The Missing Pony Caper

by Deathsia

Rating: mature
Tags: Thriller, Mystery, Tragedy, Horror, Sex, Twilight Sparkle, Gore, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Dark
Length: 9231

A pony goes missing in Ponyville and Twilight takes it on herself to find out why.

A pony goes missing in Ponyville and Twilight takes it on herself to find out why. However the closer she gets to solving it the more she wonders about her new friends and what they might be hiding...

Published 2012-03-20 09:14:01 UTC
Last updated 2012-03-20 09:14:01 UTC

THE MISSING PONY CAPER

TWILIGHT SPARKLE AND SPIKE THE DRAGON STARING IN:

THE MISSING PONY CAPER

It was a bright and sunny day in Ponyville as Twilight Sparkle woke up bright and early to get ready for a new day to spend with her friends. “A little too early.....” Twilight remarked looking out her window as the sun hadn't even come up yet. However she was awake so she figured she had no reason to go to back to sleep. As she looked out her window she noticed a pony wrapped in a bunch of cloths making it impossible to see who it was, but what made it suspicious was the fact the pony was dragging a large sack that looked as if something living was kicking inside of it.

Twilight immediately rushed down the stairs and out her front door to confront the pony but there were already gone. “I must be imaging things....wake up girl! You're seeing things!” Twilight thought to herself letting out a sigh.

Later that day Twilight headed into town once the sun was up and Ponyville was bursting with activity today. “Wow. What's going on?” Twilight asked one pony who was looking around.

“Another pony has gone missing!” One pony said. “I thought it was over!” said another one. “Not this again!” said a third.

Just then Applejack came trotting up to the scene and saw the missing poster.” Another one? Why the hay does this keep happenin?” Applejack said with a sense of worry on her face then turned to see Twilight. “oh hey thar, Twilight.” Applejack said with a smile.

“I'm still new to Ponyville but does this happen often?” Twilight asked nervously.

“I wouldn't worry too much about it sugarcube. This kind of thing hasn't happened in years. It's just probably somepony who got lost in evergreen forest.” Applejack said however her voice wasn't all that convincing.

“I think we should investigate this. Princess Celesta would want to know if something has happened to her subjects.” Twilight replied.

“Now Twilight. I wouldn't be stickin my nose where it don't belong now. Leave this up to ponyville's finest. They'll figure it out.” Applejack replied and trotted off.

Twilight however decided she would try to figure out this missing pony caper herself. After all if it were one of Applejack's friends she would be worried about them wouldn’t she? Twilight immediately went back to her home to find Spike whom was just waking up. “Spike. I need you to take a note and send it to princess celesta.” Twilight said at which point Spike pulled out a paper scroll with a quill.

“Dear princess Celesta. I am writing to you out of concern for the ponies of Ponyville. There has been a mysterious disappearance and according to ponies around town this isn't the first time. Therefore I am going to perform my own investigation to get to the bottom of these disappearances. Your faithful student, Twilight Sparkle.” Twilight said finishing at which point Spike rolled up the scroll and blew fire on it sending it directly to princess celesta.

Moments later spike gave a loud belch at which point a rolled up scroll appeared from within the magical flames. Spike opened up the scroll and began to read it.

“To my Faithful student Twilight Sparkle, I too have heard of these mysterious disappearances and am concerned myself but I am unsure if it is such a good idea for a single pony such as yourself to get involved with such things. However I approve of your concern and therefore grant you permission to investigate this incident but use caution. Your proud mentor, Princess celesta.” Spike said and rolled up the scroll.

“Right. Lets get investigating.” Twilight said with a smile.

Ten minuets later.....

“Where do I even begin?” Twilight asked aloud in a discouraged tone.

“Well how about the place you said you saw that mysterious pony heading?” Spike suggested at which point Twilight's eyes lit up.

“Of course!” Twilight then charged in the direction that the pony was going earlier this morning which oddly lead her to Pinkie Pie's store.

“Why would it lead me here?” Twilight thought to herself but either way she entered the store and was immediately greeted Pinkie Pie who was smiling as usual.

“Hey, Twilight! Did you come to try some cupcakes? I just made them this morning! Yep! And I did a great job making them!” Pinkie Pie said with a smile hopping around Twilight.

“Sure, and maybe you could tell me if you saw anypony come by here early this morning.” Twilight asked her friend as she took a cupcake off the tray and bit into it.

“Oh? Nope! I didn't see anyone this morning! Why you ask Twilight?” Pinkie Pie asked curiously.

“Well a pony disappeared this morning and I think it may be connected to the pony I saw in cloths this morning carrying a sack towards this place.” Twilight replied and took one last bite of the cupcake finishing it.

“Ooohh.....hmmm...nope I don't know anypony who looks like that!” Pinkie Pie replied.

Just then Rarity opened the door and came in. “Why hello Twilight! You're looking absolutely stunning!” Rarity said with a smile before turning to Pinkie Pie. “Pinkie Pie. Is that special package ready yet?” Rarity asked Pinkie Pie.

“Yep! Let me go get it!” Pinkie Pie replied dashing to the back of her store.

“Special package?” Twilight asked curiously.

“Oh yes, well you know...I just love Pinkie Pie's cooking. So I make a special order now and then.” Rarity replied with a smile.

“Okay. Say Rarity. Do you mind if I come over and ask you a few questions later today?” Twilight asked in reply.

Just then Pinkie Pie came back with a gift wrapped red box. “Hear you go Rarity!” Pinkie Pie replied with a smile.

“Oh good gracious. I would Twilight but I am going to be very busy today and won't be able to have any visitors.” Rarity replied with a nervous smile then turned to Pinkie Pie.

