Pinkie’s head tilted in confusion at the sight of her friend’s misfortune, however, instead of worrying, she giggled and walked over to Fluttershy. “Wow wee Fluttershy, I never knew you played this version of the game before! I didn’t think you were the kind of girl for it, but I think you’re doing it wrong.” Before anyone realized it, she was already examining Fluttershy’s body as it laid on the table. “Hmmm… These are clearly Mule ears, not Donkey. There needs to be a bulls eye drawn around your butt cheeks to give the other player a target.” She grabbed the dildo gag from Sunset’s grasp and examined that as well. “This isn’t even the right tool for the job, you need a stallion size to fill you in just right. We can probably ask one of the guys downstairs to join us, I’m sure they’ll be more than happy to lend their dicks for the cause.”

Both Sunset and Cadance were awestruck by the unexpected actions from the pink pony, neither of them knew how to respond to this.

“What’s wrong sillies? Cock got your tongue?” Pinkie began to juggle three dildos in her hands as she continued to laugh. “This isn’t my first kinky party you know, I just wish you would have told me about it so I could be more prepared.” She placed a riding crop straight on her nose and balanced it. “There’s this one yellow Pegasus, Rory Kenny… Kenne? Kenneigh? Well, anyways, he’s always up for these kinds of parties, I can go get him if you want.” She gave the duo a large grin as she continued to play around with the toys.

“Well… looks like she’s got more experience at this than you thought Cadance.” Sunset wore a smirk in her face. Things had just gotten much easier for her, but first she would have to play her cards right. She walked up to Pinkie, whom had somehow managed to balance her body on the tip of the largest dildo available. “My dear Pinkie, it seems that we are indeed in need of your aid.” Her voice had a tone of kindness to it. “Could you perhaps demonstrate to us how to properly play this game? It would be a shame to dear Fluttershy, who mustered up the courage to volunteer for this, to not get the full enjoyment.” She used her magic to levitate a double ended strap on, which went inside Pinkie with ease as soon as her shorts were off, and secured it around her waist.

Though Pinkie had lost her balance as the strap on invaded her, she landed with ease and allowed the toys she was playing with fall to the ground. “Wowzers, this thing is huge.” The end that was sticking out was about 15 inches long and 3 inches in diameter, far longer and thicker than the average pony. "Are you sure you’re up for this Shy? This thing is going to wreck you!”

Fluttershy’s body shifted around a bit, she was unsure of how to feel about being violated by one of her friends. However before she could make up her mind, Sunset gave her a slap on the butt and she nodded. Her legs began to spread, her tail raised and moved to the side, exposing her two holes ready for the choosing.

“See, she’s practically begging for it.” Sunset rubbed Fluttershy’s butt where she had struck her. “Cadance, be a dear and help get that nice and coated. We wouldn’t want any resistance when it enters.” She hated herself for being so nice, but this was the easiest way to manipulate the pink pony and not alarm her of what was in store.

Cadance got on her knees and began running her tongue throughout the shaft, lubricating every single part of it. Pinkie giggled as she began licking the head, “come on silly, if you want to get it nice and wet you have to get it inside.” She grabbed the back of Cadance’s head and jammed the dildo into her mouth. Her gag reflex acted up but managed to hold, the sound of slurping could be heard through the room as Cadance’s face kept being pushed in and out of the toy. Meanwhile Pinkie seemed to be enjoying playing the game, “Weeeeee!” After several minutes of thoroughly coating the dildo, Pinkie laid an exhausted Cadance on the ground and moved to the back of Fluttershy. “Now for the game, though it’s called ‘Pin the Tail on the Donkey,’ the ‘tail’ doesn’t have to go into the butt. First we must see which hole is Fluttershy’s most sensitive, that’s the one that’ll give her a doozie.”

She grabbed a smaller, smoother dildo off the ground and began probing Fluttershy’s vagina. The yellow mare instantly reacted to the toy entering her body, she moaned sexually through the ball gag and was making a move to close her legs but Pinkie gave her another slap on her butt. “We’re just getting started with the game, you can’t stop now.” Pinkie continued to gently move the dildo in and out of her vagina for about two minutes until she finally pulled it out and placed the tip on her anus. “This is the tricky part now, don’t clench your butt~” Without warning, she shoved the toy inside as far as it could go. Fluttershy let out a scream of both pain and pleasure, which made Pinkie stop almost instantly. “Are you sure you can handle this Shy? I’m beginning to think that this might be a bit too much for you.”

Fluttershy laid almost motionless on the table, heavily panting to catch her breath. Sunset walked up behind Pinkie Pie and pushed her hand, continuing to probe the mare’s hole. “She’s fine, trust me. Me and Cadance have been helping poor Fluttershy break from her mold, she actually told us herself that she needs to expand her interests, isn’t that right Shy?” Fluttershy’s head nodded in reply as she continued to moan from the pleasure her body was receiving.

