Sweetie's Stud

by mrdojo18

Rating: mature
Tags: Slice of Life, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Sweetie Belle, Romance, Button Mash, Comedy, Rarity, Sex
Length: 9671

What do you do when your sibling is having some fun with her coltfriend? Do you watch, or run away? In Rarity's case, she stays to watch and is met with unexpected results.

Sweetie Belle is all grown up, living her life just as she wants to. She has quite a few different talents, and she's almost out of school. She even has her very own Coltfriend. When Rarity is out of the boutique for a little while, the two decide to have some "fun". What they don't know is that Rarity came home early, and becomes intent on watching the two go at it.

Cover Art: http://br-david.deviantart.com/art/Button-Sweetie-411134516

This story will contain Sweetie Belle x Button Mash (Chapter 1) and Button Mash x Rarity (Chapter 2). Both Button Mash and Sweetie Belle are aged up to the age of consent (18-19). This story has also only been proofread by me, so expect a few errors here and there, nothing too seriously bad (I hope). Oh, and there are a few cases of terrible humor.

Published 2014-02-28 21:00:13 UTC
Last updated 2014-05-24 19:08:18 UTC

Chapter 1

Rarity’s horn filled the dining room with a blue tint for a brief moment as she finished setting the table when she heard a knock on the front door to the boutique. Tonight was the night that her sister, Sweetie Belle, was bringing her new coltfriend over for dinner, Button Mash. Sweetie’s Eighteenth Birthday was today and she was currently finishing her last year at Miss Cheerlie’s Schoolhouse; she didn’t want to spend her savings for her own place, as she was going to use it to pay for her tuition at Celestia’s School for Gifted Unicorns. As it turns out, after spending time with Twilight and the rest of the Cutie Mark Crusaders, Sweetie Belle had gained exceptional skills in the Magic Department, as well as singing. Fluttershy had no problem teaching her more than enough to get her on a professional level.

Rarity on the other hand wasn't doing as good as Sweetie Belle, but she was managing. She would get occasional visits from Fancy Pants or Sapphire Shores, and they would usually request her to make something “Over-The-Top Marvelously Stupendous” as she would put it whenever she told Sweetie Belle about it. About Forty Percent of her income was from those visits, so basically if they were to ever quit requesting dresses/outfits, she would have to cut back on a lot of things she wasn’t willing to cut back on. That’s Rarity for you though, always so damn needy...anyways, she trotted to the door to greet both Sweetie Belle and her Coltfriend.

They looked odd standing next to each other. There was just such a size difference. Sweetie belle was about half as tall as Button Mash was, and she had quite a long mane that Rarity was a little bit disgusted by, simple because it wasn't “Up to par” with her own. Sweetie Belle had told her many times that she didn't care as much and that she still stole looks from other Colts at school. She's a tiny little thing too; her horn wasn't as long as Rairty’s, and her tail wasn't as long either. She must've gotten that trait from their Dad. Rarity’s dad was a thin Stallion of average height, weight, pretty much everything else. At least they could both eat whatever the hell they wanted to, and not gain a single pound.

Rarity herself was definitely better looking than her sister. She was taller than Sweetie Belle in height, while being shorter that Button Mash, making her perfect in the height department. Even with her pushing thirty years of age, she prided herself on keeping her lovely figure intact, mostly for all the local stallions who could stare at her for eons.

Button Mash towered over both of them it seemed, especially Sweetie. He must've been a hoofball player at one point, maybe Rarity was thinking that simply because how fit he was. Not like that one Pegasus who’s wings are the size of Sweetie Belle’s Friend, Scootaloo, and he has the muscle mass of Iron Will. If anything he was more like Big Macintosh fit, except it was actually a little less than that. Rarity was too busy deciding who she could compare his body to to notice that Sweetie Belle had spoken up.

"Hiya Rarity! This is Button Mash, I’m sure you two have met before, right?" Sweetie said.

Button stuck out his hoof, and Rarity couldn't help but notice how big it was as it enveloped her own during the handshake.

"Yes Sweetie, I believe I’ve seen him playing at the arcade a few times as I went to pick up some equipment for my dresses. It’s nice to finally meet you."

“Hi! Sweetie told me all about how you’re such a terrI-AAA…great sister and all and I was really looking forward to this dinner with you…heh-hehe…”

During the “AAA” part of that speech, Sweetie kicked his hindleg to get him to say something a little bit more polite. It was true that Rarity hadn’t been too great of a sister to Sweetie Belle on a number of occasions, but Sweetie didn’t want Rarity to know that she had told Button about any of it…not yet anyways…

"Well, come on in darlings. It’s probably freezing out there; don’t want either of you to catch something now. Especially if you spread it in here…ugh, I swear to celestia the last time Sweetie got sick I had a really tight deadline with a client and her rummaging around here got me sick aswell.”

“Oh yeah! I remember that one! Sweetie told me it was your OCD medication tho-OOO”

Sweetie had to kick the poor fool to get him to shut up again. Rarity gave both ponies a weird look and both Sweetie and Button just smiled and played it “cool”, hoping Rarity would just give it a rest.

