The Missing Pony Caper

THE KILLER REVEALED!

Twilight awoke with a start finding herself chained to a wall in a dark room. As her eyes adjusted she looked around as things slowly came into focus. The walls were covered in mantles with different pony parts some where heads, others were legs, and even some were pony genitals both male and female.

“Oh my. You're awake. That's just so great Twilight. Now we can have fun...i mean if that's okay with you. Oh it is? Great!” A soft whispering voice spoke up from the darkness and the light flashed on.

“No....freaking....way.....it's not possible” Twilight said trailing off with each word she spoke.

“Oh dear me. Is something wrong? I hate keeping you chained up like this but I can't just having you run off and tell on little old me....” The voice spoke up as the pony slowly came into view.

Twilight was in shock. It wasn't possible. It couldn't be! It was the pony she least suspected in the all of Equestia. But the proof was in the pudding as the pony began to walk over to a small table that was littered with some surgical tools,small saw,pliers, and knives of multiple sizes.

“Oh come on Twilight. No need to look shocked. Then again I guess I would be shocked to.” The pony said picking up the small saw and looked at Twilight with a sinister grin. “Especially if thought you could never hurt a fly...” The pony said as she walked over to her.

“F-F-Fluttershy?! You can't be the killer! It doesn't make sense!” Twilight exclaimed in disbelief.

“Oh it doesn't? Then let me explain it to you while I get rid of this pesky little horn” Fluttershy said as she took the saw to Twilight's horn and began to slowly cut into it. Twilight gave a shrill cry of pain as the saw began to dig into her horn while fresh blood began to stream from it down her forehead then onto her face.

“Who's house is just past sugar cube corner Twilight?” Fluttershy asked as she continued to saw off Twilight's horn. “Mine. Why did you find the corpse in the middle of the alley yesterday?” Fluttershy said nearly half way through sawing off Twilight's horn now as blood was flooding from it coating Fluttershy's hooves, Twilight's hair, and her face then dropping from her chin to the floor sounding like a faucet with a steady stream of water hitting the floor.

Twilight couldn't think strait her head was spinning from the combined effects of the extreme pain she was in, the realization of the fact that Fluttershy who she thought could never hurt a fly was actually the killer, and she was on the verge of passing out.

“Oh dear me. Don't pass out twilight. At least...not yet. I want to hear you're screams of pain as I cut you open...” Fluttershy said as she stopped cutting off Twilight's horn leaving it hanging by a thread from her head, went to her table grabbed a shot of adrenaline, walked back over to her and jabbed her in the side. Causing twilight to suddenly become wide awake but still dazed.

“Now as I was saying.....” Fluttershy said tossing the vial of adrenaline to the side which made a small clattering sound as it hit the cement floor. “You found that body because I wanted you too. I wanted you to think it was Pinkie Pie who killed that pony. But you being the loyal friend you were refused to...” Fluttershy said with a smile then looked up the horn still hanging by a thread.

Fluttershy then reached up with both hooves and yanked it off earning a shrill and agonizing scream from Twilight. “You know. You are one of my best friends Twilight...I never wanted you to be here but you didn't listen to Applejack. You should have kept you're nose out of affairs that don't concern you.” Fluttershy said as she walked over to her table and laid Twilight's horn on it then picked up a surgical knife.

“What...about....the...Piano?” Twilight asked in a dazed tone.

“Oh, that had nothing to do with me. That silly Derpy Hooves was being a klutz again...” Fluttershy replied nonchalantly.

“Where's Spike?” Twilight asked in the same dazed tone as her eyes went in and out of focus staring at Fluttershy.

“Oh him? He wasn't too much fun to play with. But since you want to know.” Fluttershy said,walked over to the corner of the dark room out of sight for a moment and came back with something on her back.

Twilight's eyes widened in horror even though she couldn't keep them focused she could tell that what was on Fluttershy's back was Spike however it was a lifeless version of him.

