Pinkie's forbidden love

by Lunar_knight

Rating: mature
Tags: Pinkie Pie, Sex, Twilight Sparkle, Slice of Life, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Romance, Original Character
Length: 5257

All he sighned up for was a 3 day trip to fix a farm,but not to be seduced by 2 ponie's!

Published 2012-02-20 06:34:02 UTC
Last updated 2012-02-20 21:39:29 UTC

One unexpected weekend

It was a cold and dark morning as the sun started to rise. I look out my window and sighed as the sun had signaled that the day had come. I looked back to my room and glanced at my fiance octavia sleeping.

She was the apple of my eye and my first and only love. As i watched her sleep i was taken back to the first time we met.It was 15 years ago. 3 years before i moved.

My family had moved to a property of land outside of ponyville near canterlot. My father had lost his job at a construction site. He was working on a library in ponyville and he fell asleep on the job.

So we packed everything up and they decided to try there hooves at rock farming. When we got there we were welcomed by a fellow rock farming family, the pies.

"Hello there." Said Mr.pie, nodding his hat. With him were Mrs.pie, pinkie, her sister which i don't like talking about because she died not too long ago, and finally octavia. When i first laid eyes on her it felt like my heart had stopped, then restarted a few seconds later.

She looked very different back then. Her hair hung down and covered her eyes. She also had a frown on her face. They all did. While i looked at her, i could feel eyes looking at me. When i looked over there was no one watching me, but i still felt like somepony was watching me.

When i looked back to octavia she was looking at me. As are eyes locked my heart started to race. She looked away after a few seconds and walked over to pinkamine and whispered something to her. After a few back and forth's, they looked back at me.

Then they walked towards me. My heart was racing as they got closer.

When they finally reached me pinkamena said, "Um, hi. Im pinkamine diane pie, and this is my sister octavia." Said the young pinkie pie.

At this age she had flat hair and was the same style as octavia's. "U-um,hi.I'm bareton." I said, a little nervous back then.

"So where are you from?" Pinkie asked.

"Um,we moved here from ponyville." I said.

"Oh,that's cool." She said.

Then she said, "Hey, you want to, maybe, hang out with me and my sister." She asked.

I was about to answer when my dad and their dad came over to us."Well it looks like you three have met."My dad said."Baret,this is mr.pie and he has a question for you." He said.I looked at mister pie.

"Bareton, i would like to know if you'd like to live with me and my family for a few years." He said.

"Wait,why?" I asked, confused.

"Well you see baret, your mother and i are going into the city to try and find a job. We were just wondering if you'd want to either come with us or stay with the pies for a while." He said.

Then i thought, then why the hell did we buy the property? I thought about it and decided that if i stayed id get more time with octavia. "Ok,ill stay with the pie's dad."I said. I heard a low cheer from behind me.I couldn't tell who it was but it was a voice of a foal.

So we took my bags and took them over to the pie's farm. I said goodbye to my parents and watched them leave from the farm.

"Come with me bareton, you too pinkamine." Mr.pie said. Me and pinkie followed him into the house, up the stairs, and into the second door on the right. We set my bags down in a room that looked like it was already occupied. "You'll be staying in here with pinkamine while your here." He said.

"Okay sir." I said. He nodded his head and turned.He walked out and shut the door,leaving the two of us alone.Before the memory could continue, i was brought back to the present by a shake.

I turn to see octavia had woke up and shaken me.I smiled at her.

"You looked like you were thinking something happy." She said.

"Well, it was the first time i met you. Does that count as happy?" I asked,a sly grin on my face.

"Heh, i hope it was." She said, grinning as well.

I leaned in and said in a low voice, "It was and it always will be." Then i kissed her on the cheek. She blushed red. Then all of a sudden there was a knock at the door. I walked down the stairs and over to the door. When i opened the door, i looked to see pinkie pie standing there with a glad look in her eyes.

"Oh,hi pinkie."I said to her.

"Oh,hi baret!I cant believe that today is the day!This is going to be soooo fun!"She said,hopping up and down.

