Cream Pie Birthday Party

by Theater Critic

Rating: mature
Tags: Sex, Slice of Life, Original Character, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Romance, Pinkie Pie
Length: 1985

Pinkie celebrates her cumming of age with a new friend.

Pinkie finds out what being a teen's all about when she throws a party, which attracts the attention of a horny but shy colt.

Collab with MontyDerp

Published 2013-07-10 21:00:01 UTC
Last updated 2013-07-10 21:00:01 UTC

The Best Birthday Ever!

It was a warm summer’s day in Ponyville. Everypony was out enjoying the sun and doing day to day activities. All the young ponies were excited for tonight. It was just any night, Pinkie Pie was throwing a party. Everypony in town had heard of Pinkie's parties.

Pinkie was just turning twelve, but she was already disregarding being a foal, she knew tonight was going to be special.

Pinkie was just getting ready to leave home and go to Sugarcube Corner for her party. She walked out of her house to go to the party place.

It was just starting to go dark, but all the lights from the sugarcube corner were lighting up nearby streets, as ponies walked into the Candy Place in a line. They were excited to see Pinkie grow up into a mare. Or, at least a teenager.

As she entered Sugarcube Corner, everyone stopped and turned. She looked amazing! Nopony could resist looking as walked along the carpet into the main hall.

Of course, ponies were gawking at her because she was wearing a beautiful dress, Blue purple and pink layers along the back, with a divine blue ribbon on her mane. Her shoe’s were even blue. It was all a matching dress, her beautiful blue eyes stood out in the dress.

Pinkie Pie sat down at a table, watching everypony have fun. They were playing games, having drinks and food, and talking. But Pinkie just watched everypony.

Everypony but one colt.

The colt walked in with his parents and baby sister, who was three years old. The colt saw Pinkie sitting down, doing nothing. Somehow, that looked arousing. His dark red wing pomfed out, a wingboner. He really wanted to fuck her badly. But that would be rude. He needed to know this beautiful mare first. He walked to Pinkie and sat down.

“Hi.” He said. He was shy of meeting new ponies.

“Wow someone's excited!” Pinkie said eagerly to the colt, noticing his wingboner.

“Oh, sorry. How rude of me.” He grabbed his wings, which were stiff, and tugged at it, putting it back in place. “I’m Windwaker, but you can call me Wind.”

“Pleased to meet you Wind, I’m Pinkie Pie, although you probably already guessed that.” Pinkie
said in her high pitched voice, showing enthusiasm towards the colt.

“I-I like your eyes, Pinkie.” Wind blushed as he complemented her.

“Why thank you! They suit my dress don't you think?!” Pinkie realized he was interested in her, she didn't mind. In fact she was interested in him too. She was getting to that age where she was ready to start getting close with other ponies.

“Can I sit next to you, Pinkie Pie?” Wind asked, sheepishly.

“Of course you can silly!” Pinkie said as she grabbed hold of the colt to draw him closer to her.

Wind sat right next to her, feeling weird inside. “I’ve never sat by a filly this close before.”

“I'm not a filly!” Pinkie said agitated, moving closer towards him showing her confidence.

“Oh, you’re a young mare then.” Wind said. His leg touched Pinkie’s leg, but backed off.

Pinkie blushed and moved away briefly, before getting closer than before and putting her hoof along his calves, “Someone’s brave.” she giggled.

“Sorry. I got a little too close.” Wind said.

“Oh, don't worry about it, I...I kinda like you. You seem nice.” Pinkie blushed, looking at him through the corner of her eyes.

Wind’s wings pomfed again. “Thanks.” He leaned in and planted his lips firmly against Pinkie’s. He blushed redder than before. Wind has never kissed a mare before.

Pinkie for a brief moment went warm and shy. She was finally getting close to somepony and she was growing up. She paused and savored his lips for a second, putting her hooves upon his, and slowly beginning to kiss him with her tongue.

Wind felt relieved that Pinkie kissed him back. His hooves were wrapped around Pinkie’s sides, slowly brushing her soft coat. His right hoof moved up to stroke her pink mane.

“Wait. Stop. Ponies can see us. Why don’t we go someplace less noisy, where we can be alone?” Pinkie said as pulled his hooves away from her and rested them along her lap.

“Um, alright, I guess.” Wind followed Pinkie upstairs to the bedroom.

Pinkie grabbed his hooves and pulled him. “Come on hurry, we don’t want anypony to see us.”

Wind walked with pinkie inside the dark room. “Can you turn on the lights?” The shy young colt asked.

“Not the lights, thats too obvious, here...” Pinkie leaned over and opened the curtains, letting in a dim light upon her body and showing just a shadow of his body. The only main thing noticeable in the light was showing his wingboner.

“So, are we going on the bed to ‘do it’?” Wind asked. He was nervous that he was alone with a mare.

“Of course silly, don’t be so nervous” Pinkie said as she kissed him slowly.

Wind pulled away. “Well, it’s just that I never had sex with anypony. I just don’t know if I’m ready to lose my virginity.” He said sheepishly. Even though he really wanted to have sex with her, he just didn’t know if he wanted to do it now, right there.

“Relax, come on” Pinkie laid onto the bed, grabbing Wind along.

“Well, ok.” His confidence took over as he aggressively kissed Pinkie.

Pinkie, turned on by everything what was going on, slowly leaned on the bed, and got his Penis out of his Pants and rubbed along his member.

“Oh my.” Wind said. “That feels weird, but good. Nopony has ever touched my weenie before, besides me sometimes.”

