Can you love two mares?

by Carter410

Rating: teen
Tags: Anthro, Romance, Slice of Life
Length: 1671

You've been working at sweet apple achers for a few months and the two most athletic Mare's fight over you and they both want to be with you. What will he do?

Applejack and Rainbow dash fight over Cloud Caster a pegasus who has been working for Sweet apple achers but the problem is he likes them both. What does he do? Read to find out.

(Note: I may makemore chapters if I get some better feed back so for now its incomplete)

(suggestive tones and anthro ponies.)

Published 1970-01-01 00:00:00 UTC
Last updated 2013-11-20 14:50:02 UTC

The First chapter (edited)

Applejack POV.

Ah woke up as usual getting ready to work the day again and went down to eat breakfast with the others. Once ah got downstairs ah heard Granny Smith calling me.

"Applejack! Can you go and wake up your boyfriend, Cloud, for me." I blushed at that word 'boyfriend' that made my heart skip a beat, but quickly shook my head clear any farther thoughts on that word for time being.

I walked back up stairs to wake him up for Granny, of course, not for myself though I wouldn't mind being next to him again. Once I reached the door to his room I found it slightly open, and slowly peeked inside only to see him peacefully sleeping. I quietly went in closing the door behind me then made my way over to wake him up, but before ah could my thoughts focused on his sleeping form freezing me in my tracks. "His cute dark brown and deep red mane... his apple red fur, makes me just want to..." My breaths were beginning to quicken "and his muscles are even a little larger than my brothers. I wonder what it would feel like to them pressed against me." I quickly gasped at the thoughts that were springing forth and felt a rush of sadness come over me as I glanced at myself in the mirror. "Are they too small?" Ah thought as my gaze fell onto my breasts. "He never seems to notice me... so does he even have feelings for me or am I just not what he wants in a mare?

Cloud's POV.

I open my eyes from a slight jarring to see Applejack bent over with her hand on my shoulder. "Wake up sugarcube, we have work to do." I suddenly noticed that she was really close and her breasts were straight in line to my face giving me clear view of more than I should have from the top of her shirt. I felt my face heat up and turned over away from her, but she didn't question my action instead she only seemed to get closer as I felt her chest press against my back. I sat up causing her quickly jump back before we collided letting me have enough room to get out of bed. As I walked towards my closet I remembered that I was only wearing my boxers, and I could feel her eyes follow me so I decided to tease her just touch.

"Umm... you see something you like?" Her face turned red as tomato before she could turn away. Her silence clearly told me that she was completely embarrassed to be caught looking at me making smile as I got dressed. Once dressed I turned and found Applejack had already left so I made my way downstairs to see what work had to be done today. When I walked into the kitchen I saw Mac sitting at the table eating breakfast before he looked towards me and spoke.

"Hey Cloud come over have some apples." I gave a simple nod and grabbed an apple from the bowl on the table, then asked about work for today.

"So what do you need me to do today?" He just shook his head.

"You've been working so hard this past week. How about you take the day off." I smiled and nodded once more at him.

"Thanks Mac, I appreciate it. I haven't seen Rainbow for awhile." He responded with his trademark 'Eeyup' and after I finishing one more apple I decided to go see my 'awesome' friend Rainbow Dash. "Speaking of which... what's she doing?"

Rainbow dash's POV.

I slid out of bed wiping the sleep out of my eyes and walked towards the bathroom to brushed my mane grabbing my morning workout clothes from the dresser along the way. Quickly getting dressed and finishing up with straightening up my mane nothing too fancy because flying fast does the job for styling my mane. I decided today would be perfect for working on some awesome tricks, but I wondered if my best friend Cloud Caster would want to have a race instead. Making my down to the living room my mind began to wonder towards him. "I haven't talked to him in a few days. Maybe I should go see him, I could even ask for a race against him!" I start to feel my heart beating faster. "When we hang out his smile makes my heart skip a beat and sometimes I even think he looks at my breasts... even though their small." I frown slowly at the thought. "I wished they were bigger. I wondered if he liked big boo..." Before I could finish my thought I hear a voice call out to me. "Hey Rainbow are you home?" Cloud's voice alone makes me a very happy mare. "I was wondering if you wanted to hang out today?" I jumped up and down squealed in happiness like a little filly on Heart's and Hooves Day.