"Yes it is pinkie."I said,having no idea what she was talking about.

She then trotted into the house. Just then octavia came down the stairs. I turned to her and gave her a look that said "Why is she here?"She then came up to pinkie and they hugged each other.

"Oh octavia, i cant believe that baret agreed to this on such short notice!"Pinkie said.

"Ya, neither. can. I." I said.

"Hey bareton we should go now. Do you have any items packed that you want to take with you while your away?" Pinkie asked.

I looked at octavia. "Um,octa? Can i talk to you in the kitchen for a minute? We'll be right back pinkie." I said. Her and I headed for the kitchen. When we were out of sight and earshot, i looked at her like she was crazy.

"What is going on?And what did you get me into?"I asked in a harsh whisper.

"Well you see a few days ago pinkie asked if i could help repair our father's farm while he and our mother are gone. I couldn't, of course, so i may have said that you would help her and stay there for a few days." She said back.

"And you never mentioned it to me. What am i supposed to do huh? Tell her i cant cause i didn't know about it?" I said.

"I don't know what to tell you baret." She told me.

I sighed and peeked into the living room to see pinkie siting there happy and bubbly. "Ok." I said. "I'll do it, but then you owe me one." I told her.

She came over and kissed me on the cheek. "Thank you" She said.

We walked back into the living room. "Oh, your back!" Pinkie said.

"Ya. Okay pinkie lets go." I said. She suddenly started jumping up and down.

"Oh this is going to be soooo fun. Just you and me and twilight!" She said.

"Tw-twilight?" I asked,remembering the last time id seen her.

"Ya, i told her that you where helping and she volunteered to help too!" Pinkie said.

"Is that ok?" She asked, apparently noticing the look i was making.

I snapped out of it and nodded my head. "Ya that's fine pinkie." I said. We left the house and made are way for the train station to pick up twilight.

On the way there,we stopped at a caffe for a drink.When we went in,we were showed to a table.

We started looking over the menus when pinkie said, "Um,Baret?I just wanted to thank you again for helping me on such short notice."She said.

"No problem pinkie."I said.

"Also for staying a few days with twilight after what happened" She said.

"Y-you know about that?" I asked, a little nervous.

"Ya but don't worry, i haven't told any of the girls, or my sister." She said.

I sighed, glad that she said that. "Oh thank Celestia." I said in a low voice. Just then a waitress came over with a notepad and pen.

"What can i get you two?" She asked.

"Um,Ill have a a order of hay fries and some tea please." I told her.

"Um, I know! Ill have the strawberry milkshake and some chips!" She said. The waitress finished taking are orders and left to get them.

"So, how have you been?" She asked,trying to pass the time.

"Oh,pretty good i guess." I said.

"That's nice, plus you and my sister are getting.......married soon." She said. I wondered why she paused. Before I could ask, the waitress came back with our food.

"Here you are." She said. She set all are food down and walked away to take more orders. I looked up from my food to see pinkie scarfing hers down. My stomach rumbled at the sight. So I started eating. When we finished are food, i payed the bill and we headed for the train station. I looked at the sun.

It was the almost time her train was supposed to stop here. When we got there the train had stopped and twilight was getting off the train.

When i saw here struggling with here bags, i came up behind her and said, "You want some help with that twilight?" I asked her. She suddenly turned to see me.

When she saw it was me,she dropped her bag and yelped."Oh Celestia! It's you." She said,blushing.

"You look so surprised for somepony who knew i was going to be here." I said.

"W-well it's just that i have not seen you in a few months and i was excited when i found out we were going to work together." She said.

All of a sudden pinkie popped out of no where and hugged twilight. "Oh my gosh! This is going to be the best few days ever!"She said.

I flung her bag onto my back."Well we better start moving." I said.

"Right,of course." Twilight said. We started are to the farm. By the time we got there the moon was rising into the sky. Pinkie unlocked the door and walked inside.

When i got in the house i dropped our bags on the floor. "This brings back old memories." I said, looking around the room.

