Just a day in the mind of a psyscopath

by Pinkamina vs Butchershy

Rating: teen
Tags: Dark
Length: 2905

What happens when Pinkie Pie and Fluttershy are behind closed doors may shock and disturb you. Be wary as this is probably not for the faint of heart.

Pinkie Pie has been working with Fluttershy in the murder business for years completely undetected until one day when Rainbow Dash follows them being nosy and finds their shed of horrors and is captured. Then the others look for their missing friend but do they have what it takes to survive the nightmare they find them selves in when they find and free her? Only time will tell as since Twilight and Rarity's horns have been cut which means no magic can help them now.

Published 1970-01-01 00:00:00 UTC
Last updated 2013-10-26 19:15:00 UTC

A strange discovery

"Yet another beautiful day in Equestria." Said Twilight sparkle as she walked down the path to her home in Pony Ville, when suddenly she heard a scream as Rainbow Dash crashed beside her. She slowly walked towards the motionless pegasus then in a worried tone she said "Rainbow Dash are you alright?"

The blue filly's eyes shot open and she said "I'm fine, just another trick gone wrong that's all" She said as she stood up and dusted her mane off.

Twilight said "Okay then be more careful next time you almost hit me!"

Rainbow Dash replied in a very light tone "I almost forgot Applejack and the others are at the barn waiting for us."

Twilight replied with a nod as she said "Okay I just need to tell spike I'll be back late tonight" With that the two split ways.

(Twenty minuets later at Sweet Apple Acres) Every pony had arrived except Fluttershy and Pinkie. "Where those two ponies?" Said Applejack impatiently.

"I'm sure they'll be here any minute darling." Replied rarity in her mellow tone.

"Ah know, and I expected as much from Pinkie Pie but its so unlike Fluttershy to be so late, in fact this is the only the second time I can recall her being late for any thing at all let alone a get together at mah place. Maybe we should go look for them." She said with worry in her voice.

Before Rarity could say anything they saw a bouncing pink blur of a pony and a yellow slow flying pegasus.

Applejack looked at rarity and saw her staring back with a smug look that had told you so written all over it. She huffed and said "What took yall so long?!!!"

They exchanged a look and Fluttershy said with a distant look in her eyes and a unusually scary smile "Sorry we had to finish some business back at my place before we got here."

Pinkie giggled and said in a strangely deep voice "Yah we had to tie up some loose ends.

"So what's up guys why are we here?" Rainbow Dash asked no one in particular.

"Lots of ponies have gone missing from different places, which usually wouldn't catch mah eye except the last place there usually is here in Pony Ville then poof there gone without a trace. And I mahself saw some of these ponies before they disappeared."  Applejack answered her in a serious tone

Twilight cut her off and said "Some of them were last seen around the Everfree Forest by just out of Fluttershy's cottage range of view."

Fluttershy looked down and said the usual "O my."  but in her mind she was thinking quite differently. "Those girls are to smart for their own good. If one of them goes snooping to deep they might find our base of operations! I guess I'll have to convince Pinkie to take it easy for a while. I just hope she'll understand the seriousness of this situation."

The moon was starting to rise so the group split ways for the night except pinkie and flutter shy who went to the cottage, they had to find a way to keep the girls from finding out about their private parties and what went on during them.

"Okay we have to think of something or we'll have to kill the others which would cause suspicion from the princess and other ponies."  Said Fluttershy calmly.

It always pissed Pinkie off when she was so calm in situations like this. "How in the flying fuck do you suppose we do that huh? I mean its not like four random ponies are making a connection here! Seriously its our four closest friends! I myself would have no trouble killing them but like you said it would cause too much suspicion. I mean really what are we suppose to do Butchershy?

She smiled at the fact she had used her code name and said "We'll figure something out Pinkamina, we'll have to.

The next day Rainbow Dash decided to investigate on her own. he had flown around the Everfree Forest a few times calling out for anypony who might have gotten lost within the unnatural forest.

To make matters worse she couldn't see past the thick leaves and branches of the tall trees. Then she Heard Fluttershy's and Pinkie's voices coming from the forest floor.

She could not see them and was about to callout to them when she heard pinkie say "So Fluttershy what are we going to do to keep the others from finding out were the reason ponies are disappearing?"

"I don't know Pinkie, I guess we don't do anything its not like they'll find out that were killing them any way and besides they would never find our little base of operations. Not to mention If they did they would never get out alive." Said Fluttershy with a certain coldness in her voice.

Rainbow dashes head swam after hearing this.

They Couldn't have killed those ponies could they I mean they have been acting strange lately but Fluttershy is so sweet and loving, and Pinkie Pie is so happy and kind hearted could they be Changelings or some other form of shape shifter?

"Only one way to find out." she decided. she slipped past the branches without a sound and landed on the forest floor.