“Now you did make sure the order was done right this time?” Rarity asked with stern stare.

“Yep! I even steam-dried them!” Pinkie Pie replied hoping about.

“Steam-dried?” Twilight asked raising an eyebrow in curiosity.

“Oh, well Pinkie Pie makes my orders a special way Twilight. I simply love my....-Cupcakes!” Pinkie Pie chimed in with a smile cutting off Rarity. “Yes. I simply love my cupcakes...steam-dried...” Rarity said with a smile firing a annoyed look at Pinkie Pie unknown to Twilight.

“Well I must be going now. Nice to see you Twilight.” Rarity said clearly looking as if she was in a rush,left the store, and closed the door behind her.

“Well Pinkie if you see anything suspicious let me know.” Twilight said as she opened the store door.

“Will do!” Pinkie Pie replied with a smile as Twilight left the store.

“Well that was a dead end.....” Twilight thought dismally to herself.

“Don't worry Twilight. I'm sure you'll stumble upon a clue any moment!” Spike said with a smile as they walked down the ally behind Pinkie Pie's store searching for clues store when Spike tripped and fell.

“Spike watch your footing would-” Twilight said with an annoyed look only to be cut off mid-sentence by what she saw with a gasp of horror.

The next thing just about all of Ponyville could hear was Twilight's ear piercing scream....

SOMEPONY WANTS TO KILL ME!

SOMEPONY WANTS TO KILL ME!

Twilight screamed at the top of her lungs in horror at the sight that beheld her. Laying before her that spike tripped over was non over than a pony's corpse horribly mutilated and missing it's head and hooves.

Spike whom tripped over it was frozen in shock and horror unable to speak let alone move at this horrifying sight.

Just then Pinkie Pie came running around the corner.”Twilight! Are you okay what's-gasp-” Pinkie Pie exclaimed in worry only to gasp in shock at the sight.

Hearing Pinkie Pie's voice seemed to jar Twilight out of her screaming as she rushed over to Pinkie Pie and hugged her tightly. “Golly....that's...scary. I can't laugh or giggle at that.” Pinkie Pie said with a stunned expression as Twilight hugged her sobbing.

Twilight's screaming had not only alerted Pinkie Pie though as Police ponies rushed to the scene at which point one of which gasped at the sight and the other got sick to their stomach and vomited on the ground.

About an hour later Twilight found herself in the Ponyvile police station next to Pinkie Pie as a Police Pony took down notes.

“Miss Sparkle I know you don't want to remember those events but I have to ask you one last question. Did you know that pony?” The police pony asked in a gentle and calm tone.

“N-no. At least I don't think so. It wa kind of hard to tell with it's head.....” Twilight said trailing off.

“Missing. Yes I understand. Thanks all for now Miss Sparkle. We'll contact you later if we find anything more. You should go home and get some rest.” The police pony said and patted her shoulder with a hoof.

“Come on Twilight. I'll come with you to your house.” Pinkie Pie said with a smile as Twilight began to walk out of the Police station.

Just as Twilight took a step out of the Police station Pinkie Pie grabbed Twilight and yanked her away from the side walk.

“My tail's a twitchin!” Pinkie Pie exclaimed as she yanked Twilight by the mane with her mouth and mere seconds later a Piano came crashing down with a loud crash.

“I don't need this today!” Twilight exclaimed horrified at the realization of her near death experience.

“My Pinkie senses saved you Twilight!” Pinkie Pie exclaimed with a smile.

“So I noticed....” Twilight remarked as Police ponies rushed out the door.

“Who in Equestria would be dropping Piano's in the middle of town?” One Police pony asked astonished.

“I can think of one....Damn Derpy Hooves....” The other officer said with an eye roll.

Pinkie Pie and Twilight began to make their way down the street towards Twilight's home. “I think i'm done with this investigating...that was too scary.” Twilight remarked as they neared her door only to notice a note with blood red letters stating:

YOU'RE NEXT

Twilight's eyes widened in horror as she read this.”I-I'm next? That means the killer knows I found out something and wants me dead!” Twilight exclaimed horrified.

“That's not good! What did you do find out Twilight?” Pinkie Pie asked looking at her.

“I don't know! I didn't even find out who the killer was! Unless....the body! I wasn't supposed to find the body! The killer must have panicked and ran when they heard me coming, ran off, and then I found the body!” Twilight exclaimed as panic enveloped her.

“But that means they want to kill me too! I saw the body as well! I better go see if there's a note on my door too! See you Twilight!” Pinkie Pie exclaimed and ran off in the blink of an eye before Twilight could stop her.

“P-Pinkie Pie! Don't leave me alone!” Twilight exclaimed in a panicked voice and began to look around herself for anything suspicious. After a few moments Twilight shakily opened her door and slowly took a step inside.

“S-Spike? Are you here?” Twilight asked timidly but there was no answer. Just dead silence.

“Twilight? Are you okay?” A voice asked causing Twilight to jump out of her skin nearly and run to the other side of the room only to realize it was Rainbow Dash.

“Oh. It's just you.” Twilight said after a few moments relief washing over her.

“Who else would be?” Rainbow Dash said with a smile.
“Didn't you see the note on my front door?” Twilight asked curiously.

“Nope. You were here when I got here so I let myself in and figured I’d wait for you to come back. Why what's wrong?” Rainbow Dash asked confused.

“Somepony wants me dead because I found the body of a dead pony.” Twilight replied and began to explain how she found the body and what happened outside of the police station.

“Oh wow. Don't worry Twilight. I'll stay with you. No pony tries to hurt my friends and gets away with it!” Rainbow Dash exclaimed standing proudly.