"Ya,it does."Pinkie said."Oh, i probably should have told you guys.There are only two rooms we can use to sleep in." Pinkie said.

"What about the guest house out back?" I asked.

"It had a tree fall on it last season." She said.

"Oh, okay. Well you girls can have the biggest room. I'll take the smaller room." I said.

"That's very nice of you baret." Twilight said looking at me with dreamy eyes like she was having a fantasy about something i don't want to know.

"Anyhow, pinkie is that lake still behind the house?" I asked.

She thought for a moment then said,"Yep.We also added a hot tub!"She said.

I looked at her then smiled."Great," I said, feeling all of my sore body, "I'm going need it."

Twilight walked right up to me and got uncomfortably close. "Mind if i join you?" She asked.

My whole face flushed red."U-um,i-if you want."I said.

"I'll be waiting." She said. As she walked out she purposely gave me a glance of her slit. When i came out side and started to walk near the hot tub i had started thinking about how weird pinkie had been acting lately, all starting when pinkie first saw me a few months ago at this exact location when she kissed me all over my face.

Also how grave she looked when she told me that she saw twilight hitting on me when she and her friends stayed at my house.

Before i could continue this thought i was interrupted by a sexy,"Hey there."

A long night

I looked up to see twilight sitting in the hot tub waving at me. "Hey twilight." I said while getting into the tub. When i got in, twilight slid over and sat right up against me. Something wasn't right, i know twilight and this isn't how twilight hits on a stallion. This is more of a rainbow move. "U-um twilight? Are y-you ok?" I asked.

She looked at me with seductive eyes. "Well, you might as well know. You see, i'm in heat." She said, rubbing my flank.

"U-um twilight. You know that i'm engaged." I said.

"I know, but this was my last chance. "She said, leaning in closer.

"L-last chance at what?"I asked,a little uneasy.

In a low whisper she said, "Last chance at you." She then licked my neck. I tried to move but no matter how much i tried, my body just wouldn't listen. As she continued to do this i could feel my cock start to harden in the water.

"Oh, whats this?" She said, noticing my cock poking out of the water. She bent down and kissed the tip of it. She then started to lick the head. I tipped my head back and moaned.

It's like she'd done this before. "Mmmmm," She said, licking her lips, "You taste good."She said, looking at me with a grin. Then she started to lick up and down the shaft of my cock. She stopped and just looked at my cock. Then all of a sudden she shoved the whole thing into her mouth.

I gasped at the sudden pleasure and hammered my cock further into her throat.Her eyes widened as she pulled back. She made a gagging noise as i noticed that she choked on my cock. "Oh Celestia! Are you alright?!" I asked, afraid i had hurt her.

But all of a sudden she turned back around and had a sex craved look in her eyes.She all of a sudden leaped at me,knocking me on to my back in the water with her on top of me.

"Twilight, wha-"I started to say, but before i could finish she pushed her lips against mine and forced her tongue into my mouth where mine and hers wrestled each other into each of our mouths.

As this was happening, my cock had hardened to where it was rock hard. And apparently, she knew this too.

She pushed back to where her slit touched my shaft. My cock pulsed at the touch. "Oooo, your hard aren't you? I'm a little wet myself.Well then, let us relieve each other." She said.

She sat up with my cock against her stomach.She brought her body up a little so her pussy was above my cock.She slowly lowered herself down to the point where her lips touched the head of my cock.

"Are you sure about this twilight?" I asked.

"Yes, just do something for me please?"She asked.

"What?" I asked.

She closed her eyes and said, "Be gentle." Then she pushed down and slid the head into her. I looked at her and could see that she was struggling. Before i could do anything, she dropped down forcing all of my cock inside of her. She lowered her head, trying to deal with the pain.

I looked down at my cock to see blood. "Are you a virgin twilight?" I asked her.

With difficulty, she looked up at me. "Not anymore." She forced out. Then she lifted herself up, then slammed down. As she continued to do this I couldn't help myself. I flipped her over so her top half was above the water and on her stomach.