“See. He was so cute and adorable I couldn't ruin that. So I stuffed him and now he makes the most wonderful stuffed dragon! You want to hug him Twilight?” Fluttershy said with a smile as she reached to her back, stood on her hind hooves and hugged the lifeless stuffed spike tightly at which point one of his eyes popped out of it's socket with a sickening squishing sound and fell to the floor. “Oh dear me. I'll have to fix that later.” Fluttershy said with a smile as she put the stuffed Spike on her back and walked out of sight again and came back into view a few moments later.

“Now if you don't mind. May I continue? I can? Thank you! You were always ever so nice to me Twilight!” Fluttershy said with a smile not giving Twilight a chance to reply. “When I found you outside of Apple Acres I figured I would try and make you think it was Applejack but silly me got caught up in the moment...” Fluttershy said as she picked up the surgical knife she put down earlier when she went to go get the stuffed spike. “Good thing Winona was there huh? If she hadn't attacked me when she did then we wouldn't be able to have this wonderful time together.” Fluttershy said as she took the knife and ran the flat part along Twilight's face, down her neck, past her chest and to her lower regions as she knelt down. “Oh my. Twilight. You're vagina looks so wonderful.” Fluttershy said with a smile looking up at Twilight then back down to it. “It looks so cute covered in purple fur...are you a virgin still?” Fluttershy asked standing up to face her again.

Twilight however didn't reply. She was overwhelmed at the moment by fear and panic of what Fluttershy was going to do to her. “You know it's rude not to reply to your best friend's questions Twilight...” Fluttershy said running the sharp end over her stomach now and without warning jabbed the tip in but not deeply causing Twilight to cry out. “Now why don't you answer me?” Fluttershy said with a giggle.
“Y-yes...” Twilight replied in a pained tone.

“Oh dear me. You poor thing...that won't do at all. I mean I wouldn't want my best friend to die without knowing what it's like to enjoy the pleasures of sex....” Fluttershy said as she walked over to the table, laid the knife down, then went to a cabinet which was located a few feet away from the table.

“Which one? Hmm...oh I know! This one!” Fluttershy could be heard saying as she fumbled around with something in her cabinet then emerged a few moments later wearing what looked like a strap-on with a male pony cock on it.

Twilight saw this and her eyes widened in horror. “Oh don't worry. The pony who had this won't need it anymore. And I made sure to clean it and everything.” Fluttershy said with a smile as she walked over to Twilight and stood on her hind hooves positioning the strap-on just outside of Twilight's entrance. “Now this will sting a bit but afterword it will feel ever so wonderful!” Fluttershy said with a deep blush and thrust the dildo in to the hilt breaking Twilight's hymen causing Twilight to arch back as she cried out in pain.

“Fluttershy...please...stop...it hurts...” Twilight said as tears of both emotional and psychical pain flooded through her.

“I said it would hurt at first you silly filly. But now that the painful part is over the real fun can begin.” Fluttershy said with a smile and a blush as she began to thrust in and out of Twilight's vagina.

“No...please...stop it! I can't take this! You're my best friend! Why are you doing this to me?!” Twilight exclaimed between sobs as Fluttershy picked up a rhythm as she continued to thrust the dildo in and out of Twilight's newly deflowered vagina.

“Oh Twilight. You're my best friend. That's why. I couldn't just let you die without knowing how it felt to have a male pony's dick between your legs. That would just be oh so horrible of me.” Fluttershy said followed by a soft moan.

Fluttershy continued thrusting each time giving a soft moan each time as Twilight silently sobbed. “Oh Twilight...you're getting wet finally...i can feel it...” Fluttershy said putting a hoof over Twilight's vagina as she thrust in and ran the same hoof along her cheek.

Twilight's eyes shot open as she felt something warm and wet run along her cheek. It couldn't be possible. Her body was betraying her. No matter how much she screamed in her mind that she wasn't enjoying this her body was saying otherwise.

“N-no....” Twilight said in a half moan. Her body now had completely betrayed her. It was loving the feeling while she in her mind was screaming for it to stop.

“I knew you'd warm up to it eventually Twilight. You spent so much time reading books. your body must have so much pent up lust. It's must be unbearable....” Fluttershy said with a smile as she began to speed up.

