It was a relatively quiet day in the little hamlet of Ponyville. Things had settled down over the past several months, after the excitement and upheaval caused by the human that had somehow found himself in the town. Gradually, after the initial awkwardness had faded and everypony got used to his presence, daily life had returned to normal for the residents. Anon, the human who had inexplicably jumped dimensions and found himself amongst the ponies, had taken up temporary residence in the second floor of one of Ponyville's many shops. A local general store, to be precise. The owner of the store had invited him to stay with her until he found a way to return to earth. Not that returning to Florida was high on his priority list, though - life here was much more pleasant than the dull and often frustrating pace of life back home. The coming and going of ponies on the level below didn't seem to bother him as he kept mostly to himself in the little room. Occasionally, he would wander downstairs to eat or chat with the customers.
However, there was one pony who he always loved to see come into the store. About once a week, a blue-and-white unicorn mare would show up to buy a few basic goods. Colgate was a Canterlot native, and had moved to Ponyville just before Anon showed up. Thus, in a way, the two were both newcomers, and by drawing upon this connection he had become closer to her than any other ponies in the town aside from the shop owner. Her visits didn't last long, but the two had great fun discussing random things, from the differences in their cultures to stories of their younger days. She was a somewhat shy and reserved pony, but seemed to open up a bit after having spent time talking with Anon. She looked forward to her weekly visit to the store almost as much as Anon did, eager to share stories of her week. And it would be hard to deny that in recent weeks Anon had developed feelings for the beautiful young pony. Probably a fantasy that would never be realised, of course, but as a young man in a town full of females, such attraction is bound to occur. The only problem was, the attraction seemed to be getting stronger. Despite the species difference, it was a feeling that was hard to stifle.
Today was to be a day like any other. It was Wednesday, the day before Colgate would normally stop by. Anon walked down the set of stairs at the back of the store, intending to pick up a few snacks to take back to his room, along with a fresh tube of toothpaste - coincidentally, the last one on the shelf. The owner had just left for a couple of errands, closing the shop down for an hour or so. Anon browsed through the various items on the shelf, picking out a few things. He would pay for the goods with the bits he earned from cleaning the store at night. He slipped the goods into his pockets and headed for the counter to write down his purchases. As he was finishing, he happened to glance towards the front door. Lo and behold, what else would greet his view but a certain blue and white unicorn? He gasped, and ran to the door.
"Colgate! What a surprise to see you here on a Wednesday!"
"Oh... yeah, I suppose it is Wednesday, isn't it?" she said, with hints of hesitation in her voice.
"Couldn't wait till tomorrow, huh?" he replied as he unlocked the doors.
"Oh... um... if the store is closed, I'll come back later..."
"No, no. See, Mrs. Wanda went out to run a few errands, so she locked the store up for a little while. I'm just here alone, getting a few snacks to carry back upstairs. Come on in."
Anon beckoned the pony into the store, and closed the door behind her.
"So... um... Colgate? What's new?"
The pony pretended to ignore his question, and started to walk the aisles of the small store. She appeared very much distracted, almost as if she weren't here to shop, but for something else.
"Colgate? Something wrong?"
With a flustered sigh, Colgate turned to face him. "Listen. I... I... just... I might need to... hmm. This is not as easy as I..." Her voice trailed off, and she hung her head.
"Seriously, what's the matter?"
"I... I don't know. I came here because I wanted to tal... I mean... I know I'm early but I couldn't... but now that I'm here, I can't even look at you without feeling..." A light blush formed on her light blue cheeks as she turned her head. "I... oh, this is so hard. I don't know why I can't just say it..."
"Come on, whatever it is, I'll listen. We're friends, right? You can tell me anything." By Colgate's choice of words in her last statement, Anon was fairly certain what she was going to say next. After all, he had read enough clopfics to know where THIS was going.
"I... I... I think... I mean, I know you're not a pony, and I know these feelings are... are kind of sudden... but I..." Colgate blushed even deeper. "... I think I like you. I mean... I mean, as more than a friend... I'm in... in..."
"In... love?"
"But... I know you're a human and... ugh, why does this have to be so difficult..."
Anon was going to play this one up. Obviously, his feelings were mutual. Colgate liked him... a lot. And he was going to make her want him even more. "Ah... well... um... you know, I'll have to think on this one. I'm not sure what to say." Colgate's heart sank, fearing that he couldn't feel the same way. "Why don't you think it over a little while longer and do your shopping a day early. I'll stay down here and think this whole... you know, thing, over. You can hang around and pay when Mrs. Wanda gets back."
