Love Me

by Dreamscape

Rating: mature
Tags: Gore, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Dark, Rainbow Dash, Fluttershy, Sex
Length: 3963

Fluttershy finally admits to Rainbow Dash that she is in love with her and that she has been for a very long time. When Rainbow tells her she doesn't feel the same, things take a quick turn for the worst.

Fluttershy finally admits to Rainbow Dash that she is in love with her and that she has been for a very long time. When Rainbow tells her she doesn't feel the same, things take a quick turn for the worst.

(WARNING: This story contains descriptive scenes of rape and abuse)

Cover Art: Fluttershy Evil Grin by arcticjuniper

Published 2013-12-07 19:40:03 UTC
Last updated 2013-12-07 19:40:03 UTC

Love Me

"Thank you so much for helping with the animals today. I never could have done it myself," Fluttershy said softly as she crawled onto her couch and sat down. She gently patted her hoof on the soft, light green cushioning beside her, indicating for her cyan colored friend to take a seat.

Rainbow Dash plopped down beside her, causing the cushion to raise up slightly and push against her yellow rump. Fluttershy quickly balanced her off-kilter body so she wouldn't be tipped over. "No problem," Rainbow sighed, placing her hooves behind her head and resting it against them. "That's what friends are for." Fluttershy opened her mouth as if to say something but all that came out was a small whimper. "Come on, Fluttershy," Rainbow encouraged, noticing her mouth moving nervously and her body shaking. "Speak up! If you've got something to say just say it."

"Oh, Rainbow," she whimpered. "I-it’s more than just that. We've been friends for so long and...and you've always been there for me." She paused for a moment, her pale yellow cheeks filling up with a bright rosy hue as she looked into her eyes. Her gaze quickly turned down to the pink rug on the wooden floor beneath them. "You've been such a good friend...i-it’s just that I've...Rainbow...I've always wanted more than that. I love you."

"Whoa, whoa, whoa, calm down there, Lovershy!" Rainbow said, placing a confident hoof on her friend's shoulder. Although her touch was confident, it could be seen by her ever so slightly widened eyes that the statement had taken her aback. "I love you too," she stated, hearing Fluttershy's pounding heartbeat quicken, "as a friend, and I always will, but loving you like that? It's just weird. You're like a sister to me, not some love interest. Sorry." She shook her head, knowing how sensitive the innocent little Pegasus was. She felt horrible for breaking her heart like that, but she didn't feel the same. The only other alternative was to lie, but living in a false relationship wasn't something she wanted to bother with.

"Bad choice," Fluttershy whispered as tears welled up in her eyes. Rainbow raised an eyebrow at the odd statement but was quickly shaken from any of those thoughts when her friend burst out into a full sob. Not saying a word, she wrapped a hoof around the wreck of a pony and pulled her close. Fluttershy nuzzled her snout against Dash's strong chest. With a sniffle, she pulled away, leaving a damp spot upon Rainbow's fur. Breathing heavily and wiping her eyes, she turned away from the pony who would have comforted her further and leaned back against the couch. Rainbow Dash sat quiet and still, allowing time for her friend to gather herself.

It stayed silent for what seemed to Rainbow an eternity. She glanced over at the clock, its tick echoing through her head, and realized it had only been a few minutes. She shuffled her body and moved her hooves, unable to stand the silence for much longer. She fought herself from opening her mouth, wondering whether or not she had given her friend enough time until finally blurting out, "No hard feelings, right?"

Fluttershy turned to her once more, all traces of sadness in her face now gone. "No, of course not," she said with a soft smile.

"Good," she yawned, looking up at the warm, orange evening light flooding in from the window behind her. It had been a long day for Rainbow. Not only did she help Fluttershy with the abundant amount of animals at her cottage but had cleared the sky after a scheduled storm the previous night, practiced her flying, played with Tank, and wasn't even able to get one nap in. "It's getting kinda late," she said, stretching out her wings. "I should probably get going, but I really don't wanna move." She let out a laugh before leaning back against the couch and closing her eyes, letting the weight of exhaustion and sleepiness take over.

