Broken Hearts and Diamonds

by TheCamel

Plan B

Previous ChapterNext Chapter

Rarity spent the next day working on Flitter's clothes. The temptation to make them even smaller crossed her mind, but she decided against it as doing the same thing might arouse suspicion or cause Flitter to go elsewhere for her clothes. It didn't take long for her to resize the outfits to the correct size; all she had to do was break a few stitches and smooth out the creases caused by her sabotage and she was done. Having completed the work faster than she thought, Rarity decided to return to her room and see if she could find something to keep her occupied for the rest of the day.

Once in her room she went over to one of her dressers and opened one of the drawers. Buried underneath many pairs of socks lay a small plastic baggy almost half filled with the dangerous drugs she had confiscated from Thunderlane. Picking up the baggy with her magic she brought the drugs to her kitchen and carefully opened the bag and spread the hoofies out on her table. Counting the dangerous pills one by one, she saw that she had a total of seven tablets at her disposal. "Hmph, I thought there was more in there." she muttered to herself. "No matter, I guess I could always pay Thunderlane a visit if I run out."

Scooping six of the hoofies back into the baggy, Rarity was forced to settle on just one to experiment with. "Let's see here, if I remember correctly these little pills are tasteless when mixed with any fluid, but they may leave a powdery taste. So that means I have to grind them up into an extremely fine powder if I want it to go unnoticed." She retrieved a small mortar and pestle set from her cupboard an tossed the white tablet in. Very carefully she ground the tablet into a fine powder, making sure that there were no stray chunks that she could find. To see if she ground up the hoofie enough she got a glass and poured a small amount of water in to it and then mixed a small pinch of the ground up hoofie. Stirring the two together she frowned as she saw that there were small particles clearly visible in the water, causing her to empty out the liquid into the sink. Returning to the table she continued to grind the powder for another twenty minutes. The powder she now had was almost like dust, and she had to take caution breathing around it to avoid accidentally blowing the lightweight powder out from the mortar. Once again she poured a small amount of water into the glass and mixed in a small amount of the powder. Within seconds the powdered hoofies disappeared into the liquid, leaving no trace at all.

"Perfect!" Rarity exclaimed, now knowing how much grinding she had to do to get the drugs fine enough to dissolve instantly. Now there was just one test left to do, but Rarity wasn't too enthusiastic to test it out.

Peeking her head into her storefront she made sure that her shop sign was showing 'closed'. Satisfied that it was, she returned to the kitchen and picked up the glass. There was a little less than a mouthful of tainted water, but it still scared Rarity. However, she had to know if there was any aftertaste to the drug, and there was no way she could ask any other pony to test it out for her. She quickly poured the mixture down her throat in one gulp before she could back out and waited a few moments. Despite the small amount, she started to feel the effects of the drugs almost immediately; she became light headed and her mind seemed to slow down.She let a smile cross her face as she detected no powdery aftertaste from the mixture, though, giving her confidence that she could now slip the dangerous drugs to almost anypony she wished, and she had the perfect idea of who she could try it on first.


A few days later Flitter came by to pick up her new outfits. Trying on the clothes once again, she smiled in delight as each on fit her perfectly. "Oh, thank you thank you thank you thank you!" she said excitedly. "I can't wait for Spike to see these!"

"I'm sure he'll love them, dear." Rarity said. "I do make the best clothes in all of Ponyville, after all."

As Flitter turned to leave with her clothes neatly packaged up Rarity stopped her. "Oh, I almost forgot, I have a little something that you and Spike may like." Reaching beneath the counter she brought out a bottle of wine. "It's just a little something I've had laying around, but I owe Spike for helping me fix up some things around here. I figured you two may like to enjoy this on one of your dates."

"Wow, seriously? Rarity, you're the best!" Flitter exclaimed. While she was no wine connoisseur Flitter could tell that the wine Rarity was offering her was worth over a hundred bits. She couldn't believe how generous Rarity was being; first not charging her extra for the alterations to her clothes and now giving away an expensive bottle of wine. "This is perfect! Spike and I are going on a picnic by the stream tomorrow at noon and this will go perfectly with it. I can't thank you enough!"

Flitter happily trotted home, feeling like the luckiest mare ever. Rarity watched her go and smirked knowing the pegasus had taken the bait. True, it had cost her an expensive bottle of wine but it was now worthless thanks to the extra ingredient Rarity had added to it. It had also cost her three of her scarce hoofies, but she had to be sure that even one glass of wine would have the desired effects she was seeking. But after seeing Flitter's enthusiasm when she was given the wine, she was sure that the pegasus would be more than happy to have a few glasses of wine, even if Spike didn't like wine all that much.


