Nightscares

by Reverie Metherlence

Rating: teen
Tags: Tragedy, Dark, Sad, Adventure
Length: 4906

When Pinkie has horrible nighscares it ruins her life. When they come real it might end her life.

Based off of Silent Ponyville.

Sorta.

Published 1970-01-01 00:00:00 UTC
Last updated 2012-07-30 12:56:29 UTC

Slumber party gone wrong

        The storm was about to start and Pinkie had just arrived at Twilights. She gulped and slowly knocked on the door. Twilight opened it and let Pinkie inside. Everypony else was already there, inclouding Rainbow. They sat in a circle around a latern and started to play truth or dare. First Twilight ask Applejack truth or dare. Applejack picked truth,(Big surpirse) And had to tell everypony that she was the reson the heard of cows almost ran over ponyville. She had aciddently scared them and then they just charged. The game went on for a while and then Applejack dared everypony to say what there worst nightscare was.

  "My worst nightscare was the one where angel died." Fluttershy said.

  "My worst nightscare was the one where everypony hated my dress and tore them to shreds." Rarity said.

"Mine is the one where a flying stunt goes wrong and I die!" Rainbow said.

"Mine is the one were I"m fibbin again and Discord has killed Twilight and everypony else is Discored." Applejack said. Everypny was quiet for a bit after that.

"My worst nightscare is that all my books are gone and the princess and you guys all hate me!" Twilight said.

Pinkie gulped and said, "My worst nightscare is the one where somepony steals all the money from Suger Cube Corner."

"Oh ya, I know that we all paid a bunch to give them close to same amount that was stolen." Rainbow said.

"Sugercube. You're fibbin! I can tell! That's not you're worst nightscare. You've had one worst then that haven't you?" Applejack said. Pinkie gulped again.

"Sugercube...you can tell us what the dream was."

"NO I can't!" Pinkie said. Pinkie was now circled by her friends.

"Come ON Pinkie tell us! PPPPPLLLEEEEAAAASSSSEEEEE!?" Rainbow beged. All the ponys were looking at Pinkie and she couldn't take it anymore.

   "Okay. Okay. In the dream I-I k-killed Rainbow." Pinkie stuttered. They all gasped. Rainbow backed up and stuttered,

  "Y-Your going to KILL me?!" Before Pinkie could respond Rainbow flew out the door into the storm. Without a word Fluttershy flew off into the rain after Rainbow Dash. Pinkie turned to the rest of the ponies and them with fear in their eyes where backing away from her. With tears running down her cheeks Pinkie walked out the door into the rain. As she walked through the rain to Suger Cube Corner the rain flattened her mane and tail. She walked home sobbing in the rain.

The Nightscares come to life

       CRASH

           The giant oak tree crashed to the ground. Pinkie panting with tears in her eyes looked around. Nothing was broken or hurt. She then saw that the tree had caused no damage not counting on lamp that was smashed. Pinkie had run out of the way in time but her tail wasn't so lucky. She looked back at her tail. She tried to pull it out but she couldn't. She had to cut it off. She grabbed a peice of glass from the lamp and used it to cut off her tail. She stood up and checked again to make sure she wasn't injured. She sighed and started to run to her house.

      Pinkie finally got her place and stepped onto her front step. When she did it caved in and she fell in her basment. She landed with a thud on her basment floor.

  "ow...great! Just great!" She said, Pinkie looked around the room she couldn't see anything because it was too dark. She walked over to a wall and felt her way across the room to the light switch.

  "That's odd usally theres so much stuff in here you can hardly walk. How come I never bumped into anything?" She said when she got to the light swich. Pinkie turned on the light and gasped. There was only two things in the room. She walked into the middle of the room to get a closer look. The first thing she saw was what looked like a surgery table with straps for holding down ponies. The other item scared her when she looked at it. It was a big metal table used for holding tools for surgery only the only things on there were big kichen knifes. She looked over the knifes one by one, she had never seen these knifes before. She knew what they were but she never really saw one. Her eyes stopped on the butcher knife, her eyes grew wide, she started breathing heavy and she had a look of fear on her face. The butcher knife was covered in blood. Pinkie ran out of the basment and up the stairs to her room. When she got into her room she went into the bathroom to splash some water on her face. As she was doing so something in the bathtub caught her eye, it was red and green. Pinkie had been playing with the hearth warming  stuff so she thought it was just that. She went to go put it in the attic with the other stuff but when she looked into the tub she screamed.

