My Friends Said Your Number Was Up!

by TwilightPoopSparkle

Diamond Tiara and Silver Spoon

Previous Chapter

     "Of course I do Applejack!" Pinkie giggled. The two ponies were in Sugarcube corner and Pinkie was finishing pouring Blueblood's organs into a cupcake batter. "If they are a Nasty Mc Nastypants, they can be on the list. Fillies are the easiest to work with. They sound so silly when they are in pain!"

     "Thanks Pinkie. You won't believe how much this means to Applebloom. I have a great plan. First we round up Diamond..." The rest of the plan was then spoken in hushed whispers.

     "Perfect! Let's go!"


     It was the end of another school day. Ten students waited patiently for the bell to ring, except two. Diamond Tiara and Silver Spoon were very excited. Today they were going to help Applebloom get her cutie mark, hopefully a bullied pony mark. The teacher Cherilee walked to Tiara's desk with a note in her hoof. "Diamond Tiara, I have a note that says that your dad isn't at your house. You have to be immidently at Applejack's barn by 3:30."

     The brat sighed. "Yes Miss. Cherilee." Then the bulling will take place tomorrow. Diamond galloped to the barn, she didn't want to displease Applejack. She shoved Applebloom who was crossing paths to Sweetie Bells's house for a play date."Move it blank flank."

     Diamond walked into the barn, catching Applejack washing some towels. "Listen up missy, since your dad isn't home, you are going to help me with some chores."

     "Ulgh...fine. But why can't you let Applebloom do the job?" The magenta filly complained.

     "Because she is having a play date right now and ah' want to talk to you." Applejack gave the pink earth filly a stern glare as Diamond gulped. Did Applejack already know?

     "Awwww ah'm just kidding with ya'. But one question, does this smell like chloroform to ya'?" A white funny smelling rag was shoved into her face. Diamond knew that chloroform was bad. Her daddy told her that evil ponies used it all the time to catch smart pretty girls like her. She tried to gallop away, but the substance reached her senses so she tripped and collapsed.

     Applejack didn't want to be a murderer, so she tried to be as fast as possible. But Diamond still had to suffer. She walked to a corner where a couple of pitchforks were resting. With tears in her eyes, she approached the sleeping body. 'This is for the safety of my sister.' The farmer threw the pitchfork as hard as she could. The pitchfork decapitated her head and pinned it on the wall behind her body. "Yippy kai yay mother bucker." She yelled as she threw the body under some hay and started stabbing it with the pitchfork, just to make sure she wasn't alive the slighest.


     Rarity came over to help clean up the mess. Applejack was shocked that the unicorn brought knives with her, but slightly relaxed when she saw what Rarity was doing. "Rarity, are ya' sure Applebloom would want that apron? It looks disgusting."

     "I'm sure that she would ABSOLUTELY adore it. Now she can wear Diamond Tiara forever." The mare finished removing the cutie marks from the sides. "I heard what you were planning with Silver Spoon, and I'm making the apron. Imagine the look on Silver's face when she sees that her best friend has been turned into a piece of clothing."

     "Ah' guess it could be okay, but please finish by tonight. Applebloom's coming home in a couple of hours." This had to take place at Sweet Apple Acres. Pinkie couldn't afford to have another pony know her secret. Fillies are notorious for telling secrets.


     Stars were starting to climb into the sky by the time the yellow filly came home. Applejack rushed to her and hugged her hard. "Remember the little talk we had about those bad feelings?"

     "Yeah..."

     "This will be the first and last time you will ever feel like this. C'mon, follow me to the barn." The duo walked into the barn silently. Applebloom's jaw dropped. Silver Spoon was rocking back in forth, but she could barely move because she was bound up, blindfolded, and gagged. She also saw a pale magenta body hiding under some hay. It looked like Diamond Tiara, but it was missing her head, cutie marks, and large sections of skin.

     Applebloom felt something solid near her hoof. When she kicked it away, she screamed at what the object was. It was Diamond's bloodied head, wearing a sleepy derp face. She was still in shock when something leathery was tied around her waist and neck. Phew...it was just Applejack...and a magenta apron?

     "Rarity made ya' a pretty apron. Be sure to thank her later. But guess who is on the apron? It's Diamond Tiara! She won't bother ya' anymore." Said Applejack.

     "..." There was an awkward pause floating in the air for about a minute. 'Ah' guess Applebloom didn't want it.'