“Thanks Rainbow. I could use some company. Spike for some reason has gone missing...” Twilight trailed off and suddenly panic filled her again.”Oh no! What if the killer found Spike! I've got to find him!” Twilight exclaimed and ran for the door.

“Alright. I'll help you find him.” Rainbow Dash said following her out the door. “I'll search around town. You look around on the ground. We'll meet back her later. Okay?” Rainbow dash said with a smile.

“Okay.” Twilight replied with a worried look.

Twilight really didn't like the idea of looking for Spike alone but since Rainbow Dash was a Pegasus she figured she would have better chances of finding Spike than her. “I hope Spike is okay.” Twilight said in a worried tone.

Hours later Twilight was still searching but she saw no sign of Spike nor Rainbow Dash for that matter. “Wasn't Rainbow Dash supposed to meet me at my house? I've been by my house five times already and she still hasn't shown up.” Twilight thought to herself as she walked along the the path towards Apple Acres.

“Spike....where could you be?” Twilight asked aloud worried as she stopped and looked around.

Suddenly something lept from the bushes towards Twilight causing her to scream in horror only for it to be Winona whom was Applejack's Dog and let out a sigh.

Winona barked happily at Twilight with a smile as Twilight Knelt down and patted her on the head.

“Whew...for a moment I thought it was the-” Twilight said with a relived sigh only to be cut off by a knife stabbing the tree mere inches from her face and a heavily cloaked figure rushing from the bushes at her with another knife in her mouth.

Twilight had little time to react so she did the only thing that came to mind and put her hooves in front of her as she was tackled to the ground the knife pointed directly at her throat mere inches away. The only thing holding it off was Twilight's hooves which held the cloaked figures head away but barely.

Even though her attacker's face was right in front of her she couldn't tell who it was due to it being so heavily cloaked.

Twilight struggled with all her might to shove the pony off her but speaking as she wasn't the athletic type all she could manage was to keep knife from her throat which she was steadily losing enough strength to do that as the knife slowly edged closer to her neck.

Fear and panic were the only two emotions Twilight could feel at the moment as the knife grew dangerously closer now so that she could feel the point barely poking her neck now. “I'm going be killed if I don't do something!” Twilight thought in a panicked tone as she continued to struggle against the cloaked pony.

Twilight let out a pained cry as the very tip of the knife pierced her neck but did not go any farther drawing fresh blood.

Suddenly out of no where Winona lunged at her cloaked attacker knocking her to the side while at the same time causing the knife to slit her throat but not deeply. it was merely a surface cut but it bleed just the same. Twilight immediately got to her hooves and ran with all her might down the path not looking back as she sobbed loudly in horror.

After some time she arrived back in Ponyville and looked around herself, panic still flooding through her but she was exhausted from all her running. Slowly she made her way to a trove of water and looked at her reflection to survey the damage.

The cut wasn't bleeding now but it could be seen all the same. It had been a VERY CLOSE call for her. If Winona hadn't lunged at her attack when she had Twilight would have been a corpse right now. “I can't go to the police about this anymore...” Twilight thought to herself and began to walk towards her house. “At this rate the only way I’m going to live through this is if I find the killer and bring them to justice.” Twilight thought to herself as she walked up to her door only to find another note on it written in blood red letters.

YOU WON'T BE SO LUCKY NEXT TIME.....

Twilight gulped. How could the killer get here before her? Wasn't she tackled by Winona? It's not possible. The only possible explanation was that there was more than one killer. The mere thought of there being more than one killer horrified Twilight even more if possible. How many killers were there? And more importantly...who were they? These questions and more flooded Twilight's mind as she opened her door cautiously and looked around.

“Good gracious! What happened to your neck Twilight?!” a voice exclaimed once again causing Twilight to nearly jump out of her skin and run to the other side of her home only to find out it was Rarity.

“Rarity? Oh thank Celetsia its you.” Twilight replied after a few moments as her eyes focused to the darkness. “Did you see the note on my door?” Twilight asked after a few moments.

“Note? No I didn't. I got here hours ago. I finished my work and thought i'd come by and talk with you about what happened today.” Rarity replied.

“I was nearly killed twice today! Once with a Piano and just outside of Apple Acres at knife point!” Twilight exclaimed walking over to Rarity and sat down with her rump on the floor.

“Why don't you go the police about this Twilight?” Rarity suggested.

“I can't. If I do the killer may try to kill me again outside of the station like earlier. I have to figure this out on my own.” Twilight replied looking around herself.

“Goodness. This is not good. Can you at least tell Princess Celestia about this?” Rarity asked curiously.

“Without Spike I’d have to send the letter the old fashioned way and if the killer works for the post office they would just get rid of it anyways. Speaking of him. I hope he's okay....” Twilight said with a sigh, stood up, and began to concentrate.

“What are you doing Twilight?” Rarity asked curiously.

“Putting a protection spell around my house. No one in and no one out.” Twilight said as her horn began to emit a purple cloud of magic that expanded and flowed all over her house and over it. “That way I can at least try to get some sleep without worrying about the killer getting into my house while I’m sleeping and kill me.” Twilight explained and let out a sight as she finished casting the spell.

“Well I suppose that does make sense. I guess i'm stuck here for the night.” Rarity replied with a smile.

“Sorry about this Rarity.” Twilight replied as she began to walk towards her room.

“Don't worry about it darling. I wouldn't want to leave my friends alone with a killer on the loose anyways.” Rarity replied with a smile and magically made herself a make-shift bed out of pillows and books.

After hearing this Twilight walked over to Rarity and gave her a hug.”Thanks Rarity. That makes me feel a lot better.” Twilight said with a smile and made her way to her room.

