Rarity's Game of Cat and Mouse

by TheOldPonyFromScene24

Rating: teen
Tags: Applejack, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Comedy, Rarity, Romance, Slice of Life
Length: 2642

Rarity just KNOWS Applejack is in love with her. Now she has to get her to admit it.

She knew what Applejack wanted. She'd known since she saw the look on the earth mare's face when she stared into the unicorn's eyes, weeks ago. Now she just had to make her admit it.

A gift for a friend, but I hope other people can enjoy it too.

Did you guys know Rarity is, like, crazy fun to write?

Update: Hey, cool, somebody did a dramatic reading! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lSxF5oQFDXU

Published 2014-01-21 23:20:05 UTC
Last updated 2014-01-21 23:20:05 UTC

Chapter 1

Dedicated to the head admin from the role play chat I frequent, who asked if I'd written any Rarijack. You know who you are, boss.

There was a thick, tense atmosphere in the Carousel Boutique as Rarity stood before her mirror. She lifted her lipstick with her magic, then quickly set it back down with a whine of annoyance. Sixty three shades from all the top brands sat before her on her vanity, and not one of them was right for the occasion! If she didn't figure out which one to wear soon, she would have to go without lipstick! It had already taken hours to choose the right eyeshadow! She was running out of time! She desperately scanned the rows and columns of assembled tubes. She couldn't be imperfect for this. Not with all the work she'd done to set it up!

A loud knock came at her door. Oh no. She was too late! She'd have to rely only on her natural beauty, and, copious though it was, it could never give her the same sense of confidence as her name brands! Still, she rushed downstairs and threw the door open, immediately regretting it and trying to look like she hadn't hurried. There she was, standing proudly with a small cart strapped to her barrel.

“Applejack...” Rarity mumbled, the earth mare's name coming out thick with desire. She quickly caught herself staring, and regained her poise. “Hello! Thank you ever so much for coming by!” The farmer gingerly loosened the straps of her cart and slipped out of the harness.

“No problem, Rarity. Ah'm just sorry yer trip got canceled!” Applejack answered, hefting large rolls of fabric out of the cart, the unicorn grabbing a few with her magic and heading upstairs. The trip was, of course, not canceled. This had all been orchestrated by the brilliant, detail oriented mind of Rarity the unicorn.

Rarity smiled smugly to herself as she led Applejack upstairs. 'Claim that you have a trip, and a large order of fabric will be coming in while you're gone, check. Get Applejack to agree to have them deliver the order to her home and bring it by the boutique, check.' She looked over her shoulder as they reached the top of the steps, Applejack's powerful tail pinning the rolls down onto her own back.

'Lament the cancellation of your so-called trip, and apologize profusely for being unable to change the shipping address of your order, check. Last step, Rarity.' She fumbled a little with her hooves, not willing to divide her magic between the heavy cloth and the doorknob. 'Get Applejack to admit to seeing you as the object of her desire, and begin the most wonderful courtship Ponyville has ever seen? Soon-to-be checked.'

The pair set down the rolls in Rarity's workshop, and the unicorn walked suspiciously close to the earth mare. “Honestly, Applejack, I can't thank you enough....” She fluttered her eyelids seductively, taking a slightly submissive posture. “If there is ever anything I can do for you, please, don't hesitate to ask....Anything at all...”

“Naw, don't you worry none, Rarity! Y'know Ah'm always happy t'help a friend!” A powerful forelimb patted Rarity on the back. The unicorn's mind was filled with screams of inarticulate frustration as her lips pouted softly, her head angled downward a bit.

“Applejack, I insist on repaying you, and I absolutely will not take 'no' for an answer.”

“Ah told you, Rarity, it's fine! What're friends for, after all?” The word 'friend' was like an exquisitely cut diamond having its veracity tested by being used to carve initials into the glass of Rarity's heart! Still, she would persevere. There was nothing that would stop her from getting Applejack to tell her how she felt!

“Applejack, it is because we're friends that I'm being so insistent! Tell me, how would you feel if one of us had done something so generous and kind for you, only to deny you any chance to repay them?” A spark of ingenuity flashed through Rarity's brain. It was all she could do to keep from cackling maniacally at the idea.

“Look me in the eyes...” She fluttered her eyelids as she spoke softly. “Tell me, honestly, that there is absolutely nothing that you want from me...” Applejack rolled her eyes, and looked into Rarity's own.

“Rarity, Ah don't need....uh...” She started to look away, having some trouble thinking while staring into those shimmering blue eyes, but she had to make eye contact while refusing her... for whatever reason. “Ah don't....” Her cheeks began to flush. “Tha...That is ta say....” She could feel the sweat beading on her brow. “There's....Ah...” A lump formed in her throat. She had to get out of there! “APPLES!” She dashed down the stairs and out the door.

“....So close.” Rarity said, a grin plastered irrevocably upon her lips. “You may not have confessed your love, darling....but you've told me far more than you might think...”