     "THANK YOU APPLEJACK!" The little filly buried her head in her sister's neck. "This is the best present ever! Ah'm so happy that Tiara's gone. Silver Spoon wasn't as bad, but she still made fun of me and beat me up."

     "Yes. You may do whatever you like to her, after all, ah' captured them. It was to risky to let ya' kill both, so I got Diamond for ya'. But PROMISE me that you will never have these feelings again."

     "Cross my heart, hope to fly, stick a cupcake in my eye. Ah' also solemnly swear on mah' and everypony that ah' know's life." This really sealed the deal, otherwise, everypony would be dead.

     "Good job Applebloom. This tray right here is all the supplies for cutting and over here is where ah' put the special tools." Applejack explained, almost as casually as Pinkie Pie. You have to adapt quickly.

     "Hey Silver Spoon?" The blinded head followed the filly's voice. "Guess who is going to be a blank flank?" The silver filly let out a muffled moan. "You aren't fun. Let me take this gag off of ya'." Even with the gag removed, Silver stayed silent as she trembled in fear.

     "Oh well, it was worth the shot. Cutie Mark time!" Applebloom grabbed the nearest weapon; it didn't matter to her which one she picked. The tool was a axe. It was a bit big, but it would do. "Just hold still please."

     Applebloom wasn't experienced at all with sharp weapons. She tried cutting off the silver spoon cutie mark, but more or less hacked into her pelvis. Silver screamed as loud as she could for mercy. "APPLEBLOOM! PLEASE STOP! YOU ARE GOING TO GET IN TROUBLE FOR THIS. YOUR BETTER THAN THAT! I WANNA GO HOME!!!"

     "Sorry, ah' can't do that." Applejack said as she watched the scene. "Granny Smith and Big Macintosh are visiting relatives in Trottingham, and the nearest house around is miles away. But keep up the good work Applebloom. Ah' managed to snag Silver as she was looking for Diamond. She will never know what this decision would have cost her. Ehhh, ah' might have caught her in the middle of the night as well, but ah' digress."

     Once Silver's pelvis and parts of her legs were basically in bloody chunks, and exposing a lower rib or two, Applebloom moved onto the next step. "Now ah'm going ta' make sure ya' can't make fun of me ever again." She put a large metal ring in Silver's mouth, forcing her to open her mouth, and Silver couldn't scream out loud any more. Her whole world hurt.

     The yellow filly grabbed a vegetable peeler, using the axe would just rip Silver's mouth open; though that would be a cool idea. Forcing Silver's long flat tongue right next to the peeler, Applebloom activated it. Layer after layer, the tongue ripped. Silver started screaming in terror, but she couldn't form words properly. Blood spilled quickly from her mouth, staining the hay easily. Her tongue was now in ruins. Little sheds hung here and there, but most of it was on Applebloom's hoof. "What do ya' have to say to yourself?"

     "E...hdn..hssssh." Was all Silver could say. Pain was in all of her senses, but there was nothing she could do. She just wished she was with Diamond hopefully in heaven. Just somepony make her suffering stop PLEASE!

     "Hmmmm...ah' thought that would shut your trap." Applebloom thought for a bit. Wait. Cherilee's lessons on the equine body! What was it? Oh yes...the vocal cords. But it was in her neck. How can she destroy it without cutting a jugular vein? Might as well save that for last. But first...the eyes. Silver's purple eyes always mocked Applebloom. Watching her flank be bare all the time. Now the eyes won't be so mean.

     Applebloom ditched the vegetable peeler for the spoon. It would be funny anyway to scoop out somepony's eyeballs. Silver Spoon's freed eyes managed to catch a glimpse of her mutilated body. "Ewww," the red mane filly cringed as she watched her victim vomit on herself. "Why did you do that? At least when ah' am done, you won't be able to see your vomit anymore."

     The spoon loomed closer and closer. Silver tried to blink as fast as she could to detour the spoon, but the sliverwear plunged deep into her eye. The silver filly screamed herself hoarse as the spoon twisted this way and that. Applebloom scooped the eye chunks into a plastic bowl until she stabbed Silver into the eye again. She even ripped out the eye stems!

     A red mist invaded Spoon's vision before blackness. One of her precious senses was removed. The one her own daddy said that's what made her so pretty. 'I wonder what daddy would say if he saw me in this state.' She thought of her mangled cutie mark resting in a bowl and began to cry through her empty sockets.