Twilight tossed and turned in her bed and soon fell into an uneasy sleep...

Several hours later.......

Twilight was jolted awake by Rarity's ear piercing horrified scream that seemed to have been abruptly cut off. Twilight got out of bed as fear began to consume her again and suddenly felt wide awake as she slowly baby steps towards her door.

“R-R-Rarity? A-A-Are you okay?” Twilight asked in a scared voice stuttering as she spoke.

Just as she neared her door however several knives could be seen stabbing it and poking out causing Twilight to jump back as panic and fear completely overwhelmed her senses now. Moments later the door was shot off it's hinges and flew over Twilight's head.

Well it was obvious now that one of the killers was a unicorn at least but that didn't make matters any better as Twilight attempted to swallow her fears and took a fighting stance ready to cast a spell at a moments notice.

However several minuets passed and nothing had emerged through the door so Twilight going against her better judgment began to walk towards the doorway and slowly through it.

The barrier Twilight had put up clearly was gone now as she took another step into her front room. Twilight looked around for Rarity but saw no sign of her. “Did the killer just take her and leave?” Twilight thought to herself however this thought didn't make her feel any better. In fact it terrified her even more.

Twilight sat down and began to sob loudly she couldn't take it. It was too much. First Spike, then her, and now her friends? It was too much for one pony to bear for Twilight. What was she going to do? She had to figure out something.

Otherwise the killer was going to pick off each of her friends until sh was the only one left....

PUTTING THE CLUES TOGETHER...

PUTTING THE CLUES TOGETHER...

Twilight's eyes fluttered open as the sun hung high over her home. She had no idea how she had managed it. Maybe it was pure mental exhaustion or possibly just that she passed out due to lack of oxygen from hyperventilating so much. Either way she stood up wearily and looked around.

“Still no sign of Rarity....” Twilight thought to herself as worry and fear filled her again. Twilight took a few steps through her front room wondering how she was going to figure out who was the killer when suddenly she had an epiphany.

“You're in a library...Duh, Twilight!” Twilight said aloud to herself and began to concentrate to summon all the books relevant to criminals and criminal psychology to her. Moments later several books stacked themselves neatly in front of her and she began to read them.

Hours later....

“Ugh! All these books are useless!” Twilight said ejecting all the books around her in multiple directions with her magic in frustration and slammed her head into a book in front of her. A few moments later Twilight felt something hard land on her head and jolted up her head with one hoof on it rubbing it in pain as she looked towards her door to see a pony wearing a hooded cloak running off.

“Would you mind watching where you're throwing-eh?!” Twilight shouted in annoyance looking out the door then to the floor to see a portfolio in front of her. It wasn't titled but that didn't stop Twilight from opening it. Judging by it's condition it seemed to be pretty old. Twilight figured it had to be at least fifty years old if not more. The photos inside it were black and white with letters written on the side of each photo.

The first photo Twilight saw was a disturbing photo of a Pegasus pony with it's wings completely severed from it's back. “My very first....he was special....i'll never forget the rush of seeing the life drain from this pony's eyes...so exciting...” the words said aside of this picture.

The next photo was of a young filly with her legs spread wide however the fact that this photo was even more disturbing than the last was not the fact her legs were spread open but the fact the spot where the filly's vagina should have been was completely missing and looked as if it was gushing blood in this photo. “Her voice was so cute...even her horrified pained screams made me all warm and fuzzy inside....”

Twilight near got sick to her stomach at the sight of the young filly but she pressed on each photo more gory than the next. The last black and white photo however was not gory at all. In fact it was a picture of a small filly with long hair whom was smiling. “My Sweet and adorable Apprentice.....you will continue my work and my legacy will live on even after I am long gone...” The words read next to the photo. Twilight turn the page and saw a newspaper clipping.

SERIAL KILLER BRANDON HOOFSWORTH ARRESTED FOR MULTIPLE MURDERS

Brandon Hoofsworth also known as “The Baker” for his sickening methods of cooking his victims body parts in his baked goods and sold them to people was arrested today on over thirty counts of murder and is being investigated for fifty more counts of murder as this article is printed.

Officer Steelmane had this to say: “It's about time we brought this killer to justice. Now the victims families can at least find some closure to this chain of horrifying events.” said as he spoke to multiple press ponies. When questioned about a supposed apprentice Brandon could be hard screaming who would continue his work Officer steelmane replied with this: “We have found no evidence supporting these claims however we will continue to investigate this.” several days later however we found that the possibility of another adult pony being an accomplice was dropped. With the killer behind bars Ponyville can now sleep safely again thanks to Ponyville's finest.

Twilight read this article and let out a gasp as she flipped to the previous page quickly and stared at the picture of the smiling filly. “They didn't find his apprentice because the apprentice wasn't an adult pony...it was a young filly! But this doesn't make sense! If he only had one apprentice then how come there is more than one killer after me?” Twilight said aloud to herself then proceeded to flip the page forward twice. The pictures were now in color and more importantly, they looked recent. These picture looked even more gruesome if possible being in color and there was writing next to these as well but not in the previous style as the last. “He taught me well...I'm so glad he found me! I just hope he isn't upset with me for waiting so long to continue his work.” The words read.

Twilight pressed on each photo of a pony she either saw at one point or another looking horribly mutilated in different horrifying ways. Each more disturbing than the next. Finally Twilight was near the second to last page of the portfolio. The first picture she immediately recognized due to the fact she saw this pony just yesterday in the alley with it's head and hooves missing. Nothing was written next to this one however. Twilight glanced down at the next photo and her eyes widened in horror.