"I'm sorry twilight but i just cant hold back any longer." I told her. Then i came up behind her and grabbed her waist with my hooves and shoved my cock strait into her. "Ahhhhhhhh!" She Yelled as i thrust in and out over and over again.

After a few minutes of continuous thrusting she said, "I'm going to cum!" After she said that i started to feel myself coming to my breaking point.

"So am i!" I told her back.

"L-lets cum together." She said. "But that would-"

I started before being cut of by twilight who said, "I know the risks, Just do this for me." She told me.

"Okay." I Said. I started thrusting harder. Forgive me Octavia. Then with one final thrust, i released all of my cum into her pussy. "Aaaaahhh!" She yelled as she too came. After about 20 seconds i pulled out and let her slide into the water.

I sat back down and was huffing trying to regain my breath. Then twilight came over and laid against my chest and nuzzled my neck." Thank you baret. I-im so happy." She said with tear forming in her eye.

I just laid there and thought to myself. What have i done? Why didn't i stop when i had the chance. But then i stopped thinking and looked at twilight and decided. All she'd ever wanted was to love somepony and to be loved back.

I know i could never give her the love she wanted, but that doesn't mean i cant make room in my heart for her. "Hey, i think we should get out before pinkie see's us." I told her.

"Your probably right. This wouldn't look very good." She said. So we got out and walked to the house.

When we opened the door we were greeted by pinkie hopping out of the kitchen and the table set and three plates with food already in place. I went and sat down in the seat that i use to when i lived here so many years ago. "Hard to kick old habits,huh?" Pinkie asked,noticing the same thing.

"Ya,i guess it is." I said. Then i started having another flash back. This flash back continued where i stopped this morning.It was me and pinkamine in her room. I looked confused. "Um, Where should i put my stuff?" I asked.

"Here." She said, pointing at a drawer next to her.

"OK." I said. But as i started towards it, She stopped me and put my bag down. "Hey,do you want to do something with me." She asked. "U-um,Sure." I said. Then she looked at me and gave me a wicked smile.

But then the flash back ended."You ok baret?" Pinkie asked from across the table.

"Ya,I'm fine." I told her. But that was a lie. I couldn't shake the fact that i had no memory at all of what came next in that flash back. It was weird,but that could wait for another time.But right now i had too worry about getting through these next few days alive.After dinner twilight went and laid on the couch while i helped pinkie do the dishes.

"Thanks for the help."Pinkie said.

"Don't mention it, your like my sister.Id do anything for you." I told her. I looked over and it looked like she was crying. "Are you ok?" I asked.

She wiped her eyes and turned to me. "Ya,im fine." She said. I couldn't tell for sure, but pinkie looked darker and less bubbly than usual.

"Ok." I said. We finished the dishes a few minutes later.

"Well, we better get to bed." Pinkie said, walking into the living room where twilight was siting. "We have a long day tomorrow." She told us."Baret, you get Octavia's room." She told me. "Twilight, you get to sleep in Baret's old bed." She said to twilight.

Twilight's eyes lit up when she was told this. "I-i get to sleep in baret's bed?" She asked, looking as if she didn't believe what she just heard.

"Yep. Well,goodnight!" She said. She bounced up stairs and twilight followed her up.

I sighed and looked out the window only to see the moon. "Oh luna." I said. I went to the door and opened it. I needed to think. I went out and closed it behind me.

I walked out to the barn where i spent most my time as a child. When i entered the barn i could see that nothing had really changed much over the years.

I walked over to a pair of stairs that led to a window at the very top of the barn.As i climbed up the stairs, i started to look back to the memory of mine and octavia's first kiss.

It had to have been 3 months since i first got there.She had brought me to the top of the barn and told me that she had a surprise for me.When we got to the top she told me to close my eyes.

When i did,She had leaned in an kissed me on the the cheek. That's how are relationship started.When i snapped back to reality,I realized that i had got to the top of the barn.

