Rarity’s expressions was priceless to Sunset, it was as though the mare had seen a ghost. The white unicorn was just about to scream, but it seemed that her captor has planned for this to happen. Sunset used her magic to wrap around Rarity's neck to prevent her from making too much noise. “I can’t have you go screaming about now, and then we won’t get to have our little fun if I get caught this soon.” Sunset began to fondle her prey’s breasts as she struggled to free herself, choking for air. “Your breasts are just beautiful, almost as good as mine I might say.” Sunset placed a hand in her pocket and pulled out a ring etched with runes, then placed it around Rarity’s horn. These rings were specially designed to prevent criminal unicorn ponies from using their magic during their imprisonment, they also gained quite a popularity in the S&M society for that very same reason. “There we go, now you can’t use magic and I added my own special effects to the ring as well,” she told her as she released the grip of her magic from Rarity’s neck.

The white unicorn was dropped onto the bed and coughed heavily as she tried to catch her breath once more. She looked at the orange unicorn, her eyes filled with rage, and attempted to yell but not a noise was made. Clearing her throat, she opened her mouth once more, but no words came out. Her hands reached to her horn in hopes to remove the ring, but as soon as she touched it, a jolt of electricity coursed through her body. Air escaped her mouth instead of screams. Though its power wasn’t enough to damage the mare permanently, the sudden shock still made her drop on the bed once more.

Sunset Shimmer casually walked to Rarity and picked her up by the horn and licked her snout. “There’ll be plenty more of that if you don’t behave yourself from now on, you’re about to join my slave harem.” The door opened slowly and Fluttershy peeked inside, she nodded to her mistress and she nodded back. “Good, it looks like we’re ready to begin.” Sunset began dragging Rarity by the horn, she struggled with all her might but it seemed as though her body was beginning to feel weak.

Rarity saw Fluttershy’s face as she was taken out of the room, with tears running down her face, she tried to plea for help but it seemed as though her friend had a different plan. With a lustful face, Fluttershy licked her lips as she followed the two down the stairs and into the kitchen. The three fillies were sound asleep, a cup of tea in front of each of them. Rarity squirmed some more, wanting to protect her helpless sister from her captors.

Slapping Rarity on the face to get her attention, she held the mare up by the horn and stared at her face. “Don’t worry, I have a far more different plan for these three than I do for you.” Shoving her to the ground, she used her magic to levitate the trio and put them side to side of each other. Rarity punched at Sunset’s leg but her hits weren’t doing anything. With an annoyed expression she quickly turned to Fluttershy, “handle her,” she ordered before going back to work.

It didn’t take long for Fluttershy to obey, she grasped Rarity around the waist and leaned close to her ear. “I’ve wanted to do this to you for a very very long time.” Without warning, her hand slipped under Rarity’s dress and began fondling her breast. “Nice and firm, just how I always imagined.” She whispered as Rarity squirmed in hopes to escape her grasp. Next her face moved up to the horn, her tongue extended and ready to give it a good licking.

With the three fillies in front of her, Sunset’s magic had located what she was looking for. Three small gems that each girl had were now in her hands, “good, they didn’t waste them like I thought they would,” she bore a smirk as she stared at the gems. Sunset had given these to Cadance when she sent her to retrieve Pinkie and ordered her to give them to anypony but was surprised whom she had given them to. These gems were enhanced by the Crystal Heart back in the kingdom and would make the holders, much like the rest of the Crystal Kingdom, become eternally loyal and in love with Sunset when activated. With a touch of her magic all three gems began to glow and return to their owners, embedding themselves onto the fillies’ chest over their hearts.

