Your Little Fluttershy (Fluttershy x Reader)

by Yamazaki

Rating: mature
Tags: Fluttershy, Sex, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Human, Other, Romance
Length: 4721

When you wake up in the Everfree Forest and are taken in by a certainkind pegasus, you soon realize you both have feelings for each other and begin a relationship of the intimate kind.

When you wake up in the Everfree Forest and are taken in by a certain kind pegasus, you soon realize you both have feelings for each other and begin a relationship of the intimate kind.

Click here for the spiritual sequel.

Published 2014-01-31 03:30:14 UTC
Last updated 2014-01-31 03:30:14 UTC

Chapter 1

It had been three weeks since you woke up in the Everfree Forest and wondered to Fluttershy's cottage. When the cream-coloured pegasus first opened the door, you were both equally surprised to see the creature standing there; both you and Fluttershy screamed. But after a few minutes, you both  calmed down and she began to ask all sorts of questions like, “what are you? What's your name? Where are you from?”

You had an equal amount of questions; “how are you talking? Where am I?” But it soon became clear you were not from this world.

You stared at the ceiling whilst sitting in her living room, reminiscing on this and thinking of home. Yet although this world was inhabited by talking ponies, it was increasingly feeling like home. Fluttershy had been kind enough to let you live with her. Actually, she begged you to live with her. Turns out she loves animals and, since you weren't a pony like her, you were no exception. Although she didn't treat you like an animal; quite the opposite. Her face completely lit up whenever she saw you and, according to her friend Twilight Sparkle, Fluttershy 'really opened up to you'.You chuckled, thinking of Twilight Sparkle's comment. It did feel rather flattering to have someone open up to you.

“Hey,” your thoughts were interrupted by a familiar, smooth and girly voice, “I'm going to go up to bed.”

“Oh, okay, well, good night,” you said, looking away from the ceiling and over at Fluttershy, who was hovering above the floor to stay eye-level with you. Her smile made you smile too. She was so cute! Her aqua blue eyes seemed to shine in the evening light.

Fluttershy settled all four hooves on the floor and looked up at you. She began blushing as she looked up at you and asked, “would you like to sleep in my bed tonight?” Only, you couldn't hear because her voice trailed off near the end of her sentence.

“Sorry, what was that?” You asked, noticing the mare's cheeks turning pink and her eyes looking nervous. The one thing on her face that didn't change was her smile.

“Would you like to sleep in my bed tonight?” She said a little louder and quicker, looking away. This time, however, you heard all of what she said.

“Sure,” you shrugged. In all your time with living with Fluttershy you had been sleeping on the couch and you missed sleeping in an actual bed. Besides, in the three weeks you had somewhat developed feelings for Fluttershy, and sharing a bed is something couples do.

“It's just that you've been sleeping on the couch since you got here, and my bed is big enough for two,” Fluttershy explained.

“Sure,” a warm smile spread across your face as you stood up, looking down at her. Your smile felt reassuring to her and Fluttershy's blush faded away. You were almost twice as tall as Fluttershy and, judging by apprehensive look on her face she still found your height daunting sometimes. “Shall we go, then?” You smiled, trying to be reassuring and hinted towards the stairs to her bedroom.

Fluttershy nodded and lifted herself off the floor with her wings, fluttering to the stairs and ascending them with you behind. Her tip of her long, pink tail dragged along the wooden staircase and you caught a glimpse of her little butt. You blushed and couldn't help but stare. You had to bend down to fit through the door into her bedroom, making you feel like some sort of obnoxious giant. The door creaked as you shut it behind you. Turning around, you could see that Fluttershy was already lying on the bed on her side with her hooves half tucked underneath her body, with her tail and mane sprawled out across the bed.

Both your heart and stomach simultaneously did a back flip!

