Betraying For A Secret

by cheetahme9

Rating: everyone
Tags: Adventure
Length: 960

Fluttershy's super secret.

Fluttershy has a secret. She has a little sister named Butterfly. Butterfly is locked away from the rest of the world, because of what happened to their parents. If Butterfly shares the same fate….
Then Fluttershy's worst fear happens. Butterfly gets taken away, and the only way to get her back is to do something very very terrible.
She's going to have to kill the Elements of Harmony.

Published 1970-01-01 00:00:00 UTC
Last updated 2014-02-02 03:49:58 UTC

The Super Butterfly

  Fluttershy ran as fast she could. Her heart pounded until she slammed the door shut. Then Rainbow Dash spoke muffled, by the door slammed in her face. "Flutters, is something wrong?" Fluttershy didn't answer. "I'm going buck down the door if you don't open it. You know I will." Rainbow threatened. Fluttershy still didn't answer. Rainbow kick the door open BAM! But Dash found no one.

      Fluttershy tapped softly on the ground under her bed three times. "Password Required." The recording told her. "Butterfly" Fluttershy whispered. Suddenly, the ground disappeared and left Fluttershy tumbling down. Ouch! Then Fluttershy looked up to see a pink ponytailed filly above her. "Butterfly! Are you ok? Is everything all right? Are you hungry?" The questions came tumbling out of Fluttershy's mouth. "You silly filly, Fluttershy. Of course I'm alright." Butterfly's voice soothed her. She felt like relaxing. But then she remember what she was here for. "Wait! Butterfly! You know how you wanted Rainbow Dash to teach you flying? Well, I got Rainbow Dash on recording teaching some other fillies how to fly. She chased me home but whatever."Fluttershy showed Butterfly the recording. It was pretty awesome she had to admit. Butterfly's eyes glowed with glee. She got up, did exactly what the video said, and started flying! "I'm the Super Butterfly! Oh Fluttershy, you are the best sis ever!" Butterfly raced over for a hug. Fluttershy blushed.

        "Sorry but I have to leave now. Love ya, before the sunrise..." Fluttershy started. "After the sunset." Butterfly finished. They gave one more hug before Fluttershy flew up the exit. "Perfect, she's gone! Now I can plan my escape! Of course, it will only be for half a hour and then I'll come racing home, but I'm just so excited!" Butterfly brought out a check list. "Better triple check everything...I sound just like Twilight!"

The Escape

Was everything ready? She hoped so. The plan was so simple. Butterfly would sneak out at exactly 12:30, that's when Fluttershy went shopping. Then Butterfly would go out for a day just to show Fluttershy that she can make friends, and go outside, and do marvelous things. But her mind still wandered. Fluttershy had told Butterfly about Twilight, Rarity, and Pinkie Pie, and other incredible ponies. Fluttershy also told her about evil creatures such as Nightmare Moon, King Sombra, and Discord (who was good now). But what if Butterfly met a changeling? No, she can't think like that.

BOOP BOP BOOP BOP! It was time. Butterfly set out to meet this brand new world.

  Now that she was in Ponyville, Butterfly needed to make some friends. Three fillies were outside with some clay. "CUTIE MARK CRUSADERS CLAY MAKERS! YAY!" They shouted. Wow, they were noisy. But they would have to do. "Hello." Butterfly walked over to the fillies. They kept focusing on their clay. Butterfly tried again. "Hello." Again they ignored her. Butterfly sighed and went to leave, but then she heard whispering. "Welcome to the club!" A little earth filly walked over. The pegusas and the unicorn walked over. "Congrats!" On what? Butterfly wondered. "Wait what club?" Butterfly was very puzzled. "The Cutie Mark Crusaders, of course!" They shouted in unison. Uh-oh. Fluttershy told her about the three troublemakers. They must of noticed her blank flank. Well, it couldn't hurt to be in their silly filly club....right?

  A strange pony walked up to four fillies. The pony's face was clouded with mist, and Butterfly couldn't tell of it was a colt or mare. "Hello Cutie Mark Crusaders." It was a colt. "How do you know' us?" Apple Bloom, the earth pony asked. The colt didn't answer. "Come here." he commanded them. Suddenly, Butterfly felt helpless and frightened. This was unusual for her, she normally so brave and confident.

     Then with a flick of a hoof, the four fillies and the colt were gone.

Fillynapped

Fluttershy set her bunny, Angel down. "Did you like your tasty carrot cake?" Fluttershy said in her "cutesy wootsey animal voice". Angel crossed him arms and went to sleep. Fluttershy sighed. When am I going to get through with Angel? Oh well, she couldn't worry about Angel now. She had to give Butterfly her vanilla cupcake.

"Oh my Butterfly..." Fluttershy sang to Butterfly. There was no answer. "Oh my Butterfly..." Again no reply. "Butterfly?" Butterfly's high-pitched voice didn't speak. Oh no! What if Butterfly was found? What if she ran away? Wait, Butterfly could just be doing hide and seek, her favorite game. Fluttershy went to Butterfly's favorite hiding spot. "I found you-" Butterfly was not there. That caused Fluttershy to panic. She ran into town. Everybody was in Twilight's library. "Fluttershy? Was is wrong?" the princess asked. Everyone was staring and it caused Fluttershy to blush. "She's been Fillynapped!" She shouted. "Woah, hold your apples," Applejack said. "Who in Equestria is missing?" Fluttershy realized that she had not told her friends about Butterfly. "Ummm, Angel!"

      Fluttershy cursed herself. Angel was a he not a she. "Oh! There dear, Angel is!" Rarity pointed to Fluttershy's mane. There was Angel, all right. Looking a little confused, Twilight spoke. "Well, that problem was solved." But, oh, it was not. Yet Fluttershy still had to act like it. "Yep! Thanks!" She faked a smile a zoomed out. There on she looked everywhere. Every crook and nanny. But sadly, Butterfly was no where to be found.

     A little while later, there was a knock at Fluttershy's door. "Butterfly!!!!!" Fluttershy screamed happily. Her heart sung as she imagined Butterfly out there. "Who in tarnation?" The voice was obviously not Butterfly. Fluttershy's heart sank and broke to a million pieces. She opened the door to find Applejack. "Fluttershy," Applejack called. "Apple Bloom's missing!"