More Than Meets the Eye

by Bina sow

Rating: mature
Tags: Tragedy, Adventure, Pinkie Pie, Sad, Main 6, Gore, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Dark, Pie Sisters, Other, Romance
Length: 2646

Pinkie's truth revealed and how she ended up with the cakes.

"So Pinkie, what did happen to your parents and sibilings?" Twilight questioned in a low whisper to keep the information from being leaked out to the others around them.
"My parents? Oh, well they are somewhere I can't live in. It's too hot. Ewww, and stinky. Not to mention too sour and sad, I got in trouble a lot for trying to throw a very special very happy party." Pinkie Pie said with a giggle. Just what did the pink mare mean by too hot, sour, and sad, was not easily caught by the all around inteligent pony. One thing is for sure though.

She didn't like the nonchalant way she had said it.

This story is planned to only retell the story of what happened after the Sonic Rainboom and why her family is not with her anymore. This is merely a fic and should not be taken seriously. Seriously, this is not headcannon material.
Rated M for a future climax.
Picture belongs to horse2rainbow77 on deviantart

Published 2014-02-05 19:30:06 UTC
Last updated 2014-02-05 19:30:06 UTC

Chapter 1 : Stepford Smiler

Shadows covered the rotting walls as they scurried on through passing to and from, no sound emitting from them leaving the room to its silence. When could it have been the last time she heard a voice? A week? A month? More? The only thing to remind the pink maned disaster of time passing would be the occasional moments when she would pass out of exhaustion. She had no contact with the outside world, no contact with anyone, no self-gratification in making someone smile. When the food did come, on the times she was awake for its delivery, she would bellow out a salutation to the fellow hoping he or she would hear through the padded locked door. He or she must not hear well, for he or she never answers. Despite that she still tried on.

Pinkamena Diane Pie was her name, and she had not always been in this situation. Long before this torturous time, she had been in an even more torturous life that consisted of going to her elementary school, coming home, work in her mother’s garden, eat, then sleep. Nothing new ever happened, and Pinkamena never tried to correct the norm. It was all on repeat. That is, until after a light rain painted the sky with the brightest of rainbows. That day was the one day the little mare smiled. Though as fast and unexpected as it came, it soon left everyone’s memories; so much so that no one remembered of it afterward. Like it never existed.

The pain of knowing that there is something out there that can make her smile began to stab at her. How could she reach it with her life on repeat? She had to make her own life worth it. But how can she when she doesn’t even know what was that that made her smile.

That was all in the past though, her parents didn’t understand the new and hyperactive Pinkamena and dubbed her insane. She brightened her mane to a lighter pink styling it up, and slapped on a smile that intimidated the gloomy town. With this change and newfound happiness, came the price of living in denial in which wouldn’t allow her to face the truth that her parents abandoned her. “I’m sure momma will be here to pick me up, and we will have great parties and play games and-“ she would blabber on with no pause until she is out of breath.

Eventually her words would no longer hold hope, and she was left behind a wall that would allow words escape her withholding any emotion behind them.

Once more she was in a cycle put on repeat.

As if the world grew tired of watching her from behind closed door, she was soon graced with access to another being. The door that allowed food in, swung open. "Hello, my name is Ärztin and I have been watching you for some time." The white mare with a tied back pure white mane said resting her ruby red eyes on a clipboard she suspended in midair with her unicorn magic.

"Hertsin? That's a weird name, what does it mean? Does it-" she wanted to take advantage of finally seeing someone other than the empty void of nothing, though her lungs would not allow her to. So she began to cough up air as if she choked on it. All the while the white mare with the sophisticated name ignored her coughing fit, never laying her gaze on the other.

"Ja, it specifically means female doctor." she said after hearing Pinkie's coughing subside.

"Why are you here? I'm not sick, is mommy sick? Did daddy finally kick the can? What does kick the can mean? And why did mommy say he was going to kick the can sooner or later? What did the poor can ever do to-" once more Pinkie found herself interrupted, this time by Ärztin. With a raise of her hoof, she finally allowed her eyes to trail to Pinkie's eyes.

"I am not here for blabber; I am only here to break the news that, despite your hyperactive personality and odd reaction towards an insanity inducing situation, you are titled not mentally insane and are allowed out a freemare." The cold words echoed through the small room and dug into the pink one's ears, excavating into her brain to allow them to be properly processed.

"Th-they thought I was insane..." Pinkamena said her eyes showing disbelief as she finally allowing the words reach her mind.

"Yes, that is why you are here."

"They a-abandoned me here?" she continued, tears swelling in her eyes.

