-Don’t risk the noise and follow Ray.

You shake your head. “It would cause too much noise and Ray will surely send some of his griffons back this way.” you say.

Spitfire and Rainbow Dash nod in understanding, and without any further words you lead them down the tunnel that Ray went down. Taking care where you step, you try your hardest to make no noise whatsoever as do the two mares following you. The pace is slow, though, and a few times the noise caused by your hoofsteps causes you to freeze in fear that one of the griffons may have heard you.

Eventually you make it to another cavern, this one almost as large as Celestia’s throne room. Of course Ray and his griffons have already reached the cavern way ahead of you, and as you, Spitfire, and Rainbow hide by the tunnel you just came down, you see that some of the griffons are wrestling with a heavy chest perched on an altar.

“Careful! If any of you damage it I will kill you!” Ray shouted at his griffons. They manage to wrench the chest free and fly it down to where Ray stands, and as soon as they place it in front of him he tries to open it. Of course the chest is locked, but without a second thought Ray punches his balled-up claw into the wood, and with three strikes he manages to punch a hole into the wood. Blood pours from his claw but he ignores the pain, reaching in and opening the chest from the inside. As he opens the lid a dark smoke begins to pour out from the chest, and some of the griffons begin to back away in fear. Ray, however, remains where he stands and reaches into the chest, smiling as he grasps something. Dramatically, he slowly brings his claw out and triumphantly holds up King Sombra’s horn.

“Hahahaha! Yes! It’s mine!” he shouts gleefully. The horn begins to glow and smoke begins to wrap around his injured claw. Staring in awe, you see that the smoke seems to be seeping into his wounds and healing them, and within another few seconds his claw is fully healed.

Ray lets out a triumphant laugh again. “With this power, I shall be immortal! There is no limit to what I can do, no limit to what lands I can conquer! I will kill any creature that stands in my way, starting with those pony princess whorses! Their subjects will be forced to watch me use them in every way possible before I have their heads cut off and mounted on my wall!”

You watch in horror as he brings the horn up to his head and places it against his forehead. The horn lets off an explosion of smoke that fills the entire cavern, and every creature except Ray can’t help but cough violently as smoke fills your lungs. All three of you stumble from the sudden smoke and a rock is knocked loose, catching Ray’s attention and he glares in your direction.

“Heh heh heh, it seems we have some visitors.” he says, feeling your presence more than seeing you. “Griffons! Capture those ponies!”

“Run!” you shout, your cover blown. You make sure Rainbow Dash and Spitfire run out first and you bring up the rear, and one glance back lets you know that the griffons are hot on your tail. You try to kick out at any loose rubble to try to slow down your attackers, but unlike the supply tunnel this one is sturdy. The most you manage to loosen is a few pebbles, but it doesn’t matter in the end as Dash and Rainbow come to a screeching halt. In front of them is the second half of Ray’s force, blocking the only exit. The original pursuers finally catch up and complete the trap.

“Get them!” one of the griffons shouts. You three try to put up a fight but of course you’re all quickly overwhelmed. There’s just too many of them and the tight space doesn’t allow for much movement, and within minutes you find yourself being dragged back into the cavern where Ray waits.

As the griffons throw you, Dash, and Spitfire in front of Captain Ray they keep their claws dug into your back, making sure none of you can fly up and try to escape. Ray calmly looks down at each of you, smiling evilly.

“Well, this is quite the surprise. My three favorite ponies all together. Too bad you didn’t bring the unicorn with you, I wasn’t done training her.” he said dryly.

“Let me go! Fight me like a real warrior, you coward!” Spitfire yelled out, spitting at Ray. Her spit hit Ray in the leg but he didn’t even flinch.

“Heh, ironic words. You want me to fight you? Well, here’s the thing… I’m a king now, and you’re nothing but a lowly little slut.”

Spitfire gritted her teeth and tensed up, trying to find a chance to escape from the griffon holding her down and attack Ray. However, the griffon on top of her sensed her muscles tensing up and his dug his claws into her spine and twisted it, causing Spitfire to scream out in pain.

Ray closed his eyes and smiled. “Ah, that’s the sound I’ve missed. Hmm, in fact, I’ve missed it a lot. But now I have a fantastic opportunity to hear that wonderful sound as long as I like while trying out my new powers.” he said. To prove his point, he concentrated on the open chest and soon a bolt of lightning came streaking out of the tip of his horn. The chest took a direct hit and quickly crumpled into a pile of ashes. Ray smiled in satisfaction and returned his attention to his captives. “Well, this is going to be fun to use.” he said.

