Anniversary Potion

Melody’s home; 1:27AM

The sounds of water being drain into a bucket started to wake Kat. Her eyes quickly adjusted to the dark bedroom that was only being lighted by a single lamp on the nightstand next to the queen-size bed. A the feeling of a cold rag being placed on her head went unresponded as she tried to gather the blurry memories from the hours ago. Moments passed by before the memories of the day flowed back to her, most clearly the events that took place mere hours before.

When the gray ceiling came into full focus, Kat turned her head where she could faintly remember hearing the splashing water. Along with the dark-gray of the bucket, Melody’s white fur and black panties that had her white Quaver shape cutie mare on it came into focus, and she tried to work her mouth to speak.

But Melody stopped her with a finger. “Don’t talk, you just woke up, but the book said that you’ll have most of your energy soon,” She said in a soft yet authoritative tone voice. Kat was slow to process all of Melody’s words but it did eventually reached her hazy brain. The twintail was going to speak again only to be yet again stopped by a white finger. “Before you ask, I saw it sitting on the couch, and you left your mouse bookmark on the page.” Kat soon realized that the ‘surprise’ was now ruin, she could at least say that they had a good dinner--mostly.

Melody sparked her horn making a glass of fresh water appear in her magical grip. “Here Kat, drink up, but not too fast.” Melody willed the glass towards Kat’s mouth as she gently raised her head up from the pillow that was decorated with princess Luna’s royal symbol.

Any movement of any kind sent a sprawling pain through Kat’s body, through her dry throat won the war of choices along with Melody’s encouraging hand. Melody started to tip the glass down so Kat didn’t have to move any further. The cold soothing water was a refreshing change to the dry soreness. Melody pulled the glass away when Kat started to cough from drinking too fast.

“I just got done telling you silly kitty, not to drink so fast,” Melody said, patting Kat on the back to help ease the coughing. “You alright,” She asked when the coughing fit was over. Kat wordlessly casted her gaze towards the black sheets of the bed, tears started to from around her eyes taking a bright green shine from her still glowing eyes. “You want to tell me what’s wrong?” Melody already knew it was about her finding out about the ‘surprise’ in a way that Kat didn’t want but she wanted the twintail’s side first.

“You know what’s wrong,” Kat shouted, more angry at herself than Melody, but she couldn’t hold back her emotions any more. “I spent nine days planning all this out, only for it to fall apart because of Ace getting seasick. I mean he is a freaking falcon-griffon for Nightmare’s shake! How does a falcon-griffon get seasick Melly?”

Melody sighed, knowing that Kat didn’t mean any real harm towards the griffon. She reached out a hand and started to rub the top of her head along with her ears. “I don’t really know, I asked him myself, but he just replied with more throw-up.” Even with the petting and Melody’s joke, Kat still remained upset, and it shown on her face. “You’re not really mad at him are you?”

“Yes...no, I don’t know!” The tears on Kat’s face started to stream down her cheeks, the beautiful emerald shine betrayed the sadness and rage they were to represent. “It’s not fair Melly, today was supposed to be our special day.”

Melody pulled Kat’s head down to her chest, knowing that the twintail likes to use it as a pillow sometimes. She started to stroke Kat’s long brown hair, humming a soft melody to calm the cat down. “And it was, dinner with you was great, and I’m sure that you liked that song.”

Kat wrapped her arms around Melody’s back, openly sobbing in the mare’s tank-top--which she must have changed into while Kat was unconscious. “Y-yeah, but even that I m-managed to mess up.” Kat’s grip tighten around her unicorn lover as her sobbing grew in volume. “Melly I-I’m sorry.”

“Kitty what do you have to be sorry for? You spent nine days without me to plan for our anniversary.” Melody started to rub the twintail’s soft ears, making her grip soften also getting her to meow in a hushed tone. “You went out of your way to study an alchemy book to find the right potion to use, which kind of makes me feel bad for not doing the same thing.”

“No! Melly, even with the book I managed to mess up. I was going to surprise you but the darn thing didn’t even work!” All Kat could tell from the potion that it just made her body feel hot for awhile and then--for no reason whatsoever--made her pass out. Nowhere near the effects she wanted it to have, so she thought.

