A Nightmare Returns

Deep inside the old castle, was a room. The room was dark, lit only by a few torches. In the center of the room, In a bed of straw on the stone floor, lay a white pegasus mare. Her body was well toned and her muscles well defined, her curvature was on average for an athletic mare. This mare was in her mid 20’s. Her short mane and tail are a royal blue, with streaks of light blue.

This mare is the one and only Golden Eye, she was a very strong stallion at one point, always putting his life on the line for his brothers, and Celestia’s oldest child

Gold’s eyes snapped open and began looking around the room, “Wh-where am I? What is this place? Am I still in the castle? Lastly, why do I sound like a mare?” She asked no one in particular. She pushed herself up and felt something fall downward on her chest. She looked down to see two borderline D cup breasts protruding from her chest.

Her eyes widened. “I’m a fucking mare! Why!? This is not cool! Not fucking cool!”

Gold had to take several deep breaths to calm herself. “Dammit… What ever happened to me, I’m sure I can get an explanation from Nightmare Moon when I see her again.” Gold stood herself up only to stumble over to a nearby wall, “Dammit, she really fucked me up in that fight. Nevermind that now, I need to focus on getting my armor and either getting to Nightmare Moon or getting the hell out of this castle and then getting turned back into a stallion.”

After resting for a minute she pushed herself off the wall and strode forward, pulling the door to her room open to find that it lead down two different hallways. “Silver, Heart, you there?” she asked.

No reply.

“Dammit, looks like I have to search for my brothers too.” Gold said as she took a left and continued down the dimly lit hallway.

As she continued walking, due to her limited field of view from the lack of consistent lighting, she didn’t see the hole in front of her until it was too late. She screamed as she fell into the hole in the floor and landed on the bottom of a pit with a dull thud, “Ugh, fucking holes, now how am I going to get out of here, there’s no fucking exit.” she complained as she searched the small room for a lever or switch until she came across what felt like a hole in the wall. “What the fuck? I wonder what’s on the other side?” Gold asked herself out of curiosity and pushed her arm into the hole and began searching for a lever or switch on the other side.

After a moment of blind searching, she felt her hand catch onto something and she instinctively pulled it down, which in turn, caused the wall to spin around, and reveal a hall of armor. “What the fuck is this place?” Gold questioned. “And by the looks of it somepony may have been here a few minutes ago.” She said to herself as she looked down at the hoofprints in the dust of the rug that ran the length of the hall. Looking at the direction they were leading she followed them but were cut off as she came to the end of the rug. “I guess I start taking my own path from here.” She said as she took the path to the left, hoping to find her brothers.

After walking down the hall for what seemed like hours, Gold began to catch a cold draft, “Apparently this hallway leads to the courtyard or something.” Gold said as she continued walking, following the draft.

After following the draft a little further, Gold found herself standing in an outdoors area, but it looked nothing like the courtyard, “Hm, I must be in the castle gardens right now, maybe I should search the area for anything that might lead me to Nightmare Moon from here.” Gold said as she began to look around, staying alert for anything that could potentially harm her.

“Hm, there’s nothing here but one new path and the path I just came from, I guess I should follow the path I just found.” she stated as she started down the path, which was a little more well lit than the one she was in.

Suddenly she thought she heard hoofsteps behind her, “Silver… Heart… is that you?”

No reply.

“Huh, I must be hearing things.” Gold said, shaking her head, and continued onward.

After walking a bit further down the corridor Gold noticed a room with a rather large bed in the middle noticing the old sheets as those of luna’s covers when they lived here. They seemed to be freshly stained and ruined. “Aren’t they magnificent.” a voice said from behind.

Gold whipped around to come face to face with Nightmare Moon. “How long have you been following me? And what have you done with my brothers?” Gold spat , her words filled with venom.

“Oh my, still sore about being beaten earlier, are we?” Moon said sarcastically. “Your sisters are just fine, although I did have some fun with Silver a while ago.”

