You mumble, looking back and forth across the town, watching the ponies go about their daily lives. Your head quickly comes to a stop as you see a rather distinctive landmark of Ponyville, the Golden Oak Library. You gaze at the hollowed out tree, towering into the air, its leaves rustling in the light breeze. "Wish we had houses like that back home." you think. "Well might as well go check it out...and check out Twilight..."
There are bounces in your steps as you happily make your way towards the library in an almost drug like state of joy from your wonderful adventure so far and think intently about what’s to come. You open the door with a giddy grin on your face and are greeted by a purple unicorn, already observing your body. "Hi Twilight!" you say excitedly.

"Hello..." she mutters, her eyes jumping back and forth across your body.

You quickly look up, hearing a very familiar voice. "There you are...I was kinda worried when you didn't show up last night."

"Oh yeah, sorry about that. I uh...sort of got busy...what are you doing here anyways Lyra?"

"Yeah, I know. I heard about your little performance this morning too." she says, looking up at you with a smirk. "I just thought that...you wanted to spend more time with me. You told me that you...never mind, don't worry about it. Twilight was just interested in anything that I could tell her about humans now that she knows they exist, so here I am.” she says somewhat sadly.

"I'm really sorry, I..." you try to say but are quickly stopped.

"No don't worry about it...just do whatever you want." Lyra tells you, looking sadly at the floor beneath her.

"I really do li..."

"So, you use these hands to grip things?" Twilight interrupts, using her hoof to raise your hand towards her face.

You grab her hoof, displaying your hand’s abilities but realize something very odd. "Hmm Twilight isn't an Alicorn yet...”

"Umm are you going to let go?" Twilight asks as you still hold tightly onto her hoof.

"Oh yeah, sorry about that." you say, awkwardly releasing her hoof.

"It's okay." she says with a smile. These 'hands' of yours are very interesting. I can't wait to examine you further!"

"..further?" you ask excitedly.

"Mhm." she mutters and begins to giggle but quickly stops herself and sighs, attempting to be serious. "I’ve been trying to figure it out since you were first introduced to the town. It seems as though no matter who they are, everypony is attracted to you. I just don't understand why two different races would be so attracted to one another...it just doesn't seem natural. Is it just you or would it be that way with any human?"

"Well, it's not just ponies that are attracted to humans, I think ponies are very sexy." you add.

"Hmm true, I wonder what the connection is…" Twilight ponders, rubbing her hoof against her chin. I sort of promised myself I'd be a good researcher and not get involved with any of this but...well, I just can't resist." she stumbles to say and blushes. "So uh...can I start examining more of your body?" she begins to giggle nervously. "Even if it's not really for scientific reasons?"

"Ye..." you begin to say, but catch the glance of Lyra's golden eyes. "Uh..."

"Go ahead." she tells you. "As long as I get to join."

You look at Twilight, waiting eagerly for her approval. She stares lustfully into your eyes and nods. "So, let me see everything." You quickly take off your shirt, unzip your pants and throw them to the floor. She examines your body once more, this time in a much less scientific manner. She blushes brightly and says "I said everything, mister." you slip your underwear off revealing your hardening cock. She moans and licks her lips, moving closer to you. You feel a rush of pleasure and beginning to pant, tilt your head backwards. Wondering what's happening, you look down and realize that an aura of glowing magenta engulfs your genitals. Twilight smiles at your pleasure. "It's a spell I found in a book a while back...I just haven't had the chance to use it until now. I hope I'm doing well. You nod your head in approval and moan. "Good." She takes a step closer and begins to rub her soft purple hoof up and down your cock.

"Mmm Twi...Twilight." you moan pleasurably. She looks up and smiles at you seductively before bending her head forward and slowly licking up and down your cock, coating it with her warm saliva. She moves her hoof back to her wet marehood and rubs it up and down, panting lightly.

"Lyra." she says staring back at the mint colored unicorn. "Help me out." She spreads her legs apart, widening her hole. "I want your horn." she moans. Lyra blushes and moves forward. Peering over top of Twilight, you watch Lyra slowly pushing her horn deep into Twilight’s pussy and her juices being squeezed out onto the floor. The purple unicorn moans loudly and shoves her mouth over your cock. You smile and greedily push her head down further. Her mouth glides up and down your cock as she quickens the pace. Twilight screams with pleasure as Lyra pushes her horn in and out of her pussy. Her body begins to shake and her juices squirt out, covering Lyra's face. She releases your cock from her mouth and looks up at you. "Now it's your turn." she smiles, rearing upwards and then crashing atop you, making you fall to the floor. She looks down and stares deep into your eyes then bends down and kisses you passionately before using her magic to position your cock, prodding her flankhole against it. You stare into her eyes lustfully, wanting more. "You really want it huh?" she teases, prodding a bit harder. You nod your head, beginning to drool. "Well, I want it too." she says thrusting her tight flankhole down on your cock. She screams in a combination of pain and pleasure and pushes your cock in further. You moan loudly and grab tightly onto her plump flank, her soft purple fur pushing between your fingers. She moves her body up and down moaning and panting loudly.