              There in the tub was her beloved Gummy, he was chopped up just like in her dream.

You're your own worst enemy

         Pinkie stepped back from the tub with tears already streming down her face. She fell to the ground in tears, the only thing she could think of was getting revenge on whoever did this. Pinki wasn't the type of pony to go seeking revenge, but she thought she had a perfectly good reason. The pink pony sat on the floor and cried for a while befroe she heard a vocie in her head,

" You arent REALLY going to let somepony get away with this are you?! You have to out there and KILL the sick pony who did this!!!!"

  Pinkie knew that vocie it was familiar but she didn't know who the vocie came from. All she knew was that she wasn't about to listen to a vocie that told her to kill a pony. Pinkie heard vocies in her head all the time and always listened to them but then again.... none of them told her to kill ponies. Pinkie was scared now and as she started to stand up to try to find somepony to help her she heard the voice again this time it was really irritated.

" Come ON Pinkie Pie don't you think it would be fun to just go outside and kill ponies?" The voice asked makeing it obvious that the voice was not in a good mood. Pinkie stood up and answered,

   "no"

" WHAT?!?! DID YOU JUST SAY NO TO ME?!?!?! YOU WILL GO OUTSIDE AND KILL PONIES NOW!!!!!!" The voice screached at the pink pony. The pony just stood there shaking for a couple of minutes before saying,

  "no.......no..........No........No....NO......NO....NO..NONONONONONONONONONONOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO" Pinkie screamed back at the voice.

"what"

   "I'm not going to kill ponies. They didn't do anything to me! I bet it was YOU who killed gummy! You better hope i don't find out who and where you are!!!!" As Pinkie said that last word her sraight hair poofed back up and she regained some of her color.

"You're going to regret saying that." Then the voice was gone. Pinkie could tell that it was gone for good. She was feeling happy until she relised that voice was way to familiar and that's when it hit her.

        The voice was her.

Meet Pinkamena

    Pinkie gasped as soon as she realised that the voice telling her to kill ponies was her voice. She couldn't belive it, she never would want to hurt a pony. But now something inside of her was telling her to hurt ponies. And what did the voice mean by you'll regret that? Pinkie was even more scared now and as she started to leave the bathroom she heard a knocking at the door.

   "Who is it?" Pinkie asked slowly waking to the door.

   "It's me Twilight.....Can I talk to you Pinkie?" The lavander unicorn asked at the door. Pinkie slowly opened the door and let Twilight in.

  "What is it Twi?"

  "Pinkie..........I'm REALLY sorry about the way I've treated you! Your dreams normally come true and I was just scared I'm so sorry!!!!!!!" Twilight was in tears as she said this, Pinkie sat down and hugged Twilight. Twilight looked at Pinkie and relised something was wrong.

   "Pinkie whats wrong you look like you've been crying." The unicorn asked. Pinkie burst into tears as she led Twilight upstairs. When Twi saw what was in the tub she almost passed out.

   "Pinkie.....what happened?!?!?!?!" The frantic unicorn asked with fear in her voice. As Pinkie explianed what happened Twilight put the peices together. She knew what was happening.

  "Pinkie I know whats going on! Your fear of loseing your friends was so strong that when it turned into nightscares they became real!!!!!!! Pinkie if we don't hury Dash could be in a lot of trouble."

  "WHAT???? DASHIE IS IN DANGER?" Pinkie yelled. The pony thought about it before asking Twilight a quiestion,

  "Twilight......who did this to Gummy?" Twilight thought for a second befroe answering.

  "Pinkie remeber when you thought we didn't like you or your parties anymore?"

  "ya........"

  "I think that part of you has come out and will hurt Dash. Pinkie, Pinkamena is about to kill Rainbow Dash." Pinkie gulped. She knew that her Pinkamena half was highly unstable, but she never thought it would be deadly. Pinkie thought about what she should do.

  "Twilight........"

  "Yes Pinkie?"

  "Will you help me kill myself?"

   "Of course I will Pinkie."

