Shining Armor has been visiting Fluttershy every night to try her cooking. He heard from every pony in ponyville that she made the best spinach, but when he starts visiting the cottage every night for a taste, he realizes he's just looking for an excuse to see the chef. When Fluttershy becomes pregnant, Shining has to confess to Cadence- and perhaps the rest of Equestria- that he's madly in love with another pony.