"Oh, it’s okay. You can stay as long as you want," Fluttershy said warmly as she crawled off of the couch. "I'm going to go check on the animals. I'll be very quiet so you can nap." Rainbow Dash responded with a grumble and leaned her head against the two pillows on the opposite side of the couch, quickly slipping into her dreams.

***

Eyes closed and still half asleep, Rainbow felt something cold and hard against her back. She realized that she wasn't on the couch any longer and that she was sliding across whatever cold surface she was now on. Her eyes shot open as she felt something tugging at her front hoof. "Fluttershy?" she mumbled groggily, looking up into her teal blue eyes as she struggled to pull her along. "Oh, I'm so sorry, but you weren't supposed to wake up," she said with a frown before dropping her hoof and turning around. The dazed pony was just able to patch together that her friend was dragging her across the wooden floor of the cottage when Fluttershy's hind hoof came down fast and hard, connecting with her head. Everything went black.

Dash's vision was blurred when she awoke in a dim lit room, the only lighting being a small bulb hanging from the ceiling above her. Attempting to rub her eyes she realized that her hoof was restrained. She tried with the other. The only result was the clink of what sounded like a metal chain. Now in a panic, she attempted to kick her hind legs to no avail. She shook her head and flapped her wings furiously, her vision along with a sharp pain returning.

"Shh, shh, its okay," Fluttershy said lovingly as she approached, her face slowly pushing its way out of the shadows and into the light. "Here's some water, you must be thirsty." She brought a cup to her mouth, pushed its brim between her lips, and tilted it slightly, allowing a small gulp of water to drip into her mouth.

Calmed by her friend’s demeanor, Rainbow Dash gladly gulped it down before pulling her head away and asking, "What the hay is going on? Why am I all tied up like this? Wait a second, you...you kicked me!" She looked frantically around the dark room, any sense of calmness now turning to panic. It was difficult for her to see anything, not just because of the lack of light but because of her captor's face obscuring the view. All she could make out was the concrete floor and stone wall she was strapped to. She assumed she was in the basement of the cottage.

A smirk appeared on Fluttershy's face as she grabbed a wet cloth and dabbed it around the encrusted blood on Rainbow's nose. "Things would have been so much easier if you just would have accepted my love right away. You're going to stay with me for a while. You'll learn to love me, Dashie," she whispered, moving her muzzle closer and closer.

A look of shock and fear appeared in her pink eyes. "T-this can't be happening," she mumbled weakly.

"It is, my love," Fluttershy cooed before dropping the bloody cloth and brushing her lips against the hostage's. Her cheeks glowed a bright red. "Oh, Rainbow," she moaned. "Your lips are so soft."

Rainbow's fear quickly dissipated as she decided to do what she knew best, fight. "Back off, Fluttershy!" she yelled, flailing her limbs in an attempt to break free from the chains. "I really don't want to hurt you when I get outta here but if you keep this up, I'm gonna," she said with a defiant stare over the loud clanging of chains.

"I know you're strong, but how are you ever going to do that?" Fluttershy laughed and gently caressed her hoof against Dash's face before pressing their lips together.

"Like this!" Rainbow yelled, quickly turning her head, and with one strong kick, her hind legs pulled the ancient, crumbling stone from the wall with a loud crash. She then arched her hooves upward, slamming them into Fluttershy's stomach. The yellow Pegasus flew backwards, all the air in her lungs escaping, and hit the ground with a thump. Chunks of stone now hanging from the shackles and weighing down her hooves, Dash attempted to do the same with the upper restraints. The stone here was much sturdier and no matter how hard she tried, nothing was going to budge. She peered down at the shivering yellow hump, listening to her soft whimpers and hoping she wouldn't get up anytime soon. Maybe, just maybe she could work a crack in the stone.

Rainbow's heart jumped as Fluttershy clambered back onto all fours. "Such a strong girl," she said with a grin. "But I really don't like it when my pets are naughty. Angel was always naughty. Want to know what happened when I had enough of him? I cut off his cute little head, chopped him into bits, and fed him to the others. They all thought he was much better that way. We don't want that for you now do we, Rainbow?" she asked, slowly making her way back to the captive.