Although it seemed optional for the ponies who lived here to wear clothes, you still insisted on wearing them at all times. Lucky for you that Fluttershy was friends with somepony (called Rarity) who was able to make you some. They lacked the quality of the ones you were used to back home; each item she made was either too tight or too loose but you appreciated Rarity's effort nonetheless. You knew that she was only ever used to making clothes for ponies, not humans like yourself. Right now, though, you were unsure whether or not to take any of your clothes off. “Are you coming?” Fluttershy asked patiently.

“Y-yeah,” you replied, “um, is it okay if I take my shirt off?” You considered that to be at least decent.

Fluttershy smiled and nodded, “sure.” Her face grew excited as she saw you topless. You already knew that she was fascinated with your body because she had been a bit touchy-feely with you since you arrived. She had always been doing things like prodding your thighs with her hoof and inquisitively nudging your face, although you didn't mind it at all. It didn't come as much of a surprise, either, considering she was fascinated with creatures of all kind. And, with no humans around, you were one of a kind. You looked around for a place to put your shirt before awkwardly asking, “can I just put this on the floor?”

She giggled and said, “Sure, that's fine. Now come to bed.”

Your heart exploded (metaphorically speaking, of course) at her giggle. It made you giggle too as you made your way to her bed and lay down beside her. Seeing as the bed was made for someone of Fluttershy's size, you took up much more room that she did and your feet poked out the end. Despite this, there was still enough room for the both of you. You pulled the covers over you and said, “good night.” Fluttershy blew out the candle on her bedside, reducing your view of her to a black outline until your eyes got a little more used to the dark. You could feel the mare's body heat radiating into your exposed upper body and hear her soft breathing. She was so peaceful it made you feel so happy and safe.

“Hey, I was wondering...” Fluttershy looked at you. The moonlight that shone through the window enabled you to make out the faint reflections on her big, curious eyes.

“Hm?” You replied, turning on your side and smiling.

“What exactly are your species...” She paused. You could tell her breathing had changed. “...mating habits?” She finished.

You were a little surprised at her question, but answered calmly, “Oh, well, we don't exactly have 'habits'. We just do it with someone we love, you know?”

“Oh, I see.”

“Or someone we quite like, anyway!” You added with a slight laugh, “why do you ask?” You tilted your head to the side.

“Oh, urm,” Fluttershy's eyes darted from side to side and she shuffled a little closer to you, “well, I've developed feelings for you. So...” Her voice trailed off again. It took you a moment to answer as you were distracted, smitten by her soft, smooth coat of fur. You realized how much she must feel trust you to let you even sleep in the same bed with her, and quickly decided not to abuse her trust by hurting her.

“Oh, okay,” you finally said, being rendered a little speechless, “to be honest, I've had feelings for you, too.” The feeling of awkwardness that spread through your mind reminded you of when you had previously tried to be romantic with fellow humans. And now, although you were in bed with a pony, the two of you loved each other and it felt like nothing else mattered. No matter what anyone might say about you two being different species, you still had each other.

You kissed Fluttershy. Or she kissed you. Either way, your lips touched. With a little bit of difficulty since your mouth was a different shape to her muzzle. You guessed her body and yours weren't exactly built for each other. The kiss lasted a few seconds until you felt your tongue subconsciously enter her mouth. Fluttershy moaned but let it in, meeting it with her tongue. You loved the sensation of your tongue brushing and rubbing on Fluttershy's tongue. When Fluttershy slowly pulled away, you could see a long strand of saliva connecting your mouths until she finally moved her head far away enough for it to get more and more thin until it snapped. She giggled with a cheeky smirk on her face. You couldn't help but wrap your arms around her body in a tight hug. She shuffled even closer to you and you felt all four of her hoofed limbs around you. Her wings extended as she settled herself into your hug.

You began to stroke up and down her bubblegum mane. Fluttershy smiled and settled her head into your chest, allowing you to appreciate every strand and comb your fingers through the long, silky hair that grew from her head. She gave a smile at the feeling of being touched by fingers instead of hooves, nuzzling your chest with her short snout as she welcomed your touch. You stroked down to Fluttershy's spread wings, an “eep,” noise escaped her mouth.