It was a photo of her with writing next to it. “My next victim...she got away from me once but oh well. She's going to be so fun so play with! After all she's my.....” The words read however the last words of the writing were fudged and illegible.

It took a few moments for her to figure it out but when it did the horrifying realization caused her to begin to hyperventilate. The killer knew her. She knew her! Twilight panicking began to try to think of every pony who knew her and shortly after tried to think of who it could possibly be. But no matter how much she tried..she couldn't figure it out she had no idea who it could be. She didn't want to think it possible but could it be one of her close friends?

“No,no...none of my five best friends would ever try to this to me....would they?” Twilight said aloud trying to think clearly.

Twilight tried to think rationally. But no matter how much she tried she couldn't. Twilight found herself questioning how well she actually knew her friends. When it boiled down to it..she realized she didn't know jack shit about them really.

“Stop it Twilight! You're not honestly going to consider your best friends to be killers are you?” Twilight asked herself aloud.

She had no choice. She had to visit Brandon Hoofsworth herself and find out who the killer was. “Twilight used her magic to lift her backpack on an put it in her back then put the portfolio in it and began to walk towards the local police station.

The police pony was shocked at Twilight's request but he showed her to his cell all the same. “I have no idea why on earth you would want to see this psychopathic lunatic Twilight.” The Police pony said with a sigh.

“It's for my research on the past of Ponyville.” Twilight lied with a fake smile.

“I suppose that's-dear Celestia!” The officer pony exclaimed as they came to the cell.

Twilight gasped in horror. Brandon Hoofsworth was in there alright...well his head anyways. On thew cell wall letters clearly written in blood could be seen.

GUESS WHO?

IF YOU GUESS RIGHT YOU'LL WIN A SUPER AWESOME PRIZE!

HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!HA!

“Dear Celestia......she's always one step ahead of me...how am I going to stop her if I don't know who it is?! She's probably watching me right now!” Twilight thought to herself horrified as she looked around herself in a panic looking for the slightest hint of a head poking through a window.

“Who was here before me?” Twilight asked the officer who was still in shock.

“Umm..uhh....no one as far as I know. I just got on shift fifteen minuets ago.” The Police pony replied and began to take Twilight out of the holding cell hall.

The police pony then picked up his phone and dialed a number. “I need to know who was on shift this morning. Brandon Hoofsworth was just found dead! And it was recent! How recent? I don't know! Do I look like a freaking medical pony to you?! What do you mean the officer who was on shift earlier isn't responding to calls?! Every single Police pony is on call day and night!” The police pony shouted into his phone talking with another pony.

“They won't find him...she already got to him.” Twilight said under her breath as filled with fear all over again but for some reason she wasn't in a state of panic anymore. Was the fact she was finally losing it? Or maybe she's see so much blood and gore that it had simply made her numb? Whatever it was Twilight was able think perfectly clear now. If the killer is one step ahead of her. Then she had to very close to her to be able to predict her actions and smart. It had to be....Rarity. She was the only one smart enough to pull this off and she knew her very well. She must have faked being kidnapped but then wait...why was she acting strange at the bakery with Pinkie Pie? Was she involved too? But hold on..Applejack and Rainbow Dash were also behaving oddly. As much as she didn't want to consider it it made sense now. Her closest of friends had begun to act oddly ever since this began. She had no choice she had to confront them. The only one who wasn't a suspect was Fluttershy. Of course it couldn't be her. She wouldn't hurt a fly much less anypony.

Twilight went to each of her friends homes with the and invited them over except for Fluttershy as she didn't want to possible put her only friend whom she could fully trust in danger with 4 killers.

About twenty minuets later her three friends and to Twilight's shock Rarity came trotting into her home.

“I've brought you all here for one good reason...” Twilight trailed off and summoned clasps and shackles around everypony's legs.

“What the hay is this Twilight?!” Applejack exclaimed in shock.

“Ohh! Is this a kind of game?!” Pinkie Pie exclaimed with a smile.

“Goodness me! What's going on Twilight?!” Rarity exclaimed shocked.

“What gives?! I'm not into this bondage thing!” Rainbow Dash exclaimed then after getting looks from everypony lowered her head in embarrassment.

“Don't tell y'all is he killer?” Applejack asked in a fearful voice.

“Oh that's rich! You all have been acting odd ever since the day that missing pony poster showed up!. Tell me Applejack. Where have you been all this time? I normally see you in town selling your goods but these past few days you haven’t left the farm..or so I thought! You were the one who attacked me outside of Apple Acres weren't you?!” Twilight exclaimed causing Applejack to be taken back in shock.

“What the hay?! You think I’m the killer?! The reason why I haven't left the farm is because I wanted to keep my family safe! I was a little filly when I witnessed this happen so many years ago and I refused to let it happened to my family! You can ask Applebloom and Bigmac! I haven't left the farm once since I saw that poster!” Applejack exclaimed defending herself.

“Okay. Then what about you Rainbow Dash?! You tried to drop that Piano on me didn't you?!” Twilight exclaimed looking at Rainbow Dash.

“Heck no! Why would I do that to my best friend Twilight?!” Rainbow Dash exclaimed angrily.

“Then why didn't you come back that day you said you wanted to meet me huh?!” Twilight exclaimed staring at Rainbow Dash intently.

“I got called to do a whether job in the middle of my searching! I didn't know doing my job as the weather control was a criminal offense!” Rainbow Dash exclaimed defending herself.

“Well then what about you two?! You two were acting awfully odd that day I saw you in Pinkie's Bakery! And You Rarity. Why did you disappear and not come back that night?!” Twilight exclaimed looking at Pinkie Pie and Rarity.