I sat down in front of the window and stared at the moon. I lowered my head in shame before looking back up and saying, "Oh Luna,what have i done?" I asked, as if Luna was listening. I must of sat there for a good hour.

Then i closed my eyes and just waited. I don't know what i'm waiting for, but i didn't know what else to do. Then i heard something behind me. I turned to see a blue mare walk towards me. I got up and faced her.

"Who are you and why are you here?" I asked. When she stepped out of shadows a crown could be seen on her head.

"I am Luna, and i'm her because you asked me a question, did you not?" She said.

I lowered my head and bowed. "It's a pleasure princess." I said.

"Rise." She said.

I rose and sat down. "Yes luna, i did ask a question." I said.

She came over and sat across from me. "I do know your situation bareton." She said.

"You do?" I asked, bewildered.

She nodded. "Yes for i have seen it with my own two eyes." She said, a deep blush rested on her face. My heart sank into my stomach.

She had seen me deflower twilight in the hot tub. "I am so sorry." I told her.

"Love is a sacred thing." She said. I lowered my head. "But you took it beyond that. Even as you knew you were already committed to your spouse, you made room for twilight in your heart. That is what love is about."

What she said shocked me. "W-what?" I asked.

She lowered her head. "Someone who lets love into there life is just like any pony else." She said. She raised her head and opened her eyes. She looked me right in the eyes."But one who can love and still make room for other loves,that is a gift." She said. She got up and walked over to me. "Remember my words." She said.

She bent down and kissed my forehead. Then she walked over to the window and flew away.

I sat there for i don't know how long. But i just sat there and thought about what luna said. But then i closed my eyes and had a well deserved rest.

When i woke the next morning, i could hear the two fillies calling my name. I peeked out the window and saw twilight and pinkie searching. Probably for me, i thought. I sighed. Id rather have all my teeth ripped out then go down and see twilight. But it had to be done. I stood there for a minute stretching.

Then i forced my self down the stairs and out of the barn. As soon as i stepped out, they noticed me and ran over yelling. At that point i was tackled to the ground by pinkie.

As i got a better look, she had tears in her eyes. "BARET! Thank Celestia we found you!I was so worried!" She said. Then she got up and wiped her eyes.

Then twilight came over as i was getting up and hugged me too. She was teared up as well.

When she was done i backed up. "Whats with all the yelling, I was just in the barn." I said.

"It's just that you weren't in your room. You didn't leave a note or anything." Pinkie said, caution in her voice.

"Well,im here now.So,how about some breakfast?I've been waiting to try some of those homemade french toast of yours." I told her.

Then all of a sudden her face was filled by a huge smile. "Yes! Lets go and ill whip some up!" She said. She bounced to the house and inside. As twilight started to walk past me, she slapped my ass.

Then said, "See you in there sexy." She said as she walked away. Well, looks like she's still in heat. I looked at the sun. Then i sighed. These few days are going to be difficult. Then i turned and walked into the house.

A day of work

After 30 minutes of talking to twilight,the food was ready. It looked like a all you could eat buffet for breakfast foods. My mouth was watering from all the wondrous aromas drifting into my nostrils. Pinkie hopped over and sat down.

I walked over and sat down next to pinkie. Twilight followed my lead. "Well,dig in everypony."She said. I have never been more full in all my life. I looked around and saw that the only one that was still eating was pinkie pie. I got up."I think ill go take a nap." I said." Hmm? Okay aret." Pinkie said through a mouth full.

"Okay baret, sweet dreams." Twilight said, half asleep herself. I trudged up the stairs and went into my room. When i closed the door, i took a good look at the room. What i saw was the exact room i knew all those years ago. I went over to the bed and got in it.

After a couple hours of sleep i woke up. I was still tired, so i tried to go back to bed. But as i rolled around in the bed, i could feel something under the bed. I got up and lifted it up. What i found was a book. But not a book, a diary.