     "Here's for all the times you called me a blank flank." A knife sliced across her neck, and Silver fell unconscious. Yellow hooves ripped her own throat open as Applebloom searched for the little nick in her neck. By the time Applebloom found the chords and slashed them, Silver started to choke on her blood.

     "No! Don't die yet. Ah' wanna gut ya'!" The knife dug into Silver's belly, failing miserably at cutting it open.

     "Applebloom stop! You've done enough damage!" The little filly was gnawing on the still heart of the bully. "Please..." Applebloom ignored her begging sister who was now beating the body. Applejack tried to intervene, but Applebloom hissed and threw the knife, barely grazing the farmer's shoulders.


     "Twilight! You have to help me!" Applejack burst through the library doors, startling Twilight from one of her experiments.

     "What is it? Did the police find Blueblood's body?"

     "No...ah' cremated it and dumped the ashes in the river," panted Applejack. She just ran seven miles at full speed to get to the alicorn's house. "The problem is Applebloom. Ah' thought it would be a good idea if she could have revenge on that bully Silver Spoon, but boy, was ah' far from right. Applebloom has been beating and mutilating the carcass of Silver for the past few minutes, thinking she is still alive. When ah' tried to intervene, she hissed and threw a knife at me! Mah' own sister!"

     "Oh my Celestia!" Panicked Twilight. "I-I don't know what to do. The only explanation is that she is severely phycolgically tramatized from this experiment. If you wish, and I may add that it's very risky, I know a spell that can erase any memory, no matter how far back. I find it very useful for helping PTSD veterans get back on their hooves."

     "Ah' doubt that she is tramatized, because she was enjoying this procedure. But I would like to erase this memory. I can't believe ah' made such a poor decision."

     Twilight just grimly smiled. "It's okay Applejack. The spell is fairly harmless. However, ANYTHING that reminds Applebloom of the memory, all the feelings and thoughts will come rushing back. It will lead to an extreme case of skitzafenza. I remember one time I helped a PP2 (Pony Apopcolypse) veteran named Flippy. Anytime he heard anything that reminded him of the war, he basically flipped out and murdered anypony he saw."

     "Yes ma'm." Saluted the farmer.

     "That means you must hide anything that reminds Applebloom of Diamond Tiara, or any sharp objects. I guess that also means...I have to erase both fillies' parents' memories. Filthy Rich would probably thrown your body in jail to rot. I bet they are comming to the barn right now."

     When the duo reached the barn, Diamond Tiara and Silver Spoon's body parts were littered everywhere. Twilight nearly stepped in a piece of brain and Applejack ducked from a liver being thrown at her head.

     Applebloom looked like she took a bath in blood. Her coat was the same color as her hair, and she wore a maddening gaze. "What do ya' want? Ah' need to finish killing Diamond and Silver! Ah'm going to get my revenge cutie mark soon."

     Twilight cautiously tiptoed to Applebloom. "I think you have done enough sweetie."

     The filly took a menacing stance with a saw in mouth. "No ah' haven't! And stay back...ah' don't want to hurt ya'."

     "Ah'm sorry Sugarcube, but you already hurt mah' heart. NOW TWILIGHT!" A green beam shot from Twilight's horn to Applebloom's eyes. The filly had a confused face, before fainting on the ground. "Phew...it worked."

     "Diamond Tiara? Silver Spoon? You fillies in here? C'mon it's ten o' clock. Leave Applebloom, it's time to go home." The families of the two brats knocked on the barn door, ignoring the stench of dead and decay.

     Twilight and Applejack locked the barn door and placed a chair to prevent it from being opened. "This may be harder than we think. Cherilee...ponies in town...they will all remember. I'm going to erase their memory, except ours. This way we will never make the same mistake again. I'm sorry." Twilight closed her eyes as her horn glowed. The green laser shot strait up into the air and billowed out into a cloud over the town. Soon everypony forgot about the two fillies. Everypony except Twilight, Fluttershy, Rarity, Rainbow Dash, Applejack, and Pinkie Pie.

     "We can't afford to do this again. This will now be the closest call we will do. All the murders will have to take place in the basement of Sugarcube Corner, no exceptions. Let's clean up this mess before anypony remembers."

     Filthy Rich and the others forgot what they were doing. They were coming up to the barn for something, but it was nothing. Cherilee was in her classroom grading papers. When she stumbled across a name that said 'Diamond Tiara' it confused her. "I never had a Diamond Tiara in my class." She just shrugged and threw the paper in the trash can.