“Um...Kat, I think you should look under the sheets,” Melody said with a hesitant voice, confusing Kat. The twintail looked towards her lover’s eyes, which only glanced towards the black sheets--particular in between her legs.

Kat did as she was told, lifting the sheets only to be faced with a limp eight inch dark brown shaft resting peacefully in between her legs like it belonged there. A heated blush came over both females as their eyes were trained on the thick shaft. “I-is it-”

“Yes,” Melody answered, knowing what was Kat’s question. “I’ve ran several magic scans on it, it’s real alright, and your cathood is still there.” Kat whipped her head towards Melody, who just nodded her head towards the shaft. The twintail wrapped her fingers around the shaft, already enjoying the shivers that it sent through her spine, and lifted it up to see that Melody was telling the truth. Her cathood still laid was nestled in between her legs, just now under the shaft.

“Melly I-”

“Kat there’s something I wanted to say first.” Kat’s voice became silent at the flat tone in Melody’s voice. “Kat, I love you, and nothing in this world will ever change that. You know that right?” The twintail’s voice failed to yield any responses so she just nodded her head. “I know that you worked real hard to make tonight special for the both of us, but you shouldn’t have done it alone, or better put I shouldn’t have let you done it alone.” Melody pulled Kat’s head back to her chest and started to sway from side to side. “I’m sorry Kat, I was too busy just trying to get home in time that I forgot to do something special for you, but now I think I know how.”

“Melody, you don’t-”

Yet again the twintail was interrupted by a white finger being placed on her lips. “Suhh, that’s enough from you. I already know I don’t have to but I want to, now lay down.” Kat followed Melody’s instructions as she laid her head back down on the bed. Melody stood from the chair she was sitting in, taking a spot on the bed on top of Kat, and starting to trail kiss down her body starting with her neck.

Kat had to bite back a fit of laughter from the teasing tickling, which turned into moans as the mare’s lips reached lower. Melody took a moment to play and lick Kat’s collarbone making Kat flinch and whine a little. The mare slowly lifted Kat’s tank-top, leaving her small breasts out in the open for her to stare at.

The twintail looked away from her unicorn lover, it was painfully obvious what Melody’s gaze was fixed on to. “S-stop staring Melly, we all can’t be cow-mares like you,” Kat said in a small flushed voice.

Melody started to giggle from the flushed look on Kat’s face. “But they’re so cute and tiny. I bet that they’re more sensitive too.” She rubbed a hand over the cat’s flat stomach, a single finger tracing up from her bellybutton to the center of her chest. Melody’s finger danced around the small breasts, daring to go across the perky mounds, but soon change course.

Kat started to shift around under Melody’s weight, the teasing becoming too much to bare, and she wished Melody would just get to the good part. Her silent wishes were granted when Melody took hold of one of the erect nipples and gave it a squeeze. Kat started to meow moan again, the cute sounds were their own individual masterpiece to Melody’s ears.

The mare soon took the rest of the breast in her hand along with the other one making Kat’s moans grow in pitch and volume. Melody leaned close to Kat’s ear, her hot breath tickling the soft fur. “You really like it when I play with your breasts huh? Your nipples are already hard and I can feel your ‘little kitten’ growing rather quickly behind me.” Melody bit on the sensitive ear making Kat scream from joy. She brushed her tail against Kat’s new shaft, sending a shiver down her cat’s spine.

Without warning, Melody removed her hands from Kat’s breasts, but quickly replaced them with her mouth and teeth. She licked the sides of the hardened nipple also circling around them as while. Kat grabbed hold of the mare’s dark blue mane, a clear line of drool forming around her mouth.

Keeping with the momentum, Melody slid down the rest of the twintail’s small body, trailing kisses and quick nibbles wherever she deemed worthy. As an act of playfulness, she sat down on the now hardened shaft making Kat subconsciously buck her hips upward.

The mare started grind her hips on the thick shaft, finding pleasure every time it rubbed against her marehood. “You know Kitty, you’re right I am a cow-mare,” Melody said, removing her navy-blue tank-top letting her massive breasts spill from the prison that’s known as fabric. “And I love it.” To tease Kat even more, Melody started to pinch and rub her own breasts. The soft angelic moaning coming from the mare made Kat want to do anything to hear more of it.