"No!" she yelped and winced as Fluttershy pounced upon her. A false sense of relaxation came over her as she realized the pony had just come in for another kiss, or so she thought. Fluttershy bit down hard upon her lip and pulled. Pain shot through Rainbow's mouth as she felt the teeth pierce her skin and then tear it once pulled back.

"You hurt me, I hurt you! Understand?" Fluttershy asked, Dash's blood dripping down her chin.

Rainbow spit the blood from her mouth and started to whimper, tears welling up in her eyes. "What happened to you, Fluttershy? What happened to the innocent, sweet, caring pony I used to know?"

"Oh, Rainbow," Fluttershy said lovingly, using her hoof to wipe the tears from her face. "It’s just that you didn't love me...a-and I was trying to be more assertive. You've always wanted me to be more assertive, right?"

"Assertive doesn't mean crazy!" Rainbow yelled, her fierce eyes piercing through the tears.

Fluttershy's caring hoof turned into a weapon as she smacked it against Rainbow's cheek. "How dare you? You did this to me and now you're calling me crazy? You made me this way, Rainbow Dash! I've always done everything you wanted me to do, everything everypony else wanted too, and what did I get in return? That's right, I didn't get anything! I'm fed up with being used...now I can finally get what I always wanted."

"What, me?" Dash questioned. "I...you-" she stopped and shook her head, realizing it was just a waste of breath.

"It’s okay, sweetie. We all make mistakes and I can let this one slide," Fluttershy said softly. "Now let me see those big strong wings." Rainbow Dash gulped hesitantly. She slightly raised her voice, "Let me see your wings." Rainbow slowly unfurled them and let them hang limp at her sides. "Nice and wide," Fluttershy stated. She nodded her perspiring head and spread her wings as if she were about to take off.

"Do we really have to do this?" Rainbow pleaded. Fluttershy nodded her head slowly, her face turning beet red as she gazed at the powerful wings before her.

"So beautiful," Fluttershy whispered, stroking a hoof against her wing, "You have the most amazing wings."

Rainbow Dash silently shook her head, thinking she'd normally love a compliment from her friend, from anypony actually, but not like this. She quickly turned her head away as Fluttershy bent over and wrapped her mouth around a section of feathers. She sucked gently, brushing her tongue slowly back and forth across them. Rainbow grimaced as she felt Fluttershy's warm saliva dripping down her wing and her soft tongue brushing against her feathers. She couldn't take much more of this. Moaning softly, Fluttershy nibbled and pulled lightly at the tips of her feathers.

This final action was too much for Rainbow. Enraging her captor seemed well worth the risk. Once again, she brought her hind legs forward and into Fluttershy's stomach. The crazed yellow pegasus bit down hard upon the feathers in her mouth, taking them with her as she flew backwards. Dash ground her teeth hard as she felt the feathers rip from her wing, not wanting to give away how much pain she was truly in. She glanced down at the missing patch of feathers, blood seeping from where they were just seconds before. From the corner of her eye, she watched as Fluttershy easily returned to her hooves and spit the cyan feathers from her mouth. Her teeth gleamed in the dim light as a grin formed on her face.

"Are you okay?" she asked, returning to her side and examining the wing. "You shouldn't hurt yourself like that." She silently rolled her eyes and shook her head.

Dash nodded her head and let out a painful, "F-fine,"

"Good," Fluttershy said with a smirk. "But that was very, very naughty and naughty pets get punished." Rainbow let out gulp as she disappeared into the shadows.

She returned a moment later with a cattle prod in her mouth. "Please don't," Dash whimpered, realizing what it was.

"I'm sorry, but you have to be taught a lesson," Fluttershy said through her teeth.

Rainbow kicked her hooves and flapped her uninjured wing, struggling to escape from her bindings. It was too late. The cattle prod made contact with her stomach in a flash of purplish blue and pain shot through her entire body as she shook uncontrollably. "Have you learned your lesson?" Fluttershy asked, pulling away. Her victim was silent. She shook her head and went in for another attack. She held it longer this time, letting it singe her fur and skin as well as sending another painful surge through her body.