“Is something wrong?” You asked.

“N-no, it's just that nopony...nobody has touched my wings like that,” she replied quietly, “but...please don't stop,” Fluttershy finished whilst talking quickly. You nodded and continued stroking and caressing the pegasus's wings. It was like nothing you had ever felt before. Her wings felt delicate enough to break if you were too rough with them as you ran your finger across their leading edge. Fluttershy blushed and let out a quiet moan as you did so.

Fluttershy, still talking quietly, moaned your name and spread her hind legs, exposing her pink special spot that lay in between them. “Would you like to touch me here too?” You could tell by her dark blushing that she was a little embarrassed at you directly seeing that part of her. You couldn't help but giggle and nod. You shakily ran your hand down the lower front of her until your fingers reached her wet pony pussy. Fluttershy tensed up her tender body and shut her eyes as you began to finger her. You weren't sure if you were doing it right and looked at her for clarity. Fluttershy, squinting, nodded and made smile to show you she was okay with what you were doing and enjoying it. You kissed her smiling lips and she hugged you even tighter as you slid two of your fingers in and out whilst continuing to caress her wings. You felt one of her hooves on your butt. “I love you,” Fluttershy moaned as she closed her eyes and rested her head on your chest again, listening to your heart beat.

“I love you too,” you replied. A warm, cute smile spread across Fluttershy's face as she snuggled into you, enjoying you pleasing her tight front. She cheekily began to lick your nipple with her thin tongue which made you gasp and moan. Fluttershy had always been fascinated with your nipples.

As your fingers explored her depths you were becoming acquainted with every nook and cranny of her body. You soon felt something familiar poke at the top of your pants which were right next to Fluttershy's hind leg. “Oh my. Is that..?”

You nodded and she squealed a little, showing combination of nervousness and excitement as she asked, “can I...see it?”

You wandered if Fluttershy wanted to see your penis because she had never seen the genitals of a human  and was curious about it. But you smiled, a little nervously since nopony had seen that part of you before. As you slid down your pants and underwear, your stiff erection springing up. Now that you were naked next to Fluttershy, you felt strangely equal to her because she was naked too.

Gazing at your erect dick, you felt Fluttershy's hooves begin to caress it. You could tell she wasn't trying to give you a complete handjob but was instead trying to find out how a human's erect dick felt like You slowed down your fingering and stroked her mane as Fluttershy's hooves continued to prod and stroke your hard member. Her long mane was as soft as ever and as you stroked it, you observed her big, curious eyes. It seemed Fluttershy's curiosity had overpowered her shyness. You laughed a little, kissing her cheek and shuffling your crotch in her direction. Fluttershy's curious eyes grew eager. “It's different...to a stallion's,” she said in her usual soothing voice which you found incredibly sexy. She made a, “mmf,” noise as she pressed her muzzle into your mouth, surprising you slightly. Her hooves rubbed you faster as both your tongues met and danced with each other.

After sharing a long, passionate kiss, Fluttershy looked at you with dilated pupils obscuring the blue in her eyes. “I want to feel it more,” she mumbled. Her voice made her sound like a curious, excited little filly.

“Sure. I'd like that,” you said with your voice shaking slightly.

She crawled down your upper body. You could feel her muzzle gently brush against your skin as she went, until it reached the base of your still erect dick. She looked up at you. You nodded and spread your legs to Fluttershy while you felt her wet tongue lick up from the base to the tip of your dick. A moan escaped your mouth when she reached the tip. “Oh, you like that?” She asked while giggling.

“Y-yes,” you replied.

