Even Nightmares Have Urges

Chapter 2

-(o)--(o)--(o)--(o)--(o)--(o)--(o)--(o)--(o)--(o)-

Nightmare made her way over to the groggy Princess, the gleam in her eye giving away her intentions. A magic aura surrounded Luna and hoisted her into the air, her snout an inch away from the larger pony’s.

“My little Princess Luna, you have no idea how much fun we are about to h-mmph!”

Nightmare was cut off by Luna pressing her lips to Nightmare’s, the Princess’ mind completely fogged over with lust. Nightmare pulled back in surprise, but quickly realised Luna’s intentions and leaned into the wet kiss.

Luna, still in the air, wrapped her front hooves around Nightmare’s neck and mane while slipping her tongue into the larger pony’s mouth. Nightmare allowed - no, wanted - this to happen, meeting Luna’s tongue with hers, losing herself to Luna’s oral assault. The two continued for a few moments, the dry ground under Nightmare’s haunches becoming darker and wetter. With a small pomf!, Nightmare’s large, black wings sprung outward to their full extent.

A soft, muffled moan escaped Luna as she got more and more into it, and this moan finally brought Nightmare back to her senses. She pulled out of the kiss and Luna’s embrace, much to the smaller alicorn’s displeasure.

“No (pant), please... come back (huff)...!” Luna said, reaching out with her front hooves while trying to swim through the air with her back towards the back peddling pony.

Nightmare smiled, out of breath. “I think my spell worked a little better than I intended.” Nightmare thought. She giggled softly at the antics of the suspended Princess, who was now galloping full-speed in the air, going nowhere fast. “Though that may not be a bad thing.” Nightmare said to herself so that Luna could not hear.

While it was fun toying with Luna, the aching, constant pressure in her lower areas was not going to be ignored. Just as Nightmare went to give Luna what she so desperately wanted, Luna remembered that she, too, had a horn atop her head. Caught off guard, Nightmare’s almost non-existent defenses withered away the instant Luna tried to break free. Luna tumbled to the ground, back on all four hooves in a flash and sprinted toward the one pony she could not live without at this moment.

Nightmare was just about to turn and run before she was barreled over and knocked onto her back. “Lun-oooh my...” Nightmare moaned. She laid her head back and closed her eyes to the pleasure coursing through her, panting and whining.

Luna had Nightmare’s front hooves pinned to the ground, her body on top of her captive’s. Nightmare’s hind legs were spread open and Luna took advantage of this, placing her hind legs between them. She lowered her crotch onto Nightmare’s and gyrated her hips up and down, effectively shutting Nightmare up.

Well, almost shutting Nightmare up. Moans and the occasional yelp were coming from the dark alicorn as Luna slowly, but steadily upped the pace. Nightmare was in absolute ecstasy, finally experiencing her much-awaited pleasure. It quickly intensified, the dark alicorn having a very short fuse due to her solitary confinement on the moon. She completely let herself go as her first orgasm in over 1000 years hit her, and she gave in to the amazing feelings stemming from the pony’s haunches above her. Her limbs jerked under Luna’s, a loud, sharp cry splitting the ever-present quiet of the forest.

Luna was not immune to the intense feelings herself. She was becoming more and more sporadic in her movements, moving faster and faster with each passing second. A deep, guttural moan was let out of the dominant alicorn as she reached one of her hooves behind Nightmare’s head and pulled it up to lock lips with her once more. Nightmare was coming down from her peak slowly, and was still out of it as her mouth was once again filled with another’s tongue, muting the small, occasional whine that found it’s way from the black pony’s throat.

Her hips grinding against another pony’s along with the kiss (albeit a very one-sided kiss as Nightmare passed out) finally pushed Luna over the edge and into her second orgasm of the night. While earlier it was amazing, having somepony else to share the feelings with made it so many times better, and Luna opened her mouth after pulling away from Nightmare’s and let out an echoing scream as pure, burning pleasure made it’s way along her spine and body.

Her legs jittered up against Nightmare’s limp ones as the Princess lost all control of her body, quickly falling asleep and joining the black alicorn in blissful slumber.

-(o)--(o)--(o)--(o)--(o)--(o)--(o)--(o)--(o)--(o)-

Celestia’s magic-induced slumber did not free her from the burden of nightmares, much as she had wished in her last moments of consciousness. How fitting, then, for Nightmare Moon to be at the center of the dream.