It said, "To baret, my love." I looked at it for a moment. I thought for a second then i realized that it must have been meant for me when i left, but octavia had forgotten to give it to me. I tried to open it, but on the side of it was a lock in the shape of a heart. I looked all over but i could not find the key. After about a few minutes, i gave up.

I walked over to my bag and slipped the book into it. I'd ask octavia about it When i got back. I went to the door and opened it. Then,stepped out and closed the door. I walked down the stairs into the living room where i found twilight fast asleep on the couch.

I looked around but i could not see pinkie at all. I noticed that the front door was open. I went over and stepped out side. I looked to see pinkie moving rocks out in the fields. I started walking over to the field. As i got closer, i could see that she was looking darker than last time.

When i got to where she was, she was sitting on the ground sweaty and at a loss of air. Her hair was laid down and looked like it did all those years ago. As i approached her, i could hear a low whimper. When i got to the point that i was right behind her, i could hear her crying.

"Is everything ok?" I asked her.She suddenly,as far as i could see,wiped her eyes quickly.Then she turned to me.

"Oh, hi.Y-ya,everything is okay. I-i just needed to get some air." She said. But i knew she was lying. I sat down next to her.

"Why try to lie to me?" I said. She gave me a smirk.

"Cant fool you huh?" She said.

"Never could,never will. So,whats wrong."

She sighed. "Well, its just that everyone i know has something going on in there life right now.

I mean, your getting married, rainbow is training for the wonderbolts try outs, your helping fluttershy with a flower show, applejack has that family reunion coming up, rarity has a clothing line she's prepping for, even twilight has a meeting coming up with the princess. But me? I have nothing going on." She said.

I sighed.

"Pinkie, do you know why we have all of this stuff going on?" I asked. She shook her head. "Why has rainbow been training all these years?" I asked her.

"Because she has wanted to be a wonderbolt her whole life."

I nodded my head. "Same with fluttershy, rarity, applejack, twilight,and your sister and i. They are doing this because they wanted it more than anything. Look inside yourself and ask yourself, what do you want most?" I said.

She looked at me. "I think i understand. I know what i want." She said.

"Good.Now,how about we go back inside and I'll make some lunch." I said. "Okay, lets go." She said.

We got up and started to walk back to the house. Twilight had woken up by this point and was siting on the couch. "Hey you guys. Where were you?" She asked.

I smiled. "Just went for a stroll." I said. Then all of a sudden, pinkie pie hugged me.

"Thank you."She whispered.I hugged her back.

"No problem."I whispered back.

She stepped back and smiled."I'm going go freshen up."She said. Then she walked up the stairs and into her and twilight's room.

Twilight looked at me."What happened between you two?" She asked.

I smiled at her."Just a little bonding." I said. I walked into the kitchen and started to make lunch. It was about noon at this point. I know i had a big breakfast, but somehow i was still hungry. I pulled out a couple of bowls and took out some lettuce, ranch,and all the components for my home made salad.

When it was done, pinkie came down the stairs. She smiled. "Ooo, that looks good!" She said.

"Thank you." I said. We all got in are chairs and dug in. After we were done eating,I got up and said, "Well,lets get to work." We stared getting to work on the guest house behind the house. First things first. We had to move the tree.

Twilight used her magic to move the tree aside. Then i use an ax to chop it into pieces.During which it felt like somepony was watching me. But i shrugged it off and continued to work. After that we moved to the roof. I went up and started to rebuild the frames.

It was a little difficult, but i got it done. The rest of the day went on with ease. We got the insulator put in, finished the roof, and tiled it. Pinkie was inside cleaning up the whole place. Every once in a while i would get that "somepony is watching me" feeling. But i just ignored it.

At about 9:00, we were finally done. "Ok,lets head in!" I said. As we started to make our way back, pinkie came up to me.

"Hey baret?" She asked. I turned to her.

"Ya?" I asked.

"Can you come to the barn later tonight to meet me there?" She asked.

I thought about it. "Sure,why not." I said.

"Thank you." She said then we quietly walked back. Why does she want to see me? I wondered. But i guess I'll have to wait and see.