She walked over to her desk, pushing some dress designs aside, and began to write out ideas. How could she get to Applejack...If she could just get her alone for a moment, a moment where the farmer couldn't simply take off running, she'd have her. There was no doubting that. She'd have liked it if the fake canceled trip plan had worked flawlessly, of course. She was rightfully very proud of the clever story she'd managed to spin, in addition to which, it had the added benefit of giving her dozens of potential dresses, just waiting to be made. Sadly, a story that complex couldn't be easily repeated. Not without raising suspicion.

'How to go about this,' she thought to herself, looking at all the possible connections that could bring them closer together. 'Sweetie Belle and Apple Bloom are good friends, and Sweetie is often eager to please...On the other hand, I can't try to force my sister to be a part of this...Can I? No, perish the thought. Sweetie Belle is innocent, and I will not tarnish that, even if she doesn't know what's going on.' She stepped away from her desk and began pacing around the room. 'I just need something, something to start a conversation, some reason to meet with her, but where would I--' Something on the floor caught her eye and the corners of her lips turned up mischievously. 'Applejack, you're making this so easy...'

Meanwhile, half way across town, Applejack burst through a door, slid under a table, curled up, and began hyperventilating. 'Was she flirtin' with me!? She can't be flirtin' with me! Why...why do I care if she...Was she...What...GET AHOLD A' YERSELF APPLEJACK. She ain't gonna be flirtin' with ya cuz she don't feel that way! If she did, she'da said somethin, and you two would be doin' all kinds'a romantic whatnot together! Don't you be gettin' that nonsense in your head! She was just bein' polite! And if you think diff'rent, yer liable to ruin yer friendship!'

Twilight came into the room to find the source of the noise, looked down at the intruder with no small amount of shock at how nervous the confident, steadfast farmer appeared.

“Applejack...Are you OK?” She asked, sounding even more worried than she looked.

“Ah like trees!” She began to explain, eyes darting around nervously. “Spent mah whole life with 'em! Make me feel safe! Needed the biggest tree Ah could find! Sorry fer burstin' in!”

“It's fine...Is there anything I can help you with?”

“Absolutely not!” Applejack frowned as she saw Twilight cringe from her shouting. “Ah'm sorry, Twi... 'sjust somethin' Ah oughta handle on my own.” She slowly stood, beginning to calm down. Her knees were still shaking after the run in with Rarity. She stared at them, trying to get them to behave, and when she looked back up, Twilight stared at her flatly.

“Do you remember the last time I offered help when you were acting strange, and you didn't accept it?” Before Applejack could answer, a banner reading 'Applebuck Season' floated in, engulfed in purple magic, hovering above Twilight's head. The earth mare let out a frustrated sigh, not questioning why Twilight had the banner ready in the first place.

“Ah know, Ah know! But this ain't like that! It ain't about me bein' too proud, it's....It's just private, is all...” Twilight looked her over for a moment.

“...Did something happen at Rarity's?”

“Ah...How did you know Ah was over there!?” She sputtered, shocked.

“Magic?” Twilight offered playfully, hoping to ease the tension. As Applejack glared at her, she sighed softly and gave in. “Alright, fine. I can tell just by looking that you recently washed your hooves, but it's not close to meal time, and you washed all four of them. You were trying to avoid tracking dirt.” Another glare. “OK, OK, you smell like the boutique.”

“Consarned frou-frou fragrances...Look, Twi, Ah know y'wanna help, and any other day, Ah'd be happy t'accept, but this is really 'tween me an' Rarity.” She headed for the door, having calmed down substantially by this point. “Ah'll see y'later, Twilight.” Twilight just stared after her.

“Any other day....Any other day....hm....” This WAS a mystery! She needed to consult a calendar as soon as possible.

Applejack headed home, glad to be done with Rarity for the day. She cared deeply for her, just as she did all her friends, but she could not deal with seeing her again so soon. She walked in the front door and breathed a sigh of relief. “Ah'm home!” She called out. Rounding a corner, she froze in her tracks at the sight of Rarity standing next to the most uncomfortably awkward looking Big Macintosh she'd ever seen. And what was that in Rarity's hoof? Was...was that...

Applejack quickly turned her head backward to see her tail hanging free and open. Before she had a chance to figure out exactly how it happened, the unicorn moved behind her and began correcting it, magically holding all of a blushing Applejack's tail hairs together, and gently slipping the small band of red cloth around the end. Happy to have his sister home to get the attention off of him, Big Macintosh quickly headed out to do some work.

Rarity stayed behind her, still fiddling with the tail a little. “...Applejack, you are so very, very lucky...” she said softly, now stroking the tail.

“Ah...Wuh?” Came her well reasoned and eloquent response.