“P-please, no, I-I don’t want this...” Celestia pleaded. Her front legs were tied behind her back while her hind legs were spread apart by Nightmare Moon’s as she lay on a flat board, presumably in Nightmare’s basement. An anti-magic ring adorned her horn, blocking all hope for a magical escaped. Celestia glanced around, seeing whips, chains and other, more sadistic-looking toys.

“Oh my, I guess I must stop now. After all, you did say please.” Nightmare said mockingly as she moved lower and lower down Celestia’s body, running her hooves along every curve as she passed. She gave a quick, light nip to Celestia’s wings as she passed, making the white alicorn barely hold back a moan. The wings twitched repeatedly, Celestia just holding herself in as Nightmare’s hoof moved over her primary and secondary feathers, knowing just where to hit.

As Nightmare pushed down near the base suddenly, Celestia yelped quietly as her wings shot out, knocking Nightmare’s hooves away.

“My, my, Celestia does know how to resist what she wants. First bringing Luna back,” Celestia’s eyes looked straight into the black alicorn’s, a look of pure hate etched into them, “then letting Twilight Sparkle go away from the castle.”

“Don’t.” Celestia said, the word dripping with malice.

“And now,” Nightmare steamrolled on, ignoring Celestia completely, “you deny yourself even the most basic of pleasures.” The last word was punctuated by a flick of Nightmare’s hoof as it grazed the area in the center of Celestia’s hips, drawing a sharp gasp from the Princess.

“Nightmare, stop. Please.” Celestia was close to tears now; her body not responding to her, being dominated by one of her most hated enemies, and now knowing that there was nothing she could do to stop-

“What?” Celestia looked down, seeing Nightmare Moon scowling at her, her face inches away from Celestia’s haunches.

“You have no idea how lucky you are.” Nightmare strained the words out, clearly pissed at this turn of events. Celestia, on the other hoof, was lost.

“I don’t-” She started.

“The sleeping spell I put on you is unraveling quickly.” Nightmare explained through clenched teeth. “You will be waking up momentarily. How unfortunate.” Nightmare untied Celestia and took off the ring in a short burst of magic before fading away into blackness. “For you.”

Complete darkness descended, rendering sight useless for the Princess. Lighting her horn did nothing to illuminate her surroundings. But why should she care? She felt so nice right now, laying on the floor, drifting off to a peaceful sleep...

-(o)--(o)--(o)--(o)--(o)--(o)--(o)--(o)--(o)--(o)-

Celestia jerked awake, quickly taking in her surroundings. No whips, no chains, no boards. Just trees, bushes, Nightmare Moon with Luna laying on top of her, and the midnight sky.

...Wait, what? Nightmare Moon with...

“...LUNA?” Celestia jumped to her hooves, managing to make it five feet before collapsing again.

“Okay,” She thought, huffing and puffing on the ground while battling a sudden headache, “let’s not do that again. Nice and slow.” The Princess of the Day slowly rose to her shaky, but working, hooves. She looked at the two-pony pile and tried to process what had happened while she was out.

Just as she came to realise what happened, Nightmare opened her eyes and rubbed them like a newborn foal waking up from a nap.

“That’s so cute...no, that must be aftereffects from the spell she cast on me.” The dark alicorn looked at Luna, who was still sleeping, and wrapped her hooves around her, holding her tight. Celestia couldn’t help but smile at the sight. “...Right?”

In truth, it was the spell that Nightmare had cast on her that was causing her to feel this way. When Celestia had attacked the spell inside her, she managed to loosen it’s influence on her down from mindless lave to adoring fan. Neither Celestia nor Nightmare had realised this, however, so Nightmare had not thought to reinforce the spell and Celestia was left thinking she was going mad.

Celestia’s hooves suddenly gave out, and she fell back onto her flank with a slight thud.

That was enough to get the black alicorn to look up at the noise at the same time Celestia resumed staring. Both ponies froze in place instantly. Nothing moved but the leaves and the wind. Then a cricket chirped and both alicorns sprang up and charged.

Nightmare was handicapped with Luna’s dead weight, which proved to be her downfall as she attempted not to wake or hurt her while getting up while also rushing, leaving Celestia to close the distance and ready a spell in the meantime.

Nightmare looked up from putting Luna on her back to find a golden horn glowing at her neck.

“Hello, Nightmare Moon.” The intensity of the glow spiked as Celestia readied the finishing blow, “Goodbye, Nightmare Moo-oof!” Celestia was on her stomach for the third time in as many minutes, a pony-shaped weight holding her down.

“Luna! Help me get-” Celestia craned her neck to look at her sister and stopped talking when the seductive gaze met her.

“Hi, sis.” Said the spellbound alicorn. “Want to have some fun?”