She then proceeded to follow their voice until she saw them stopped in front of a fairly small looking shed.

"So are you ready for todays victims Pinkamina?"

"As I'll ever be Butchershy."

"They call them selves different names here?" Rainbow Dash thought aloud and gasped at her mistake.

"That wad Rainbow's voice!" exclaimed Pinkamina. She then pointed to the tree where she could see the red of her rainbow main sticking out.

Butchershy nodded and silently picked up a shovel then said "Don't be afraid Dashie we just want to talk about what you just heard." She snuck up beside the tree and yelled while swinging the shovel "Nighty night Rainbow!"

The last thing Rainbow dash saw was the look on Fluttershy's or rather Butchershy's face. It could only be described as the look of pure evil.

The horrifying secret is out

It was another sunny day as Twilight was walking to Applejacks farm. she had not seen anyone but Rarity and was getting worried about the others.

Not to mention that dream she had disturbed her greatly.

She and the others were running down a hall from Pinkie And Fluttershy except their names and manes were different.

Instead of Pinkie Pie It was Pinkamina.

And instead of Fluttershy It was Butchershy.

Pinkamina's mane was straight instead of fluffy and a darker shade of pink that looked it had a greyish tint to it.

And Butcher shy had a long scar down her stomach and her over her eye. Her mane was cut short and also had that greyish tint to it.

Pinkamina was wielding a short axe but not quite a hatchet. It was double bladed with a strange diamond like image in the center.

Butchershy was wielding a cleaver with the same emblem in the center and a cloth on the handle. But the strangest thing is she called it Barry.

We continued down the hallway until a trap door opened sending everypony down onto the spikes below.

I shuddered at the memory of the dream and continued on to my destination Sweet Apple Acres.

When I arrived applejack was in a frenzy pacing quickly in circles.

When she saw me she stopped and threw her arms around me and said with tears in her eyes "Have you seen Rainbow Dash, Fluttershy, or Pinkie Pie sugar cube?"

"No, why do you ask?" I said with genuine worry in my voice.

"Well nopony has seen them in two days, and I think whatever got them other ponies might have got them too!" Applejack said with pure fear in her voice for her lost friends.

Twilight thought about this for a moment. Okay whatever this is apparently does not limit their self to out of town ponies like we originally thought.

"Maybe we could set up a search a party of me you and Rarity." Twilight said as she considered the supplies they would need.

"Ah don't know Twi, I mean we I know can't leave them out there but what if whatever this thing is gets us too. Then who would save us?" Applejack said logically.

"It's just a chance we'll have to take I guess. They would do the same for us." Twilight  replied with little enthusiasm in her voice.

"Ah suppose your right Twilight. They would do the same for us and we need to be there for them no matter what the cost or danger is!" Applejack said with much more enthusiasm in her voice than Twilight had expected.

"It's settled then, lets go get Rarity on board for this little rescue mission then we leave at day break." Said Twilight as she and Applejack trotted off for Rarity's house.

Upon arriving at the carousel boutique the girls saw Rarity sitting on a quilt starring up into the clouds.

Applejack yelled to her  "Rarity get up and listen to us we need your help!"

Rarity turned and saw them and replied "Help with what darling?"

"Well you see apparently Pinkie Pie, Rainbow Dash, And Fluttershy have gone missing and we need your help to find them. Are you in for a little exploring in the Everfree Forest?" Twilight replied with little hope that the fashionista pony would actually want to go into such a forbidding and dirty place such as the Everfree forest.

But to her surprise she replied "Of course I will help you look for them! After all they are our best friends and I just simply  wouldn't know what I would do if they suddenly were gone forever!"

The excitement in her voice made Twilight take a step back as if Rarity was going to attack her.

"Alright then it's completely settled we will leave for the forest at day break!" Twilight exclaimed with her fear of the forest hidden from her voice.

The next day just as planned they left at the as first ray of sunlight broke over the side of the hill and hit the little town of Pony Ville.

Upon arriving the trio discussed their plan for when and if they do get separated or caught.

Alright girls I don't know what's out there and I want this to be a clean rescue if at all possible. So if we get separated I need to know where your location is, to put it simply I'm going to cast a tracking spell on you, and rarity you need to do the same to us also.

Rarity nodded As her and twilight's horn began to glow brightly.

Afterwards Applejack said while wobbling a bit "I feel kinda funny."

"Well seeing how as you just had two spells cast on you at once I'm surprised your still standing." Twilight said with a small amount of amount of amazement at her friend's strength.

"Well lets get on with this." said Rarity with a strange amount of confidence in her voice.

They entered the forest and walked about three miles before Twilight heard an extremely faint scream coming from a long distance away. She turned her head in the direction and exclaimed "Come on guys I heard a scream coming from this direction!"