Nodding, she concentrated her licking around the tip of your member. You moaned loudly and lay your head back. Feeling more confident in herself, she wrapped her lips around it and went down on you. The inside of her mouth was as wet as her pussy. Fluttershy went up and down in a repeated rhythm, sampling every inch of your member with her tongue. When she went down deep, Fluttershy gagged on it and had to take her head back up. You didn't want it to stop! You began to clench the mane on the back of her head, gentle enough for her to get back up if she needed to. You heard little “mmm mmm mmm,” noises each time her head bobbed down. She held herself as deep down as she could get without gagging, for as long as she could before quickly pulling her head back up. She breathed heavily before going back down, prodding at your balls with her hoof. Fluttershy was clearly trying to give you as much pleasure as you could which made you want to thank her even more.

She winced at the first sign of your precum, a sign of things to come. You pulled some of her mane away from her face, allowing you to look down at both her narrowed eyes. She could see you tensing your body up and, knowing what you were about to do, she went a little faster and sucked harder. Until you felt something warm fly out the end of your member and into the mare's mouth. “Eep!” Cried Fluttershy as she withdrew her mouth from your dick while you moaned out loudly. As took her head up, you came again and watched as some more of the sticky liquid splatted on Fluttershy's cheek and pink mane.

“Oh my!” She exclaimed, being rendered speechless by you cumming in her mouth and on her face.

“Sorry,” you breathed.

“It's alright,” Fluttershy made a cheeky smile, “so this is what, um, cum, feels and tastes like.” She began to wipe some from her face with her hoof before giggling again, “it feels so warm!” You could tell by small movements on Fluttershy's neck that she had swallowed some of it, yet she still wiped her hoof across her lips, rubbing off them a substantial amount of your seed. You couldn't help but smirk at Fluttershy. Her mane, stained white in a few spots with your sticky juice, her cheeks with long streaks of it she had missed and the amount that had ended up in her wet mouth made it seem so sexy. You could tell Fluttershy felt the same when she said, no louder than a whisper, “I liked that.”

A drop of your cum became dislodged from the front of Fluttershy's mane and landed on the bed sheet, narrowly missing her left front leg which she had extended towards you on the bed. You both ignored it.

“Me too,” you said with a smirk still on your face. You quickly sat up and kissed the mare passionately. As you extended your tongue into her, the taste of your semen still lingered in her mouth. Not that you minded. Fluttershy hugged you. She was still having some difficulty staying as physically close to you as she could since she didn't have any fingers, so she improvised with her wings which you made careful attention not to damage. As Fluttershy lay herself down beside you, you two finally broke the kiss. “I think you'll like this, too,” you continued. You couldn't believe you said that! Back at home you were never this smooth. Maybe you just trusted Fluttershy a lot more than any human back at home. Your mind took you back to the time she had first introduced you to other ponies. In this strange new world, Fluttershy always took care of you by saying, “it's okay; please don't be nervous; I know all this must be strange for you.” You adored how caring she was. You loved her! Just thinking of this made you want to kiss and hold her close again, so you did. She let out a blush during the kiss.

When you had finished kissing, you couldn't help but blow a raspberry below Fluttershy's neck. She laughed loudly, rolling from side to side, retracting and extending her wings. The mare said your name, but had difficulty doing so from all the laughing. “Stop,” she said, still laughing.

“What's wrong?” You smiled whilst resting your head on Fluttershy's chest. She felt like a big, warm pillow to you.

“It tickles!” She giggled.

