Midnight felt the telltale tingle of Twilight's magic cover the barn. He was pretty sure he knew what his fillyfriend had in mind, but was unwilling to jump to conclusions. The look Twilight gave him - half-lidded eyes, biting her lip - left little doubt. She closed the distance between them and pressed her lips to his. She didn't hold it long before separating and looking into Midnight's eyes.
“I... I was going to wait until after the party, when we got home, but,” Twilight began, but paused, thinking of how to word her thoughts, “Midnight... I want you. I would understand if you're not ready, but if you are...”
Midnight had to look away, “You know, I've asked myself what I would do. I'm sure you know what this would mean. Not only would it sever the last ties I have to Sarah, but too my humanity.”
Twilight pulled his face back up, his scarlet eyes meeting her violet ones, “I know. It's okay if you don't want to.”
Midnight gave mimicked her earlier action, pulling Twilight into a passionate kiss, before returning to gazing into her eyes, “And the answer is, yes, I do want this. It's time I let David Corbin go, so Midnight Star can live a full, happy life.”
Twilight's smile could have given Pinkie's best a run for its money. She wrapped her hooves around the back of Midnight's neck and, once again, kissed him, this time her tongue came into play. The lavender mare, stepped into Midnight, pushing him back further into the barn.
Eventually, Twilight broke the kiss and stepped to his side, flicking him in the face with her tail as she went. Her horn lit up as she fluffed up a particular pile of hay. When it was just right, she laid down in the middle, giving her best bedroom eyes to Midnight.
The blue stallion nervously joined her, his heart racing, “Um... I should probably say, I... have no idea what to do. I've never done it as a pony.”
Twilight giggled, “That's okay, Midnight. I've only done it once, and that was, well, for science – shut up – but I’m sure I remember how it's done.”
“Well then, my love,” Midnight gave her another peck on the lips, “I'll just follow your lead.”
Twilight smiled and pulled her stallion on top of her, as she laid on her back, plunging her tongue into his mouth. Midnight broke away, only to trail light kisses and nips down her neck and body, making her moan in delight. His seal lit up as the ethereal digits of his ghost-hand extended from his hoof.
“I guess foreplay shouldn't be too different,” Midnight commented as he lightly glided his fingers along Twilight's inner thigh.
Twilight shuddered at the touch, affirming his theory. He traced circles around her awaiting tunnel, before brushing her lower lips. Twilight moaned quietly as his magical digits stimulated her mound. Without warning, the blue stallion plunged two mage-form fingers in, causing his fillyfriend to gasp.
Midnight began pumping his hoof, sliding his fingers in and out. Twilight threw her head back in a loud moan as she began to lose herself in the ecstasy. Her hips began rocking instinctively as the glowing appendages drove her crazy.
She couldn't take it anymore. Twilight tackled her coltfriend to the ground and straddled him. The lust driven mare pressed her lips to his, as her vulva ground into his solid shaft, coating it in her slippery secretions.
Twilight broke the kiss to stare into his eyes, as she took his phallus in her magic and carefully aligned herself. They kept their eyes locked onto each other, as Twilight slowly lowered herself. The feeling of Midnight's meat spreading her walls nearly sent her over the edge, but she held on.
After a moment to catch her breath and calm down a little, Twilight placed her hooves on Midnight's stomach and slowly raised her hips. His cock slid out, leaving only the head before dropping back down, a little faster than before. Again, she slid herself up, this time Midnight grabbed her hips, thrusting up as she dropped down. The satisfying, furry slap nearly drowned out the moans of the lovers as Twilight found a rhythm, and they soon lost themselves in the pleasure of each other’s bodies. Twilight's pace, though, began to slow as sweat soaked her fur and mane. Midnight could tell she was exhausted.
“Do you want to switch?” he asked.
Twilight just nodded as she slid off him. She turned away and presented herself, flagging her tail to give Midnight a clear path. The earth pony stallion got to his hooves and mounted his mare, thrusting his pole back into the wet cavern of love. From his new position, he began ramming himself into her. He could feel himself growing closer, but refused to finish first. His mouth found Twilight's ear as he began nibbling on the auditory device.
“Ah! I-I'm close!” Twilight called out, “Cum inside me. I'm safe.”
Not one to refuse his lady, he began plowing into her like an animal. Twilight moaned loudly as a sudden spray of juices slathered Midnight's crotch. The contracting walls broke what little resistance Midnight had, and with last thrust, he buried himself as deep as he could. Twilight felt a hot sensation filling her, intensifying her own climax.
After what felt like hours, their orgasms subsided and Twilight collapsed. The wet popping sound of her lover leaving her body was a pleasure of its own. Despite the exhaustion, Midnight managed to ease himself to Twilight's side. The lavender unicorn rolled over to face the one who had just pleased her so thoroughly.
They stared into each other’s eyes for several minutes before Twilight spoke up, “Are you sure you never did this as a pony?”
Midnight had to laugh, “As tempting as Rainbow's offer was, this was the first. Of course, it wasn't as different as I thought it would be.”
“Oh?” Twilight giggled, “I might have to find a spell to turn us human, so I can experiment with that.”
“Okay, as long as you give yourself big tits.”
Twilight laughed, “Oh? Well, my 'tits' are flat, so I guess you didn't enjoy this?”
Midnight grinned as he rolled on top of her, “Well, I don't know. Maybe we should double check.”
Twilight was about to respond but was cut off as Midnight reentered her with renewed vigor. He wasted no time. Last time was romantic, this time was animalistic. He was ravaging her and she loved it. His forceful thrusts quickly brought them to orgasm. She pulled him tight to her body as he filled her for the second time.
Midnight gazed into her eyes, “You know... I like your body how it is.”
Twilight smiled. She looked forward to more nights like this.