He walked over to Rainbow Dash and grabbed her chin, holding her head in place. He forced a kiss on her, laughing at her as she spit on the ground after he broke away. “Looks like you need some training again. You’re supposed to beg for my cock after I grace you with such a nice gift.” he teased.

He turned his attention back to you. “Well, I must thank you for returning my toys to me, even if they were used goods.” he said. “I really should find a way to thank you. Hmm… oh, I know.”

He barks out an order to tie up Rainbow Dash and Spitfire against the altar, and within moments they’re tied down on the cold stone stage facing each other, their legs forced open. Ray walked around the two bound mares and inspected their sexes, nodding his approval after looking them over. “Well, you did quite the job fixing up these two fuck toys, so here’s your prize! I’m going to practice using my new powers, and YOU will be the one to tell me who I should test it out on.” he cackled.

He thought hard for a few seconds and then grinned. “Well, I’ll try this out first.” he said. The horn on his head bursts into flames and he smiles in satisfaction. “I’m going to set one of these sluts on fire. No, I won’t actually burn them, they’ll just go through the pain of being burned. I think. Now you just have to choose which one.”

You are shocked by his game. “There’s… there’s no way I can choose!” you shout out. “If you’re going to torture somepony, torture me!”

“Tsk tsk, come now, you really are terrible at this.” Ray says disappointedly. “You didn’t choose back when I visited Canterlot, and you still can’t. And no, choosing yourself is NOT an option. Guess I’ll have to do it to both of them.”

“Wait! NO!” you shout out, but it’s too late. Ray casts his spell and both Spitfire and Dash are lit in black flames. Both of them scream out in pain and thrash around, but their bodies don’t actually burn, nor is there the smell of burning flesh. Even so, the pain they feel is absolutely real, and though you try to yell at Ray to stop your voice is drowned out by their pain.

After what seems like an eternity Ray finally dowses the flames. Spitfire and Rainbow pant heavily as the pain disappears with the flames, but the terror of Ray’s torture is now very real.

“Ray, stop this now! Don’t hurt them, they’ve been through enough!” you yell at him.

Ray sighs and walks up to you. “You’re just no fun, you know that. Yes, it’s fun to hurt you ponies, but with you the mental anguish is just so much sweeter.”

He stops and thinks for a moment before continuing. “Though… I guess we’ve been through quite a bit, you and I. Plus I do owe you for killing my predecessor and allowing me to gain control of the entire kingdom. So, I’ll make you an offer you can’t refuse.” he says.

He walks back up to the altar and stands between Spitfire and Rainbow Dash. “I’m willing to let one of these little sluts go. Just one. Well, after I break her wings and maybe rip them off to keep as a souvenir. The other I am going to rape, then let my griffons rape her when I’m done. And then I’ll kill her.”

Ray smiles at the horrified look on your face. “I really don’t care which one you choose, they’re both just cum dumpsters to me. Oh, and don’t even think of saying to kill you. You have to choose one of those two. If you even think of trying to barter with me right now I’ll just kill all three of you.”

You feel your eyes water as you look helplessly at Spitfire and Rainbow Dash. Both look scared as there seems to be no hope of escape or rescue. Ray taps his claws against the stone and looks at you. “I don’t have all day.” he sneers.

You gulp and silently ask Celestia to forgive you. “Rainbow, Spitfire… I love you both. I’m sorry.” you say.

Rainbow looks at you with tears in her eyes. “I love you too.” she responds.

Spitfire tries to remain strong but you can see the fear on her face. “I lo… I… just make the asshole pay.” she says, unable to say what’s really on her mind.

“Ten seconds before I change my mind.” Ray says, counting down on his talons.

You take a deep breath and choose their fates…

-Choose to have Rainbow Dash raped and killed
-Choose to have Spitfire raped and killed
-I... I can't choose...

Author's Note

Well, that last poll was close. Really close. Like down to just a few votes close.

So... for those of you starting to finally catch on to a certain trend to the polls... keep your eyes on my blog. There will be a contest soon, and the winner will get a copy of My Little Slave (Con edition!)*

*must be 18 years of age or older to participate, US residents only.