Fluttershy and Rainbow Dash discover the body of a pony just outside the Everfree Forest. Not just dead, eaten! They seek help from the new town sheriff and his deputy. But it's soon clear that they'll need a lot more help than that. Enter J. Edgar Hoofer, head of the recently formed Equestrian Bureau of Investigation. The case doesn't turn out to be as simple as either party thought. And the closer they come to solving the case, the more they realize just what evil is lurking around the normally peaceful town.

Shout out to my best buddy Ravebrony42 for allwoing me to use his OCs. Credit to rem-dog for helping me name the OC character of J. Edgar Hoofer.