Even Nightmares Have Urges

Chapter 5

-(o)--(o)--(o)--(o)--(o)--(o)--(o)--(o)--(o)--(o)-

Twilight’s face was one of blank shock. Staring at what appeared to be both Princesses fast asleep, wrapped tightly in the hooves of Nightmare Moon threw a wrench in the unicorn’s thought process. If this were a cartoon, there might have been smoke pouring from her ears.

Twilight resisted the temptation to run away, or curl up into a ball, or pass out, and instead choose to see what exactly was going on. “It could be a trick.” she thought, cautiously approaching the multicolored mass of dozing ponies. “Or Nightmare Moon could have subdued the Princesses. But then why would she be sleeping so close to them?” The answer to Twilight’s unspoken question would be as unwelcome to her mind as losing her friends had been while Discord ran loose.

She stood several feet back from Nightmare, very slowly walking up to the black alicorn. Her hoof suddenly became wet, and bringing the leg up to her face she detected a musky scent emanating from the viscous liquid, making her thoughts hazy.

The purple pony’s brows furrowed, showing her confusion. The innocent, kind, sheltered Twilight had never seen this particular substance before. Of course, she had read books about how foals were made, and knew what went on in somepony’s homes at night, but she had never given a second thought to sex, much less participated in such acts.

The area between Twilight’s hind legs felt funny. If she had to describe it, she would say it felt like something was pushing outwards, trying to escape from her. This pressure had visited a few times before, mostly when she was an adolescent, but every time it went ignored as it never really bothered Twilight. This time, instead of the pressure lessening over time as it usually did, it only grew more persistent, an itch that refused to go away unless scratched.

“Ew! No!” She yelled quite loudly, the realization of what the mystery fluid was washing over her like a tsunami. “No no no no no...” Each word was accompanied by a powerful shake of the wet hoof and a little hop as Twilight tried to get the stuff off her hoof. Droplets flew everywhere, splattering the ground, the bodies of the alicorns, and Nightmare’s snout. The dark pony, forgotten by the unicorn in her desire to do nothing more than cleanse her hoof of the unwanted liquid, woke up to shouts of “No!”, “Ew!”, and “Oh my god how did this get here?”.

With a slight ploosh Nightmare removed herself from Celestia, a small torrent of semen following her limp appendage. Climbing to shaky legs, Nightmare gave a big yawn and stretched her body like a cat would after waking up from its nap. Small pops and cracks sounded as stiff joints were bent and straightened, a strong gust of air knocking over a very frightened purple pony as large black wings were extended.

Sighing happily, Nightmare looked over at her enthralled ponies, who were still off in dreamland. She grinned sleepily, reflecting on what had been going on the during the past hour. How Luna and Celestia had both submitted to her, how they made her feel in control, powerful...happy... Nightmare reigned herself in before she could get too horny again. “Happy...” That was the word that cropped up in her thoughts most often. She was happy, plain and simple. “And who would have imagined that the ponies who were once my mortal enemies were responsible for it!” Nightmare laughed lightly.

“Wait,” she thought, her smile vanishing like the last slice of cake at one of Pinkie Pie’s parties. “Have I changed so much that I gave myself to them? Of all the ponies in the whole of Equestria, why them? Do I really have feelings for those accursed Princesses?” She couldn't deny that she had a soft spot for Luna, but Celestia...

“Damn armor!” She exclaimed suddenly, making an unseen, terrified unicorn leap into the air with fright. Her hoofsteps were so noisy with the shoes on, and her head and chest were sticky and hot with perspiration. Lifting herself out of the hardened metal hoofguards, unclasping the peytral, and sliding her helm off let Nightmare’s fully naked body feel the night air for the first time since before her banishment. The barding was only ceremonial, anyway. It hadn’t kept Celestia from slashing a scroll-sized gash in her shoulder, had it?

A cool summer breeze rippled through the leaves, adding to the already serene scene around the alicorn.

Perfect.

A twig snapped nearby. Normally, this would not be something to get worked up about, but Nightmare was in the Everfree Forest; home to more than your average wolf or bear. Looking around, Nightmare locked eyes with a cowering pony. A pony with a lavender coat, dark violet mane, and a familiar cutie mark...