“I swear if you did anything to hurt hi-… wait did you say sisters?” Gold questioned curiously. “What are you talking about, having ‘fun’ with Silver?”

“Did I stutter? Of course I said sisters, as for what I mean by having ‘fun’ with Silver, you will soon find out for yourself.” Moon replied, lust settling in on her voice as she picked Gold up in her magic and threw her onto the bed. Then used her it to bind her arms over her head.

Gold tried to struggle against her bonds, but to no avail. “What the fuck are you doing? Are you going to…” Gold questioned while looking up at Moon fearfully as what she had for clothing was stripped from her body, exposing her muscular form to Nightmare Moon.

“Yes, I’m going to give you the best night of your life.” Moon said, gesturing to a large member between her legs.

Gold’s eyes widened in fear as she gazed at the the throbbing flesh. “Y-y-you mean... that you’re gonna...f-f-f-fuck me?!” She cried out in fear of what was about to happen, beginning to thrash about trying to escape, but her bonds held fast, preventing her from escaping.

As Gold struggled against her bonds, Nightmare climbed onto the bed, reaching around her and placing the ball of a ball gag in her mouth and fastening it in place behind her head. “I was actually going to play with you first but if you want to get it over with sooner then I’m afraid you’ll just have to endure.” she said as she ran her fingers along Golds slit, eliciting a weak muffled cry from her.

Moon continued rubbing Golds needy lips while she reached up and began fondling her breast, tweaking her nipple, increasing the pleasure she was giving to Gold, causing her to moan lightly from the unwanted pleasure. Moon pulled her fingers away to notice that they were damp with what appeared to be Gold’s arousal. “You say that you don’t want this, yet your body says it wants more.”

Gold could only sigh in defeat as she had no choice but to take what she was being given as she cursed her body for enjoying the pleasure.

“That’s a good girl, just give in and relax.” Moon purred lustfully into Golds ear, as she shoved a finger into Golds moist folds before leaning in to start licking and suckling on her other nipple

Gold moaned as she felt the intruder begin to work it’s way in and out of her, coating the finger in her arousal as her breasts were fondled, groped and suckled on.

Moon then began licking a trail slowly down past Gold’s stomach and down to her ultimate goal.

Once she came face to face with Gold’s, marehood she pulled out her fingers and blew a single breath over her slick folds, teasing her.

Gold could only quiver from the sensation of Moon breathing on her wet marehood, causing her to squirm with pleasure.

“Tender, aren’t we?” Moon said as she closed the gap between her and Golds precious folds, licking from the base to her clit, eliciting a muffled cry of ecstasy from her, but whined when Moon pulled away. “Let’s just get rid of that gag shall we? I would rather like to hear your moans and cries clearly.” Moon said as she removed the ball gag, before moving back down to continue licking at Golds marehood.

“Ahhhh… I-It feels… It feels so… D-damn… Good.” Gold moaned loudly.

Hearing this, Moon pressed her tongue into Golds tight crevice and began eating her out, wriggling her tongue and collecting all the juices she could coax out of her.

Gold cried out as she felt the slick muscle entered her. Her whole body spasmed with pleasure as her new sex was taken advantage of, throwing her headlong into heights of pleasure she had only heard of.

Moon slid her hand down the white mare’s thigh, before trailing it to her tight tail hole and slipping her fingers inside, working them in and out, loving the array of sounds her new toy made.

Gold’s moans increased in volume as the pleasure from both of her holes being penetrated intensified, which encouraged Moon to shove her tongue as deep as she possibly could, aiming to bring her to her first climax as a mare.

“Gahhhhhh…. F-fuck yes…” Gold cried out loudly signaling that her climax was getting near.

Moon intensified her efforts to force the mare to orgasm, hitting every sensitive spot possible with her tongue. She worked it in circles, wanting to taste every part of her.

“Ahhhhhh...I-I’m gonna...c-cum… soon!” Gold cried out in blissful pleasure.

