Butchering Faith

by Sunset Glimmer

Rating: mature
Tags: Tragedy, Dark, Sad
Length: 1162

Fluttershy has returned, but she's not in the Ponyville we all know and love, she's in the most feared PonyVille of all. Even Twilight doesn't know it exists, yet she always has dreams about it....

Fluttershy has returned, but she's not in the PonyVille we all know and love. This is the PonyVille that everyone fears will come soon. No one even knows if it exists, not even Twilight. She dreams about it every night, and everything that happens there. When Twilight appears, her world is turned upside down, as she discovers that what happens in her dreams, happen in real life. When she asks Fluttershy what she's doing there, Fluttershy's only response, will shock Twilight. **In The Same World As CupCakes*

Read Death Is In The Air first.

Published 1970-01-01 00:00:00 UTC
Last updated 2013-08-01 02:20:03 UTC

The Arrival

Fluttershy jumped out of the portal that she had opened up and looked around. This PonyVille looked the same as her old one, but she knew that it was different. She hid her weapons so no pony would be suspicious. She then slowly walked over to Sugar Cube Corner. She needed another insane pony to help her. Even if Pinkie wasn't insane in that way.

When Fluttershy walked inside, she noticed that no one was there. She walked around, and through the building/house and saw no one. As she walked into the kitchen, she heard screaming coming from the basement.

"No Pinkie please! NOOOOOO DON'T!" This voice screamed out in agony and pain, which Fluttershy enjoyed. She pulled out her butcher knife and quietly opened the door so Pinkie wouldn't hear. She walked down the steps careful not to trip on anything.

Once she was fully down the basement stairs, she saw Carrot Top. One pony that used to bully her as a filly. Carrot Top was around when she fell from the sky, but she didn't help her at all.

"Oh, Fluttershy thank goodness you're here now you can help me!" Carrot Top cried out.

"I don't think so." Pinkie replied, throwing some knifes at her.

Fluttershy sighed. "Relax Pinkie, I'm here to help you."

Pinkie stood shocked. She hadn't had an assistant before, but she knew that if she had one, things would be a lot better.

Pinkie began to imagine all the fun they could have together. She would love having an assistant. But to have Fluttershy? Fluttershy wasn't evil one bit! Something told Pinkie other though. Perhaps it was her look? Or her face?

Fluttershy had a bloody saddle-bag. She was surprised any other pony hadn't noticed it before. She also looked at Fluttershy's face. It had blood on it.

"OK." Pinkie finally replied.

Fluttershy walked over to Pinkie, and pulled out her butcher knife.

"What shall I do first?" She asked with an evil grin.

"Start by cutting up her guts." Pinkie replied.

Fluttershy obeyed, and walked over to Carrot Top, so she could start slicing her up.

"Fluttershy, Pinkie why? Why would you do this?" Carrot asked sadly.

"Your number came up.." Pinkie replied simply.

"When have you ever helped me?" Fluttershy asked.

Carrot frowned, and broke out into more tears, but that didn't stop Fluttershy.

Fluttershy started to cut out her guts, and once they were all out, she began to stab and cut them viciously, blood splatting everywhere.

Pinkie walked over to Carrot Top, she still had lively eyes, yet she could see pain in them.

"Don't worry you part pooper! I'll help you out!" Pinkie said.

Carrot's eyes turned pleading.

"No." Pinkie said. She started injecting some liquids into Carrot Top. Suddenly, she went numb.

Pinkie then picked up a scalpel and started to take out her organs. Carrot felt nothing, and she was happy with that.

Fluttershy stopped what she was doing, and watched Pinkie, her mouth watering as she saw the blood dripping on all over her coat. Pinkie noticed, and filled up a cup, then handed it to Fluttershy, who accepted the cup and drank every last drop.

Fluttershy then pulled out her other knife, and cut out her heart, which was still beating. The life was slowly leaving Carrot Top's eyes, but they still continued to work on her.

When they were done, Pinkie congratulated Fluttershy on her first time. She told Fluttershy about how these would make the best cupcakes ever! Fluttershy believed it. They walked upstairs and cleaned up. When they were done, Pinkie told her to come back tomorrow. Fluttershy nodded, and walked home. She was excited for the next day. After all, why couldn't murder bring a smile to your face?

Fluttershy continued to hum on her way home, dreading having to feed her animals. She was slowly turning as insane as Pinkie, but she was okay with that. She felt OK as long as she could kill people and things. She could feel her mind clicking, and her eyes started to twitch. She walked inside to her animals, who looked at her with pleading eyes. They wanted food.

Fluttershy picked up a bird and went upstairs. She would be having some Phoenix for dinner. As she walked upstairs, she grabbed a knife.

This was also good practice for Fluttershy. She wouldn't want to disappoint Pinkie. She strapped the bird down to a small table, and gave it some medicine. Once it was asleep, she began.

She slit open the bird, and looked at it's organs. They looked delicious to Fluttershy. She started to slowly pull them out, so that if the bird was to awake, it would feel pain. Once she got it's guts out, she started on getting the Lungs out. Around this time, the bird awoke, shock on it's face as it saw it's friend Fluttershy killing it.

Fluttershy brutally chopped up the birds guts and started singing to herself. She felt better. She began chopping up the organs, and she then made some casserole, and added the organs. Afterwards, she fed her animals. She knew that they too, would soon be on her menu. She licked her lips at the thought, and took a shower. She couldn't wait till she got to kill more ponies.

Fluttershy then climbed into bed, wanting some rest, before her big day. She was about to wake up, but she enjoyed her dream so much, she decided that she would stay asleep for a few more minutes.

She was an animal, and she was a killer as she is now. She was also with these two-legged creatures, and they thought she was so innocent. One day, she got into a lot of trouble. She was planning her revenge one day. Everything was set in motion, and it went down perfectly.

She walked into her owners room, and saw them sound asleep. She climbed onto the bed, and slit their throats.

It was then that Fluttershy had awaken. It was only 3:00 in the morning. This was the third time that Fluttershy had awaken from her excitement of the next day. She wanted to tell someone, but she knew that she'd get into a lot of trouble if anyone knew.

When Fluttershy had finally gone back to sleep, her bunny Angel, and hopped on out of the house. He had to get out of there. He did not want to be her next meal. He didn't get very far, until he was greeted by Fluttershy. She found out that he had gotten out, and now she had found him. He knew it was all over now. He was scared, and started crying.

He then awoke in his bed next to Fluttershy's. He just had a silly dream. He couldn't believe that Fluttershy was killer. He laughed at his dream, and went back to sleep. Little did he know, his dream may be the truth...