This story will not completely follow the actual movie, just the same general idea.

When a boat carrying a class from Ponyville High is attacked by a two-headed shark, the students and Miss Cheerilee are forced to take shelter on a small island. But the shark is picking them off one by one, and a dangerous storm is threatening to sink their only safe place. With the ever present possibility of death, how long do they have until their will to survive crumbles?

WARNING: THIS STORY CONTAINS GRAPHIC GORE AND DESCRIPTIONS OF THE FEMALE BODY

Characters

Students: Rainbow Dash
Fluttershy
Applejack
Pinkie Pie
Rarity
Diamond Tiara
Silver Spoon
Choconator (OC)
Featherweight
Snips
Snails
Rumble
Truffle Shuffle
Atlas
Button Mash
Shady Daze

Teachers: Cheerilee
Big McIntosh

Ship Crew: Lyra Heartstrings
Zecora
Little Strongheart

Ships

Choconator X Rumble
Diamond Tiara X Silver Spoon

ALL CHARACTERS EXCEPT FOR 2 WILL BE KILLED. YOU HAVE BEEN WARNED.