The next morning couldn't come come quick enough for Flitter. When she woke up the sun had been up for barely an hour, but she rushed out of bed and into the bathroom to prepare herself for her date with Spike. She dashed in a few moments before her older sister could get in first, and Flitter couldn't help but giggle as Cloudchaser banged on the door. "Flitter! You better not take forever in there again!" she yelled.

"Don't worry, I have to meet Spike at noon so I won't be too long." Flitter called out, turning on the shower.

"What?! That's... that's over four hours from now! Flitter!" Cloudchaser shouted, banging on the door again, but the sound of the running water was drowning out her voice.

Running the warm water over her body, Flitter let out a long sigh as the water soaked every inch of her. The last few days for her had been absolutely perfect for her, and she swore that there was nothing that could make her happier than she was now. She had finally mustered up the courage to ask out her crush and he had said yes, their first few dates had gone off absolutely flawlessly, she now had a few new outfits to show off to Spike, not to mention she had gotten a free bottle of wine for today's date!

As she thought of today's date with her dragon she blushed slightly. She had never kissed anypony before and wanted Spike to be her first but had no idea how to get to that point. Her sister had jokingly told her to just jump on top of Spike and give herself completely to him, but even though it was just a joke the thought still got Flitter completely flustered.

"I couldn't... would he want to go that far with me?" Flitter asked herself softly. She brushed a hoof over her stomach, feeling her body. She had always thought that she kept herself fit but the remarks made by Rarity were now causing some doubt in her mind. 'Am I small enough for Spike? I don't want him to lose him because I can't stay in shape.' she thought. Ever since she found out she was letting herself go she trotted around town more than flying to get more exercise and started cutting back on what she ate. 'I hope it's enough. Although I could always join Rainbow Dash during her morning exercise routine. She's definitely in shape, she could help me.'

Flitter let her imagination wander to how Spike may react to her new toned body. 'He'd probably want to touch me and feel my body.' Flitter thought, once again running her hoof from her chest down to her stomach. As she dipped her hoof even lower, she began to wonder how Spike's claws may feel on her more sensitive areas...

Flitter teased the area just above her crotch with her hoof as she closed her eyes and imagined Spike rubbing her instead. His hot tongue inside her mouth as he gently slid a claw down lower until he reached her private area...

She gasped as her hoof hit her clit, sending a small jolt of electricity through her body. "Oh Celestia, I wonder what he'd do then." she whispered. She closed her eyes again and imagined that he would tease her, tracing the outline of her lower lips before flicking her love button.

"Mmmph! Oh Spike, that feels so good..." Flitter moaned as the rubbed herself. Even with the warm water falling onto her body Flitter could still feel a small trickle of her own fluids sliding down her rear leg as she imagined Spike prodding her with his small dragon. She turned red from the thought of him getting hard for her, and she wondered if his tool would even fit inside of her. She had bribed Cloudchaser to go over to the library when she was out on a date with Spike and borrow a book on dragons, and once she was home she found a very detailed chapter of a male dragon's anatomy. Even with Spike's small size his pecker could possibly too big for Flitter to handle, especially since she was a virgin, but she found the pictures in the book oddly interesting beyond educational purposes.

"Flitter! Flitter, it's been over an hour! Hurry up before I buck this door down!" Cloudchaser yelled, snapping Flitter out of her trance.

"S-sorry, sis! I'm almost done!" Flitter called back, quickly washing her hind legs of her slick fluids. She shut off the water and began to dry off as she went to unlock the bathroom door. As soon as the door clicked open it burst open and Flitter quickly found herself being shoved into the hallway.

"Luna's flank, it's about time! I have to pee so badly!" Cloudchaser exclaimed, slamming the bathroom door shut behind her. Flitter couldn't help but laugh as she heard her sister sigh as she relieved herself after waiting so long.

Returning to her room, Flitter finished drying off and sauntered over to her closet. Her newest additions to her wardrobe all hung neatly, ready to be shown off to a very special dragon. Flitter thought hard about which one to wear, wishing she could somehow wear all of them at once. After some hard thinking she decided on a sky blue tank top with a white shawl and a light pink skirt with matching panties. Putting on the outfit, the clothes fit her slim body perfectly, once again proving Rarity's expertise at making custom clothing. 'Perfect!' Flitter thought, looking herself over in the mirror. 'Spike is sure to love this!'