Colgate dropped her head, feeling rejected and heartsick, and still rather confused. Why had she suddenly developed these strong feelings for this human? She was going into heat, yes, but this was more than just a passing crush. She was infatuated. "I... I suppose I... I could do that..." She picked up a basket in her teeth and slowly plodded down the first aisle, using her magic to levitate items into the container. Her aim was a bit off and she knocked over several items, clearly distraught and distracted.
Anon stood off to the side, feeling sorry for the poor unicorn, but knowing that his quickly-devised plan was soon to make it up. He watched as she reached the dental section, knowing she always bought a new tube of toothpaste every week. Dental hygiene was her specialty and obsession. And he had the only tube in the whole store in his pocket.
"Where... where's the toothpaste..." she whispered aloud to herself.
Anon smiled, and called out to her. "Hey Colgate? You looking for this?" He reached in his pocket and pulled out the tube. "Last one in the store, you know. I bought it just before you came in."
She looked at him with a mix of confusion and sadness on her face. First rejection, now not getting toothpaste. Talk about worst day ever. "But... but... can I please... if you don't..." Tears began to well in her deep blue eyes.
Anon had to play his cards right. If he taunted the poor pony too much, she would probably run out of the store crying and he might never see her again. If he handed it over without resistance, he might not have a chance to reveal his feelings. Now was his chance. "I don't really NEED this. But maybe we can work out something." She stared at him, unsure how to react. "I've thought it over and... well, you know what hippogriffs are, right?"
A few seconds of silence followed. She wasn't quite sure what he was getting at. He repeated the question, and she slowly replied, "... a griffon and... and a pony's offspring..."
"So obviously, interspecies relationships here /are/ possible." He strolled toward her. "But you know, if that were my 'thing', I'd have to pick out a truly beautiful, sexy, talented pony. I couldn't settle for less." She was unsure what to say, and wasn't really comprehending what he was saying, as he kneeled down to her eye level. "And I've only found one of those here in Ponyville." Without warning, he grabbed Colgate from behind her neck and pulled her into a deep, passionate kiss. At first Colgate was completely stunned, but she quickly got the message. She closed her eyes and began to explore the inside of his mouth with her pony tongue. Their tongues, of different sizes but surprisingly similar, met each other in a moment of passion.
After what seemed like hours, she broke free of the kiss and leaned back, taken aback. "You mean... you... we... it's..."
"Don't think you were alone in your feelings. It's totally mutual." Anon smiled at the mare, who was blushing harder than ever before.
"Oh sweet Celestia... that's... I..." Colgate lunged forward, pinning Anon to the ground, and returning a strong, passionate kiss. His mouth and her muzzle seemed amazingly compatible.
After several moments, Anon slid out from under her, and the two looked deeply into each other's eyes. Never before had either felt such a burning passion. Anon slowly reached in his pocket and again brought forth the item of Colgate's attention... the last toothpaste tube in the store. "Now for our little deal." He rapidly jumped to his feet and within a few seconds had made it to the stairs. "You'll have to catch me to find out!"
Colgate jumped to her hooves and dashed up the stairs in hot pursuit. Within seconds, she caught up to him, in the middle of his room, and tackled him. With a devious grin, she looked down at the hapless young man and said, in a rather sultry voice, "I want toothpaste."
Anon returned the mischievous smile, and, using the nearby bed frame as leverage, he threw her over so that he was now on top. "What you gonna trade for it?"
Colgate, using her full weight, flipped him over so she was again on top. "I think I know something you'd like." At this point, Rose suddenly noticed a spot near his crotch turning very warm and wet. Colgate's expression quickly turned to that of shock and embarrassment, and she moved off him. "Oh... oh dear... I... I'm sorry... I'm pushing too far. I... I'm in season and I let my hormones get..."
"Oh don't be sorry. Not at all." Anon said, with a wicked gleam in his eye. "Only problem is, what I want may not be a fair trade... because looks like you want it as much as I do." He stared at the pony, who was furiously blushing. A small pool of liquid had formed in the floor under her tail. She was as horny as a pony could possibly be.
"I... I was afraid I was pushing too fast... we've only... you know..."
"We've known each other for several months, Colgate. And I've wanted you for nearly the whole time. You are most certainly not moving too fast."
Colgate pawed her hoof across the floor and looked away. A small grin formed on her beautiful face. After a few moments, she began to walk toward him. "Well... there's really only one thing we can do about... this... then." She stopped right beside him, her little grin growing into a huge smile. In one swift motion, she swung her hips around and turned 180 degrees, so that her rump was facing Anon, mere inches away. Still blushing, she lifted her tail to the side, revealing a perfectly formed and very wet vagina. The aroma of her juices, made extra potent by her being in season, filled the room. "Don't make me wait, Anon... my lover."