"I wouldn't say abandoned, more of allowed you to stay under the care of well-trained doctors. They thought you were sick, and worried for you." Despite the poor choice of words, Ärztin was given a smile in response.

"Yea... Mommy and daddy worried for me... thank you Hertsin." she said nodding, getting on her hooves she trotted slowly to the other.

"Ärztin(ær-tzin)...." she corrected but Pinkamena never noticed. The pink mare’s thoughts circled on the fact that she had been abandoned by her family in this horrible place. Just because she smiled. Just because she choose to do something diffirent. To break the sorrowful cycle.

With a sigh the nurse handed Pinkamena a box, “you seem to react well with music. It has often cheered you more than we thought was your limit. I expect you to take this along to be well,” she said allowing herself the privilege to smile faintly for once. Pinkamena, already smiling, bounced with glee taking the box and instantly opening it. At the second it was fully open a pony doll bounced up from its hiding and danced in a twirl silhouetted by streamers that, despite the still doll, flowed and twirled with the movement of the doll; a song playing lightly holding no words. “I call this piece No Fear; a friend had bought it for me to give to my child; if and when I ever do decide to have my own filly, which I won’t. You, in honesty, have been the closest to a child I have ever received. Your case was just too much for me not to find you so intriguing.”

“Did you make a song for it?” Pinkamena smiled leaving the box opened, mesmerized by the little doll’s dance.

“I did not”

“It sounds nice, and she looks so happy. Like she is laughing, No fear, huh?”

“Ja, because of the upbeat tempo and smiling doll, almost like she is laughing at whatever may cause fear.”

“Giggling at the ghosties!” she pepped up at the words Ärztin had given. With a nod of her head she turned back to the hall that could lead to freedom.

“We must leave now, before lockdown night watch.” She began out believing that the mare would follow, which she did. “Lockdown night watch is basically what it sounds like, this hospital had employed tough security for the night shift so no danger could come to both the doctors employed for night shift or full day shifts or the patients.” She said after a brief pause knowing that silence from the pink mare means she is in a state of confusion.

“Have you ever had the night shift?” Pinkamena asked the guiding doctor, stuck in awe at the new information. She was never let out of her cell, and so didn’t know the hospital ever changed.

“They couldn’t pay me enough to, I actually do have a life outside these steel doors you know.” Ärztin said almost immediately after hearing the question. “I was almost caught into nightshift when I didn’t hurry out of here, but a friend who works the shift allowed me to leave.” As they turned the corner, the world around them began to grow brighter; with each step that passed the scent of the world that once shut her out, enveloped Pinkamena.

“It’s so bright outside,” exclaimed Pinkamena as she raised her eyes to meet the wide open door letting in the welcoming world.
“Not as much as yesterday, it is summer after all.”

“Look a bird!” she unintentionally ignored the other, still in awe of the outside's beauty. Upon reaching the doorway, the tiny mare stopped dead in her tracks, shaking as her eyes grew wide.

“Is there something wrong miss Pie?” Ärztin had questioned the other as she turned to see her still inside. The reaction was a bit odd as most of her patients allowed freedom, literally jump out the doors.

“No, I just want to savor this moment” She took two steps back and jumped out landing near the albino and startled her.
“Wha-?! Oh, you had frightened me!” she said holding up with her magic a bottle she instinctively pulled out.

“Goodbye then Hertsin! I won’t forget you!” Pinkamena hopped by her never noticing the white mare’s reaction. After a few trots she stopped and turned her head to question, “Why don’t you want to have a filly of your own?”

“I,” she began surprised at the other’s inquiries, “A child is, by nature, dependent on it's caretaker... and I never believed I’d ever become a good mother after seeing so many make mistakes with their own. Why does it matter?” Pinkamena smiled brightly and turned back to the direction she planned on taking.

“You’d make a perfect mom, I would know!”

Author's Note

I know I have another story going on, but this one kept stabbing me asking me to start it. I wrote like the first paragraph and instantly fell in love. Gah, why do I have such a short attention span.

I know I'm milking the scene with the doctor, but she is finally gone. Now comes Ponyville!
The title is based on the personality disorder that renders the victim in a state of hunger for attention and leads them to often have radical emotions often rage or bliss. The name Pinkamena will be used instead of her alternate nickname for a good reason, just look closely.