"Well, I suppose we should get started. This meal took me hours to get it just right and I hate for it to get cold and have the entire meal ruined."

She led them to the table in the back of the boutique, which had three cushioned seats with very complex designs stitched on them, three plates were spread out on the table, along with the food sitting in the middle in what seemed to be really expensive pots and pans. After all three of them sat down, Rarity spoke up.

"Sorry If you don’t find anything you like, I just went by what I know Sweetie likes hoping that you would like it too, Button."

“Don’t worry ma’am. I like whatever Sweetie Belle likes, Even if it does look like Jeponya’s Final form from Pony Fantasy VII.”

She wondered what the buck he had just said, and also wondered if it was a compliment or he was mocking her. Either way she didn’t care, and continued to serve her guests. They all did small talk as they ate. Button Mash was almost 19 years old, and was on the swim team, which explained why he was decently fit, and Button Mash also explained to Rarity that he had failed a grade before, which was why he was a year older than Sweetie Belle but was also in the same grade as her. Sweetie then explained to Rarity that Button Mash played A LOT of video games and rarely did anything else. She also explained that He and Sweetie had been dating for about two weeks now as well. Rarity knew that 'dating' during the last few years of school pretty much means “We’re Buck Buddies!”. She herself had some wild times in her late school years until she settled down a bit and opened the boutique. Even with that said, she still would mess around with stallions from time to time. Mostly Thunderlane and Big Macintosh, since she convinced herself that Thunderlane deserved a reward for saving her that one time. Actually, she felt like he deserved a whole lot of rewards...like, about 10, maybe more, I lost count, I was too busy watching Button’s Mom getting rutted by Mr. Cake...don’t judge me... Big Mac was a nice candidate too since he was part of the Pony Tones. After every other show, she would show her gratitude to him for the marvelous performance he put on. Rarity didn’t even feel a bit of jealousy for Sweetie Belle and Button Mash. After all, Button probably didn’t even have nearly as good of a package as Thunderlane or Big Macintosh. Rarity had told Sweetie about sex a long time ago and that it’s better to be safe than sorry. She also told her a lot of other things, like how to be a lady and all that…stuff. As far as Rarity knew, Sweetie was taking Pills every other day just in case there ever was a heated Situation.

After dinner, Rarity thanked them both for coming over and wished Sweetie Belle a Happy Birthday. Sweetie exclaimed she was going to stay the night at Button’s place, so they left together and Rarity was left with thoughts of what they would be doing when they got there…

*Fancy as hell transition to one hour later*

“Hey Sweetie, Wanna stay up ALL night and play some…dirty games?~”

“Hehe, Sure thing my Handsome Stallion~<3”

“Mmmm, in that case…I’ll go turn on the Coltbox and put in Mares of War 3, then we’ll pull that out and we’ll take turns playing PmC Pone May Cry. This is gonna be so awesome!~”

*Fancy as hell transition back to Rarity’s Boutique*

In bed that night, Rarity fell asleep thinking of the crazy times she had when she was just out of school. Pinkie Pie’s Parties, Sweet Apple Acres Hard Cider, and the Stallions... Lots of them, just like Button. She actually started to feel jealous of Sweetie. Maybe it was just her dreams making her think that by over-exaggeration. Either way, She fell sound asleep that night with a smile on her face that would rival Pinkie Pie’s.

The following week, it was just after dark and Sweetie was at the Boutique with Rarity, who scheduled them to go see a movie together. It had been atleast a year since the last time they had done something like this, and Rarity was very enthusiastic about going with her. Rarity went up to her Bedroom and knocked on the door.

“Oh Sweetie Belle! Are you ready to go see the new Pony Games movie?”

"Sorry, I have a ton of homework. I don't think It would even be remotely possible to go see the movie with you and get it all done without having to stay up all night..”

“Oh please. That is THE most pathetic excuse I have ever heard of. You NEVER have that much homework, ever!”

“Well, maybe sometimes I do! And I’d appreciate it if you didn’t get so upset over something as stupid as watching a movie!”

“FINE THEN, I’ll go watch the movie BY MYSELF, and I will enjoy it, BY MYSELF! Hmpph!”

“Hmpph!”

Rarity turned away from Sweetie Belle in rage and practically ran out the boutique with the same attitude as well. She trotted in anger, generally going nowhere in particular, even though she knew she was going to see the movie. How could Sweetie Belle turn her down like this? Did she really have that much homework? Was it just a lie? She figured it had to be more than just homework, but later on she didn’t care as she approached Ponyville’s one and only Movie Theater. When she got to the ticket window she had a problem: she forgot to bring the bits to pay for the movie ticket. She felt so incredibly stupid for forgetting them, she almost went back to her previously enraged state, but quickly remembered she was in public and remembered to just stay calm. The bits were most likely just sitting on her fabric shelf at home. The next showing for her movie was in 10 minutes, so if she hurried to the boutique and back she could easily make it. She trotted at the speed of sound back to the boutique.