“That red package was a surprise gift for you Twilight...i had Pinkie Pie keep it in her storage because I simply don't have enough room for it till recently...and as for why I disappeared that night. The killer tried to come after me!” Rarity exclaimed defending herself.

“Only a unicorn can take down another unicorn's spell Rarity. So tell me that!” Twilight retorted.

“You're spell stops ponies...not inanimate objects Twilight...i took down the barrier in a panic and ran out the door. By the time I stopped running I feared the worst for you! But I felt so bad I couldn't bring myself to come back apologize more so for the fact I was terrified I would find you....dead.” Rarity replied lowering her head in shame.

“This doesn't make sense! I was so sure you four were in co-hoots! If it's not any of you..then....who the heck is it?!” Twilight exclaimed in frustration.

“Twilight! Behind you!” Rainbow dash exclaimed trying to fly forward but the cuffs around her legs prevented this.

Twilight turned around only to get a large and heavy object to the head knocking her out....

THE KILLER REVEALED!

THE KILLER REVEALED!

Twilight awoke with a start finding herself chained to a wall in a dark room. As her eyes adjusted she looked around as things slowly came into focus. The walls were covered in mantles with different pony parts some where heads, others were legs, and even some were pony genitals both male and female.

“Oh my. You're awake. That's just so great Twilight. Now we can have fun...i mean if that's okay with you. Oh it is? Great!” A soft whispering voice spoke up from the darkness and the light flashed on.

“No....freaking....way.....it's not possible” Twilight said trailing off with each word she spoke.

“Oh dear me. Is something wrong? I hate keeping you chained up like this but I can't just having you run off and tell on little old me....” The voice spoke up as the pony slowly came into view.

Twilight was in shock. It wasn't possible. It couldn't be! It was the pony she least suspected in the all of Equestia. But the proof was in the pudding as the pony began to walk over to a small table that was littered with some surgical tools,small saw,pliers, and knives of multiple sizes.

“Oh come on Twilight. No need to look shocked. Then again I guess I would be shocked to.” The pony said picking up the small saw and looked at Twilight with a sinister grin. “Especially if thought you could never hurt a fly...” The pony said as she walked over to her.

“F-F-Fluttershy?! You can't be the killer! It doesn't make sense!” Twilight exclaimed in disbelief.

“Oh it doesn't? Then let me explain it to you while I get rid of this pesky little horn” Fluttershy said as she took the saw to Twilight's horn and began to slowly cut into it. Twilight gave a shrill cry of pain as the saw began to dig into her horn while fresh blood began to stream from it down her forehead then onto her face.

“Who's house is just past sugar cube corner Twilight?” Fluttershy asked as she continued to saw off Twilight's horn. “Mine. Why did you find the corpse in the middle of the alley yesterday?” Fluttershy said nearly half way through sawing off Twilight's horn now as blood was flooding from it coating Fluttershy's hooves, Twilight's hair, and her face then dropping from her chin to the floor sounding like a faucet with a steady stream of water hitting the floor.

Twilight couldn't think strait her head was spinning from the combined effects of the extreme pain she was in, the realization of the fact that Fluttershy who she thought could never hurt a fly was actually the killer, and she was on the verge of passing out.

“Oh dear me. Don't pass out twilight. At least...not yet. I want to hear you're screams of pain as I cut you open...” Fluttershy said as she stopped cutting off Twilight's horn leaving it hanging by a thread from her head, went to her table grabbed a shot of adrenaline, walked back over to her and jabbed her in the side. Causing twilight to suddenly become wide awake but still dazed.

“Now as I was saying.....” Fluttershy said tossing the vial of adrenaline to the side which made a small clattering sound as it hit the cement floor. “You found that body because I wanted you too. I wanted you to think it was Pinkie Pie who killed that pony. But you being the loyal friend you were refused to...” Fluttershy said with a smile then looked up the horn still hanging by a thread.

Fluttershy then reached up with both hooves and yanked it off earning a shrill and agonizing scream from Twilight. “You know. You are one of my best friends Twilight...I never wanted you to be here but you didn't listen to Applejack. You should have kept you're nose out of affairs that don't concern you.” Fluttershy said as she walked over to her table and laid Twilight's horn on it then picked up a surgical knife.

“What...about....the...Piano?” Twilight asked in a dazed tone.

“Oh, that had nothing to do with me. That silly Derpy Hooves was being a klutz again...” Fluttershy replied nonchalantly.

“Where's Spike?” Twilight asked in the same dazed tone as her eyes went in and out of focus staring at Fluttershy.

“Oh him? He wasn't too much fun to play with. But since you want to know.” Fluttershy said,walked over to the corner of the dark room out of sight for a moment and came back with something on her back.

Twilight's eyes widened in horror even though she couldn't keep them focused she could tell that what was on Fluttershy's back was Spike however it was a lifeless version of him.

“See. He was so cute and adorable I couldn't ruin that. So I stuffed him and now he makes the most wonderful stuffed dragon! You want to hug him Twilight?” Fluttershy said with a smile as she reached to her back, stood on her hind hooves and hugged the lifeless stuffed spike tightly at which point one of his eyes popped out of it's socket with a sickening squishing sound and fell to the floor. “Oh dear me. I'll have to fix that later.” Fluttershy said with a smile as she put the stuffed Spike on her back and walked out of sight again and came back into view a few moments later.

