The Missing Pony

Applejack began to stir awake, the pain that had filled her head now seemed gone but now she had a whole new set of problems. When she opened her eyes all she could see is darkness, at first she thought it might have been from her being knocked out but she quickly realized that her vision was being blocked by something. Her hands were unable to move much, they had been tied behind her back and she could feel her legs had also been bound and connected to her hands in a form of hogtie. She tried to feel her way around but was unable to move her fingers either, they had been cupped into a fist and held firmly in place by something. Now panicking, she yelled out in a scream but now noticed that something had been forced into her mouth which muffled her cries for help. Squirming and trying to break free, she struggled against her bonds in a fit of panic but to no avail, all she managed to do was tire herself out. Laying there, catching her breath, she tried to listen for something, anything, that would give her information but all she got was silence. Her eyes filled with tears as hope was beginning to fade for her, her muffled crying being all that filled her head for now.

The door to the basement swung open but Applejack didn’t hear anything, not the evil laughing or the steps that Sunset Shimmer took to get closer to her. She only realized that someone was there when they had sat on her like a common chair. Once again she squirmed to buck them off but she wasn’t able to get enough motion to do so. Sunset moved their finger around AJ’s flank, which only made her squirm more, as it slowly made it’s way up to her breast and pinched her nipple. AJ let out a muffled squeal as the hand was now groping her, while she felt a tongue lick the tip of her other nipple as she tried her best to get away. After several minutes of constant struggling she had tired herself out, breathing heavily as she could do nothing to stop her attacker. Whatever was inside her mouth was taken out after a few minutes of teasing, after panting hard to catch her breath she was just about to yell at her attacker when Sunset suddenly started kissing her. She shook her head to get them off but the attacker was very persistent on their mission. “Stop… What are... Who…” Was all that she managed to get out in between kisses before something slick and long began to be pushed into her mouth. She tried to force it out with her tongue but it was too late, the harness had been locked and her cries were muffled once more.

Sunset moved in closer to Applejack’s face, removed her magical sound dampening ear plug and whispered “You’ll get used to this soon enough Applewhore, just like the rest of your friends have.” She put the plug back into AJ’s ear and was just reaching for a dildo to shove up her prisoner’s butt when her magical sensor began going off, someone had just entered the house’s perimeter and was going to knock. With a heavy sigh she stuffed the dildo where she had wanted, got up and walk out the basement. “You’d better keep that in,” she said to AJ before exiting, even though she couldn’t hear, “or else there’ll be something far worse in store for you.”

Sunset, using the changeling mask to look like Cadance, had answered the door and it was Twilight. She had several small scrolls in her hands, stared up at the fake Cadance.

“Hello Cadance, have you heard the news about Fluttershy?” She asked in a low, sad tone, she was clearly having a hard time to not break down into tears.

Sunset, or rather Cadance, almost panicked at seeing her. She stepped outside and closed the door before anyone decided to get into view and calmed herself before talking. “No… no I haven’t... what seems to be wrong?” She lied, bearing a worried look. “Hope nothing terrible happened to her.”

Twilight handed her a flier with a very shaky hand which said the following:

Missing: Fluttershy was last seen around the Ponyville plaza, accompanied by a blue Pegasus mare, on June 10th at around 4 PM. Her pet bunny, Angel, has also informed us that she has also not been present at her home for several days prior to her last known date seen. If you have any information leading to their whereabouts please contact the Ponyville Guard.

“Oh… that’s awful…” Sunset nearly cursed as she read the flier, she was so stupid for being so careless about this. “If there’s anything I can do, please let me know immediately.”

“That’s why I’m here actually,” Responded Twilight, “I was looking for Pinkie and Rarity earlier but was unable to find them at their house so you were my next stop.” She handed her one of the scrolls, which she opened quickly. “That’s a map of the surrounding areas of Ponyville, the red areas are the ones that the Guard have already searched over but as you can see,” the map barely showed any red marks at all, “there’s still a lot of ground and sky to cover. I wanted to gather everyone up and cover as much as possible later today.”

Sunset almost accidentally ripped the map in half as she heard that, her eyes widened as she saw her plans falling apart right in front of her. “O-okay, sure, I would love to help out with this.” But if she did go out, how would she keep the other ponies in line? Pinkie was a rebel whom only listened when she wanted to, Cadence’s obedience was questionable, Applejack was nowhere near broken in yet and Rarity still had some way to go before she was ready. “How about you let me help with those?” She pointed at the scrolls, “I can deliver one to Applejack and help look for Rarity and Pinkie while you go deliver the last one to Rainbow Dash and get things ready for tonight.” She smiled, rather nervously at that, in hopes for this to work.