As she arrived, she casually pushed the front door open and walked in. She immediately heard music playing from upstairs, along with other noises she couldn't quite make out. The sounds were definitely coming from Sweetie's bedroom.

Rarity crept up the stairs almost cat like, interested as to what was going on up stairs, and as she did she could make out the sounds that were previously masked by Sweetie’s Record Player. Moans of pleasure, the sound of flesh smacking, and the creaking of a bed. She recognized the sounds fairly well which made her heart beat faster, along with the movement of her legs. She slowly walked to her Sister's door and it just so happened to be ajar, just enough to peer in. She peeked inside and the sight beheld to her made her go wide eyed.

Sweetie Belle was on top of Button mash, riding his cock cowpony style. They were closer to the end of the bed, so Rarity had a full view of Button’s Cock, And holy buck was it a cock or what. Sweetie's marehood looked stretched way beyond its natural limits because of how thick it was. Her hind legs were off the bed and she was being held in the air entirely by his cock. She had her head leaning back and she was drooling and moaning immensely. He was pushing up into her with every bounce she took, and Sweetie made loud slapping sounds as she took all but 2 inches of his cock. His hind legs twitching every other thrust he made.

Rarity was mesmerized by the sheer size of Button Mash’s Cock. It was at least twice as big around as Thunderlane and Maybe even bigger than Big Macintosh. His balls were about the size of apples and looked extremely rounded, as if he hadn’t cum in months. They bounced up and down on the bed as Sweetie bounced on his cock faster and harder, and in a circular motion. They were doing really long strokes but she never saw the tip once. His cock looked so beautiful and glossy with Sweetie’s juices covering it. She loved the way it glistened as it went in and out of Sweeite's severely stretched Pussy. It appeared to barely fit inside and Rarity wondered how long it took her to take it on the first go and if it was hurting her at all. However, based on all the liquids now covering Button Mash’s crotch area, including his bloated balls and his marvelously huge cock, she just assumed Sweetie was way beyond enjoying it.

"Oh Button! You’re s-so fucking huge. You’re gonna…aaaahhh…make me cum again!~”

"Hnnnn…Cum for m-me Sweetie…cum all over my c-cock!~”

Sweetie bent over and pulled Button in for a long, deep kiss. Sweetie moaned louder than before as she came. Coating his cock three times over with what looked like a quart of marecum.

Rarity felt her own marehood moisten from watching the two fuck, and she decided to take a moment to survey the scene. Sweetie’s bed had been covered in various liquids already. They didn’t seem to waste any time while rarity was out of the boutique to start going at it. Rarity’s eyes caught the picture in the frame on Sweetie's nightstand. It was a photo of her and Sweetie Belle from the Sister Hooves social they had participated in quite a few years back. Sweetie Belle was hugging her sister who was still covered in mud mostly, with only her face showing. Rarity was struck by the innocence of the photo, and now her innocent little Sister was a young mare getting the fucking of a lifetime by her stud of a coltfriend.

Her eyes were drawn once again to the giant cock that was currently inside Sweetie Belle for the most part. The Boutique started to feel hotter by the second as Rarity kept her eyes on the two. She began to slowly move one of her hooves to her marehood and moaned as she touched her lips.

After they were done panting and kissing, Button Mash pulled his cock out of Sweetie Belle completely, and Rarity saw the full length of his stallionhood. It had to be at the very least sixteen inches, shorter than most local stallions but thick enough to make up for it big time. He rose up and sat on his haunches, facing away from Rarity. She couldn't see his dick anymore, just his muscular back, tail, and Cutie Mark.

"Sweetie..please…f-finish me off, p-please..”

“h-how..? It’s…too big to s-suck on…”

“Just…ooohhh…use y-your hooves…”

“Al..Alright..”

Sweetie moved towards Button and now Rarity could properly see her sister's face, which was now facing Button’s. Rarity couldn’t see it clearly but she saw Sweetie Belle wrapping her front hooves around something and slowly starting to move them up and down in long, but slow strokes. Rarity was starting to picture herself trying to fit her small muzzle around the thickness of Button’s massive tool. With those thoughts leaking into her head, she started rubbing herself slightly faster, causing her juices to drip down her hind legs which were starting to tremble in fear and excitement of being caught watching them.

Button Mash had moved his hooves behind him for better leverage on leaning his head back in pleasure. This gave Rarity a better view of what was happening as she saw Button’s cock in all its glory, throbbing every other second and leaking precum all over Sweetie’s hooves, which were working his cock to the best of her ability.

“Aaahh~..Hurry u-up…your sist-Ohhh~…sister c-could get b-back any time..”

“I’m…d-doing my best Button…maybe I’ll t-try sucking it..”

“B-but I thought you…you said it w-was—AAHHHH~”

Before Button could finish his sentence; Sweetie pushed her muzzle down onto the tip of Button’s thickness and started to go to work. It was amazing to see Sweetie Belle struggling to keep just the tip in her mouth while Button Mash moved both of his hooves up and onto Sweetie’s mane. Rarity bit her lower lip as she rubbed her marehood to keep herself from moaning too loudly. She watched as Button pushed her head down onto his stallionhood farther, taking in about 4 inches of it. Sweetie started lapping up all the precum he was providing her and it would occasionally spurt into the back of her throat, causing it to go almost directly into her stomach without even having to swallow.