Smoke drifted upwards as Fluttershy pulled away, leaving a sickening smell in the air. As her voice returned, Dash let out a loud scream, vomit dripping from her mouth. Afterwards she sputtered a "Didn't even phase me," followed by a defiant glare.

"If you say so," Fluttershy said, pushing the torture device against her once more. Her body convulsed violently as the blackened skin and fur around the device singed even further. Her mouth fell open, her tongue flopped out of her mouth, and finally, her eyes slowly rolled backwards, leaving only white.

Rainbow Dash awoke to the smell of urine and looked down to see Fluttershy wiping her marehood with a tissue. "Somepony had a little accident," she said cutely, looking up at Rainbow with a frown. "Don't worry, it happens to even the greatest."

All the pain that had seemingly disappeared in her sleep quickly returned and was followed by a blast of emotion. Tears streamed down her face as she wept uncontrollably, her bright, proud eyes faded. "Alright...I give up, okay? I'm done fighting...you can do whatever you want."

Fluttershy wrapped her hooves tightly around the captive. "Aw, such a sweetheart. I always knew you were a softy under that tough outer-shell but not this soft." She kissed her gently on the cheek. "I love you so much, Rainbow. I only did that because I had to. I never wanted to hurt you."

Rainbow Dash sniffled and nodded her head, "J-just do whatever you want."

Fluttershy smiled and used the urine soaked tissue to wipe the crusted vomit and blood from Rainbow's lips. "Now that's what I like to hear." Finishing her touch up work, she threw the tissue over her shoulder. "Cleaning you up got me so excited, I just can't resist it any longer!" she yelled quietly and pressed her hoof against Dash's marehood while wrapping the other hoof around her neck.

Rainbow shuddered, feeling the tip of Fluttershy's hoof pushing her lips apart and gliding up to her clitoris. "I've wanted this for so long, Rainbow," she moaned. The victim slowly closed her eyes, the rest of her body now motionless. "I've been sneaking looks since we were fillies. I didn't just walk behind you because I was a scaredy pony. There was always nice view too." She tilted her head and nuzzled it against Dash's as she slid her hoof forward, pushing her way inside and stretching her lips wider and wider. "Do you know how many times I've dreamed of this...how many fantasies I've had about you? The hottest, sexiest, most awesome mare in Equestria?" Rainbow Dash could barely discern the question or even the compliment. Her eyes being closed, it was as if the only thing that existed was her marehood and the hoof making its way inside. She thought to herself how enjoyable this act would be in ordinary circumstances but how wrong and revolting it felt now. She knew there was nothing she could do about it though, unless she wanted another punishment.

The yellow monster pulled her hoof out. A dejected look could have been seen on her face if the other pair of eyes was opened. "Aren't you having fun? I know I am," she said, both of her hooves now wrapped around Rainbow's neck. "Oh my, I'm so wet." She glanced down at her marehood which was covered with clear juices, and watched as the liquid dripped down onto the concrete floor below. "I've never been this wet before and it’s all because of you." She gently thrust her hips forward, causing their marehoods to collide. Her wet lips pressed against Rainbow's and as she continued to thrust, lubricated them as well. Fluttershy forced her tongue into her captive's mouth, moving it from wall to wall until their tongues met. Her tongue wrapped around Dash's like a serpent constricting the life from its victim. She let out a muffled moan as she ground her marehood in a circular motion, her juices flowing even more freely.

Rainbow Dash's marehood remained small and tight, her clitoris and inner lips only slightly enlarged by the stimulation. She attempted to retreat into her mind but could only think of who her friend used to be and what she had become. All the wonderful moments that they had shared and spent together were now ruined. Tears trickled from her closed eyes, soaking into her fur as they traveled down her cheek. Hearing small whimpers and feeling Rainbow's heavy, rattling breath passing into her mouth, Fluttershy released her tongue and pulled away. "Oh, what's wrong?" she asked tenderly, watching the degraded pony slowly open her tearful eyes. "You're being such a good girl," she praised, using her hoof to brush Rainbow's mane to the side of her face. "I think somepony deserves a little present...well, it's actually a present for both of us." She pushed away from the weeping pony and her hooves clacked against the floor as she disappeared into the shadows once more.