Gathering Friends

    "What do I need to do Pinkie?" Twilight asked the pink pony. Pinkie was walking back and forth in her room with Twilight sitting on her bed.

"Twilight, while I finish everything here I need you to go get our friends. They won't listen to me. Get Fluttershy and Dashie first they're the ones in danger." Pinkie said as she turned to Twilight. Twilight nodded her head and ran out the door as fast as she could while Pinkie started digging in her closet.

    Twilight was running through the pouring rain to Fluttershy's cottage. When she got there she was so exhausted she almost fell over. After she stopped panting she looked up and gasped. Fluttershy's door was wide open. Twilight stepped inside the cottage and gasped (again). Fluttershy was knocked out on her floor and Rainbow Dash was no where to be seen. Twilight relised she was to late and walked towards Fluttershy. She saw the head injury and that only one pony could help Fluttershy, Applejack.

_________________________________________________________________________

  Applejack was cleaning up some reackage from the storm with rest of her family when Twilight ran up.

  "Well howdy Twi! There something wrong?" The pony asked.

  "Applejack, Fluttershy needs you right now!" Twilight said as she started running to Fluttershy's cottage. Applejack droped the treebranch she was holding and ran after the unicorn. When they got there Applejack started inspecting Fluttershy's head.

"It's nothing to serious. Just a simple knock to tha head she'll be fine in a few minuites." Applejack said after a while. Twilight sighed out of relief. Twilight put Fluttershy on Applejack's back and they started over to Rarity.

  When they got there Twilight told Applejack to wait outside with Fluttershy the she stepped inside.

  "Rarity? You in here it's Twilight." The purple unicorn called into the what seemed to be an empty house. She heard some crashing in the back then Rarity popped out.

  "Twilight darling!!! What are you doing here?" She asked like she was trying to Twilight out as fast as possible. Twilight noticed that Rarity must have gotten into a fight with Opal because her face had a few scratches.

"Oh gosh Rarity look at those scratches!!! Applejack is right outside she can look at them for you. Did Opal do that?" She asked. Rarity shifted a bit and looked behind her before saying,

"Um yes Opal did this. She has been punished though. Why are you here darling?" As Rarity said that she put one hoof over Twilight and started leading her to the door.

"Well....um.....Rainbow Dash is in trouble and we really need you Rarity." Twilight said trying to get out of Rarity's grip.

"Oh is that all.....tell me where to go and I'll be there in a bit." Rarity said as she and Twilight reached the door. Twilight told her to meet her at Pinkie's as soon as possible. Even though a look of pure horror came across Rarity's face sh said she'd be there soon and Twilight and Applejack left.

_________________________________________________________________________________________________

   Pinkie was paceing in her room wondering what was takeing Twilight so long.

Maybe the other me got her before she could get to anyone. She thought as she sat down on her bed. While she waited she was trying to think of where she would take Dashie if she wanted to kill her. After a few minutes Twilight, Applejack, and a now standing Fluttershy. Pinkie jumped up when she saw her friends but quickly sat back down,

"Where's Dashie and Rarity?" She asked fearing she knew the answer. Twilight told her what Fluttershy had said. That 'Pinkamena' came hit Fluttershy in the head and took Dash. Twilight then explained that Rarity would be here shortly. Pinkie stared at the ground as tears began to form in her eyes.

"Now wait just a darn second!" Applejack suddenly said. "Twi would ya please tell me what in the hay is going on?" Applejack demanded. Twilight sighed and told Applejack and Fluttershy the whole story.

"So wait.....that wasn't Pinkie that attacked me but this Pinkamena?" Fluttershy said quietly after Twilight was done.

"Yep." Said the unicorn. " Pinkamena also........um killed Gummy." Twilight trying to be quiet as to not get Pinkie upset. Just then Rarity burst in asking what was going on. Twilight rexplained to Rarity then told her about what happened to Fluttershy. After that no pony said anything for a while before Fluttershy asked,

"Um Pinkie we of course have to get Rainbow back but um.....do you know where she is?" the pegasus sqeaked. Pinkie kept her down and said, "No" Then Rarity asked,

"Darling, this might be a bad time but can somepony tell me why there is a hole in the steps outside?" Rarity said looking around she saw everyone srhugging then she looked to Pinkie.

