It's Nightmare Night and what better way to celebrate it by telling dark stories by the campfire with the Lunar Goddess and an old friend of hers. Follow along with Spike and the elements as they listen to the new comer's Nightmare Tale.

Side Note: This is set a few months after the events of the Ponyville paint war, but it's not needed to read this story. Written for Nightmare Night.
I would like to thank Minette for the editing. Happy Nightmare Night!