After a minute or so passed, Sweetie was deep throating half of his cock and was using her hooves to rapidly jerk the rest of his length in hopes of getting him to cum soon. She soon got her wish.

"Sweetie…I’m g-gonna…hnnnng…cum..”

Sweetie Belle pulled her muzzle off of Button’s cock to make an exclamation.

“Cum for me B-Button…shoot it all o-over me…coat me with your c-cum~!”

That was the absolute last straw for Button. Rarity watched as Button leaned back and groaned loudly. Rarity’s jaw dropped a little as she saw the first shot of cum explode from Button’s cock. His jizz looked incredibly thick, white, and voluminous as it flew about a foot over Sweetie Belle’s head and landed on the floor behind her. The next two shots of cum hit her mane and almost completely covered the front of it. The fourth spurt made a huge streak across her muzzle heading up to her horn. The Fifth, Sixth, and Seventh managed to cover her stomach and her neck. While the last three shots were just mere dribbles that landed no farther than Sweetie’s Hooves, which were still stroking Button’s cock, trying to coax more spunk out of him.

Finally, Button collapsed on the bed completely and Rarity got an even better view of Sweetie. She was completely covered in cum. Her face, stomach, mane, horn, it had it all, and both the floor and the bed were probably coated in their own fair share of Baby Mix.

Rarity trotted back down the stairs and out the back door of the boutique. After seeing Button release a load that she previously thought he couldn’t ever do, from a cock that she also previously thought he didn’t have, she was soaked and needed some release. Behind the boutique was a couple of conveniently placed bushes, totally not put there by the narrator for any sort of sexual purposes or anything…no seriously, I didn’t put them there, stop blaming me.

She jumped behind the bushes and closed her eyes, thoughts of Her and Button mash rutting to no end swarmed her mind, and she immediately began to rub herself to the thoughts. She imagined him on top of her, thrusting his rod in and out of her like she was a mare in heat. She thought of how much she would love to ride that giant piece of meat just like Sweetie Belle did. She wanted him to fill her up again and again with his magnificent loads as she coated his cock with her own juices time and time again.

After that thought passed, she came almost as hard as her first time with Big Mac. Coating her hindlegs in her juices and letting them drip down to the ground below. Her Legs were shaking slightly from how intense it was. After her euphoria died down, she realized what a mess she was and how uncouth it was sitting behind a bush. So she tried her best to clean herself up, and she waited outside for about 5 minutes before heading inside the boutique.

"Oh Sweetie belle, I'm baaack!"

Button Mash appeared at the top of the stairs. He looked somewhat tired, like he had been working out for about 10 minutes. Rarity knew what he had done though and smiled slightly at the flashbacks of them fucking playing back in her mind.

"Hiya Rarity! Sweetie is in the shower. I picked up a new video game today and I had to show it to her. My mom is probably wondering where I’m at now so I guess I’ll see you later, bye!"

He gave her a maniac like smile, the one you use when you’re obviously hiding something, and passed her on the stairs, then he ran out the front door, leaving it slightly opened.

Rarity sighed. She wished that maybe, just maybe, she could go back to the good old days and have one last, excellent fuck with a Stud like him.

Author's Note

So...about chapter two....

It may or may not happen...Don't get me wrong I enjoyed writing this chapter but I do things based on feelings. If I don't feel like doing something, I simply don't do it, and right now I don't feel like writing for a long time, so for now the Hiatus tag will stay.

Who knows, maybe a week will pass and I'll feel like writing it, you never know.

Chapter 2

Author's Note

Here's the last chapter folks. The ending was somewhat rushed but I think it'll be fine.

If you thought Chapter 1 was "WTF???" worthy, then prepare to be blown out of the water and higher than the sky itself.

Oh, and thanks for making this as popular as it was. See you guys around for next story, which might actually contain Nurse Redheart x Rumble (aged).

Chapter 2

It had been three days since Rarity had watched her sister get the fucking of a lifetime by her un-believably hung coltfriend, Button Mash, and no matter what she did she couldn't stop thinking about that night. Various scenes and images kept floating into the front of her mind subconsciously, and just last night she had a vivid dream about going at it with Button, getting him to ravish her over and over, until she could no longer walk properly from all the intense orgasms she had with him.

While working on some of her most requested outfits, she would often get lost in thought about her past, thinking back to the times in her late school years. The amazingly populated parties, the hardest of hard cider, and the biggest of the big stallions, it was in those days in which Rarity felt like she could live in the moment forever. All of that may have ended when she opened the Boutique, but she still had thoughts about the good old times on occasion, and now after watching Sweetie Belle get ravaged by Button Mash and his monster cock, the thoughts consumed Rarity. She could barely hold onto her mind at this point, and she wanted the weekend to hurry up and arrive more than ever now, mostly so that she could get the chance to ask a local stallion to just rut the living hell out of her. After all, maybe that’s all she needed in order to clear her mind correctly.