“Now if you don't mind. May I continue? I can? Thank you! You were always ever so nice to me Twilight!” Fluttershy said with a smile not giving Twilight a chance to reply. “When I found you outside of Apple Acres I figured I would try and make you think it was Applejack but silly me got caught up in the moment...” Fluttershy said as she picked up the surgical knife she put down earlier when she went to go get the stuffed spike. “Good thing Winona was there huh? If she hadn't attacked me when she did then we wouldn't be able to have this wonderful time together.” Fluttershy said as she took the knife and ran the flat part along Twilight's face, down her neck, past her chest and to her lower regions as she knelt down. “Oh my. Twilight. You're vagina looks so wonderful.” Fluttershy said with a smile looking up at Twilight then back down to it. “It looks so cute covered in purple fur...are you a virgin still?” Fluttershy asked standing up to face her again.

Twilight however didn't reply. She was overwhelmed at the moment by fear and panic of what Fluttershy was going to do to her. “You know it's rude not to reply to your best friend's questions Twilight...” Fluttershy said running the sharp end over her stomach now and without warning jabbed the tip in but not deeply causing Twilight to cry out. “Now why don't you answer me?” Fluttershy said with a giggle.
“Y-yes...” Twilight replied in a pained tone.

“Oh dear me. You poor thing...that won't do at all. I mean I wouldn't want my best friend to die without knowing what it's like to enjoy the pleasures of sex....” Fluttershy said as she walked over to the table, laid the knife down, then went to a cabinet which was located a few feet away from the table.

“Which one? Hmm...oh I know! This one!” Fluttershy could be heard saying as she fumbled around with something in her cabinet then emerged a few moments later wearing what looked like a strap-on with a male pony cock on it.

Twilight saw this and her eyes widened in horror. “Oh don't worry. The pony who had this won't need it anymore. And I made sure to clean it and everything.” Fluttershy said with a smile as she walked over to Twilight and stood on her hind hooves positioning the strap-on just outside of Twilight's entrance. “Now this will sting a bit but afterword it will feel ever so wonderful!” Fluttershy said with a deep blush and thrust the dildo in to the hilt breaking Twilight's hymen causing Twilight to arch back as she cried out in pain.

“Fluttershy...please...stop...it hurts...” Twilight said as tears of both emotional and psychical pain flooded through her.

“I said it would hurt at first you silly filly. But now that the painful part is over the real fun can begin.” Fluttershy said with a smile and a blush as she began to thrust in and out of Twilight's vagina.

“No...please...stop it! I can't take this! You're my best friend! Why are you doing this to me?!” Twilight exclaimed between sobs as Fluttershy picked up a rhythm as she continued to thrust the dildo in and out of Twilight's newly deflowered vagina.

“Oh Twilight. You're my best friend. That's why. I couldn't just let you die without knowing how it felt to have a male pony's dick between your legs. That would just be oh so horrible of me.” Fluttershy said followed by a soft moan.

Fluttershy continued thrusting each time giving a soft moan each time as Twilight silently sobbed. “Oh Twilight...you're getting wet finally...i can feel it...” Fluttershy said putting a hoof over Twilight's vagina as she thrust in and ran the same hoof along her cheek.

Twilight's eyes shot open as she felt something warm and wet run along her cheek. It couldn't be possible. Her body was betraying her. No matter how much she screamed in her mind that she wasn't enjoying this her body was saying otherwise.

“N-no....” Twilight said in a half moan. Her body now had completely betrayed her. It was loving the feeling while she in her mind was screaming for it to stop.

“I knew you'd warm up to it eventually Twilight. You spent so much time reading books. your body must have so much pent up lust. It's must be unbearable....” Fluttershy said with a smile as she began to speed up.

Twilight by now was moaning with each thrust while tears of emotional pain continued flooding from her eyes despite the fact the rest of her body was lit up like a match in pleasured bliss.

“Are you close Twilight? I know I am..” Fluttershy said between pants.

Meanwhile Twilight's mind began to fog up as her body grew closer and closer to climax with each thrust until she gave an orgasmic cry.

“That's it Twilight cum for me!” Fluttershy exclaimed hitting her climax as well.

“Ah,ah..no,no....uhh!” Twilight said in a pained yet pleasured voice as her body road out it's climax while her legs involuntarily clamped down on the strap-on.

Fluttershy pulled out of Twilight with a content sigh on her face and walked over to her cabinet. Meanwhile Twilight looked down at her lower regions which were coated in her cum still dripping from her vagina.

Fluttershy emerged a few moments later from the shadows, walked over to the table, picked up the surgical knife again and walked over to Twilight. “I hope you enjoyed that. Now we can continue with the fun we were having earlier...” Fluttershy said with a smile once again running the flat part of the knife along her body.

Twilight still recovering from her orgasm panted and gasped fear and panic once again consuming her quickly replacing the blissful afterglow feeling she had.

“Lets start with those cute little ears of yours...” Fluttershy said with a smile running the knife along her face then abruptly taking the sharp end of the knife to her right ear.

Twilight let out a scream of pure agony as Fluttershy began to carve at her right ear slowly causing blood to gush from it. “I don't want to be to rash when removing this ear Twilight. It would be oh so horrible if it was damaged.” Fluttershy said in a sweet voice even though Twilight continued to shriek and cry out in pain.

After what seemed like a lifetime of torment ended abruptly as Twilight's ear came off with a sickening slashing sound. The part that used to be Twilight's ear was bleeding profusely now stinging and aching as Twilight sobbed loudly in pain.

Fluttershy walked back to the table placed her ear next to the horn and walked back.”Time for that other cute little ear.” Fluttershy said in a sweet tone and began to cut at it causing Twilight to shriek and cry out in agony as fresh pain surged through her.

“Just kill me! I can't take it!” Twilight screamed at the top of her lungs as Fluttershy continued to work at her left ear.

“Oh I can't do that Twilight. This is just too much fun. If I killed you then I couldn't hear you're reactions to my little game I’m playing. And that would be oh so sad for me.” Fluttershy said as she finished cutting off her left ear, walked over the the table, and laid it down next to her horn.