“Huh…. Well, if you say so.” Pinkie awkwardly looked at Sunset’s face, closely studying her. “Hey… don’t I know you from somewhere? I could have sworn someone describing a mare like you…”

Sunset stepped back a bit, she nervously laughed at Pinkie’s remark and hoped that her lies would be good enough, the last thing she wanted to do was use magic and give away her position so soon. “Well you see… I know Rory Kenneigh as well. He and I go way back, we used to do a lot of orgy parties together until I decided to settle down. I’m just here to help out our dear princess Cadance plan with for the festival, isn’t that right dear?” Cadance, whom was now slowly picking herself off the ground, simply nodded in reply.

Pinkie moved in closer to Sunset’s face, rubbing her lower chin as she tried to remember. “I suppose… he does talk about lots of girls after all.” She took out the dildo out from Fluttershy, whom gave a sigh of relief, and pulled up her floppy strap on that she had on. “Well, after much teasing, I have decided that Fluttershy prefers it on her number one hole rather than her number two. So, without further ado.” She flipped the helpless mare over and backed up to the wall of the room, putting on a blindfold and taking off her remaining clothes in the process. Once the wall was reached, she spun around several times then stopped. “Okay, now make lots of noises Fluttershy!” She began to slowly inch her way around, putting her hands up in the air to feel her way around.

Sunset grinned at the opportunity that had been handed to her, she went up to Cadance and pulled her towards Fluttershy’s head. “You know what to do,” she whispered, “don’t fuck this up or else.” Sunset stepped back and watched closely.

Cadance began massaging Fluttershy’s exposed breasts and kissed her sweet, embarrassed face. The poor, helpless mare could do nothing but struggle and moan as her body was tormented. “Oh, I hear you~” Called out Pinkie from across the room, she turned around and began inching her way towards the pair. Sunset’s horn began to glow, the strap on began to vibrate which almost made Pinkie fall to her knees. “Ohhh… that feels good.” Her body began to shake as she continued forward until finally she made contact with the table that contained Fluttershy. “Found you!” She cheered as she began positioning herself between the legs. Once she positioned the dildo on top of the vagina, Fluttershy’s moans increased in volume. “Don’t worry Shy, I promise to be as gentle as possible~” Slowly, she began inserting the tip of the large, vibrating toy into her hole.

Cadance unlatched the gag from Fluttershy’s mouth, she was panting heavily as the fake cock was beginning to make its way inside of her. “P-pinkie… please…” Was all that she managed to say before Cadance planted a kiss in her sweet lips. She began massaging one of her breasts, Fluttershy could do nothing but sink into the bliss enjoyment.

“Ooo, I want a piece of that action too.” Pinkie called out as she leaned her body lower and began sucking on Fluttershy’s remaining tit as she continued to slowly jab the dildo inside.

At that moment Sunset leaned in on Cadance, touching her horn with her own and combining their magic. A small, dark purple heart popped out and gently floated towards Pinkie Pie, whom was still too busy suckling on Fluttershy’s breast. The heart popped as soon as it touched Pinkie’s head, at first look it seemed as though nothing had happened, suddenly she began to pick up speed and laugh in a very creepy way. Her cotton hair began to go down, as though it was a balloon that had been deflated. She bit into Fluttershy’s nipple, whom screamed out as Cadance broke her kissing in shock of what was happening. “Huh… that’s an interesting reaction.” Sunset watched Pinkie’s transformation with amazement, the pink pony began thrusting harder at Fluttershy whom began to scream. “It seems that your friend Pinkie has a darker side to herself, just as Fluttershy does, however hers is far easier to release.”

“I have to change her back!” Cadance lashed out, her horn began to glow and shot a pink beam at Pinkie but it only seemed to irritate her. “W-what’s going on? My love spell should have cleared her mind.”

“Insolent bitch.” Sunset used her own magic to bind Cadance and placed a special ring on her horn, which was designed to nullify her magic. “Your friend is far from your love’s reach now, I’ve infected her with a different type of love. You see, she now loves to serve me. Unlike you though, she is now fully under my command, isn’t that right?”

“Okey dokey lokey,” Pinkie answered in a very unhappy manner, she had been thrusting so hard into Fluttershy that she had stuffed more than half the length of the strap on into her.

“She too will make a far greater, more obedient pet than you.” She lifted Cadance up and began to drag her out the door. “Pinkie, be a dear and keep training our dear guest, I have to do some training of my own. It seems that my oldest pet still doesn’t know her place, maybe another night with the boys will teach her a lesson.”

“Pinkie! Snap out of it!” Cadance called out as she was being pushed out of the room. “I’m sorry for what I did! This wasn’t supposed to happen!”

Her cries were cut off as the door closed behind her, Pinkie’s sinister grin grew once more as she was now alone with Fluttershy. She pulled out of the hole, making a small satisfying pop as she did so. Walking over to the front of her face, Pinkie deeply kissed her friend in the mouth, savoring her taste. “You’d better be ready for a long night,” she began to stroke her hair softly, “because you’re in for the ride of your life.”

Author's Note

There you have it folks, my first chapter with lots of sex scenes. This was rather challenging to write but I like how it turned out.