The sky is blue and all the leaves are green in Ponyville, and the only thing that can make this day even better would be something sweet from the local bakery. Yet a phenomena occurs when the delicious treats at the Sugarcube Corner appear to taste even better than usual! And so the CMC, using their great skills of investigation, attempt to find out the source of these wonderful pastries. What entails is a story of mystery, horror, suspense, shock, and in the end, hope.