Horror of Ponyville

by Loganstrang

Rating: teen
Tags: Tragedy, Crossover, Sad, Dark
Length: 1943

Twilight and her friends move into the Amityville house but it's reported as a haunted home.

A year after Ronald Defeo Jr killed his family, Twilight and her friends move into the Amityville house. But while living there, strange events are happening at the house. Will they ever survive or be scared to death?

Published 1970-01-01 00:00:00 UTC
Last updated 2013-09-06 03:50:02 UTC

Moving In

December 1975

Same location

Twilight was taking her friends around to find a perfect home for all of them to stay in. So far, they only looked at a two story house and a one story home with a attic. When they came upon the Amityville house and thought to themselves if they should buy the house. "Well guys, do you think we should buy this house?" asked Twilight.

"Well, it is a nice house, Twilight," said Spike.

"I say it looks divine, darling," said Rarity.

So after taking answers from her friends, Twilight tells the pony dealer that they'll buy the house. So, they went top their old homes and packed up and moved into the house.

"Whoa, this is a nice home, Twilight," said Applejack's sister Applebloom.

"Thanks for letting us move in," said Rarity's sister Sweetie Belle.

"This will be a action packed house of fun," said Scootaloo.

Soon everypony went around the house to find a room to sleep in. So, Scootaloo and Rainbow Dash chose the second story twin bedroom. Twilight and Spike took the master bedroom. Rarity and Sweetie Belle chose the second bedroom on the same floor. Pinkie Pie chose the third bedroom on the still the same floor. Applejack, Big Mac, and Applebloom chose the third floor bedroom. But Fluttershy decided to sleep in the second bedroom on the same floor.

"I'm sure that this house will be just fine," said Twilight, "it's perfect for us."

"Yeah, I hope so, Twilight," replied Spike.

"Boy howdy, this will be a rooting tooting house for us," said Applejack.

"Yep," said Big Mac.

As they were getting settled, they put all their belongings into their rooms and hoped that they will handle the history of the house including the murders of the Defeos. They may have heard that the house could be haunted but they know that they will not be scared and not leave the house until they feel like that they want to leave. "I know that we'll be fine," said Twilight.

"Yeah Twilight, this home will be just fine like you said," replied Spike.

But what Twilight and her friend don't know is that their house of excitement may become a haunted house of terror.

First hauntings

The next morning, Twilight and her friends were outside playing horseshoes and having races. But while they were playing, Fluttershy was hearing a noise of someone or something was choking. She walked over to the left side of the house and saw Angel was hanging on the side of the fence on a branch, choking to death. "Twilight, Twilight!" shouted Fluttershy.

"Fluttershy, whats wrong?" asked Twilight.

"Angel is choking on the fence," said Fluttershy, "come quick."

So, they walked over the fence and saw Angel's face was bright blue from his choking.

Soon, Twilight uses her magic and removes Angel from the branch, causing Angel to breath normally again. "That's strange, Angel never jumped on a branch and choked before," said Fluttershy. Everyone agreed to Fluttershy but they kept their cool for the strange incident. Later that afternoon, Applebloom and Sweetie Belle went downstairs into the basement and found an secret room shelved out. They were so shocked to see that the room had blood red painted walls and know that it was not in the blueprints of the house. They called it as " The Red Room." The two fillies ran upstairs with fear and told everypony about what they saw in the basement.

Late that night, Twilight woke up a 3:15 in the morning, feeling so sleepless and heard noises downstairs. Her friends woke up and saw Twilight was up early. They know that Twilight never wakes up early in the morning. "Twilight, what are you doing up so early?" asked Applebloom.

"I don't know, Applebloom," replied Twilight, "I'm always normally asleep but I don't know why I'm so sleepless."

"Twilight darling, what are you doing up so late?" asked Rarity.

"Twilight feels sleepless and she can't sleep," replied Applebloom.

Soon, Applebloom and Rarity try some opinions to help Twilight sleep. They tried warm milk, a sleeping song, and a sleeping drink but Twilight still wouldn't sleep till the next morning.

When morning came, Twilight and Rarity were in the final second floor bedroom that they used as a sewing room. Rarity then felt someone who was woman touch her back. "Twilight, something just touched my back," said Rarity.

"I didn't touch you. Nopony was there." said Twilight.

Then when Applejack went upstairs to the third floor, she heard and saw huge swarms of houseflies in the sewing room. "That's strange. There are flies in here but it's mid winter," said Applejack. Then, she walked downstairs and told everypony what happened in the sewing room. Soon, they all know that something strange is  going on.

Final night and aftermath

Late that night, Twilight and her friends decided to go to bed because of their scare day at the house. As they were all sleeping, Twilight heard screaming and yelling all over the house. She woke up in terror and went into the hallway and laid flat on the ground and covered her ears from the screaming. The screams were so loud that it woke up all of Twilight's friends. "Twilight, what's going on?" asked Pinkie Pie.

"I'm not sure but just ignore it and it'll go away," replied Twilight.

