Haunted

by KateTheNeko

Rating: mature
Tags: Pinkie Pie, Tragedy, Princess Celestia, Sad, Main 6, Princess Luna, Gore, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Dark
Length: 1939

Pinkamena is constantedly haunting Pinkie Pie, will she break free from Pinkamena? Or will she slowly give in to the insanity?

Pinkie has been able to control her secondary personality, Pinkamena, for as long as she can remember, but she's slowly taking over. With Rainbow Dash already tortured to death and Applejack her next victim, will Pinkie Pie be able to stop Pinkamena before its too late?

Published 2013-12-26 16:30:05 UTC
Last updated 2013-12-26 16:30:05 UTC

Chapter 1: Nightmare

As Pinkie Pie stared down at Rainbow's cold, dead corpse, a tear ran down her cheek. She glanced down at her blood stained hooves, then back to Rainbow. "Oh, Dashie, I'm so sorry, I didn't mean it!" She said, hugging the dead body.

"I will never forgive you Pinkie," Rainbow said. Pinkie quickly glanced at her face, confused. She was glaring at Pinkie with and unforgiving look in her eyes. "Instead, I'll just have to do to you exactly what you did to me."

Dashie stood up from the table her body was laying on. Pinkie fell to the ground and skidded across the floor, her back hitting the wall. "I swear Dashie, it wasn't me, it was Pi-"

"I don't care about your excuses! You're going to pay" Rainbow Dash interrupted and hit the helpless pink pony in the temple, knocking her out cold.

Pinkie jumped up from her bed, panting for breath and in a cold sweat. Just a dream. A small amount of light beamed from the half open curtains. Pinkie glanced over at the calender on one wall, today was Rainbow Dash's funeral. "I'm sorry Dashie," Pinkie whispered.

She crawled out of her bed and slowly made her way down the stairs of Sugercube Corner. A note was carefully placed on the counter. She walked over and stared down at it, reading its contents.

Dear Pinkie,
Mr. cake and I have to go run a few errands this
morning, we will be gone most of the day. I baked
you some pancakes for breakfast, if you're hungry.
Sincerely,
Mr. and Mrs. Cake

Pinkie stared at the plate of pancakes on the counter beside the note. She didn't have an appetite and really didn't want to eat anyhow. She meandered through Ponyville, slowly making her way to Twilight's house, the site all her friends agreed to meet at before the funeral.

As she walked in, Pinkie saw a group of four ponies and walked over to them. "Rainbow Dash was a great mare, loved by many. And although her life was short, she did many great things," Twilight said, resiting her speech for later. "She was one of my best friends and helped me with my transition from Canterlot to Ponyville.

"She was a great friend and I'll never forget our times together," she continued.

The line of speeches continued until it was Pinkie's turn. But before she could begin, she burst out crying and yelling, "I'm sorry, I'm sorry! I should've done something!"

Fluttershy rushed over to hug her and one by one the other three ponies did too. "It's ok Pinkie, there's nothing you could've done. Nobody knows who her murderer is," Applejack said, trying to calm the pink pony. But that was not true, she was the killer, she was the one who killed Rainbow. The thought of that made Pinkie cry even harder.

There were few who could see the pink mare crying.

At the funeral, Pinkie was hardly paying attention. Her mind was somewhere else. She was having another flashback. She was hiding Rainbow Dash's body. She dragged her from the basement and took her to the river. Not even a day after Pinkie disposed of the body, it was found a mile down stream.

"Pinkamena Diane Pie" the mayor called for her. She hated that name, Pinkamena.

She slowly climbed up to the speaker box and started the speech. "Rainbow Dash was one of my best friends. We would do everything together. When I found out she was murdered, I swore I make them pay for what they did to her. And if you're here, in the this crowd," Pinkie spoke harshly, "I will find you, no matter what it takes." Every word she said was true, she would make Rainbow's murderer pay.

She trotted back to where she was before. Her friends stared at her with gaping mouths. "Was that to much?" No answer. Pinkie sighed deeply and looked away.

Once Pinkie Pie made it back to Sugercube Corner, she trotted upstairs to her room and hid under the covers of her bed. She wanted to stay hidden under those covers forever and never return to real world. But she knew life wasn't that easy.

Pinkie got up and pulled a box from under the bed. Inside the box was a knife, she would make herself pay, slowly and painfully. Pinkie took the knife in her hoof and cut marks into her other hoof. She winced as blood flowed from the freshly made cuts.

"You can't run from the truth Pinkie, I'm going to kill all your cute little friends. There's nothing you can do Pinkie, give up!" a harsh voice said inside her head, it sounded identical to her own voice, though it was much darker in comparison.

"No! I will not give in, I won't let you kill any more of my friends!" Pinkie yelled out and put her hooves to her head.

"We'll see about that, one of your precious friends are my next victim, prove to me that you can stop me..."

The voice was not heard for a few minutes, so Pinkie knew she was gone....for now. "I won't let you hurt them," she whispered to herself.

"Pinkie? Is everything okay? I heard screaming," Mrs. Cake yelled from downstairs.

"Yeah, everything's fine, I just had a nightmare..."

Pinkie Pie quickly rushed to the bathroom and washed her blood stained hoof. The blood had already started to dry, so cleaning the cuts was more painful than making them. After most of the blood was washed away, there was a name visible. Pinkamena.