Kat started to reach out towards the breasts when Melody pulled them away with a seductive smirk. “Na-ah, after I get my treat--seeing that I didn’t get to have any dessert.” Melody lean down to Kat’s flat belly, she traced her tongue downwards, and stopped at Kat’s inward bellybutton to tease her even more.

Kat couldn’t hold back the overwhelming laughter from Melody’s teasing. She started to squirm about giggling like a little kitten. “M-Melly, s-stop I’m ticklish…” To get a better grip on the cat, Melody placed her hands on her small hips, and upped the teasing with her tongue. Kat grabbed onto Melody’s ears, when she started to rub them Melody took that as a sign of approval to continue with the teasing.

Melody circled around the cat’s bellybutton making her fits of giggles turn into moans of delight. While the mare’s tongue played with Kat, her breasts rested firmly on top of the fully erect shaft, and each movement form either sent a tingle through the twintail’s spine. Soon Melody grew tired of simply teasing Kat, so she resumed her travel downwards until her venture brought her to the course of the cat’s week of work.

She traced a soft finger on the shaft, sending more chills through Kat’s body, and making the large shaft throb. Melody was impressed by the sheer size of the meaty shaft, it was nearly twice the size of any toy they had used in the past, and the thought of it pushing past her outer petals sent a chill down her own spine.

“Kat, how many of those potions did you drink?” Kat blushed while she looked away from Melody’s questioning gaze.

“Oh I-I don’t know...nine maybe,” Kat said, blushing. At first she didn’t really like the bland taste of the potion but as time flew by she started to drink more and more after growing accustomed to the taste. “In a half.”

“Nine huh? Well let’s see what this thing can really do.” Melody wrapped her slender hands around the large shaft, the mare’s hands only made the shaft look bigger in comparison as she started to give an experimental stroke. She was rewarded with Kat’s soft moans, this prompted her to continue to stroke with more vigor.

Melody could feel Kat’s rapid heartbeat through the thick vines along side the shaft. With the approving moans from Kat, Melody started to lick the underside of the tip, and soon took the head in her mouth.

Kat shot up from the pleasure of having Melody’s warm mouth around her shaft. She placed her hands on the mare’s head and begged for her to go lower. Melody granted Kat her wish by taking more of the shaft in her mouth before coming back up. A slow pace soon found it’s way into Melody’s rhythm.

Her tongue started to circle around the twitching shaft, taking her to play with the head before going back down. She could feel the tip of the rod on the back of her throat, Melody was glad that she taught herself to control her gag reflex for when she performing on stage, or she wouldn’t be able to take most of the shaft.

Kat soon let Melody’s head go after she build a steady rhythm of her own, opting to cup her smaller breasts. She started to pinch and twist her hardened nipples as her eyes started to roll to the back of her head. Her thin cat tongue rolled out of her of mouth as she begged for release of the thigh pressure that was building around her shaft.

Melody recognized the violet twitching as a sign that Kat was close to the edge. She pulled the mouth off of the wet shaft with a ‘popping’ sound, which caused Kat to whine from premature release of her shaft, but was quickly replaced with louder moans when Melody started to lick her wet cathood and stroke the shaft at the same time.

As she continued to lick the leaking cathood, Melody savored the energy taste that Kat seemed to naturally have. She lick all along the outer petals before pushing past the wall. Kat couldn’t no longer think straight, the simulation from being stroked, and having her cathood lick was too much for her to process at the same time.

It wasn’t long before she was pushed over the edge and the first waves of her climax fired from both the shaft and poured from her cathood. Melody kept her mouth firmly around the gashing cathood, drinking as much of the wild-berry tasting juices as possible. Cum from the shaft landed on Kat belly and parts of Melody’s mane before the twintail finally collapsed onto the bed.

Melody took a few moments to lick the thick strands of cum from Kat’s belly, taking her time with the small pool that formed in the cat’s bellybutton, and the remaining cum from the still hard shaft.