"That's because earlyer I fell through into my basment but there was nothing there but a........................................" Pinkie looked up gasped.

"I know where Dash is!!! I know where Pinkamena took her!!" Pinkie said jumping up and walking to the door.

"Well where the hay is she?" Asked Applejack. Pinkie turnned around said,

"My basment!"

   OMG soooooooo sorry this took so long. I was having lots of trouble with the wording of this chapter. I coudn't think of what to write. But the next chapter (the last one) I already have planned out so it won't take as long as this one did I promise. After the next chapter it's on to the next story! So yeah sory this chapter took so long thanks for reading please don't be a jerk in the comments.

Pinkie .VS. Pinkamena

     Rainbow Dash groaned as she slowly woke up. Her vision was blury but she could make out a table with some wierd objects on it. Then as her vision cleared more she saw Pinkamena,

  "Pinkie!!!! What are you doing? Where are we?!?! Why can't I move?!?!" Rainbow was panicked as she tried to free her hovves only for each attempt to fail. She stopped squriming when she heard the crazy laughter comeing from the pink pony in front of her. She could finally see clearly and when she saw her friend she knew something was wrong. Her usally poofy hair was long and straight. She had one of those grins that makes you shiver, and she was holding a knife. As soon as Rainbow saw the knife she panicked again and struggled even more. Rainbow was flapping her wings as hard as she could and screaming for someone to help her. She heard more giggling and looked at the pink pony holding the knife,

  "Oh Dashie!!!! Your so silly. You know you can't get away, besides don't you want to help me make cupcakes?"

  "NO NO I DON'T WANT HELP YOU MAKE YOUR STUIPD CUPCAKES!" Dash screamed. "HELP! SOMEPONY ANYPONY HELP ME PLEASE!" Rainbow knew what would happen to her if she didn't find a way to get out of here.

"Dashie!!!! Are you ok?!?!" Rainbow heard Pinkie but the one standing in front of her didn't say anything and instead was looking at the door with a look of hatred. Rainbow turned her head and the Pinkie pie that she knew, and behind her where all of her friends.

"Pinkie?! What's going on how can you be in two places at once?!?!" Rainbow was now more confused than scared.

"No time time to explain Rainbow come on!!" Twilight said as she realsed the straps that where holding the cyan pegasus. Rainbow flew over to the door as soon as she was free. She looked back when she heard an angry scream.

"NONONONONONONONO!!!!! THIS ISN'T WHAT I WANTED!!!!!!!" Pinkamena was stomping the ground in a fit of rage and then suddnely turned her attention to Pinkie.

"You........this is because of YOU! Because of you my plans are ruined....I HATE people who ruin my plans." Pinkamena said as she held up her knife. She then screamed again and chareged at Pinkie. Pinkie saw the danger that a battle could bring for her friends,

"Twilight get everyone out of the basment NOW!!!" Pinkie yelled at Twilight as she started to direct Pinkamena away from her friends. Twilight started to protest but as she looked around at her friends she led them all out of the room just as Pinkie kicked Pinkamena in the face, makeing her drop the knife.

  "TWILIGHT we need to be in there to help Pinkie!!!" Rarity said as she tried to get past Twilight.

"I'm sorry Rarity but this something that Pinkie has to do alone." Twilight said this with a sad look in her eyes. Rarity just sat down and didn't say anything else.

   Pinkamena recovered from the blow to her face and tried to find her knife. Pinkie saw this as her oppertuinty to strike and she grabed one of the knifes on the the table and ran to Pinkamena. Just as Pinkie was about attack Pinkamena made a large cut on Pinkie's left leg. Pinkie fell to ground in pain and everytime she tried to stand up she fell again. She finally manged to get up only to be pushed over by Pinkamena.

"Finally! Now to end this." She said as she started makeing simalier cuts to the one on Pinkies leg on her  chest. Each cut brought more pain to Pinkie as more and more blood pooled around her. Pinke suddenly couldn't breathe and was crying harder than ever. She finally managed to kick Pinamena off of her just to have Pinkamena stick the knife straight into Pinkies right leg pinning Pinkie there. Pinkie cried out in pain and her brain scrambled as she tried to think of something. Pinkie was starting to lose all feeling in her body and she knew she was losing horribly. Finally she managed to cal Twilight loud enough for her to hear that she need help.