It took about a minute or two for the girls to open their eyes, each of them holding their heads as though they’d just had the biggest brain freeze of their lives. Sweetie Belle was the first to recover, whom got a good look at her sister being played with by Fluttershy and laughed. “That’s pathetic Rarity, I know you’ve been wanting to play with Fluttershy for a very long time now, you even wrote about it in your diary.” Clearing her throat, she began to mimic Rarity’s voice. “Oh Diary, I just had the most wonderful time with Fluttershy at the spa again. We both got usual treatment and once again I got to face her cute little flank during out massage. What I would do to just have my way with that, but I fear that even bringing up the idea might be too much for the poor girl… One day I hope to be able to get through her shy nature and show her how I would treat a lady in private.” All of the girls laughed at this, even Sunset, whereas Rarity’s expression was at the verge of tears. As she noticed this, Sweetie moved in closer to her older sibling and gave her a good slap across the face. “Get over yourself, you know you like it… not like you have a choice anyways.”

“That’s enough,” said Sunset as she looked at the clock in the kitchen, it was well past evening time, “we’ve been here far too long and must make our way back. Girls,” the three Crusaders lined up in front of sunset once more, ready for their task, “I need for you to make a distraction so that we can make our way back easier. After that, I want you,” she pointed at Scootaloo, “to find Rainbow Dash and stay near her just in case you are needed. And you,” she pointed at Apple Bloom, “go back home and stick around your sister as well.”

“What about me, miss Sunset?” Sweetie Belle asked as she curiously stared at her sister whom was now crying her eyes out but no sound escaped her mouth.

“I want you to find the snotty Twilight Sparkle and keep her occupied.” She replied with a rather angry expression, “surely it won’t be too long before she notices what’s been going on and I need her out of the picture for as long as possible. Lie, cheat, cause mayhem, whatever it takes, just make sure that she is kept away from Dash and AJ… I want to save her for last.”

With their orders in mind, the trio bowed to their leader before going upstairs to pick up some supplies. It didn’t take them long to get what they needed, they carried off a large supply of fireworks, and they headed out the door without another word.

“As for you,” she turned to face Rarity now, a cup of now cold tea in her hand, “I need you to take a nice nap before we go.”

Rarity struggled but Fluttershy had one arm around her waist, pinning down her own arms, while the other arm forced her mouth open. “It’s okay Rarity, when you wake up I promise to make your little fantasies a reality.” Fluttershy kissed her on the cheek before the tea began pouring into her mouth. She tried to cough it out but it seemed as though it was to no use. Her body already weakened by the device on her horn, it didn’t take long for Rarity’s body to go into slumber.

As they waited for the distraction, Fluttershy began tying up Rarity’s arms and knees while Sunset picked out a long trench coat to use on her. Once the bounds were hidden, they both stared out the window and waited. “I wonder what kind of distraction they plan to use…” Mentioned Fluttershy, eagerly wanting to get her way with their prize.

“I don’t know but we’re going to have to make our move soon…” Sunset replied as she too was beginning to get impatient. As they stared out the window, several pops of stars appeared in the far off distance. Fireworks began going off, showering the town in a marvelous glow. “Really?! This is the best they could come up with? I should of known better than to…” Suddenly she remembered a similar display of fireworks back in the other world that had been done by the crusaders and the aftermath that followed. Moving quickly, she pushed Fluttershy’s head away from the window and took cover herself. “Don’t look out there!” She ordered.

It seemed that the plan was working, ponies were gathering outside their homes in awe of what they thought was an early show for the Celebration to come, little did they know of what was to come. The sky was filled with colors when a large boom filled the town, making the night disappear for a few seconds and turning it brighter than the morning sun before turning dark again. People began screaming in panic and bumping into one another, it seemed as though the light show had blinded plenty of ponies’ vision as intended by the trio.

Quickly taking a look out the door, this was now the perfect time to make their escape. Fluttershy grabbed one side of Rarity while Sunset held the other, the two carrying off the sleeping mare as though she had been a victim of the blast much like other ponies around. With a majority of the populace blinded, they made their way literally unseen by anypony back to the home where they would begin having fun with their newly added pet.

Author's Note

Firework idea came from here, I have no plans to use the CMC in any actions of sex within my story. I also promise that the next chapter will be mostly dedicated on welcoming Rarity into the harem :3