Kat laid on the bed, too tired to even giggle from Melody’s tongue dancing around on her belly as she patted from exhaustion. “You know Kat, you’re smarter than you make yourself out to be,” Melody said after using her magic to clean up the cum in her mane. The twintail lazily looked down to see that the mare had already removed her black panties. “You single-handedly planned an anniversary surprise, was able to understand an alchemy book in less than nine days, and taught yourself how to cook a meal; all for me.” Melody placed a kiss on the side of Kat’s jawbone while the cat’s shaft pressed against her stomach.

“Melly, I love you, and I’ll do anything for you,” Kat whispered, wrapping her fingers in Melody's mane. “I’m sure you’ll do the same for me.”

Melody removed herself from the cat’s body as she looked towards the other side of the room in shame. “That’s the thing, I’ve haven’t been doing anything for you. I left you here all alone for a week while I was on tour and I didn’t do anything for you while I was away. Kat, I’m sorry, I’m a horrible marefriend.” Tears of her own started to form at her overdue realization.

Kat caught Melody by surprise when she suddenly sat up and placed a kiss on her lips. The mare tried to put of a fight but soon gave in the comforting kiss. The lover’s hands interlocked one another’s as their tongues met for a short-lived dance before Kat pulled away--even though Melody didn’t want her to.

The two remained in the close embrace, their eyes transfixing on one another’s. “Melody, just being with you is enough for me, and it all I can ask. I did all of this for you because I wanted to, not because I felt that I had to, and you know that.” Kat started to lick away her lover’s tears before she planted another quick kiss on her lips. “Melly the time we spend together is all the gift I can ask for.”

“But that’s not fair to you Kitty, I want to do so much more than just be with you,” Melody said, new tears forming around her eyes. “I want you to feel special, I want to give you something in return for your love, but this time I’m the one that falls flat.”

“Well, there is one thing you could give.” Kat shot Melody a seductive gaze as an obvious hint to something she’s been craving to do for a week now. Even though they have had sex in the past, Melody always have been reluctant to let Kat use any toy on her marehood. Even so, they still though it count, but there’s been a part of Kat that always wanted to take the mare’s purity, and now’s she thought was the best time as ever.

Melody blushed when she realized what the cat was talking about, through a warm smile spread across her face as she and Kat pulled each other into another kiss, this time Kat started to push Melody down to her back, and took the mare’s breasts in her hands.

Melody could feel the head of Kat’s shaft brush on her wet marehood, a slight ping of fear overtook her for just a moment, but Kat’s gentle message calm her down enough to where she wasn’t shaking. Kat moved the kiss down to Melody’s neck, in hopes it will keep the mare calm.

“Kat, I-I’m ready,” Melody shudder, knowing that the shaft is going to hurt at first, but she trusted Kat more than to be too afraid. Kat nodded her head, she moved off of Melody’s body to be able to line her shaft to Melody’s marehood. With one last reassuring nod from the unicorn mare, Kat started to push the shaft passed the tight walls, and almost doubled over from the amount of pleasure--and slight pain--she received from the entry.

Both females started to groan from the shaft’s entry, Melody’s tight walls squeezing around the meaty shaft, and the next few inches started to become easier as time went on. But Melody still felt immense pain from the girth and when Kat reached the finally barrier in the tight marehood.

Melody took hold of the bed sheets, the pain from the entry sting slightly more than she thought it would. “K-Kat it...h-hurts.” The pain alone was enough to bring tears to Melody’s sapphire eyes, now that the shaft rested deep within her right in front of her thin lining of innocence the pain was near unbearable.

The mare’s twintail lover started to rub her lower stomach to ease the strain the shaft was putting on her. “I know Melly, just wait a little longer, and I promise that it’ll get better.” Kat bend down to take one of Melody’s hardened nipples in her mouth and started to suck on it. Melody let the black bed sheets go to wrap her hands in Kat’s long brown hair to keep her mouth on the nipple--not like Kat was going to let go any time soon.

