In an alternate Ponyville in an alternate Equestria, a blonde and grey mare by the name of Derpy Hooves was executed for causing many different accidents everywhere she went. She caused fires, toppled buildings, ruined a lot more properties of other citizens; but… did she really mean any of them? Did she deserve to gain the ultimate punishment for it? Apparently, the citizens of Ponyville and many others seemed to think so, and the mare was soon brought forward to the public to die.

Everypony there found her to be a total klutz; a stupid retard; and many other things that seemed to cruel to just say alone; and they all wanted her to be gone forever from their lives. But before they executed her, they put her through many different painful torture; whether it was smacking her in the face, beating her with their hooves, sticks or other things, or having many ponies rape her constantly. But it wasn’t just the grown ponies, many colts and fillies were there to give their share of torture as well, including Derpy’s own daughter, Dinky! It was the worse day of her life when Derpy saw her daughter who she thought was the only one on her side beating her and ridiculing her like everypony else.

However, despite all of that, the pony named Fluttershy agreed with some others and planned to privately kill Dinky off too, because they thought that she would gain her Mother’s retarded genetics (at least that’s what they called it). Fluttershy did the deed while freely raping the little filly herself, and her friend, Twilight Sparkle, soon came to her to help her out a little. After that, Derpy was gone, done and dead, and so was her daughter; and Ponyville couldn’t have been happier.

That execution brought out the sick and twisted side of the town, but no pony felt ashamed about it; all they really cared about was ridding themselves of Derpy Hooves and any offspring of hers for good.

But… what would happen if one little thing had changed? What if the execution still took place? What if Derpy’s daughter, Dinky, still loved her Mother? What if she was the only one in Ponyville who didn’t want her Mother executed but couldn’t do anything about it? And what if she overheard the plan of them getting rid of her as well… just because she was Derpy’s daughter?

Well… this is what would happen.

The young filly couldn’t watch as the entire town, everypony that she knew and thought she loved brutally torture and kill her Mother; and she wasn’t planning to hang around to be killed herself either. So, the best thought she came up with was running away into the Everfree Forest where no pony would even think of looking for her.

After the execution, Fluttershy and her friends looked all over for Dinky hoping that they could find her just hiding somewhere, but they had no luck. But they soon found some yellow fur from Dinky’s mane stuck on some branches that led inside the Everfree Forest. They realized then of what happened and thought that maybe this was a better idea. If Dinky ran off into forest, then maybe they should let its monsters and dark unknown forces take care of their job for them. After all, Dinky was just a 7-year-old filly, there was no way she was going to be able to survive out there on her own; one less worry for them.

Now picture this; it’s been 2 years ever since Ponyville and all of Equestria was free from Derpy’s klutzy, destructive lifestyle, and when Dinky was presumed dead. Everypony was living in peace not regretting their actions from that moment at all; things were much easy and relaxing without worrying about wasting money on destroyed property or hospital bills. But then one day, Ponyville got a bit riled up when a certain Zebra by the name of Zecora came into their town and gained their attention nearby the town. She shouted…

“Beware, beware, pony folk, the news I bring you is no joke! All of you here are living calm and free, feeling that your lives are finally at ease! But be warn, for your tranquility will not last, your lives will be destroyed by somepony you know from the past! The crime you all committed, your sins that you’ve developed; it shall come back on you in one big wallop! Beware of this foe, filled with hatred and dread; if you make one wrong move… you’re dead!”

After that, she disappeared in a puff of smoke. A lot of the town’s citizens were scared and spooked by Zecora’s speech; especially the foals. But there were still many others who were skeptical of the whole thing. Who was this somepony from their past that would be here to ruin their peace? It couldn’t have been Derpy, could it; she was dead.

Three days had passed since Zecora’s dreaded speech, and most citizens began to forget about it or at least ignore it. But unfortunately, that day as the dark clouds were rolling in, Ponyville was about to receive a visitor. Who was that visitor, someone they knew pretty well but had no idea that she was still around? The dark, maleficent figure creeped out of the forest, looking at Ponyville with pure hatred in its eyes and an intention to kill. It waited quite a while to finally do this, and now while wearing a murderous scowl, it was finally ready to send this town… to hell.

Author's Note

Onto victims 1 & 2.