Chapter 2: The point in time

The Point in Time

The summer sun has proven to be quite a hassle as the moments passed. Pinkamena had only walked for two days, and already she had grown tired of trotting. Since she never knew where she was in the first place, finding her hometown was practically improbable. She finally decided to rest in a town that seemed to be disconnected. Everypony with their groups; earth ponies in the south of the town, unicorns in the north east of the town facing the mountains, and the pegasi in what little left, the center to be left for all to mingle, buy, or gather for meetings. She had gathered from what she saw in the mountain, that this was the once famed town of Ponyville; acclaimed for their multi-cultured roots and interactions with the regal Canterlot. It was nicknamed the little sister of Canterlot.

She walked around in the center of town before finally coming into contact with somepony.

“Howdy, y’all ok there?” a booming voice called from behind Pinkamena startling her half to death. Pinkamena turned to see if it was said to her, and to her delight it was.

“Yup, just looking around.” She replied growing giddy from the exchange of words, aside from Ärztin, she hadn’t spoken to anyone in a long while.

“You don’t look like a local, are you new here?” she said approaching her, in that movement the pink mare noticed a little filly that shared some features.

“Yea, I just got here. I got lost on my way back to my hometown.” She watched as the filly trotted over holding out a hoof.

“I’m Apple Bloom, and this is my sister Applejack!” Apple Bloom began before the elder of the two could. She was given a subtle look in response by the other before she allowed herself to speak on behalf.

“Pleased to meet you-“ she allowed herself to stretch her words a bit hoping the pink mare would complete her statement.

“Pinkamena Diane Pie,” she quickly put in, “and nice to meet you too Applejack and Applebloom.” She reached out her hoof and was quickly shaken by the other’s fierce shake that, despite it, felt like an approval rather than hurtful.

“You seem thin, why don’t ya come ‘round my home and eat,” Applejack said in a motherly tone. Of course, before Pinkamena could decline, her stomach jumped at the chance to make it known that she indeed was hungry. She nodded rather embarrassed for herself. “Good, we live further down south there,” she pointed with her hoof, “you’ll see it. It is a nice farm with a garland of apple trees. I’d take ya myself, but I have to take Apple Bloom here to her first day of class, and pick up a couple of things.” Pinkamena listened closely, nodding after every word. “Got it?” Applejack had asked wondering if the ditzy pony did get it.

“Got it, you live down south,” she pointed to the same direction Applejack had pointed, “it is a nice farm with lots of trees with apples. You need to take Apple Bloom to her school and-“

“We’re gonna be late Applejack.” The young filly whined to her elder sister. Applejack looked at her then at Pinkamena, biting her lip still worried for the other.

“All right, hold your hay. Here, in case you get hungry on your way.” She handed Pinkamena ten bits and was pulled along by Apple Bloom. “Alright see you later.” She called out before turning to give her sister attention.

Pinkamena watched them leave until they were out of sight before she turned to find something to eat. She trotted about looking. She noticed how distant everypony was towards each other. She would find some unicorns talking to pegasi and ect, but it wasn’t very often. They interacted then left.

Pinkamena didn’t like it, but what could she do?

That’s when she noticed some mare talking to another mare; they were both pegasi and looked different in both looks and how they display their personality through their stance and conversation. Nothing in particular could have caught anypony else’s attention, though one thing did for Pinkamena. The rainbow mane. The same pattern she remembers seeing in the rainbow in the sky. ‘It couldn’t have been a coincidence, right?’ She told herself as she approached the two.

“Hey!” Pinkamena said with a giant grin, almost pouncing to their side. The impression didn’t sit well with the other two and quickly their reactions were less than pleasing. The pink and yellow pegasis jumped behind the rainbow maned pony, who in turn took a defensive stance after letting out a surprised scream. “Oh, sorry. Just wanted to say hi.”

“Some way,” the rainbow maned pony said rolling her ruby eyes. “Flutter-“ she looked behind her, only to realize the shy pony had ran off after jumping behind her, “shy… Great, you scared her off.” She began turning back to the pink pony. Pinkamena lowered her head a bit drooping her eyes a bit as she showed to the other she was sorry.

“Wha- no no, don’t cry. Look, let’s just find her and fix this. She is always like that, don’t take it to heart.” The rainbow pony said trying to correct herself, feeling bad for making her sad.

“Really?”

“Yea, c’mon.” She said starting to walk.

“I’m Pinkamena by the way, Pinkamena Diane Pie.” She introduced herself skipping alongside the other.

“And I’m Rainbowdash, the fastest pegasis in all of equestria,” she said rather proudly. “Pinkamena huh; sounds a bit complicated, how about just Pinkie. Pinkie Pie.” She said with a sort of candid attitude that made Pinkamena wonder if she was always like this.