“Do you have any idea how much work and money most mares have to put forth to get their hair so voluminous and vibrant? So soft and silky?” She asked, smiling softly and staring into those brilliant green eyes. She spoke as if she had something seductive caught in her throat, and was pushing it out a little more with each word. “And, not to offend, but I doubt you do a thing to get it this way... Quite frankly, I'm jealous...”

“U-uh....R-Rarity, yer makin' me a mite uncomfortable...”

“What could possibly be making you uncomfortable, Applejack? I'm simply paying a compliment to one of the ponies closest to me. And an honest one, at that...”

“W-well, y'see, y'keep strokin' mah tail, an...an' makin' them eyes at me, an' osh kud luffi bugh--” Did her tongue start swelling? Or did it just go numb? Rarity stared at her, but quickly tried to get back on course.

“...Applejack...Did you ever want something from somepony? Did you ever have something you desired so much, but could never take for yourself?” She moved away from the tail, moving closer and closer to her face. “I'd be willing to give it to you...”

“Warghibly!” Applejack replied, dashing into the bathroom and locking the door. Rarity walked over to a table and daintily slammed her forehead on it. She swallowed her frustration and approached the bathroom door.

“Applejack? Are you--”

“BLARRRFFF!”

“...Oh dear!” She stepped back in alarm.

'Way t'go, Applejack. Way t'keep a handle on them nerves,' the earth mare thought sarcastically. “Ah'll be fi—BLARRRRR!.....” She whimpered. “....Ah think that's all...”

Rarity waited patiently as the farmer composed herself, cleaned up, brushed her teeth, and exited the restroom. Her eyes were waiting there to wow Applejack the moment she came out, but their target avoided eye contact. 'Look at my eyes...come on....look at my eyes dammit! Wait, Rarity, patience is the key here...' “...Is something wrong?”

“Uh...Nope! Nothin' at all!” She lied horribly. “What makes y'think somethin' might be wrong?”

“Well, you're not looking me in the eye for one...” She said, smiling to herself.

'That's cuz Ah'm afraid of what Ah might do if I looked...' Applejack thought. She cleared her throat, and, in the interest of buying herself some time, began coughing into her hoof.

“Applejack, clearly something is on your mind. If you can be honest with yourself about what it is, I'll be generous enough to lend you my ear.” She smiled sweetly.

Applejack swallowed audibly and looked Rarity in the eyes. “Ah....”

“Yes, Applejack?” She urged, moving a little closer.

“Ah...Ah...” She clenched her eyes shut. She couldn't do this! Rarity was....was Rarity! She'd never love a farmer! She wanted those fancy stallions up in Canterlot, not a simple mare in Ponyville! Applejack had to quash these stupid dreams of romance befo—why did she feel warm? Why did it feel like somepony'd wrapped their forelegs around her?

She hesitantly opened her eyes to find that not only was she in Rarity's embrace, but somehow she'd begun hugging back. The question of whether it was instinctive or her forelegs were the target of unicorn witchery quickly vanished as she realized that Rarity's cheek was pressed against her own. She pulled back a bit, and the unicorn instantly pulled her in tighter for a moment before letting her go.

Rarity watched her soon-to-be-more-than-just-a-friend expectantly, a delicate smile on her lips. “I'm sorry for interrupting... What were you saying, Applejack?” She waited, starting to lose hope, as the farmer stuttered and stumbled over her words.

“Ah...Tha-that is...Ah'm....A-an' yer....Ah....” Just as Rarity was finally about to give up, Applejack threw her hat to the ground in frustration. “CONSARN IT ALL!” She grabbed Rarity in her powerful hooves and kissed her! It was no kiss for the ages, a small, timid, thing, clumsy for a lack of experience, but Rarity was sure she felt her heart skipping a beat when it happened. Applejack released the seamstress, clenching her eyes and teeth shut. “....Ah love ya, Rarity...” She let out weakly.

“I know.” Came a confident and tender reply. “And I love you too, Applejack...” She gently returned the kiss and stood calmly before her.

Applejack's head swam with love and elation, but a few questions seemed to worm their way to the forefront of her mind. “Wait, y'knew? How long!?”

“Oh, a few weeks, dear.”

“How did y'know!?” She demanded, feeling mortified. “If y'knew, why didn't y'say anything? Why'd y'wait for me to say it? Why'd you put me through all this today when y'coulda just told me y'loved me back?!”

“I knew because it was quite frankly written all over your face. I didn't say anything because I didn't want to scare you off or embarrass you by bringing up the issue. And as for your last point...I do not simply...confess to other ponies. No, no. Other ponies confess to Rarity. But I am more than willing to reciprocate.” She locked eyes with Applejack, ire and humiliation being burned away in the earth pony, who finally sighed in defeat.

“...This is gonna suck, ain't it?”

“At times, undoubtedly. But I'm certain we'll enjoy more than we'll regret.”

Applejack nodded, leaned in, and nuzzled against her new fillyfriend, as Rarity began to wonder just how much easier all of this would have been if she could have just picked the right shade of lipstick!