“Really? That’s nothing!” She said, as she pulled him onto the bed, pinkie slowly got on top of him and put his penis in her mouth, slowly teasing his tip with her tongue.

“T-That feels good. Continue what you’re doing.”

Without saying a word, Pinkie began to go further on his cock putting her lips around it rubbing it with her tongue.

Wind moaned in pleasure. This was the best feeling in his life. It felt tingly at first, but it felt good. He felt his penis moving a little bit. Maybe it was because of it being erect.

Pinkie began to go deep into Wind’s erect penis, pleasuring him as much as she could. Wind was moaning, so Pinkie knew she was doing a good job.

Pinkie stopped, for a moment..”So what do you think? Are you having fun?” She asked.

“Yeah.” Wind got up and softly kissed Pinkie Pie. He went back to the same position as downstairs, putting his left hoof around Pinkie’s waist, and his right hoof stroking her mane.

“You’re so gentle” Pinkie put her hoof on his lap and kissed him on the cheek.

“Thanks.” Wind said. A smile was on his face. His full confidence took over. “So, are you ready for the main course?”

“What’s that?” Pinkie was curious as she leant away.

“I think you know what it is.” Wind said with a bit of laughter in his tone.

“Well, I'm ready when you are.” Pinkie giggled, as she got off the bed and kneeled down on the floor facing the colts penis.

“Do you want it hard or gentle?” Wind asked. He didn’t want to hurt Pinkie.

“Let’s go hard, might as well right” Pinkie said eagerly.

Wind slowly put him hooves onto Pinkie’s waist, as he slowly inserted the tip of his penis into Pinkie’s pussy. It was tight but wet. It felt weird but good. He had no problem going a couple inches deep. He was encouraged to begin thrusting her as she began to moan. “This feels so good!” Wind moaned loudly.

“”Well I’m...” Pinkie moaned. “Glad you like it” Pinkie moaned again, as she slowly pushed herself up against his cock.

The noises of the party downstairs soon became polluted from the moans in the bedroom. It was a wonder nopony had realized Pinkie was gone.

She slowly began to rub her clit as Wind thrusts her.

“Wait, uh, what is somepony hears us?” Wind asked Pinkie, anxious about the noise the two was making.

“Don’t worry, we’ll just have to be quiet” Pinkie whispered to him

She stopped and pushed him gently onto the bed. She leans over and sits on top of him.

As a moan escapes his mouth, Pinkie quickly stops him from alerting anyway by kissing him strongly, forcing her tongue down into his throat.

Wind was slowly feeling himself reaching a climax. He tried his best to hold it in and slowed down his movement, kissing Pinkie gently.

“I don’t know if i should gush out in your coochie. I don’t want to make you pregnant.” Wind says. “Can I cum in your mouth instead?”

Pinkie giggled, “Sure!” She said as she laid back onto the bed.

Wind put his penis inside Pinkie’s mouth as he cummed in it. Wind moaned, whispering, “I came!” In Pinkie’s ear so nopony would hear it.

Pinkie gagged as she swallowed the cum, “I noticed”, she wiped her lips and put her dress back on.

“That was good, Pinkie.” Wind said as he softly kissed her for one last time. “Thanks.”

“What do we do now, are you going to go?” Pinkie said, as she began to get upset. She didn't want to see him leave so soon.

“I’m going to see you again soon enough.” Wind said. “We need to get downstairs, but quietly. We don’t want ponies to know we were gone.”

“I-I just wanted to cuddle for a bit. Okay then. Promise you’ll come back?” She asked, as she began following Wind downstairs.

“Wait, maybe my parents can let you sleepover. I can make them believe you’re sleeping on the couch, but then when everypony’s asleep, you can sleep in my bed.” Wind whispered to Pinkie as they walked around the room.

“Okay. Here, let’s get back to the party then. It’s got to almost be over by now. It’s already late.” Pinkie was nervous.

As they walked down the stairs it was dark, and everything was quiet, all of a sudden a noise came out of nowhere. “Pinkie where have you been? Everyone left ages ago” a worker from sugarcube said.

“Oh. Sorry.” Pinkie said, as she was talking to the worker. Wind sneaked past and left, looking at Pinkie. He slowly turned around and flew off into the night.

Everything was over, but one thing was for certain: Pinkie Pie had a good birthday.

Two days later...

Pinkie was asleep on Wind’s couch, wrapped up into a bed sheet comfy. A sillouette of a pony stood in front of Pinkie.

“Wanna snuggle in my bed now?” Wind whispered.

“I thought you would never ask!” Pinkie whispered giggling, she got out from beneath the sheet and followed Wind into his bedroom.

Wind and Pinkie went under the covers of Windwaker’s soft bed. Pinkie layed her head down next to Wind’s. Their hooves were wrapped around their bodies.

“I love you, Pinkie Pie.” Wind whispered to the beautiful pink mare that was cuddling next to him.

“I love you too Windwaker. Thanks for letting me stay around. Can we...can we be more than friends?” She asked as she rests her eyes as she lay in her arms.

“Like lovers?” Wind asked.

“Yes, like lovers. You mean a lot to me Wind.” Pinkie told him eagerly.

“Thanks.” Wind said. He pressed his lips against Pinkie’s and kept it there the entire night.

Author's Note

Me and Montyderp had a lot of fun writing this fanfic. We were going to make Wind a lot older, like 15 to 18, but it was kind of pedo, so we went with a cute romance foalcon sex story.

Hope you enjoyed it!