Twirling around in excitement Flitter glanced at the clock and saw that she still had a few hours before she was due to meet Spike. She trotted downstairs to the kitchen to prepare their lunch for later. Hers was easy enough; a fresh green salad with a small selection of fruit. What to make for Spike was what she was more concerned about. 'He really liked that pie, but there's not enough time to make it. Oh! I could try making a small cake with his favorite gems.' she thought, getting straight to work on it. She decided to make the cake chocolate with rubies and diamonds, thinking that it would go perfectly with Rarity's gift.

A couple of hours later Cloudchaser came into the kitchen, following the scent of Flitter's cooking. "Mmm, that smells absolutely delicious. Watcha making?" she asked.

"Just a small cake for Spike. We're going out to the stream today, remember?" Flitter said, peeking into the oven to check on her creation.

"Oh, it's for Spike? Ugh, it probably has the gems inside of it already, doesn't it?" Cloudchaser said, drooping her ears. There was no way she was willing to risk a mouthful of broken teeth to sneak a nibble at the cake her sister was making.

"Don't worry, I made another one for you. I know how much you love chocolate." Flitter said, opening the oven door to show Cloudchaser the second baking pan.

Cloudchaser's smile was bigger than Derpy's when the mailmare heard that Mr. and Mrs. Cake were having a free muffin day a few weeks ago. "You're the best sister ever!" she exclaimed, hugging Flitter tightly.

"Gah! Stop it, you're going to mess up my outfit!" Flitter protested, struggling free from her sister's grasp.

"Oh stop it, you look fine." Cloudchaser insisted. "Besides, I'm sure Spike wouldn't mind seeing your top slid down a little bit..."

"Sis!" Flitter said, her face burning bright red by Cloudchaser's suggestion.

"Calm down, I'm only kidding." she said, winking at her. She turned to leave but her eyes caught something she had missed before; the bottle of wine Rarity had given Flitter, tucked into the basket Flitter had started preparing.

"Holy Celestia, where did this come from?" Cloudchaser exclaimed, holding the wine up. "This is... is this yours?"

Flitter nodded. "Yeah, Rarity gave it to me yesterday. I'm going to take it today to share with Spike."

Cloudchaser looked concerned at her sister. "Flitter, you know you're still too young to be drinking this kind of stuff." she said.

Flitter stomped a hoof in frustration. "Oh come on! I've had alcohol before, I can handle a few glasses of wine." she protested.

Cloudchaser shook her head. "I'm sorry, I don't think I can let you take it. This stuff is stronger than most wines, it's even stronger than most brews that they serve at the pub in town. I'd really feel much better if you took something else instead."

Flitter wasn't happy with her older sister's decision, and Cloudchaser did genuinely feel guilty about stopping her sister from taking Rarity's gift. "Look, I'll make a deal with you. I have some of my strawberry lemonade still in the fridge. Take that for your date instead and you and Spike can try the wine here during your next date."

The young pegasus mare thought about the offer for a few moments. "Fine." Flitter finally conceded. "But you don't get your cake until Spike and I have the wine."

Cloudchaser let out a small laugh as her sister turned to go upstairs to fix her outfit before going out to meet Spike. "Hahaha, that's a good one. Wait, you were joking, right? Right? Flitter!"


Checking her clock, Rarity saw that it was about time for her to take a little stroll. Scribbling a quick note that she would be back in a hour or two, she locked up her boutique and trotted to the stream that ran in front of the town hall. On the opposite bank two figures could be seen setting up a blanket, and Rarity positioned herself behind a nearby tree and watched her targets. From her position she could faintly hear Spike and Flitter's conversation.

"Wow, this looks amazing, Flitter! You really know all my favorites, don't you?" Spike said, his mouth watering as Flitter handed him the cake that she made earlier that morning.

She blushed shyly at his compliment. "It... it's nothing, really." she said nervously. "I hope it's okay."

Spike took a bite of the cake and his eyes instantly lit up. "This is... this is amazing! It's even better than the one I tried to make!" he said. He leaned over and kissed Flitter on her cheek, hoping his sign of affection wouldn't scare her away. It didn't, but it did turn her face a shade of red that rivaled Big Mac's coat. A soft 'poomf' reached Spike's ears as her wings shot out erect, and Spike had to try his hardest not to laugh at her unfortunate wing-boner.

Rarity was turning a deep shade of red also, but for an entirely different reason. She wanted to desperately rush over and throw Flitter into the water but managed to restrain herself, mainly because she WAS in front of the mayor's office. She instead ground her hoof into the ground and gritted her teeth, losing patience and hoping that the moment she was waiting for would come soon.