Nightmare got over her shock at the same time Twilight turned and bolted in the opposite direction. Twilight almost got away, her teleportation spell a fraction of a second slower than the field of magic that scooped her up and knocked her unconscious, levitating the sleeping unicorn over to the caster.

Luna winked at Nightmare, the blue alicorn already gathering magic to cast the same spell she had used on Celestia to place her under Nightmare’s control as she floated Twilight in front of her.

The black pony simply laughed; And she thought Celestia was the one getting old. Her reaction time was not what it used to be.

“Wait!” The voice was soft, yet still commanding. Luna stopped moving, her horn inches away from Twilight’s, and looked back at her sister, who was just rising from her sleep. The white Princess walked slowly, seemingly hesitant to approach as if her faithful student scared her. Celestia’s head was tilted, her expression resembling confusion. “Isn't that...Tri...Tay...Twi-light? What is she doing here?” The Princess asked a panicking Nightmare.

“My hold on her is slipping! Is it because of the unicorn? Or am I simply tired?” True, it did take much more effort than it should have for Nightmare to reinforce the mind-control spell on Celestia. Once she felt the alicorn fully submit to her once more, she felt that it was safe to let the two interact.

“In fact,” Nightmare grinned wolfishly. A malicious idea had formed in her mind. “This little unicorn did stop me the first time... why not let her teacher punish her for being a bad girl?” Nightmare spoke aloud now. “Yes, Celestia, it is your student. She is here because she is a very naughty girl. I think she needs to be punished a little, don’t you?”

A smile crept onto the white pony’s face like the sunrise over a mountain as she processed those words. “Yes,” Celestia echoed. “Punished...” The Princess took hold of Twilight as Luna let her magic go, levitating the pony in front of her face. The white alicorn woke Twilight up as she placed her own spell over her faithful student...

-(o)--(o)--(o)--(o)--(o)--(o)--(o)--(o)--(o)--(o)-

Twilight opened her eyes quickly, regretting it once the glowing whiteness in front of her burned her retinas. She tried again after a moment, slowly cracking open just one eye now. While the light still made i hard to see, Twilight could manage.

“Princess Celestia! Are you okay? Where’s Princess Luna and Nightmare Moon? I saw your contrail in the sky and I knew it was you so I came here and (gasp)... why are you looking at me like that?” Twilight stopped her tirade of questions for two reasons; one, Celestia was giving her student a very provocative stare, the Princess’ eyes half-closed and a slight grin on her face; And two, as the unicorn spoke her last question, something inside of her took hold on her mind. A sudden, strong urge to kiss her mentor, to feel the white fur on her coat, to share her body with the white alicorn had appeared out of thin air, as well as a strong blush on the unicorn’s face. And it terrified Twilight.

“Celestia, what did Nightmare Moon do to YOU?!” Twilight said the last word rather loudly, as the white alicorn had started nibbling her way down the unicorns neck.

“Why, my faithful student, Moony has taught me a valuable lesson these past hours.” The princess started to strengthen the spell on Twilight, sending heat waves up and down the lavender pony’s body and making the unicorn gasp when touched. “She opened my eyes, for I had sealed them shut until tonight.” Celestia had made it down to her student’s teats, and she pinched each lightly with her teeth, licking and sucking on them. Much to Twilight’s tortuous delight. “She opened my mind to the most basic of pleasures...”

The spell had worked its way into almost every area of Twilight’s mind, as evidenced by the wet fur between her flanks. The unicorn felt like she was ready to explode if the pressure between her legs wasn’t released soon.

“Pure.” The Princess stopped the spell, allowing free thought to her student. She wanted the unicorn to understand why this felt so great, why this was okay. Why she should want this.

“Simple.” No more games. Celestia dragged her tongue down the rest of Twilight’s body, stopping just above the dripping slit. The alicorn forced her student to look her in the eye; Celestia saw the fear, the insecurity, but she also saw the burning desire in the unicron’s eye.

“Sex.”

Twilight screamed. Nothing in her life had ever made her feel this way. What Celestia was doing to her made learning a new spell feel as good as getting slapped in the face. The unicorn’s screams and moans let the white alicorn know that her student more than enjoyed this; She loved it. Celestia’s tongue attacked the sensitive button that had emerged from its hiding place, causing the lavender pony to throw her head back in bliss, sending violet hair everywhere. Twilight’s breath quickened as she neared her first climax, and the Princess was all too eager to help her student reach it.