You laughed slightly and said cheekily, “well isn't that the point?” Fluttershy laughed again and stroked your hair with her hoof as you crawled down Fluttershy to her hind legs, getting your face close to what lay in between them. Fluttershy could tell what you wanted to do which caused a dark blush to spread across both of her cheeks. She still nodded in approval of what you were doing and spread her hind legs apart. Although you had already become acquainted with what was beneath Fluttershy's folds, you had never tasted it before. Curiously, you lowered your mouth onto it and licked up Fluttershy's marehood. Fluttershy's lips delicately touched on yours, only they weren't the lips on her face. They were more special lips. Fluttershy was wet for you again. You sucked and lapped up some of her wetness before focusing on what you thought must  her clitoris. (You still found it difficult to tell as you still weren't completely sure about her anatomy.) She moaned and breathed heavily and quickly. You looked up at Fluttershy with your tongue deep inside her and saw the face of the pleasured pegasus; mouth drooping slightly open and eyebrows facing up with her eyes squinting. It encouraged you to continue to eat Fluttershy out. Although you had no experience pleasing a mare with your mouth, you seemed to be doing a good job. Fluttershy's moans grew louder, “yesss!” She cried, followed by calling your name and spraying her ejaculate out into you. Some of it landed on the bed and mingled with your own fluids. You managed to swallow all of it that was in your mouth. The fact that you had been able to bring Fluttershy to cum felt amazing!

You looked up at her from between her legs. She was panting and laying her head back, making you wonder if she was tired out. You lay your head down next to her pussy and made little circles on her inner thigh with your index finger, “are you okay?” You asked.

Fluttershy opened her eyes and looked down at you and answered, “just tired. It's almost dawn!”

“Is it really that late?” You exclaimed, glancing out of the window to see the once black sky had now turned imperial blue, the dawn obscured by a thick layer of clouds.

“Don't you mean early?” Laughed Fluttershy as she petted your head with her hoof, “let's get some rest.”

“Yeah, okay,” you nodded and crawled back up to be eye-level with Fluttershy, whisking the covers over the both of you, “you know,” you began as you wrapped your arms tightly around Fluttershy, snuggling into her neck and looking at her, “I don't just love you. I'm in love with you,” you said.

“Oh! I, well,” Fluttershy was lost for words again which you found incredibly cute, “I think, I think I'm in love with you too,” she finished the sentence with your name and cuddled into you. You relaxed together and, shutting your eyes you felt snug and secure between Fluttershy's hooves and in the embrace of her warm body. She lay her head next to yours with her main sprawling out across your face.

“Good night, I love you,” she whispered.

“Good night, I love you too,” you said equally quietly.

The last thing you remembered before finally falling asleep was the peaceful sound of her breathing and the sensation of her breath on your forehead. Falling asleep naked with your lover, after a passionate night made you feel so content. It was wonderful; falling asleep with your little Fluttershy!

You awoke with the sun shining through the window onto your face. Fluttershy was nowhere to be seen so you immediately sat up. “Fluttershy?” You called.

“Good morning!” The cream-coloured pegasus rapidly jumped into you right in front of your face, startling you, “yaay! You're up! Good morning!” Fluttershy began to smile and closed her eyes, hugging you whilst flapping her wings to stay airborne. “Sleep well?”

“Yeah, I did, thanks,” you hugged back, being reminded of how much you loved the feel of her fur on your bare chest, “you?”

Fluttershy giggled like a filly and answered, “I did thanks to you!” Her comment made you blush. She daintily landed on top of your lap and bent her legs so she was directly on top of you, before you both shared a kiss. You felt the familiar sensation of something hard poking it's way to the covers but weren't sure if Fluttershy could feel it or not. “You know, last night I know you were staring at my butt,” said Fluttershy.

“Oh, yeah I was,” you admitted, “sorry.”

Fluttershy giggled and said, “it's fine,” her giggle became a cheeky laugh as wiggled her flanks from side to side, “did you think I wouldn't notice, silly,” her voice grew slightly more earnest, “if you wanted to look at my butt, all you had to do was say so!” She stood up, turned around so her rump was facing you, and lifted up her tail to the side, exposing the tight, round hole that it was covering. Her tail was so long the end of it drooped off the end of the bed and dangled close to the floor. You opened your eyes wide at the very sight of Fluttershy's ass this close to your face. It smelled, but you didn't mind, instead you filled your lungs with Fluttershy's personal scent as it graced your nasal glands. You could tell that Fluttershy wasn't relaxed, possibly still nervous, because her butt was still clenched fully tight.