Flitter recovered from her embarrassment and brought out her salad and two cups. As she reached in to the basket to get the bottle at the bottom Rarity's ears perked up in excitement as she saw a bottle finally being brought out. Flitter poured Spike and herself their drinks and both of them gulped down the liquid inside, causing Rarity to smirk in satisfaction.

'Perfect, they didn't even notice the powder!' she thought. 'Now to wait... it shouldn't take too long for the effects to hit them. Flitter will probably drink more than my Spikey-Wikey, and it won't be long until she's acting like a complete whorse. Then I'll swoop in and save Spike from her slutty advances and show him that I am the better mare for him.'

Rarity watched the two take another large gulp of their drinks before refiling their cups. As the bottle was lifted up Rarity noticed something odd; the bottle looked different than the one she gave Flitter yesterday. Peering closer, she saw that it was, not to mention the liquid inside was a bright pink instead of a deep purple. The answer finally came to Rarity's mind, but she was not happy about it.

"They... she didn't bring the wine I gave her! That... that inconsiderate bitch!" Rarity hissed under her breath, forgetting the fact that she had planned on drugging them both with the wine. Moving out from her hiding place, Rarity began to storm off back to Carousel Boutique, but after only a few steps she stopped and turned around. She wanted to find out why Flitter didn't bring her gift, and set off towards them.

"Why hello there, you two. Fancy meeting you out here." Rarity said as she approached Spike and Flitter.

"Oh, hi there, Rarity! What are you doing out here?" Spike asked, wiping a few crumbs of cake from his face.

"Just taking a stroll around town, have to clear my head after working so hard all week." Rarity said dramatically. "Speaking of which, how do you like your clothes, Flitter dear?"

"Oh my gosh, Rarity, I can't thank you enough!" Flitter said. "You should have seen Spike's jaw drop when he came to pick me up at my house."

"Well, I'm glad you like it as does Spike." Rarity said. "Oh, and how are you enjoying that wine I gave you yesterday? Superb, isn't it?"

"Oh, I couldn't bring it today." Flitter said. "My sister didn't think it would be a good idea, so I brought strawberry lemonade instead, and we're going to try the wine sometime later."

Rarity was severely disappointed that she wouldn't be able to humiliate Flitter in public today, but another idea started to form in her head. "That sounds lovely. Oh, since I have you both here, would you like to come over for a small wine tasting I'm having at my place? Nothing too extravagant, I'm just looking to replenish my collection and thought you two may enjoy trying some with me and one of my friends."

"Of course, we'd love to!" Flitter said excitedly, thinking that this would be the perfect opportunity to prove to Cloudchaser that she could handle adult beverages. "Right, Spike?"

"Of course, we'll be there." Spike said, confident that a night of drinking wine with Rarity and Flitter couldn't possibly go wrong in any way.

Rarity smiled. "Perfect. Come over to my place tomorrow evening around seven." With a quick wave goodbye, Rarity trotted off back into town, leaving Flitter and Spike talking excitedly about the next evening. Rarity headed past her boutique, not caring that her estimated time back was far gone, and headed for a certain stallion's house. She knocked on the door politely, but once she received no answer she banged on the door harder. It finally opened, and the pony inside was somewhat startled to see Rarity at his door.

"W-what are you doing here?" Thunderlane gasped. Rarity pushed him backwards and let herself in to his home, shutting the door behind her. "Look, what do you want? You're not here to turn me in, are you?" he asked nervously.

"No, I need you to do me a favor." she said firmly. "Do you have any of those hoofies left?"

Thunderlane gulped. Since she took his small supply he had to withdraw a sizable amount from his bank account to buy another bag of the drugs. He figured lying would just dig himself a deeper grave, so he told her the truth. "Y-yeah, just a small bag. I was going to throw them out, I swear!" he said.

Rarity smiled. "Well, don't. If you do this favor for me tomorrow I'll forget all about the fact that you tried to drug me and have your way with me."

"Really?" Thunderlane said in disbelief. "Whatever you want, I'll do it. Just name it!"

An evil grin crossed Rarity's face, scaring the stallion in front of her. "Tell me, do you like wine, Thunderlane?"


Author's Note

Just to reiterate; I'm going with the notion that Cloudchaser is the older sister and Flitter is the younger sister. There's no canon proof (yet) that they're sisters at all, let alone twins. The evidence I've seen leads me to believe that if they are related they're different ages. Besides, there are enough twins in the show already.

Also, I'd rather bang a set of older/younger sisters than twins.

Next Chapter