Twilight by now was moaning with each thrust while tears of emotional pain continued flooding from her eyes despite the fact the rest of her body was lit up like a match in pleasured bliss.

“Are you close Twilight? I know I am..” Fluttershy said between pants.

Meanwhile Twilight's mind began to fog up as her body grew closer and closer to climax with each thrust until she gave an orgasmic cry.

“That's it Twilight cum for me!” Fluttershy exclaimed hitting her climax as well.

“Ah,ah..no,no....uhh!” Twilight said in a pained yet pleasured voice as her body road out it's climax while her legs involuntarily clamped down on the strap-on.

Fluttershy pulled out of Twilight with a content sigh on her face and walked over to her cabinet. Meanwhile Twilight looked down at her lower regions which were coated in her cum still dripping from her vagina.

Fluttershy emerged a few moments later from the shadows, walked over to the table, picked up the surgical knife again and walked over to Twilight. “I hope you enjoyed that. Now we can continue with the fun we were having earlier...” Fluttershy said with a smile once again running the flat part of the knife along her body.

Twilight still recovering from her orgasm panted and gasped fear and panic once again consuming her quickly replacing the blissful afterglow feeling she had.

“Lets start with those cute little ears of yours...” Fluttershy said with a smile running the knife along her face then abruptly taking the sharp end of the knife to her right ear.

Twilight let out a scream of pure agony as Fluttershy began to carve at her right ear slowly causing blood to gush from it. “I don't want to be to rash when removing this ear Twilight. It would be oh so horrible if it was damaged.” Fluttershy said in a sweet voice even though Twilight continued to shriek and cry out in pain.

After what seemed like a lifetime of torment ended abruptly as Twilight's ear came off with a sickening slashing sound. The part that used to be Twilight's ear was bleeding profusely now stinging and aching as Twilight sobbed loudly in pain.

Fluttershy walked back to the table placed her ear next to the horn and walked back.”Time for that other cute little ear.” Fluttershy said in a sweet tone and began to cut at it causing Twilight to shriek and cry out in agony as fresh pain surged through her.

“Just kill me! I can't take it!” Twilight screamed at the top of her lungs as Fluttershy continued to work at her left ear.

“Oh I can't do that Twilight. This is just too much fun. If I killed you then I couldn't hear you're reactions to my little game I’m playing. And that would be oh so sad for me.” Fluttershy said as she finished cutting off her left ear, walked over the the table, and laid it down next to her horn.

“Why are you doing this?” Twilight said between sobs after a few moments becoming light headed from the amount of blood she was losing.

“Because I have to continue my teachers work Twilight. He was ever so wonderful to me. He showed me all these fun games. He was the best pony you could ever meet. He loved me like no other. Our first time was when I was a small filly. Even though he couldn't fit all the way in we shared a love like no other. I then decided I would do anything for him. He taught me everything he knew.” Fluttershy said with a blissful smile.

“You....won't...get..away..with..this...” Twilight said between huffs and puffs her voice slurring now due to the mass amount of blood she was losing.

“Oh I know. I'll eventually be caught. I know this. That's why my teacher taught me the most important part of playing these games with ponies. I must pass along the knowledge he gave me to another so that his work can continue.” Fluttershy said with a smile taking a clean knife off the table.

“You...have...an.... apprentice....too?” Twilight said weakly as she was slowly losing consciousness.

“Oh, yes. She an ever so sweet filly. And i've already taught her everything I know. She will continue my work many years later after i'm caught.” Fluttershy said and took note of Twilight's steadily loss of consciousness. “Oh dear me. You can't pass out yet. The best part is about to begin.” Fluttershy said with a smile, put down the knife, picked up another vial of adrenaline, walked over to her, and jabbed into her neck making her wide awake again nearly instantly.

“Now then...” Fluttershy said as she picked up the knife again from the table,walked over to Twilight and ran the knife along her chest deeply causing Twilight's eyes to shoot open and cry out in pain as she felt the knife run through her skin like a hot knife through butter.