“Why are you doing this?” Twilight said between sobs after a few moments becoming light headed from the amount of blood she was losing.

“Because I have to continue my teachers work Twilight. He was ever so wonderful to me. He showed me all these fun games. He was the best pony you could ever meet. He loved me like no other. Our first time was when I was a small filly. Even though he couldn't fit all the way in we shared a love like no other. I then decided I would do anything for him. He taught me everything he knew.” Fluttershy said with a blissful smile.

“You....won't...get..away..with..this...” Twilight said between huffs and puffs her voice slurring now due to the mass amount of blood she was losing.

“Oh I know. I'll eventually be caught. I know this. That's why my teacher taught me the most important part of playing these games with ponies. I must pass along the knowledge he gave me to another so that his work can continue.” Fluttershy said with a smile taking a clean knife off the table.

“You...have...an.... apprentice....too?” Twilight said weakly as she was slowly losing consciousness.

“Oh, yes. She an ever so sweet filly. And i've already taught her everything I know. She will continue my work many years later after i'm caught.” Fluttershy said and took note of Twilight's steadily loss of consciousness. “Oh dear me. You can't pass out yet. The best part is about to begin.” Fluttershy said with a smile, put down the knife, picked up another vial of adrenaline, walked over to her, and jabbed into her neck making her wide awake again nearly instantly.

“Now then...” Fluttershy said as she picked up the knife again from the table,walked over to Twilight and ran the knife along her chest deeply causing Twilight's eyes to shoot open and cry out in pain as she felt the knife run through her skin like a hot knife through butter.

Fluttershy cut along Twilight's chest gliding the knife down and around in a circular motion but stopped before she made a complete circle, pealed the fur and skin back revealing a flood of blood and Twilight's internal organs. “This is the ever so much funniest part Twilight. I get to see how many of your organs I can remove before you die.” Fluttershy said with a smile.

Twilight looked down to see the flap of skin as well as her internal organs and literally vomited the contents of her stomach onto the floor in front of her nearly hitting Fluttershy with it. “Oh my. Twilight that was ever so wonderful. I just got to see your stomach spasm and convulse. It was ever so neat to watch.” Fluttershy said with a giggle.

“I think...i was...right..when..i said....this when I first met you ponies...YOU'RE CRAZY!” Twilight exclaimed in a pained voice.

“Now..what shall I take out first. I don't want to remove anything vital just yet...after all I don't want you to die too quickly.” Fluttershy said with a smile as she ran the knife along her insides.

By now there was a puddle of blood at Twilight's feet as she looked around the room trying her best not to focus on Fluttershy. Her body felt numb now though. She wasn't sure if her body was finally shutting down or what. Part of her wished she would just die from blood loss. So she wouldn't have to endure anymore or this. While another part of her wanted somepony...anypony to come and save her from the psychopathic pony.

Fresh pain however shot her back into reality that she was in fact not numb as Fluttershy began to carve out her kidney causing her to cry out in pain. “This is useless anyways. Nopony knows what it's really used for anyways.” Fluttershy said with a giggle as she continued to carve out her kidney.
Twilight's body began to convulse uncontrollably now as her eyes rolled back into her head due to the extreme and agonizing pain she was in as well as the blood loss.

“Oh dear me Twilight..are you going to kick the bucket on me already?” Fluttershy said as she lifted stood up on her hind hooves to show her her bleeding kidney.

Twilight's vision was completely gone now she couldn't see anything however even though she could no longer see anything what was left of her ears could hear a faint sound of a door being rammed down and Fluttershy's faint shocked cry followed by a flood of hooves before she finally lost consciousness...

Twilight's eyes fluttered open weakly as vision slowly began to come back into focus. She saw Applejack, Rarity,Pinkie Pie, and Rainbow Dash sitting in chairs beside her bed. She realized she was in a hospital room with an IV in one arm.

“Hey Y'all she's wakin up!” Applejack said in a excited and happy voice.

“W-What...happened?” Twilight asked wearily.

“Well, after you got dragged away by that cloaked pony we tried to get out of those shackles you put us in. Thanks to Rarity the others were able to follow you and Fluttershy to her cottage while I went for help.” Rainbow Dash said with a smile.

“But we had no idea where she was hiding at. We searched all over the place. But would couldn't find you. It wasn't until we heard you scream out that we figured out that she had a trap door under the floorboards.” Rarity chimed in with a smile.

“Then we all rushed the door at once all and tackled Fluttershy to the ground before she could react!” Pinkie Pie exclaimed with a smile.

“When I got back with the Police ponies we came down and I helped them take the chains off you and we rushed you here got you patched up and all. It's a good thing she hadn't gotten to anything vital but you lost some much blood you weren't going make it.” Rainbow Dash said in a dramatic voice.

“So we all volunteered to donate blood to you! And here you are! All safe and sound!” Pinkie Pie exclaimed with a smile.

“Thanks guys....I’m so sorry I thought you were the killers.” Twilight said with a tearful smile.

“Hey, don't y'all worry your cute little head about it ya hear?” Applejack replied placing a hoof on her cheek with a smile.

“I still can't believe Fluttershy was the killer..I’ve known her since we were fillies. I thought I knew everything about her....” Rainbow Dash said after a few moments with a shocked expression yet saddened expression.

“It's alright Dashy. At least it over now.” Pinkie pie said with a smile.

“I hope so....” Twilight said with a sigh then let out a small gasp. “They don't know about her apprentice! But then again... Fluttershy was a complete psychopath maybe she was spouting off nonsense...” Twilight thought to herself....

OR WAS SHE?

THE END?