"I want some too." Lyra says, stepping over top of you and shoving her marehood in your face. You use your free hand to spread the lips of her pussy apart and shove your tongue deep inside. She moans loudly as you forcefully move your tongue up and down. Twilight begins to hump faster and faster, screaming with pleasure, the juices of her marehood flowing out onto your body. Building up, you cannot resist the amazing combination of warm juices on your body, Twilight's tight flankhole and her sexy screams of pleasure. You pant loudly, grabbing even tighter onto the mare's flank and thrust your tongue deep into Lyra's pussy before cuming. Twilight's small hole is quickly filled with your semen and it drips out over your cock. Lyra moans as she too orgasms, squirting her juices onto your face and into your mouth.

"Time to switch." Twilight says, sliding her flankhole off of your cock and stepping away. Lyra lies down on top of you and stares passionately into your eyes.

"This'll be fun." she smiles, moving her wet pussy up and down your cock and leans forward to kiss you.

"Umm you know what? Let me just leave you two alone." Twilight says, realizing how passionate Lyra really was. "I've already gotten my share and I have to get cleaned up anyways. Both you and Lyra silently watch as Twilight makes her way up the stairs and listen to the sound of her hooves against them. She enters her bedroom and quickly closes the door behind her.

"Good." Lyra whispers, turning her head towards you and blushing again. "I'm glad I have you all to myself." she smiles and stares deeply into your eyes. You smile back and cup your hand around her head, bringing it closer so you can kiss her. She moans as the two of you play with one another’s tongue, once again moving her marehood back and forth across your hardening cock. She breaks away from your kiss and pleasurably sighs "I want it."

"Well you can have it." you say with a smile, using your hand to position your cock. She slowly pushes her tight marehood down onto you, blushing brightly and moans loudly, slowly moving up and down the first inch of your cock. She pauses for a moment and nervously pushes it in deeper

"Are you alright?" you ask noticing her nervousness.

"I uh...I..." she pauses for a moment and then thrusts your cock deep into her pussy, letting out a scream. You moan with pleasure but quickly stop as you realize that blood drips from the mare’s hole.

"Is this your first time?" you ask, your eyes growing with surprise.

"Y-yes" she says nervously.

"But you..." you stumble to speak, becoming rather confused.

"Almost everypony thinks I'm weird here so, I don't really get much attention...I should've told you but...I guess I was worried."

"No it's fine. I'm happy to be your first." you say, placing your hands around her waist and push your cock deeper inside her. She slowly pushes back against you, moaning quietly. She smiles blissfully as you gently move your hand down her body, to her flank, and then down her leg. She leans down and kisses you again, closing her eyes as she quickens the pace. You move your hand from her leg to her head and gently push your fingers through her hair, joining in with her movements. She backs away from the kiss beginning to moan loudly. Biting her lower lip, she wraps her hoof tightly around your arm and grinds hard against you. Her eyes glisten brightly and she lets out a small scream as you feel her juices pour over your cock.

"Thank...you" she says through heavy breaths. She leans down and wraps her hooves around you, grinding her body against you and pushing your cock deep inside her. She pants heavily as her juices continue to flow over your cock.

"For a first time, you're pretty amazing." you say, leaning your head back and moaning. You begin grunting quietly, feeling yourself building up. Before you can cum she lets your cock slide out of her and begins to rub her body up and down it. Her soft fur feels amazing, quickly sending you over the edge. The mint colored Unicorn leans down and kisses you one more time, suppressing your moans as you squirt your cum onto her fur.

"That was wonderful..." she moans, rubbing the cum through her fur. "I-I love you" she stumbles to let out and blushes.

"I...uh..." you mutter, not expecting the sudden announcement. You stay silent, your eyes growing wide.

(Do I love her? Is this really meant to be? If not, what should I tell her? I really don't want to hurt her feelings...maybe I really do love her...she's amazing but)

Author's Note

Yeah, that's right! It's time to get serious...Do you really love Lyra that much? How are you going to deal with this situation? It'll be fun to see.