Nightmare Moon reached down and began tweaking and playing with Golds clit eliciting several cries from her.

That was all it took, one tweak and a rub on her clit was enough to send Gold over the edge, causing her to arch her back hard and spray her juices into Moons willing mouth, splashing over her tongue, and even spilling out past her lips.

Moon swallowed what she could of Gold’s juices, before going and licking her still quite sensitive marehood clean.

“How do you feel?” Moon asked Gold after cleaning her.

“I-I feel like… I was...in heaven.” Gold panted.

“Well I think you deserve your reward, don’t you?” Moon purred lustfully.

“Mmhm.” Gold moaned as she sat up and stared at the large shaft, throbbing before her, sitting an inch from her snout. Her eyes widened. “Oh fuck…”

“Well?”

“I-I think I left something back in my room.” Gold said as she tried to get up off the bed, only to be pinned on her back, looking Nightmare in the eyes.

“I’m waiting, Golden.”

Gold, swallowing her pride, started by licking at the base of the shaft and trailing her tongue all the way up to the tip to swirl her tongue over Moon’s head. She then dragged her tongue back down to the base.

Moon whimpered loudly at the unexpected skill. “Ahhhh… W-who did you blow before me, Gold?”

Gold didn’t answer, but kept licking and swirling her tongue on Moons shaft, before enveloping her mouth around the thick head and started bobbing on Moons thick member.

Moon, in her lust induced haze while being blown, released Golds bonds, allowing her to fondle her balls. which caused the alicorn moan loudly.

Hearing Nightmare’s moans, Gold doubled her efforts and began going deeper taking all of moons shaft into her maw, deepthroating her, taking balls and all into her maw.

“Gahhhhh… fuck yes… Take it like your sister did...” Moon moaned loudly as the pleasure spread throughout her body, she reached down and began pushing on Gold’s head trying to get her to go deeper.

Moon’s moaning only encouraged Gold to pick up the pace, increasing the rate at which she delivered pleasure to the owner of the shaft she was deepthroating, trying to get her to cum.

“Ahhhhhhh…. I-I’m getting… close!” Moon cried out.

Hearing this Gold started going full throttle going as fast as she could while deep throating Moon trying to push her over the edge.

Moon couldn’t take it anymore. She bucked her hips one last time and pressed Golds face into her crotch, shoving her flared cock down Gold’s throat and shot rope after rope of her warm sticky load down her throat.

Gold gagged, but was forced to swallow it all, unable to pull free of Nightmare’s grip.

Once Moon was finished, she pulled out and sighed from the pleasurable experience, “That was… Great.” Moon panted lightly. “Now… Present yourself to me.”

Gold, knowing what would be coming next and afraid of what Moon would do to her if she refused, laid down on the bed with her legs spread waiting for Moon to have her way with her.

“Ready for round 3?” Moon said, lust heavy on her tone, but stayed where she was. “But I want to try something else.”

The magic shackles suddenly appeared back on Gold’s wrists and ankles, snapping them onto the bed. “W-what the hell are you doing!?”

Moon giggled. “I want to hear you laugh. I love your laugh. It excites me.” She replied as a feather appeared in her hand.

Gold’s eyes widened. “You wouldn’t…”

“I would…” She gave a sadistic smile. “And I will.”

The pegasus shook her head. “Nonononono! Anything but that!”

Moon slowly brought the feather closer to Gold, who jerked against the bonds, until the feather finally made contact with her side. She then furiously tickled the mare, smiling for every torturous second.

Gold burst out laughing, helpless to the tickling. “N-no! Hahahahaa! P-please!”

Moon giggled as she continued, moving the feather across Gold’s other sensitive spots. She slowly brought it to her pits, navel, nipples, all of them making Gold writhe in ticklish torture.

It was then that Moon reached her hoof.

“No!” Gold cried as Moon brought the feather closer, a sinister smile on her lips.

As soon as the torturous feather made contact with the tender frog of her hoof, the pegasus burst into laughter again. She laughed for so long and so hard that it hurt, so that when
moon finally stopped, Gold was whimpering at the pain in her stomach and sides.