Author's Note

This is my first fanfic, so no judging. Hope you enjoy :3

Chapter 2: Dead Apples

A dark figure moved swiftly through the shadows, keeping herself hidden in the shadows. The dark figure was Pinkie Pie's dark side, Pinkamena. This unforgiving mare had one and only one destination. Sweet Apple Acres. This'll be fun, once I attack one of them, the others will be trying to take me down.

Pinkamena shook her head, making her hair poof and tapped her hoof on the door of Applejack's house. A small yellow filly with a red mane and a cute pink bow opened the door and said "Hey Pinkie, you looking for Applejack?"

"Yeah, have you seen her?" Pinkamena said, imitating Pinkie Pie. She hated being stuck in the same body as that annoying party pony.

"Sure, I'll go get her" Applebloom said before rushing off to find Applejack. It wasn't to long later that Pinkamena saw Applejack walk up to her.

"Hey, Pinkie, what's up?" she asked in her normal southern accent.

"Oh, I just wanted to tell you extra special news, but you have to keep it a secret" Pinkamena exclaimed, trying her best to maintain a Pinkie Pie-like hyperness. "Could we go out to the barn or somewhere secret?" she asked.

"Sure Pinkie" Applejack said, following the pink pony out to the barn. While all this was happening, Big Macintosh was listening to their conversation and knew something was up.

As Applejack took the lead into the barn, Pinkamena took out a hidden knife walked up to the orange mare in front of her. "So what was it you wanted to tell me?" she asked before spinning around to face the pink pony, now with straight hair and a knife.

"I was the one to kill Rainbow Dash, and now I'm going to kill you" Pinkamena growled. Applejack saw Big Mac in the door to the barn and nodded.

"No ya ain't" Before Pinkamena could react, Applejack round house kicked her and knocked her to the floor. The big red stallion ran in and pinned her to the floor, leaving her immobilized.

"I'm sorry, I was just kidding!" Pinkamena begged.

But Big Mac kept his secure grip on her. Think, think! Pinkamena saw her knife laying on the ground next to her head. She grabbed it between her teeth and stabbed the big stallion on top of her. He winced and jumped away from Pinkamena.

An evil smile spread across her face and she lunged out at Applejack, stabbing her deeply in the shoulder. She yelled out in pain and fell to the ground.

Big Macintosh rammed into the pink mare and pinned her on her back. "Bad move" she mocked and kicked him hard in the groin. She then slid from underneath him and rushed back over to her real victim.

Pinkamena pulled her knife from Applejack's shoulder and trotted back over to the red stallion, stabbing him multiple times in the chest. Blood splattered across the walls and quickly spread on the ground. "No! Big Machintosh!" Apple yelled out for her big brother who was quickly dying.

The frightened look in his slowly changed into an emotionless one. As Pinkamena saw the life leave Big Mac's eyes, she felt so...happy.

Applebloom heard the commotion and rushed out to investigate. "Big Mac, Applejack!" she screamed, then looked over to Pinkamena.

"Applebloom, no!" Applejack yelled, but it was to late. The young filly had already chased after the murderous pony. Pinkamena twisted her head, breaking her neck and causing an instant death for the young pony.

"Pinkie, you killed my big brother, little sister, and one of my-- our best friends, why are you doing this?" Applejack asked, wincing as she forced herself to stand and face Pinkamena.

Pinkamena said nothing but just trotted over to the wounded pony. She stabbed Applejack in the stomach and she fell to the ground once again. "Entertainment" She said with a psychotic smile. She spun the injured pony on her back and carefully cut a circle around the area of Applejack's heart.

Pain jolted through her as Pinkamena exposed her heart. "It takes a lot of practice to do this with the pony still living and breathing." AJ knew what this meant, she's done a lot of killing, "Now for the fun part" she said as dug her hand into the opening in AJ's chest. Painful screams filled the air and satisfied the pink pony. Pinkamena pulled out her hoof, covered in blood, and showed Applejack her still beating heart before her vision went black.

The blood stained pink pony stared at the three dead ponies surrounding her. A psychotic laugh filled the air and echoed out into the night sky. This was becoming to much fun for Pinkamena, she couldn't wait to destroy her next victim.

The evil smile faded away she trotted over to the bloody knife on the floor, picking it up and hiding it safely. She left the barn swiftly ran through the shadows, similar to how she did before.

Once inside Sugercube Corner, Pinkamena rushed to the shower and washed away all the blood covering her pink coat. She also cleaned her knife and hid it where it originally was. The pink pony rushed into her bed and instantly fell back into a peaceful sleep.

The next morning, there was a knock at the door and Pinkie rushed down the stairs to answer it. Upon opening the door, she saw only three ponies: Twilight Sparkle, Rarity, Fluttershy. "W-where's AJ?" Pinkie Pie asked anxiously.

"Pinkie....Applejack, Big Machintosh, and Applebloom were found dead in their barn this morning..." Twilight said.

Pinkie began crying uncontrollably again and she was comforted by the mares standing before her. She pushed them away, knowing that she was the one that heartlessly killed the innocent ponies. "I'm...so...sorry..." Pinkie murmured softly.

Author's Note

This was kind of an interesting Chapter to write, but I hope you enjoyed.