Twilight nodded in reply, “thanks a lot Cadance,” she said as she began handing the scrolls to her, “this’ll give me more time to speak to Mayor Mare about the matter, I’m hoping she can get more of the guard to help us out tonight as well.” With one last hug Twilight made her way out to visit Rainbow Dash, leaving Sunset cursing at herself for allowing this to happen.

Sunset slammed the door behind her as soon as Twilight was out of sight and marched onto the kitchen, yelling at the top of her lungs for everyone to gather around the table instantly as her magical aura drew shut each of the curtains. Cadance, Pinkie, Fluttershy and the two guards, Ultima and Flash Sentry, quickly gathered and sat at the table.

“We have a problem.” Sunset stated with a frown, eyes moving over the group as she tapped her fingers on the table nervously, sitting on the last available seat. “We’ve moved too slowly. Ponies are noticing the disappearances, and with that, the guard are as well. Search parties are being organized, and…” She sighed, looking down “...We may not have long until this all comes crashing down on our heads.”

Ultima, Fluttershy and Flash frowned, the jaws of the boys setting as their eyes widened a little, making eye contact with her worriedly. Cadance’s head scanned the room, reading everypony’s reaction before looking at Sunset, “Does that mean it’s over, mistress?”

Pinkie, however, smirked and leaned back in her chair, her arms folding over her stomach as her legs crossed. “Worried about a few guards? That isn’t the mistress I’ve come to know and love.” She said seductively, winking.

“B-But we can’t come back from this!” Sunset stammered “They’ve caught us off guard, and while they haven’t searched much of the area they’re bound to find you soon!” She exclaimed, her eyes wide. “W-We’ve lost, it’s all over… What can we possibly do?” The fiery mare sighed, her eyes and ears lowering as she focused intently on the table “...It’s all coming apart…” She muttered with a frown “...I’ll never have my revenge… Now’s the time to either run, get used to prison, or… Worse.” She sighed, her eyes closing.

Pinkie smirked, leaning forwards on the table, making eye contact with Sunset. “Come on, mistress. Don’t give in. Remember, we have something that the Guard won’t be able to defeat in a hurry, and that could just buy us a little more time…” She whispered with a grin, trying to make eye contact with Sunset.

“...And what could that be?” Sunset asked dejectedly, eyes slowly raising to meet Pinkie’s “The ‘power of friendship’? Sure, like that’s going to do anything…” She muttered.

“You forget that it isn't just you in this, mistress.” Pinkie said with a grin, maintaining eye contact “You have us. More importantly, you have…” she pointed at Cadance, “Alicorn magic… let it aid you… Take it until it serves no further purpose.”

Cadance gave everyone a shocked look, she couldn't believe what she just heard. “Wait, what? I…” was all that she managed to say before being interrupted by Pinkie.

“Twilight told us how she and the other two high and mighty princes’ transferred their magic onto her,” she explained, “if she can handle it, I’m sure you’ll have no problem.”

“You’re right!” Yelled Sunset, keeping eye contact with the mare for a few seconds, her jaw dropping as her eyes widened. “… At my fingertips I could have more power than i’d ever imagined…” Sunset stated, grinning and looking down at her hands “...It may not be the power of love, but lust combined with a few memory spells..” She stated breathlessly, slowly standing up and walking over behind Cadance, before she grinned and pulled her head back by her hair, Sunset’s lips lowering to capture the pink alicorn’s in a deep kiss, which Cadance eagerly accepted, arching her neck back and gasping as her eyes closed.

~I… I can’t....~ She thought to herself as her eyes opened, now locked with Sunset’s, ~I… I shouldn't… I have to stop this… yet, I...~

“This will take some time, so be on the lookout for anypony coming our way” She mentioned to Pinkie and Fluttershy before turning to the two guards. “You two, I want you to go help Twilight on her fruitless search, lead her as far away from here as you can. As for you,” she turned to Cadance and grabbed her by the collar of her shirt, “...Come with me, slave. Let’s go somewhere… Darker, to transfer the magic.” Sunset whispered, slowly raising and looking down on Cadance with a praising smile.

Author's Note

After a much hated writing block and having to re-write the chapter, I can now say it's finally finished x.x Big thanks to Dark Vessel for motivating me through this and even helping me write part of this! Hopefully next chapter won't take me as long to write >.< On other news there will be more art coming up for the series (hopefully soon) so keep an eye out in derpibooru for that, it'll all be tagged as my little enslavement