Nightmare tossed the feather away, before releasing the shackles as she crawled over top of Gold, Lining her cock up with Golds pussy. “I want you, Gold.”

“P-please… Just let us go.” Gold begged.

Without answering, Moon thrusted inside, parting her pussy lips with ease. She groaned, feeling the strong inner muscles clench and milk at her as she pushed deeper.

“Gahhhhhh… F-fuck.” Gold moaned from the penetration alone.

After waiting for Gold to adjust, Moon began slowly thrusting into her, drawing out the pleasure being given and received. “Ahhhhh… Fuck… Nyahhhh… You’re f-fucking tight, Gold... A-almost as tight as your sister.” She moaned as she finally hilted deep inside of the mare.

Gold panted loudly at the sensation of being filled to her limit. “I-I’m so f-full!” She cried as she instinctively rolled her hips against Nightmare’s crotch, causing her inner muscles to squeeze around the thick shaft that had buried itself into her deepest depths.

Moon leaned over, continuing to thrust into Gold, and pulled her into a kiss, which Gold returned without resistance or hesitation as she moaned into Moons maw.

Gold felt something pressing against her lips as if trying to pry her mouth open and without hesitation opened her mouth to allow the muscle to enter and wrestle with her own.

During their passionate kiss, Moon brought a hand up and began groping Gold’s left breast, occasionally grazing over her nipple, eliciting several small moans from her in combined pleasure.

Moon broke the kiss to regain her breath, then began kissing and nibbling along Golds neck while continuing to thrust into her and massaging her breast, causing Gold to moan loudly.

“Gahhhhh… F-fuck… Me harder!” Gold cried out, unable to control her lust.

“Y-you… Hahhhh… Want me… To...Mmmmm… F-fuck you… Harder?” Moon moaned out loudly. “Beg for…Ahhhhh... I-it.”

“Nyahhhhhh… P-please… Fuck me...Hahhh… H-harder… Fuck m-me… S-senseless… Please!” Gold cried out, begging to be ravaged.

Hearing Gold’s begging, Nightmare picked up the pace, thrusting as fast as she possibly could into her.

With the increase in Moons thrusting, Golds moans and cries became near screams as her orgasm quickly approached, her inner walls starting to contract around Moons large shaft as it continuously filled her at a rapid pace.

“S-sounds like… Someone’s...Hahhhhh… Getting close.” Moon moaned loudly. “Well… I have some… Nyahhhhh… N-news for… you… Mmmmmm... I-I’m getting… Gahhhhh… Close m-myself.” Moon said through heated grunts.

By now Gold was teetering on the edge, screaming in ecstasy. “I-I’m… Ahhhhhhhhh… G-gonna… I’m… I’m cumming!” Gold screamed as her body went rigid, her inner walls constricting around Moon’s thick rod in an orgasmic vice. Her warm cum spilled past the cock that was embedded deep inside of her, soaking Nightmare’s crotch and the bed beneath.

As soon as Gold had slipped over, feeling her cock caught in a tight embrace of pleasure and the warm mare cum spilling past her, coating her crotch, Moon threw her head back, groaning loudly as she shot load after load into Gold, filling her to the brim, causing the excess to spill out past her cock mixed with Gold’s juices.

“Oh my… Y-you were built up nicely.” Moon cooed at the obviously pleasured mare.

Gold said something inaudible through her blissful afterglow, about to drift off into a deep sleep before Moon got up off the bed. “I’m not done with you yet.” Moon said, getting up off of Gold.

“Wha-what? What do you mean you aren’t done with me?” Gold asked, a sudden expression of shock and confusion on her face.

“What I am talking about is... I want your ass, Golden.” Nightmare stated bluntly.

Gold’s eyes widened. “Wait, what!? N-no!”

“What was that!? Did you just say no?” Nightmare growled, before gently as she could, touched Gold’s thigh with a single finger.