“O-okay Kat, do it.” Melody knew the pain was only going to get a LOT worse before it’ll get any better. Kat removed herself from Melody’s breasts, to look in the tear-filled orbs of pure sapphire. Melody could see the concern in the cat’s glowing green eyes, she started to rub the sides of Kat’s ears as reassurance. “I-I’ll be fine, just get it over with.”

Kat nodded towards her love, she started to push her hips further in Melody’s marehood, but couldn’t muster up the strength to break the wall of virginity causing more pain for Melody. “I-I’m s-sorry Melly, I...I can’t do it,” Kat said, giving a few more pushes only to meet failure.

Melody fought through the pain and tears to look Kat in the eyes. “Then let me help.” She wrapped her legs around Kat’s slender waist, keeping her from pulling out any more. With one more thrust Kat finally broke the seal, making Melody scream from the pain. Kat was quick to pull Melody in for a kiss, putting the pain-filled screams to rest, and cupped the mare’s breasts to help her overcome the pain before they continued.

A few moments went by before Melody gave Kat permission to being. The twintail pulled the shaft out of the mare’s marehood a few inches before pushing back in. Kat started to build a slow rhythm for Melody until she grew accustomed to the pain, which was becoming less of a worry with each thrust, and eventually the mare started to beg for more harder thrusts.

The slow rhythm soon became a quick and steady one that both could find pleasure in. Kat started to have trouble keeping up with Melody’s demands, so the mare started to buck her hips in time with Kat’s. Each thrust became deeper and faster within time, so was Melody’s demands.

Wanting to do nothing but make her happy, Kat throw out the steady thrusting in favor for more powerful long ones that had her burying the shaft deep inside of Melody. Kat couldn’t believe how warm Melody’s marehood was as it rivaled her mouth. The same pressure from before started to build in the shaft again, prompting her to up the thrusting so to please Melody.

With the new thrust, Melody’s chest bounced in time. Kat lunged for the massive mounds taking them in her teeth and sucked on them as if she trying to milk the mare.

Melody’s eyes started to roll to the back of her head, all feeling of pain gone from the shaft, and only pleasure was left. Along with bucking her hips with Kat’s, Melody reached down to her two tails giving them both a rough squeeze and pulled. Kat moaned around Melody’s nipples, increasing her thrusting from the mare messing with her tails.

Melody also took Kat’s ears in her mouth, biting down on them with her teeth. Kat could feel Melody’s marehood clenching down on her shaft, telling her that her lover was as close to the edge as she was. “M-Melly...I’m gonna-”

Kat was unable to finish the sentence because of Melody pulling her in for a kiss. “I-I know Kitty...I want it inside of me...please.” Kat couldn’t hold back the immune pressure that’s been building again in the shaft. Kat let loose a torrent of cum from both the shaft and neglected cathood, firing thick creamy gobs of cum deep in Melody’s marehood.

The force of the twintail’s climax was enough to bring Melody to her own. She tightened her grip around Kat’s waist, keeping her deep inside of her as she rode out the stream of cum the shaft was firing. Kat was able to give a few more thrusts before she passed out on top of Melody’s chest.

Both lovers basked in the warm afterglow of their time together, the only sound they could mustered to make was breathless breathing. Melody kept her hands on Kat’s head while the cat moved her’s to Melody’s sweaty back.

They could feel the excess amount of cum leak out of Melody’s marehood, also the absence of the shaft. Kat looked down conforming the feeling of the shaft being gone. “Hey wait, where did it go,” Kat asked breathlessly.

Melody caned her head downwards so she could see what Kat was talking about. “I-I think the book said something about it turning into cum after being used on a female,” She said, remembering reading the part in the book. “You read the book right?” Kat looked away with a sheepish grin on her face, telling Melody all she needed to know. “So you didn’t.”

Kat rested her head back on Melody’s chest to hid the flustered look on her face. “I did...kind of.” Melody simply rolled her eyes and planted a kiss on top of Kat’s head, getting a meow from her. “Night Melly, I love you.”

Melody wrapped her arms around Kat’s body also lighting her horn making the covers appear on top of them before closing her eyes. “Goodnight Kitty, I love you too.” The lovers soon found Luna’s and Nightmare’s world of dreams, creating ones that only had them in it in each other’s loving embrace.

-The End, Sid.