Fluttershy cut along Twilight's chest gliding the knife down and around in a circular motion but stopped before she made a complete circle, pealed the fur and skin back revealing a flood of blood and Twilight's internal organs. “This is the ever so much funniest part Twilight. I get to see how many of your organs I can remove before you die.” Fluttershy said with a smile.

Twilight looked down to see the flap of skin as well as her internal organs and literally vomited the contents of her stomach onto the floor in front of her nearly hitting Fluttershy with it. “Oh my. Twilight that was ever so wonderful. I just got to see your stomach spasm and convulse. It was ever so neat to watch.” Fluttershy said with a giggle.

“I think...i was...right..when..i said....this when I first met you ponies...YOU'RE CRAZY!” Twilight exclaimed in a pained voice.

“Now..what shall I take out first. I don't want to remove anything vital just yet...after all I don't want you to die too quickly.” Fluttershy said with a smile as she ran the knife along her insides.

By now there was a puddle of blood at Twilight's feet as she looked around the room trying her best not to focus on Fluttershy. Her body felt numb now though. She wasn't sure if her body was finally shutting down or what. Part of her wished she would just die from blood loss. So she wouldn't have to endure anymore or this. While another part of her wanted somepony...anypony to come and save her from the psychopathic pony.

Fresh pain however shot her back into reality that she was in fact not numb as Fluttershy began to carve out her kidney causing her to cry out in pain. “This is useless anyways. Nopony knows what it's really used for anyways.” Fluttershy said with a giggle as she continued to carve out her kidney.
Twilight's body began to convulse uncontrollably now as her eyes rolled back into her head due to the extreme and agonizing pain she was in as well as the blood loss.

“Oh dear me Twilight..are you going to kick the bucket on me already?” Fluttershy said as she lifted stood up on her hind hooves to show her her bleeding kidney.

Twilight's vision was completely gone now she couldn't see anything however even though she could no longer see anything what was left of her ears could hear a faint sound of a door being rammed down and Fluttershy's faint shocked cry followed by a flood of hooves before she finally lost consciousness...

Twilight's eyes fluttered open weakly as vision slowly began to come back into focus. She saw Applejack, Rarity,Pinkie Pie, and Rainbow Dash sitting in chairs beside her bed. She realized she was in a hospital room with an IV in one arm.

“Hey Y'all she's wakin up!” Applejack said in a excited and happy voice.

“W-What...happened?” Twilight asked wearily.

“Well, after you got dragged away by that cloaked pony we tried to get out of those shackles you put us in. Thanks to Rarity the others were able to follow you and Fluttershy to her cottage while I went for help.” Rainbow Dash said with a smile.

“But we had no idea where she was hiding at. We searched all over the place. But would couldn't find you. It wasn't until we heard you scream out that we figured out that she had a trap door under the floorboards.” Rarity chimed in with a smile.

“Then we all rushed the door at once all and tackled Fluttershy to the ground before she could react!” Pinkie Pie exclaimed with a smile.

“When I got back with the Police ponies we came down and I helped them take the chains off you and we rushed you here got you patched up and all. It's a good thing she hadn't gotten to anything vital but you lost some much blood you weren't going make it.” Rainbow Dash said in a dramatic voice.

“So we all volunteered to donate blood to you! And here you are! All safe and sound!” Pinkie Pie exclaimed with a smile.

“Thanks guys....I’m so sorry I thought you were the killers.” Twilight said with a tearful smile.

“Hey, don't y'all worry your cute little head about it ya hear?” Applejack replied placing a hoof on her cheek with a smile.

“I still can't believe Fluttershy was the killer..I’ve known her since we were fillies. I thought I knew everything about her....” Rainbow Dash said after a few moments with a shocked expression yet saddened expression.

“It's alright Dashy. At least it over now.” Pinkie pie said with a smile.

“I hope so....” Twilight said with a sigh then let out a small gasp. “They don't know about her apprentice! But then again... Fluttershy was a complete psychopath maybe she was spouting off nonsense...” Twilight thought to herself....

OR WAS SHE?

THE END?