Rarity heard the faint noise of the Boutique’s front door bell ring. She simply assumed it was Sweetie Belle since it was around 3 o’clock, so Rarity turned off her Sowing machine, and walked into the front room to meet Sweetie.

"Rarity, I’m home!”

“Sweetie Belle, darling, Indoor voices please.”

“Oh…Sorry Rarity…”

“Apology accepted, everypony makes mistakes someti—“

“OH YEAH, I JUST REMEMBERED! Button Mash said he loved the dinner you made, so he’s coming over in about three hours to eat with us again!”

Rarity accidentally stopped listening after hearing the name “Button Mash”. With just those two little words, it all came back to her. The Image of Sweetie Belle and how she was riding his irregularly and impressively thick cock, the way she stroked it for the first few minutes. Suddenly, her mind started warping these images, and she started having extremely clear flashes of herself being in place of Sweetie Belle, watching as Button unloaded himself all over her beautifully white coat, making it all the whiter.

"Rarity…are you okay? Hello?”

Rarity suddenly shook her head, getting her mind out of the Sexual Gutter that it was temporarily trapped in.

"Oh…Um…Yeah great Sweetie, by the time I finish these dresses I should have an hour before he arrives to tidy up and cook dinner.”

“Awwright! This is going to be a blast, thank you so much, big sister!”

Sweetie Belle quickly trotted over to Rarity for a fast and light hug as she went up into her room. Time flew by as Rarity worked her flank off on the dresses, Occasionally stopping to think about how the hell she was going to make it through the night without jumping on Button and riding him right on the floor of the dining room table.

Button Mash showed up at about six o'clock, and Rarity was again struck by how absurdly big Button looked while standing next to Rarity. A small thought like that was all she could do to keep her hind legs from trembling when Button smiled at her and shook her hoof.

Dinner was a blur as Rarity tried to concentrate on finishing her food. Mostly because looking at Button Mash or her sister did nothing but flood her mind with very detailed and very naughty thoughts. Sweetie Belle had just finished her food, used a napkin to clean off her muzzle with, and spoke up.

"I’m sorry Rarity, I know I usually help you sort your Newly made dresses and stuff, but Fluttershy told me earlier today that I need to come over to her cottage tonight and show her how well I’ve improved on this one song.”

“Ugh! Sweetie Belle, why didn’t you say so earlier?”

“I…forgot?”

“Seriously Sweetie Belle, this is the second time in the month you’ve done this to me! Do you know how long this job takes with only two hooves? I swear, you are the most inconsiderate pony in Equestria sometimes!”

“I can’t help it! Fluttershy never gives me a very good notice on these things…”

Rarity gave Sweetie Belle the “r u fukin kidin’ me m8?” look and Sweetie Belle could only smile and blush back.

“Well…I guess it could be that, and the fact that I keep forgetting this important stuff.”

“Oh, but what am I to do now!? I worked so hard on these dresses and I would hate to see them all get wrinkled up! It’s a crime against Fashion!”

“I could help!”

The one voice that had yet to speak on the matter spoke, Button Mash.

“Oh no no no no no darling! I c-couldn’t possibly—“

“THAT’S AN EXCELLENT IDEA BUTTON! Okay, you stay here and help Rarity out, and when I get back we can go over to your house together!”

Sweetie gave Button a long kiss on the cheek and jumped out of her chair, heading for the front door to the boutique.

“See you two in a few hours, bye!”

Right after she said that, she opened the door, went outside, and practically slammed it shut. Rarity was now alone with a Colt she so desperately needed to stay away from, for both her and her sister’s sake, and now she would practically be forced to work with him for two hours, and she was already having thoughts about sliding under Button Mash’s stomach and coaxing his stallionhood out from its sheath.

“So..uhmm, what do you want help with first?”

Rarity sighed in slight frustration and turned her head towards Button.

“Well, I think we…we should start on the d-dishes first thing. After a while the left-over foods on the plates h-harden and it makes the task of cleaning them much…much more difficult later on.”

Rarity had some difficulty talking to Button; she had to look at the ground just to even say what she just said without going completely "whore-moan" driven.

“Okay, Do the dishes first, got it. What exactly do you want me to do though, ma’am?”

“Just…bring all the plates over to the sink for me and I’ll wash them.”

“Alright, sounds easy enough.”

Rarity could have sworn Button had never even heard of washing the dishes before. Perhaps it was because his mother had one of those fancy new dish washing machines? She didn’t know, and was too damn hot and bothered to care.

Button cleared the table and he handed her the dishes, mostly in silence. Being alone with him and this close, Rarity's mind was running wild with fantasies and she couldn't wait for Sweetie Belle to come home so that they could leave her in peace. She wanted nothing more than to take a nice, hot bubble bath, and to pick a toy from her collection to release much unwanted sexual tension. Then again, what she really wanted more than that was to seduce Button Mash on a really awkward level so that she could take his cock in all its glory. However, she had more self-control than that, she is a “lady” after all. When the last dish was cleaned and put on the counter to dry with the rest, Rarity spoke up.