Anon was ready. Very much ready. He tore off his clothes, freeing his already rigid member from its cloth prison. The sight of a perfectly positioned and pleasantly primed pony pussy a few inches from his crotch was far too alluring to possibly resist, even if for some bizarre reason he had wished to do so.
"But please keep in mind..." Colgate stammered, "this is my... my first time, please go easy. I've never been with anypony before, especially not a human."
"Don't worry, I will be gentle." He replied, resisting the urge to jump forward and plunge right in. No, not yet. He couldn't just start thrusting away so soon. This situation was too hot to let it end so soon. He would tease her just a little more. There was no way she was getting out of the room without being fucked senselessly, but that could wait for a few moments more. The wicked grin returned, and he wondered aloud, "Well, maybe a few more minutes. I need to savior this moment a bit. Examine the merchandise, you know."
"Pardon my language but... don't just stare at it, put it in! Please, fuck me now!" She backed up so that her dripping pussy was literally up against his crotch. "Please, I need this. I want this. You need this. Don't... don't make me wait any longer..."
"I will, I will. Just got to get into position. Can't you... can't you roll over on your back for a moment?"
She immediately dropped to the floor, rolling over onto her back with her legs in the air. She spread her back legs as far as they would go to accommodate him. "There. Take me. Now."
Anon could hardly resist any longer. He was close to exploding just looking at the scene before him. He knelt down and lay himself across the belly of the blue unicorn. His penis lay over her outer lips, which were now very hot and still sopping wet. He slowly and deliberately began to rub back and forth without penetrating. "So close... and yet..."
Colgate, sexually frustrated and so horny she couldn't take the teasing any longer, shifted her hips forward and bucked upwards, at such an angle that his penis was directed right between her folds and into her. They both gasped at the sudden and deep penetration. The wait was over.
Both briefly paused their movements. Anon savored the feeling of her incredibly tight, hot, and slick virgin pussy. Colgate savored the sudden feeling of her sexual desire being filled. She had never felt such an amazing sensation, having her vagina filled so tightly and stretched by a penis... a human one, at that. It had come to rest very near her hymen, but with some shaft yet to go in. Anon was surprised how tight pony pussy seemed to be, but certainly wasn't complaining.
"Ah... gasp... this... oh Celestia. I... oh... ah...." Colgate was breathing heavily, panting and groaning. Already, the sensation was amazing. And already, she wanted more. She wanted him to start pounding... harder, and harder. She wanted him to bring them both to orgasm simultaneously, their muscles pulsating in unison. She pulled his head to hers, and pressed their mouths together for a deep, passionate, long kiss. "I'm... I'm yours. Do whatever you w.. want with me, Anon."
With this, he pulled partially out, with only the head still inside, and then shoved forward, much deeper than before. A slight resistance gave way, and she squeaked at the brief hint of pain. She had officially lost her virginity. But that did not matter now. She screamed in pleasure as he thrust into her again. In, and out. She was so wet that there was no longer much resistance... so she squeezed her rear legs against Anon's sides, constricting her vagina even further. He gasped in pleasure and continued thrusting. In and out. In and out. Alternating between fast and slow strokes, pushing deeply then shallowly. But his pace slowly got consistently faster.
"Oh! Oh! I... ah! Ah! I'm goin... ah! Going to..." Colgate was nearing orgasm quickly. Oh, how she wished this would last. But the sensations were so strong that she was finding it hard to hold back.
Anon slowed down, catching his breath. The both of them were on the very edge. He was going to try to keep it going a bit longer. Abruptly, he stopped thrusting, his member still swollen inside her. For several seconds, he lay there, gazing deep into her hypnotic eyes. Eventually, he started again. Very slowly at first. But gradually, gradually he increased the pace again. And a familiar sensation began to return. This time, there would be no turning back. They were going all the way.
Moans and grunts filled the room. As the pace of both increased, Anon thrusting ever quicker and Colgate thrusting her hips to meet his thrusts, Colgate began to orgasm. Biting her lip to avoid screaming, her juices began to fill her chamber, some squeezing between the still-thrusting cock to flow out to the floor. Her muscles contracted, pulsing around Anon's shaft. He could hold back no longer, and came.
The two lay there, motionless and quiet, for many seconds. Neither said a word, lost in the afterglow. Anon very slowly pulled out of Colgate and sighed. "That was... amazing. Wow."
"Thank you Anon... I... I needed... I needed that."
"I love you, Colgate."
"I love you too, Anon."
The two laid there, Anon noting the mixture of seed and her fluids still dripping out between her thighs. Colgate stayed silent for a minute or so before speaking. "Anon... dear... can we... can we go... again?"
He smiled at her, replying, "Refractory period. Give it a few minutes and we'll be ready to go. Unless..."
