What if the real Pinkie Pie was the one sent to the Mirror Pond. What if in spite of her desperate efforts, the true Element of Laughter was wrongly banished to an unknown, mysterious realm where no light shines, no laughter heard, no magic enchanted. Desperate to stay alive, she clings to one thought repeated over and over again: I'm real…

It is not long that she has to come to terms with living inside a hollow pocket dimension. Yet for some reason, Pinkie learns that she is not alone. As the secrets of the Mirror Pond are reveal, Pinkie Pie's only escape my be a price too heavy to be paid.