“Ooh, ahh, aaAAHHH! CELESTIAAAA!” Twilight’s screams of ecstasy filled the clearing as her limbs shook violently in their magical restraints. her mind was overloaded with pleasure as her orgasm rocked her to the core. Celestia smacked her lips, pleased with her work and finding her student to be rather tasty.

A quick check told the white alicorn that it would be at least a few minutes before her student was able to function again. The unicorn’s eyes were rolled back in her head, and her mouth was wide open, allowing a small trail of drool to hang from a corner.

“Aww, Celly, why did you have to knock her out? We could have had fun with her!” Luna trotted up to her older sister, playfully reaching up to nip on a white ear.

“Don’t worry, my little Luna,” Moony said softly as she walked towards the group. “I’m sure our new toy will be awake again soon. Then we can use her to our heart’s content.” A wolfish smile played across Nightmare’s face as she said this; the Element of Magic that had played a role in her defeat two years ago would pay tonight. And Nightmare would make sure the unicorn enjoyed every second of her punishment.

The dark alicorn hovered over to the black pony with a flap of dark blue wings. A few inches away from Moony’s face Luna stopped. Expecting another round of kissing, Nightmare closed her eyes and leaned her head forward, but after several seconds of just standing there, the alicorn cracked one serpentine eye open to see a very obviously fake frown on the lunar Princess’s face.

“Celly could have kept her awake,” Luna began, trying to push the feeling from between her hind legs out of her mind for a moment. “Then we wouldn’t have to wait for anything!” Luna could barely keep the frown on her face, as the sensation from her haunches was just too much.

Moony leaned close to the spellbound alicorn, brushing their cheeks together. “I’m sure we can find some- (she trailed her tongue behind one ear) -activities- (running her appendage up the base of the blue horn, replacing the false scowl with shut eyes and a bit lip) -to keep us entertained in the meantime.” Nightmare pulled away quickly, taunting Luna with her eyes. “Unless you’re too tired...”

The small pony quickly rushed towards her master, eager for more of the black pony. As the two resumed kissing and other fun, Celestia turned her attention to the levitating Twilight. The spell that had been reinforced by Nightmare still dominated most the the Princess’s mind, but seeing and interacting with her student had a way of loosening the effects. Celestia was not free, but she was in control of enough of her mind to know that things would end badly -for herself and Twilight- if Moony... Nightmare... was allowed to stay in control.

The white pony placed the comatose unicorn on her back, and in her moment of resistance felt shame. Shame for letting herself be used by Nightmare. Shame for letting herself use Twilight, her faithful student, her only true friend for the past years. Shame for knowing that there was nothing she could do to keep herself from using and being used by Nightmare. Celestia knew there was no way Twilight would ever forgive her teacher for tonight, even if the unicorn knew that Nightmare was making her do these things.

But was she really? Was Nightmare the one making Celestia do these things to her student? Did Moony take Twilight’s virginity, or did Celestia? Or did Celestia really want to do these things? Who cared? Celestia relaxed. What did it matter? As long as Twilight enjoyed it, and Twilight wanted it, it was okay.

“Besides, Celestia, you have not really taken her virginity yet.” Nightmare began as she appeared in the Princess’s field of vision, a seductive, yet somehow comforting, look on her black face. “All you did was make her feel good. But I know something.” Nightmare circled the white pony, using her starry tail to cradle the Princess’s head. The cool, intoxicating scent calmed Celestia’s mind and body, allowing the spell to take over once more. “I know that Twilight would want you to take it.”

Celestia smiled. Of course Moony was right. How could she be wrong? “I know she would want you to be the one to take her, instead of one of us. Couldn't you see it in her eyes?”

The tail fell away from the alicorn’s face as she looked back at her student. Moony was right; Twilight had loved the feelings Celestia brought to her. Her current expression, her screams and the burning desire in her eye was evidence of that.

The Princess smiled as her new mission took shape in her mind. She would not rest, she would not stop until Twilight had experienced all of the pleasure three alicorns could give her.

Nightmare smiled. This day was perfect.