They nodded and followed her off for another mile before arriving at a small looking shack. Twilight thought to herself, what in the name of Celestia is this doing so far out here?

Rarity said well lets go inside and find out what's going on.

Twilight and Applejack nodded and went in one at a time.

"It's just a normal shack full of old furniture!" Twilight groaned impatiently.

Rarity huffed and leaned against a board on the wall and suddenly the shack was filled with sleeping gas.

The last thing they saw was a spot on the floor open and two ponies in hazmat suits coming up on a small floor lift.

Applejack woke up tied to a wall in complete darkness and said "What the? How in the hay did I get here?!!!"

She suddenly heard the groans of her friends on the wall beside her when suddenly a light came on and an unknown but familiar voice said It's about time you guys woke up, I thought I was going to have to kill you in your sleep! But where would be the fun in that? HEHEHEHEHEHE

She suddenly realized who's voice that was when she giggled and stepped into the room. "PINKIE PIE IS THAT YOU!!!!!"

The pink mare stepped into view and said with an evil smile, "Well well well look who's not as stupid as they appear to be."

"What have you done with Fluttershy and Rainbow Dash?!" She demanded.

"Hey Applejack what's soaking wet and clueless?" Applejack's eyes widened at the sound of the voice, "Your face!" Fluttershy said as she stepped around the corner and threw a bucket of blood on her. She was extremely carful as to not get any on herself.

She came so close as to vomiting that she gaged at the fact another pony's blood was on her.

Pinkie smiled at the discomfort Applejack was feeling and said "Your going to make the best batch of cupcakes I've ever had."

Old murderers in a new city

As Pinkamina inched closer with a scalpel she stopped and said "O how silly of me, I almost forgot."

She Went into the back of the room and put on a suit that resembled a Wonderbolt costume, except it was solid black with no special design and there was no holes for wings muzzle or eyes. where there was supposed to be eye holes was fixed gogles.

"Wouldn't want to get any blood on me would I now?" She said with a hidden smile.

"I hope you know you'll never get away with this!" Said Twilight as she struggled to get free. "Dammit why isn't  my magic working! What have you done to me!" She spoke with more hatred than she ever had before.

"Oh, well you see, I knew that magic of yours and Rarity's would be a pesky problem so i cut them off." Pinkamina said smugly.

Twilight and Rarity's jaws hit the ground as she spoke. It would grow back in time but still thats the worst posible thing you could possibly do to a unicorn.

Then Rainbow Dash woke up and said "What happened, where am I?"

"O goodie you finaly woke up after a whole day of sleep." Butchershy said.

"Ow my back is killing me." Was her only reply.

"Naturally I mean once your wings get cut off your gona feel pain." Pinkamina replied coldly.

Dash's eyes grew wide as the heard the crazed pony speak.

Pinkamina picked up her scalpel and approached Twilight and said "You always did get on my fucking nerves!"

She yelled as the scalpel went into her abdomen and cut down her stomach spilling blood into a bucket below her. She then proceeded with opening her stomach and taking her organs out.

Apple jack couldn't take it, she vomited all over the floor and yelled "You sick little bitch if it's the last thing I do I'm going to get you and gut your ass! Then we'll see how you like it!"

Pinkamina paid her no mind as she continued to gut the poor pony.

With her dying breath Twilight said "I somehow knew you would be the cause of my death Pinkie. But I always thought it would be of a stress related heart attack."

With that she died. How Applejack knew she was gone is she saw her heart stop beating with her own eyes. This sent the apple bucker into a rage and she broke the ropes that bound her.

With a war cry she tackled Pinkamina and took her scalpel then drove it into her heart. With a smile she said "Told ya so."

Butchershy had disappeared so she set Rainbow Dash and Rarity free as they was preparing to leave the room Butchershy came back with her knife and said "I've got Barry now so now your dead!" she lunged on to Rainbow Dash and cut her throat wide open. Then she turned to Applejack who was already charging at her.

Applejack bucked her causing her to drop her knife "Barry" and fought her in hoof to hoof combat after a leg sweep and a hoof to the temple Butchershy was out cold. Applejack picked up the knife and suddenly a sword went through her back.

She dropped the knife and fell on her side and saw Rarity helping Butchershy up!

She said while gurgling blood "What the hell your one of them to Rarity!"

"Of course who do you think made that suit on Pinkamina and the special shampoo that takes the smell of blood away from their coats darling?" She said in a sarcastic tone.

"I fucking hate you both!" Applejack said as everything went black.

(Two months latter)

"Its a beautiful day in Manehatten don't you think Fluttershy?"

"Oh my yes its just the perfect weather to make a good old fashioned Pinkamina batch of cupcakes out of some pony." Said Fluttershy with an evil smirk.