Golden screamed in agony as pain like she had never felt before coursed through her body, rivaling the pain that Silver had felt when Moon had deflowered her.

After about a minute, Nightmare Moon released the painful spell and allowed Gold’s body to drop to the bed, where she lied panting. “Now… Will you cooperate?”

Gold just laid there, as if petrified by a cockatrice, her eyes still clamped shut tightly from the still present pain, although it is not as bad as when Moon was holding the spell.

“Now, you are going to do what I tell you when I tell you to do it.” Moon snarled. “Do you understand?”

Gold hesitated from the painful experience of which she had just been slammed with.

“Do you understand?” Moon repeated, her voice laced with venom.

Gold slowly nodded.

“Now, turn over and get on all fours, before I am given no choice but to use that spell again.” Moon commanded.

Gold slowly lifted herself up, wincing from the pain that still resided, and bent over on her hands and knees, tears streaming down her face.

“Now, are you going to be a good girl from here on out?” Nightmare asked asked.

Gold stayed silent and motionless. “Hm, I’ve never seen this before, refusing to answer me even after a threat of pain beyond your wildest dreams. That matters little now, your punishment will be very... forceful.” Moon said as she got behind her and lined herself up with Gold’s puckered tail hole.

“N-no...not there… Dammit l-let me go!” Gold cried out.

Nightmare ignored her and thrust forcefully inside, causing Gold to wince at the pain. Moon took a firm grip of her ass and, not even giving a moment for her to adjust, continued thrusting into her. “Yes! Ohhhh! Yes!” She cried as she pounded the mare beneath her.

Gold had to bite her lip to keep from screaming, the pain from Moon continuously hilting in her ass making more tears pour from her eyes. Her whimpers were muffled by her bottom lip, trying to keep at least some of her pride.

Moon reached her hand around the pegasus she was fucking senseless and rubbed against her soaked pussy lips.

Gold gasped loudly and moaned in a mixture of pain and pleasure. A mixture that was, for some reason, arousing. So much for pride.

Moon continued like this for another two minutes, Gold moaning loudly from her bitter/sweet treatment. Moon reached with her free hand and grabbed the mares wing. She yanked hard on it while thrusting harder and deeper into her, pushing her fingers deeper into her as well.

Gold screamed in both pleasure and pain as Moon thrust into her at a quickened pace.

The pain that had been but moments ago had subsided and made way for even more pleasure as she felt nothing more than the pleasure from her wings being pulled along with her pussy taking in two of Moons fingers, while being pounded in the ass, causing her orgasm to rise quickly. “I-I’m… Hahhhhhhh… Getting… Close… Ohhhhhhhh… S-so close!” Gold cried out in utter bliss.

Hearing Gold’s cries, Nightmare inserted a third finger and increased the rate at which she was pumping them in and out of her dripping snatch, while also increasing the pace at which she thrust into her ass. She kept continuously pulling at her wing. “I-I’m gonna cu… Ahhhhh… Cum!” Moon cried out uncontrollably. She slammed herself as far as she could go inside of Gold, her head flaring inside, before releasing violent spills of cum into the mares rectum, filling her to her limit. Moon’s mind went completely numb with pleasure as she emptied herself inside.

Feeling the mare behind her fill her was all it took to send Gold into her own orgasm, spilling generous amounts of her fluids onto Moons fingers and the bed beneath.

Finding she had little strength left, Moon collapsed on top of Gold, panting. “Y-you… sounded… like… you enjoyed… yourself... A-am I… right?” She whispered into the mares ear.

“Y-yeah… I… did… I-I… never… thought that… it… would feel… so… good.” Gold moaned out through exhausted pants. The feeling of Moon’s slowly softening cock still hilted deep inside of her, coated in warm sticky seed was something she never thought she would enjoy so much, yet here she was, about to pass out from being fucked senseless.

“You’re a naughty mare… Just like your little sister.” Moon said just as Gold finally slipped into unconsciousness.