Twilight and the others came in as soon as they heard Pinkie calling for help. They saw Pinkie laying there and Pinkamena grabbing a new knife from the table. Twilight, Applejack, and Rainbow Dash imeditly stood inbetween Pinkie and Pinkamena while Rarity and Fluttershy tryed to tend to Pinkies wounds. Pinkamena growled and charged at Twilight. Instead of take one knife as a weapon Twilight threw the table itself at Pinkamena knocking her into the wall. Applejack ran over and gave Pinkamena's head a great big buck, smashing her skull and killing her. Twilight and Rainbow walked over to the earthpony who was almost in tears.

"Applejack? Are you ok?" Twilight asked.

"Im fine Twi...it's just I....I just killed a pony..." Applejack said looking down at the floor.

"But Applejack! The pony you just killed was a crazed psycopath who kills otherponies." Rainbow Dash said as she patted Applejack on back. "Thanks gals but I still feel like I did a bad thing..."

"Applejack, you did nothing wrong. Now let's get you cle-" "Girls we need to get Pinkie to the hospital now we can't stop the bleeding!!!!" Fluttershy said. Twilight teleported all of them to the Ponyville hospital. As soon as a nurse saw Pinkie she was on her way to the ER. The doctors didn't ask any questions but Twilight knew there would be an explanation.

____________________________________________________________________________

  Two days later Rainbow Dash came to vist Pinkie. She was the first pony to see her scence they got Pinkie in the hospital. When she stepped into the room she saw Pinkie asleep in the bed with her right leg in a cast, her left leg and torso wraped heavily in gause. Rainbow slowly walked over to her friend and never more in her life did she want to hear Pinkie talking. Slowly Pinkie started to move around in her bed, as Pinkie started to wake up she saw Rainbow Dash standing right next to her. She instanly sprang up and hugged Rainbow only to lay back down because of the pain.

"Dashie...im so glad you're ok!" She said smileing at the rainbow maned pegasus. Rainbow had tears running down her face now as she hugged her friend back and said. "I'm glad you're ok too." She then stepped up and wiped the tears from her eyes.

"Awwwww Dashie why are you crying? Im fine see!" Pinkie wiggled around a little bit in her bed to prove that she was fine. Rainbow chuckled and sat down,

"Hey Pinkie guess what Twilight did."

"What Dashie?"

"She found a spell....and she......"

"What? What did she do?"

"She brought Gummy back." Once she heard this Pinkie was wipeing her eyes.

"She did she really brought him back?" Rainbow nodded and Pinkie hugged her again.

"So is this Pinkamena thing over?" Rainbow asked.

"Yep it sure is."

First Nightscare

   We all know about Pinkie sence. And how it works. But we don't know anything about her dreams. Well Pinkie Pie rarely gets dreams, when she does they tell the future this is the story of the time her dreams almost killed everything dear to her.

"Dashie! It's not nice to pass out when I'm playing a game with you!" Pinkie said as Rainbow Dash came to. Rainbow Dash was in tears for her best friend was about to end her life.

"PINKIE PLEASE STOP PLEASE!!!!!!" Rainbow screamed as Pinkie slowly started to chop off her leg. She screamed in pain and cried harder than she ever had.

"PINKIE PLEASE STOP!!!" Rainbow said as she started to pass out again.

   "AHHHHHHHH" Pinkie sat up in bed. She thought about the dream she just had. She started to cry. She would never hurt her friend. But her dreams tell the future so... she was actually going to take Rainbows life. It couldn't be. She would never even hurt a pony let alone kill one! And to her best friend? Why would she do such a thing? She looked out the window and saw Rainbow Dash helping to get the big storm ready. She sighed and got out of bed, and walked to the bathroom. She decided to forget the dream. It had to be wrong. She took a bath, brushed her teeth, fixed her mane and tail and went downstairs to the shop to start her shift. It was a really slow day sence everypony was getting ready for the big storm. A hour before the storm started Twilight came in and invited Pinkie to the sleep over she was having sence the storm was going to last through the night. Pinkie acepted the invite and as Twilight walked out of the door Pinkie was only thinking one thing,

   "I've got to make sure I don't let Rainbow know about this. She'll hate me." Pinkie thought as she looked out the window and saw Rainbow again. This time Rainbow spotted Pinkie and waved. Pinkie put on a fake smile and waved. As rainbow flew off to help more Pinkie sighed, hopeing that her friends would never know of that horrible dream.