"While we're waiting... can I... um... you don't happen to have an extra... toothbrush?"
"You seriously want to brush your teeth right now?"
"Well... um... not quite. See, it's my... my... um... I like to..."
Anon understood. "Your fetish."
"Erm... yes. It is." She blushed once more.
Anon stood up and shuffled over to the chest-of-drawers. He opened a drawer, then another, searching for a spare toothbrush. He found one, finally. With slight hesitation, he delivered it to the insatiable mare. He watched as she levitated it into the air... and then directed it towards her nether regions. With one swift motion, she brought the tip into her swollen vagina, and began to pull it slowly in and out. In and out.
"Brushie... brushie... brushie. Brushie... brushie... br-brushie..."
It didn't take too long watching this beautiful mare pleasuring herself before Anon began to feel excited again. Colgate noticed his staff standing at attention. And now was her turn to tease him.
"Ahh... yes... ahh... oh Celestia this feels... even better. I... I think I'll just do th-this instead of going again..."
"Not gonna happen." Anon leapt forward and grabbed the handle of the toothbrush before Colgate could react. The ray of magic surrounding it faded away as Anon wielded the brush. He began to scrub her inside, gently at first, but once he ascertained that the stiff bristles weren't going to cause any damage, he let her have it. For two minutes, he used that brush in a way the manufacturer surely didn't intend, all the while the mare above him was giggling and moaning, bucking and squirming. Eventually, he pulled it out and smiled at her.
"Oh... wow... that... haha... yes." Brushing her hoof through her disheveled, sweaty mane, she continued "But now... now it's time for round two." She stood up on all fours and walked up to him, again staring him in the face with lusty eyes. "Ready, partner?" And again, she swung her rump around to face him, spreading her legs wide and lifting her tail high. "I... I want you to take me standing this time."
Anon needed little further instruction. Now fully erect he lunged forward and penetrated her. She gasped as he once again entered her. He grabbed the back of her mane with one hand and her neck with his other. The rough thrusting splashed more of the remnants from their first round from her vagina out to the floor, but that mattered little. All he cared about was this moment. Lost in pure, unadulterated pleasure. His shaft pulling out of her swollen love tunnel and immediately returning forwards, his balls pushing against her flank. Suddenly, though, she moved forward, and his penis pulled completely out of her.
"Can we... t-try... something n-new?" Colgate asked, panting in pleasure and exhilaration.
"Such as?"
"I... I'd like to try it... in the... um... up my... oh dear, how do I ask this..."
Again, Anon knew exactly what the timid mare was asking. With little hesitation he moved forward and pressed the tip of his dick to the outer rim of her anus. She squeaked.
"Oh! Oh... yes... go... go on. Please... please do my ass. Just be... be slow and g-gentle... please."
Anon didn't really need much lubrication, as his penis was already soaked with the mixture of liquids from her other hole. He pushed in gently. He had thought her pussy was tight, but this... he could barely fit in this. It was about the size of a human anus. It was almost painful for him... and Colgate was gritting her teeth trying not to cry out. But this was what she wanted.
"Just... j-j-just... keep... going... but ohdearslowerohdear!"
The incredibly tight sensation nearly drove him to the edge immediately, but he somehow held off. He pushed in very slowly, little by little. Then, once he had explored the first couple of inches, he started to pull very slowly in and out. As he did this, he stealthily reached his hand down below his swollen member. With his fingers, he began to tease her pussy. She gasped and began to pant, unable to speak. As he very slowly continued penetrating her ass, he slipped two fingers into her pussy. Then three. Then five. Then, he carefully slipped most of his hand into her. It barely fit, but clearly she enjoyed the sensation. He was filling both holes, and they were both in ecstasy.
It was only a few minutes, but it felt like hours. Hours of unimaginable pleasure. He continued playing with her vagina with a free hand, and pulling in and out of her anus. Colgate began to shudder and moan louder, close to her orgasm. And Anon, at the same time, was nearing his own in her tight anus. The two came at nearly the same time, with her muscle clamping nearly driving his hand out of her pussy. Liquid spilled out around his fingers. And her anus quickly became filled with his seed. Slowly, completely exhausted, Anon pulled back from the utterly spent Colgate. After a few seconds of silence, the two collapsed into each other's limbs, holding each other in a tight embrace. Neither had to say anything, they knew exactly how the other felt. They just gazed into each others' eyes for what seemed like an eternity.
Anon's room was a mess. The floor was covered in sticky liquids, and the two occupants were sweating and completely unkempt. It looked like a hurricane had swept through. And it was only fitting that this was the moment when the door to his room opened.
"Hey Anon! Back from errands. Why was the front door unl- oh... oh... my!"