Twilight's friends tried to ignore the sounds but the screams got louder and louder that they were all getting spooked really bad. "This is one spooking house we choose after all," said Twilight.

"Yeah, this house is scaring all of us,darling," said Rarity.

"We have to get outta of here," said Applebloom. Twilight and her friend went to very window and door but keeping finding all of them were locked. "What are we going to do?" asked Sweetie Belle.

"We need to leave the house, NOW!" said Spike.

But, Rainbow Dash put up her hooves and demanded a fight with the ghosts that were haunting them. But a angry voice shouted, "GET OUT OF HERE!!" The ponies were so scared that they know that they have to get out of the house. Twilight went to the back door and broke open the door and went to the boat house with her friends following her. Rainbow Dash kicks the door open and said "Whoa, nice boat but now. LET GET OUTTA OF HERE!!" Twilight noticed that keys were in the ignition.

Soon, Twilight used her magic and turned the key, causing the boat to turn on. Twilight and her friends finally take off on the boat with her one of her friend, looked at the house. "Don't look at the house and lets get going," said Twilight. After Twilight and her friends escaped the house, they all stayed at a hotel for the night. The next morning, a mover collected their belongings and gave them back to the ponies but he reported no hauntings when he was inside. Twilight and her friend move back into their old homes and the Amityville house was put up for sale but nopony bought the house.

Death of the Defeos

November 13, 1974

Ponyville, Equestria

23 year old Ronald Defeo Jr was at the Henry's bar, having a drink of wine before heading back home to his house. He returned home with his dad 43 year old Ronald Defeo Sr, looking very disappointed at him. "You should have told me or your mother where you have been," said his father.

"Dad, you need to stop asking me where I'm going," said Ronald Jr, "I was only at the bar but it's not a problem."

Ronald Jr's mother 42 year old Louise Defeo told her husband, "Honey, you need to cool your rage and angry with our son."

"You should have never helped with our son and I don't want another word," said the father.

Later that afternoon, 18 year old Dawn Defeo was returning home from high school with her boyfriend in her car. When she got home, she and her boyfriend saw her 23 year old brother and her father fighting and arguing at each other. Dawn went to the living room and sat next to her boyfriend. During the argument with Ronald Jr and Sr, Ronald Defeo Jr's father said to him, "Don't you talk to me like that again." After his father punched him, Ronald left the home and went his friend's house. Then Ronald Sr was talking in rage with Louise before he begins to punch her.

Late that night, Ronald Defeo Jr went back into the house and went to his room and grabbed his Marlin Model 336 rifle from his room and walked to the master bedroom. Then, he loaded the gun and shot his father two times and his mother two times. Then, he walked upstairs to the second and went to the twin bedroom and shot his two brothers, 12 year old Marc and 9 year old John Matthew. Then, he walked to the room next door and shot his sister, 13 year old Allison. Then, finally walked upstairs to the third floor bedroom and shot his other sister.

After killing his family that night, the guards and police arrive and removed the dead bodies from the house and took them to a nearest cemetery. When morning arose, the police arrested Ronald Defeo Jr and took him to his neighbor's house that they were using as a headquarters.Then, they began questioning Ronald if he committed the crime of killing his family in the house. After hours of questioning, Ronald convinced that he killed his family and was sentenced to 25 years to life in prison.

Scared ponies

Soon, Twilight and her friends were really getting confused about what was going on with their home. "Man, something strange is going on," said Rainbow Dash, "First, Fluttershy's bunny almost choked. Then, Twilight's sleeplessness. Then the fillies discovery in the basement, and the plaque of flies in the rooms."

"Yep," aid Big Mac, "More things may go strange around these parts."

"Big Mac is right. There can't be anything else that can go wrong," said Applebloom.

That afternoon when Fluttershy and Angel were making lunch, she heard doors banging, windows sliding up and down, and locks clicking locked and unlocked. She and Angel were so terrified that they made lunch quickly and took it to their friends.

During the day, Twilight has been seeing strange things happening to her friends. She first her friend sometimes were snapping at each other. Then she heard Applebloom, Sweetie Belle, and Scootaloo saying bad words. She also noticed that she got into arguments with her friends. "Man, things are going on here," said Twilight, "but it can't be worse."

"You're right, Twilight," said Applejack, "Things is going with ya'll."

That evening, Applejack, Rarity, and Rainbow Dash heard Applebloom, Sweetie Belle, and Scootaloo were in the attic, talking to someone that isn't there.

"Howdy girls, who ya'll talking to?" asked Applejack.

"A friend of ours," said Applebloom.

"Oh darlings, who is this pony you are talking about," asked Rarity.

"Her name is Jodie," replied Scootaloo, "and she's a human"

"Really girls, whoa,' said Rainbow Dash.

Rarity looked at a paper that Applebloom had in her mouth and said, "Is this Jodie."

"No, that's not Jodie," said Scootaloo.

They asked the fillies what the picture is. But when the fillies said what it is, the ponies told them that they're not allowed to say the word they said. Soon, the ponies turned and saw nopony in the chair and told them to go downstairs and have lunch.