Second Nightscare

this entire chapter is a dream just so you know.

Rainbow Dash ran down the hall from her 'friend' scared out of her mind. Pinkie chased after her with a knife in her mouth. Pinkie had a frown on her face as she chased Dash around the pink ponys house. Pinkie jumped at Rainbow Dash and was about to strike the knife into her friend when Rainbow had a burst of speed. Pinkie missed by a foot and screamed as she struggled to pull the knife out of the ground. Rainbow found stairs and ran down them as fast as she could. She slowed down thinking she had outrun her killer friend. She turned her head and bumped into none other than Pinkie. She screamed and backed up. Pinkie jumped at Rainbow again and this time sunk the knife deep into Rainbows head. The body of the rainbow maned pegasus fell to ground while pinkie laughed.

"Nighty Night!"

And yes this is another short chapter but don't worry the next chapter will be longer.

Worst. Day. Ever!

                   Pinkie awoke with a start and sat up. She had tears running down her face as she thought about her nightscare. She couldn't belive it, she was going to kill her best friend. She sat in her bed for a bit before going back to sleep hopeing to have a good dream that stops the murder of her dream.

        "Oh HI gummy!!!!!!!!!" Pinkie said as she walked over to her loved pet. Gummy just sat there as Pinkie walked closer. Gummy started to walk away when Pinkie used the knife she had in her mouth to chop him to bits. When it was done Pinkie sat down, face covered in blood laughing.

     "AHHHHHHHHH" Pinkie was panting. She burst into tears thinking about her killing her beloved Gummy. "It has to be wrong. Maybe sometimes it dosen't tell the future. That has to be. It has to." She jumped out of bed and ran to the bathroom. She looked in the mirror and saw that her hair was flat. She sighed and began to curl her hair back up. After two hours of struggling with her hair she gave up and just walked away. Pinkie stepped back into her room and looked at the clock. It was 9:39, she sighed and sat down. Gummy walked over and rubbed Pinkie. Pinkie chuckled and picked up Gummy. She sat there holding him for about ten minutes. Then she put Gummy down and went outside. She started walking over to Twilight's house, she was hopeing Twilight could help her. When she got there she knocked on the door and waited.

   "W-Who is it?" Twilight said.

   "Twilight it's me Pinkie!" The pink pony said. Twilight slowly opened the door and poked her head out. When Twilight saw that Pinkie's mane and tail was flat she sqeaked and slamed the door shut.

"GO AWAY PINKIE!!!!!!!!" She yelled through the door. Pinkie started crying and ran over to Fluttershy's. When she got there she knocked and said,

  "Fluttershy please open up." Fluttershy opened the door and stared at Pinkie. Pinkie saw Rainbow Dash in the house and was hurt when she saw the look Rainbow gave her. Fluttershy stood there a little longer before turning back to Rainbow Dash. Pinkie heard them wispering about something but she couldn't hear. Finally Fluttershy walked back over to Pinkie and said,

"Please go away Pinkie." She then closed the door and left Pinkie standing there. Pinkie started to walk over to Rarity's place and on the way it started pouring. When she got there Pinkie saw Rarity outside trying to open the door. Pinkie ran over and said,

  "Rarity! Can I come in?"

  "NO! You can not come in Pinkie."

   "But Rarity."

   "NO! Good-Bye Pinkie." Rarity opened the door and walked inside and left Pinkie in the rain. Pinkie now had tears runing down her face as she started walking to Sweet Apple Acers. When she got there  she saw that Applejack and her family had already gone into there celler to wait out the storm. Pinkie walked into the park and looked around. Even in the pouring rain the park looked amazing. She sighed and thought about how her friends all shut the door in her face. The more she thought about it the more she cryed. She was so busy crying she didn't hear or see the thunder and lighting. As she sat there a bolt of lighting struck a nearby tree. The tree started to fall. Pinkie looked up to see what the noise was but it was to late.

                                           The tree fell on top of Pinkie.