Rainbow's sore, red eyes grew wide and attempted to find the figure of the Pegasus in the darkness. She wondered what had been meant by present and trembled as she thought of the last device that was retrieved. Fluttershy returned with a double headed cyan toy. "It matches you very well," she giggled. "I got it just for the two of us." She raised up on her hind legs and wrapped a hoof around Dash's neck, returning to her previous position. Using her free hoof, she took the toy from beneath her wing and brought one of the ends down to the prisoner's marehood. She slowly traced around her lips with its tip, gazing lovingly at the sight as she did so. "You're so perfect Rainbow, every single thing about you." She licked her lips and slid the toy up and down the perfect pony's marehood, letting its tip prod gently against her clitoris. "Aren't you having fun?"

Rainbow nodded her head although she felt no pleasure whatsoever. Fluttershy smiled and pushed the toy inside her. The captive let out a small groan as she felt its smooth rubber surface pushing against her walls as it traveled inside her. After pushing the toy in a bit further, Fluttershy situated the other end and with a quiet yelp, slid her dripping marehood over top of it. Her entire face flushed red as she pushed the toy forward, deeper into Rainbow and then pulled back, pushing it inside herself. Panting loudly and sweat dripping from her body, she continued the process. Dash groaned painfully, her inner walls still quite dry.

Concentrating on good thoughts, Rainbow let out an imaginative sigh as her juices finally began lubricating her marehood. The toy slid in and out much more freely now. Glancing down, she noticed red. Returning her gaze, she realized that a small amount of blood was dripping from Fluttershy's marehood and coating the toy. "That's right, Rainbow," Fluttershy moaned blissfully. "You're my first. I've been waiting for so long."

Rainbow shook her head in silence, as the pony pushed the toy in deeper and faster, inadvertently thrusting her hips in an elysian state of mind. The toy along with Fluttershy's marehood got wetter and wetter as the top of it rubbed against her engorged clitoris. "So good," Fluttershy moaned through her gaping mouth and tilted her head back, enjoying the massage.

Rainbow Dash's entire body began to shake, not from pleasure but from weakness caused by the dreadful and seemingly never ending hell she entered. She felt numb, cold, and hopeless. Unable to cry, all she could do was wish that it would be over. Her wish was granted, maybe there was some minuscule form of hope left after all.

Fluttershy's face returned to a bright, beet red hue as her hot, perspiring body tensed and her hoof squeezed tightly against Dash's neck. She thrust her hips one final time, letting her marehood slide down over the toy, going so deep that their marehoods were now touching. After letting out a pleasurable squeal and wrapping her lips around Rainbow's, her body relaxed and the prisoner felt her warm, sticky juices pour out onto her marehood.

"So awesome," Fluttershy giggled, gently sliding off of the toy. As she pulled away, strands of the thick liquid connected by the two marehoods stretched outwards and then broke away. "I love you, Rainbow Dash," she cooed after sliding off of the toy and pulling the other end out of her captive. "You're such a good girl. I've never had that much fun in my entire life." She licked some of the juices from the toy and then shoved it in Rainbow's mouth, wanting her to do the same. Dash twirled her tongue around the toy to please her and then gulped down the collected residue as it was pulled away.

"C-can I go now?" Dash muttered weakly, her body still shaking.

"You've been such a good pet," Fluttershy said warmly, staring into her eyes. "Don't you want to be my pet forever? You know how well I treat my animals...the ones that I love that is. I certainly love you."

"I just wanna go home," Dash pleaded, tears returning to her eyes. "I promise I won't tell anypony."

"I'm so sorry," Fluttershy said, frowning and shaking her head. Rainbow's heart jumped with hope. She was going to let her go. She was realizing what she just had done to her. Her reinvigorated heart was quickly crushed. "But you have to stay. You’re my most favorite pet and we'll have so much fun together. You'll love me, I know it." She smiled, and turned to walk away. "Don't you worry, Dashie. I'll be right back with some food and I can clean us up while you eat."