aughta get goin. We got a lot to catch up on.” Applejack replied as Pinkie Pie ran up to Big Macintosh and tackled him much to his own shock. “Don't be goin easy on her bro. She likes em rough and hard from what ah hear.” Applejack remarked with a giggle as Pinkie Pie began to nibble on his ear.

“Oh Horseapples....might as well.” Big Macintosh said got to his feet, slammed Pinkie Pie against the back of the stage and began to plow her puffy pink pussy for all it was worth.

The days seemed to fly on for the mane six as time went on and even Big Macintosh finally decided to go steady with Pinkie Pie to see how things went but if there is one thing they would never forget it is this:

Thought times may be hard, never forget the ones you love, for they will always be there for you when you need them...