“Alright…I think we’re done here. Good…good work B-button.”

“Thanks, I’ve never done anything like that before. My mom usually just throws our dishes in some contraption near the sink and that cleans them for us.”

Looks like her suspicions were right…

“Well then now, let’s go fold and sort the dresses I made earlier today”

Rarity ushered Button Mash through the living room towards her “Inspiration room”. While they were walking, Button Mash looked down at the ground and muttered something.

"I saw you the other night."

"What did you say darling? Speak up please.”

“I said I saw you the other night.”

“I still couldn’t hear you. Say it one more time please, and a little bit louder too.”

“I said I saw you the other night!”

Rarity stopped in her tracks as he blurted that out. She turned towards him and made a fake, confusing look.

“Why, whatever do you mean Button?”

She knew exactly what he meant.

“When I came over here three days ago…Sweetie Belle wanted me to…to have sex with her. She told me to lay down on the bed so that she could…ride me, and a few minutes later I noticed you were…standing in the doorway, watching us.”

Rarity was as frozen as a game boy with the cartridge pulled out. She just stood there, in shock and fear. Button Mash knew she had watched them fuck. It would be only a matter of time before he told Sweetie Belle about this. Wait, what if he already told her? What if Sweetie had already told her classmates and her classmates had told her parents? What would happen if this got out? Would her fame for being a sophisticated, lovely young pony, turn into her being a slutty, perverted peeping tom? Rarity, out of fear, decided that it was just best to admit to doing the horrible deed she had done. Maybe he hadn't told anyone yet, maybe she would forgive him, she just had to believe that he would.

“Button Mash…I…I admit it…Yes, I watched you two have sex until the very end and I even pretended that I wasn't there. I admit what I did was morally wrong and was also an invasion of privacy and I am deeply sorry.”

“Its…Its okay…I’m actually kind of glad that you aren't mad that we did it or anything. I haven’t told anyone else, not even Sweetie. I know you’re really well known around here and I don’t want to ruin that for you.”

Rarity was extremely relieved to hear that. It felt like an a thousand pound assortment of dresses had been lifted off of her chest and she felt so happy to know what she had here in Ponyville was safe. She still felt a need to say something else, she couldn't put her hoof on it, but it just needed to be said.

“T-thank you Button Mash…Since you've told me about this, I feel like I also need to tell you something…”

Button sat down and continued to look at Rarity while she talked to him.

“Ever since I saw you and Sweetie, I…I can’t stop thinking about your…your thing…”

“What…thing?”

Button knew exactly what thing she was referring to. He just wanted to hear her say a “dirty” word.

“Your…penis…I know it’s horrible to be thinking about something such as that but ever since I saw Sweetie on top of you and how unimaginably big it was I’ve been thinking about it ever since…It’s been three days and until now I…I haven’t been able to even look at you without wanting you to rut me or me pleasuring you. I feel just awful about this whole scenario and I wish I knew how to make the thoughts go away but I don’t.”

Button sat on the living room floor, mouth agape slightly. He had no idea what to say. A few moments passed and he started to smile slightly. He had just came up with an idea that could help her.

“So…you like my penis hmmm?”

Rarity was a little bit shocked by the vulgar sentence Button had just said. Then she realized just why he said it. The tone of his voice, and the way he said it, they were all clear signs, and she knew what he was getting at, so she just played right along with his little game.

“Button…you don’t have a penis.”

Button was more confused than ever, until she moved her face closer to his, using very seductive looking eyes.

“You have a cock, darling…”

Rarity then lunged forward for a kiss. Button Mash couldn’t believe his plan was working. Usually his plans would end in something getting set on fire, but this plan looked almost rock-solid to him at this point.

The force of Rarity pushing against Button while she kissed him caused them both to fall over. Rarity was now on top of Button Mash, kissing him and licking his tongue while moving her front hooves to hold onto his head, stroking his mane all the while. Rarity's head started spinning; she couldn’t believe this was happening. She couldn’t believe she was kissing Sweetie’s rightful colfriend. She couldn’t believe that he was letting her do so either. After a while, she broke the kiss and a long string of saliva oozed from their muzzles. Button Mash thoroughly enjoyed the kiss and he thought Rarity was most definitely a better kisser than Sweetie. Maybe it was just because Rarity had more experience? He didn’t know for sure, but the way Rarity had pulled back away from him and was now trailing a hoof down from his chest, painfully slow, to his stomach, and lastly, his crotch.

“Oh my gosh…Its not…its not even hard and its…huge!”

Even in her last days of school, she had never seen a cock even remotely as big as Button Mash’s. It was a much darker brown than the rest of his fur was, and had a few completely black spots here and there. It was currently lying against Button’s stomach as he was lying down on the floor, but with Rarity’s attention completely focused on it now, it started to throb slightly. After the first three throbs, Rarity wasted no time. She grabbed Button’s cock with both her hooves, feeling it throb harder than it was previously, as Button Mash leaned his head back some and groaned. Rarity was used to measuring things due to making dresses and she could tell that even though he was still flaccid, Button Mash proved to be well-endowed. His tool was already measuring in at 10 inches and just reached a thickness that rivaled her fore-hooves.