“Fluttershy, it's okay, you don't need to be nervous,” you said, trying to reassure her. You noticed her hole not clench so tightly and you teased at it with your tongue.

“O-ohh yes,” Fluttershy breathed as you did so, so you continued. “Fuck...me...” The words escaped her mouth through clenched teeth.

“Oh, I can do that too,” you said jokingly, before giving Fluttershy more anilingus.

“W-well, you can. But if you want to!” Said Fluttershy, turning around.

“I do want to,” you told her, throwing the covers off you, revealing your rock-hard dick.

Fluttershy stood straddled on top of you, “be gentle,” you heard the mare say with her voice trailing off.

You nodded, “I promise I'll be gentle, Fluttershy.”

“Thanks, it's just that I've never done this before with a stallion,” she said with a quick, quiet voice which made it difficult for you to understand what she was saying. But you knew why she was talking so quietly and fast; she didn't want to say she was a virgin but thought you'd better know.

You raised your crotch to meet with Fluttershy's marehood. You could feel her lips parting around your member to let it in as she let out a whimper, unable to lower herself onto your dick the entire way, it was too big for her inexperienced pussy. You began to slowly thrust your dick in and out of Fluttershy's vagina which felt tight around it. Looking up, you admired Fluttershy's cute face which displayed a mix of pain, pleasure and concentration. She lowered her rump down, further this time, allowing your cock to enter deeper within her folds. While doing so, a loud moan erupted from her open mouth, “urrraaahhhhhh-aah-nnn!” Wailed Fluttershy whilst her rump slowly went up and down on your dick. You too felt moans escaping your own mouth. Leaning forwards, you held onto the cheeks behind her rump and shut your eyes tightly as you began to run your meat in and out of Fluttershy. You went a little rougher, hesitant at first but judging by the fact that that she was repetitively breathing, “yes, yes, yesss,” you continued to fuck Fluttershy rougher and rougher.

Your breathing was interrupted by Fluttershy's tongue in your throat. With both legs and wings spread, the mare's body was now utterly submitted to you in every possible place except for the mouth; she loved having her tongue in your mouth too much to allow herself to submit to you in that particular part. You stroked down Fluttershy's feathery wings with one hand as she began to call out your name whilst both of you made love together. You noticed Fluttershy cock her head back in ecstasy at you stroking her erect wings.

You could feel Fluttershy's inner walls cave in before warm, wetness soaked your member before you came too. Feeling like butterflies were fluttering around inside your brain with such an intense orgasm. “Oooooh,” you heard Fluttershy moan as you filled her up.

You both lay back, panting. Your breathing synchronised as both of you looked over at each other. Fluttershy smiled faintly, “thank you,” she breathed, still out of breath, “that was amazing.”

“Thank you too,” you shuffled yourself close to her, “it really was!” You grinned which provoked a cute giggle from Fluttershy who was no longer a virgin mare. She began to cuddle you tightly and shut her eyes tight. You lay your head on her cheek and nuzzled her, making Fluttershy more relaxed. She whisked her tail over your thighs and wrapped it over your legs. You had no idea how long you lay there cuddling Fluttershy, cradling her in your arms while she was doing the same. You had never felt more safe, more comfortable in the hands (sorry, hooves) of anybody before, and now, a little unexpectedly your little Fluttershy had made your cares go away.

However you soon felt the day slipping by, so you opened your eyes a little more, smiling at her and said, “hey, want me to go make you some brunch?”

“Oh, um, that would be lovely,” said Fluttershy, sounding pleasantly surprised. You sat up and got out of bed, happily making your way downstairs. “One more thing,” said Fluttershy.

“Hm?”

“Can you please put some pants on? Angel Bunny would have a heart attack if he saw your...thing,” Fluttershy said, suppressing a giggle. You burst out laughing while she did the same.