I was overjoyed and I quickly shouted "Yes!" before I realized that I was shaking with nervousness and excitement. It was hard to admit to anyone else, but I had a huge crush on him and I wanted to know if he felt the same way so badly though I couldn't bring myself to do it before or even now. "Maybe I'll tell him later." I thought to myself. "I've been hiding my feelings for so long... a few more days can't hurt right?"

Cloud POV.

I watch the door open and Rainbow was standing there smiling happily at me. "Hey Cloud! I wouldn't mind hanging out with you." I smiled back at her and simply nodded. I am not much of a talker and Applejack says I reminder her of Mac in that way. "So Cloud what do ya wanna do?" I thought for a moment on what Rainbow would want to do... Of course, a race.

"How about a race?" A grin spread across her face as she nodded excitedly in agreement. Now I wasn't a very fast flyer, but like her I loved a challenge.

At Sweet Apple Acres, Applejack POV.

Ah couldn't find Cloud anywhere so ah decided to see if Big Mac knew were he was and as I expected Mac was pulling carts full of apples into the barn so I walked over to ask him. "Hey Big Mac do ya know were Cloud went? He should be working right now." He looked over at me and sighed.

"Yer 'boyfriend' is taking the day off. He also mentioned somethin' about Rainbow Dash." I felt my heart sink at the mention of my best friends name "Rainbow Dash". I felt angry at her and knew that I shouldn't, but my thoughts kept bring it back stronger and stronger. 'She better not think she can steal him because he will be mine.' Ah thanked Mac quickly and ran as my thought continued to rampaged through my mind. 'I hope she doesn't love him because he will be mine... all mine.'

Clouds POV.

Rainbow and I went to Sweet Apple Acres to use the race track there, but we needed to ask Applejack for permission first. When we arrived at the farm we were met with Applejack running towards me and tackling me to the ground. After the slight dizziness goes away I find Applejack laying on top of me, and we both began to blush at the feeling of our bodies touching one another.

"What are you doing? Get off of him!" I hear Rainbow yell as she pulls Applejack off me by her arm. Applejack quickly shoves Rainbow away, but before Rainbow can counter I step between them.

"Girls! Why are you fighting?"I asked. They blushed with embarrassment then mumbled something before turning away from me. I frowned until I felt a hot feeling on both my cheeks. 'They both just kissed me!' Thanks to my one tracked mind I came up with one conclusion. 'They both love me!' I took a deep breath before speaking to calm myself. "You girls were fighting over me?" They looked back at me smiling, but still embarrassed over their actions earlier.

"So which one?" They both ask as I raised an eyebrow confusion to their question.

"What do you mean? Can't I be with you both?" They raised an eyebrow as well not sure how to answer, but for me the matter at hand was I couldn't choose. Applejack was a hard working mare, always honest even if it hurts and protective of her family never letting them get hurt or worse. While Rainbow Dash was hot headed and always sure of herself, but is also loyal to her friends and family always taking risks to ensure everypony's safety.So how could I choose between them. It would hurt one of them either way, and cause their friendship to be ripped apart, I couldn't do that them."Girls I could never choose between you two. Applejack your always honest even when it hurts and protective of family and friends never wanting them to get hurt. Rainbow Dash your loyal to the very end, never betraying your friends and family no matter how much you are tempted. So you see girls I can't choose between you two. I love you both too much to hurt you gir..." Before I could finish they tackled me to the ground giving me two massive hugs.

Applejack was the first one to look into my eyes and kiss me on the lips. It felt so good and refreshing then Rainbow kissed me sighing happily  as she did. They stayed there holding me and I never wanted to let this moment end. After they each had a chance to make out with me, we got up  dusting ourselves off and blushing like crazy, but all sharing a smile. I couldn't wait to spend another day with my two beautiful and now marefriends, Applejack and Rainbow Dash.