“Hnnnng…your h-hooves feel so s-soft…much softer t-than…oooohhh…Sweetie Belles”

Rarity was glad to receive such a complement, but in no time flat, Button Mash’s cock started growing much faster and she needed to start using both hooves more firmly. She closed her eyes while she worked his shaft, wanting to be greatly surprised at how big he was at full size. A few moments passed by and Rarity had finally managed to get Button Mash fully erect. Rarity looked down and was greeted with a sight like no other.

“Its…magnificent…I have n-never in all my life seen such thickness and…oh my stars, it’s even longer than I estimated…”

Rarity had her entire front leg up side-to-side with Button Mash’s cock. Not only was it as long as her leg, which was 19 inches and longer than Big Mac by an inch, but he was also thicker by quite a bit. The only other pony whose dick managed to beat her leg in thickness was Soarin, and even he hadn’t come close to having what Button Mash had.

“Am I really all t-that big?”

“Button…your cock is just dreamy. It’s no wonder I was having so many…dirty thoughts about it, any mare that is lucky enough to see it in all its glory would. It’s so unbelievably t-thick and….mmmm~”

Rarity went back to stroking Button’s cock with her eyes closed. She stroked all the way from the tip to the base and wasted no time at all, finishing each stroke within a second. She decided that it was time to go faster and she did, but she then wondered if perhaps she started stroking too fast, because almost as soon as she started, Button Mash groaned a bit as small spurts of precum started covering Rarity’s hooves and slowly died down after a few moments. She stopped stroking and sighed because she thought Button had just cum. Button looked up at her with a confused facial expression as to why she stopped stroking. She was disappointed but at the same time didn’t want to hurt Button’s feeling, so she cleared her throat and spoke up.

“It’s alright Button Mash dearie, sometimes young colts get carried away. It even happens to the best ones…no need to feel ashamed about it.”

“But…Rarity…that was just p-precum.”

She looked slightly horrified for a second as she looked down at her hooves, which were still almost completed coated in his precum. There was quite a bit of it, and she had never seen a Stallion even come close to actually shooting pre. Rarity’s mind started to flood with ideas on how much he would cum if was leaking that much precum already. So she almost immediately went back to stroking Button’s cock in long and hard strokes, much like she was doing a minute ago. At this point she was completely lust driven, wanting to bring Button Mash to a powerful orgasm. She looked down and finally got a good look at his balls, which seemed to be just as big, if not bigger, than they were when she last saw them. Rarity figured she should give them some attention, so she moved one of her hooves down to his ballsack and began to knead and massage the over-weight orbs.

“Mmmmm…has Sweetie Bell been taking good care of these? They feel so bloated with your seed~”

“N-not really…we haven’t messed around s-since that one n-night…”

“Aahhhh…perfect, more cum for little Miss Rarity then!”

She continued to rub Button’s Balls at a painfully slow rate, all while moving her muzzle down to the tip of Button’s Stallionhood at the same, excruciatingly slow pace. Eventually, she reached it and tried her best to fit her muzzle around the thickness. After the second try, she managed to fit the tip inside and started to lightly suck on it while using both of her hooves on the base of his length.

Button Mash was writhing in pure bliss. He thought Sweetie Belle was good at sucking him off, until now. He didn’t take Rarity to be the kind of pony to have experience with these things, but he was gravely mistaken as Rarity started to take in about 4 inches of his length and started bobbing her head up and down on what little she took in. The pleasure only doubled for Button as she began to moan around his shaft, making it throb harder and more frequent than ever.

Rarity was enjoying herself almost as much as Button Mash was. However, she wanted him to hurry up and cum now. She knew for a fact he would have atleast 4 rounds in him, so she wanted him to release a load now to know for sure what she was getting into. Rarity bobbed her head on Button’s cock a few more times before releasing the head with a soft “pop” sound and began stroking the entire length with her hooves again. It wasn’t before long she started talking dirty to him, hoping it was make him cum faster.

“Button, darling…surely you’re gonna cum for me soon no?”

“I…uhhh…ooohhhhh~”

“Cmon now…we both know you wanna shoot your jizz all over me…or maybe…maybe you wanna shoot that big load of yours down my throat hmmm?”

Rarity felt his cock throb extra hard this time and knew for sure that did the trick. Within moments, she had her mouth wrapped around his cock again, and was humming and sucking on it as hard as ever. She felt his cock throb even harder before she felt a liquid poor down the back of her throat. Button has just shot his first wad of cum into her muzzle and it filled her to the brim. She managed to swallow it all just in time for the second shot which also filled her mouth and made some leak out around the sides of her muzzle. She only managed to swallow half of it before her mouth overfilled with cum from the third shot. She took her mouth off of Button’s spasming cock and her mouthful of seed fell onto the floor and her stomach as she was assaulted with the next five shots of cum, which felt extremely thick and heavy as they flew onto her face and chest.

When Button Mash’s orgasm ended, he slowly lifted his head up to view the mess he made. To him though, it was no mess, it was a work of art. Streaks of cum were all over her stomach, chest, face, mane, and horn, while a generous amount coated the floor beneath them. Rarity was in total disbelief on what had just happened. She soon got back on track from being shocked to being sexy, and started to scoop up some of the cum off of her chest and lapped it up hungrily.

“I’ve…I’ve never been coated in so much cum before…you sure know how to please a lady, Button.”

“Heh…hehe…Sweetie Belle told me the same thing last week.”

“Well, it’s no surprise dear. Just look at me! I’m completely coated in your thick spunk, and your cock is still just as hard as ever. I’m going to have to take a shower to get it all out.”

“Can’t you just…use that blanket over there real quick?”

Rarity looked behind her and noticed there was a small blanket about the size of a towel on the living room couch. She used her horn to levitate the blanket over to herself and began to respond to Button Mash’s Question.

“Awww, does big ol’ Button need to cum again, and so soon?”

Rarity teased her question further by wrapping the blanket around Button Mash’s still erect Stallionhood and rubbing it briefly, cleaning it of any excess cum that might have still been on it. She then flipped it around and used it to clean her face and body of all traces of Button’s seed. Rarity still felt sticky in a lot of places, especially her hind legs, but she decided she would have to do. She proceeded to crumble up the blanket and threw it into the nearest trash can with her magic, besides, that Blanket probably would have been near impossible to clean now.

“So uhh…are we done?”

“Oh heavens no, I still haven’t got to ride it yet, plus I’m sure you’d love to plow this, wouldn’t you?”

Button Mash blushed slightly at the sight of Rarity turning around and shaking her plot in front of his face. It’s seemed to bounce and jiggle more than usual, but maybe that was just because Button was horny as hell at the moment, and the beautiful sight of Rarity’s flanks and her folds made his cock throb extra hard.

“Well cmon darling…I’m sure you’d rather have my other holes milk you dry, rather than those icky hooves of yours.”

“Y-yes ma’am!”

Button Mash picked himself up off the floor and began following Rarity up stairs to her bedroom. He watched in awe as her flanks bounced with each step she took, and it caused his member to leak a trail of precum on to the floor every other step he took.
They eventually reached their destination and Rarity took the initiative to push Button Mash back first onto the bed. She found herself face to face with his monster cock once and wondered to herself how she was going to do this. She remembered how well Sweetie Belle had taken it 3 nights ago and decided it was best to ask a personal question to figure this one out.

“B-Button…How many times have you and Sweetie Belle…had intercourse on this type of level?”

“I’d say around…F-five times.”

So that explains it…Sweetie Belle was so loose from all the other times she had ridden him, or he stuck it to her, that there was no problem taking it once more. Non-the-less, Rarity did not want to give up the Opportunity of riding what might be the Biggest Dick in all of Equestria, just because it “might be painful” or it “Might not even fit”. If Sweetie Belle could do this, so could she. Rarity determinedly rose up onto the top of Button’s cock and aligned her marehood accordingly. Then, she took a deep breath, and plunged down.

“OOOOHHHHHH FFF-FUUUCK~!!”

“Ooohhhh~ F-fuck…”

Yep, the first sentence there is straight from Rarity’s mouth. She was in so much pain at the moment; however, she also managed to fit the tip inside on the first go. Button Mash on the other hoof, was in total bliss and he felt like he had just cum right there and then from the tightness surrounding the tip of his cock.

“F-Fuck…you’re…s-so damn huge Button…fuck~”

Rarity couldn’t help but curse as she slid down just two inches of Button’s tool. She was over the initial pain now, and all other pain she felt now was just to the point of added pleasure to her nether region. Button Mash could only lay backwards as his cock throbbed hard with each dribble of precum escaping his member and coating Rarity’s insides.

“Aaahhhhh…mmmm~ Your p-precum…its so, warm…”

“Th..thanks..”

In no time at all, Rarity had managed to take his full length in completely, and Button Mash was balls deep inside Rarity. However, All Rarity could manage to do at the moment was moan in pleasure as a bit of drool hung from her muzzle.

“R-Rarity, are you o-okay?”

“So…t-thick…Can’t…ride…”

“I t-think I can help...”

Button Mash proceeded to push his hips upward, causing Rarity to pull off of his cock slightly, and then fall back down, Rarity screams in pure pleasure and started to yell at Button Mash.

“F-FUCK! FUCK ME BUTTON, KEEP THRUSTING, I’M SO CLOSE~!”

Button Mash followed her orders and pushed his hips upward five more times before Rarity screamed out again and released a torrent of marecum all over his cock. She managed to squirt three times, covering Button’s cock and his balls, which would be the absolute best thing that she could have done to make Button’s shaft all the easier to ride.

After Rarity’s orgasmic high subsided, she stared at Button Mash for a moment before she started to slowly move up and down his length, giving him a sexy smirk and giggling slightly.

“Mmmm hehe…now it’s your turn to cum for me~”

Button Mash was extremely turned on right now. Normally when Sweetie Belle rode him, she would just moan aloud with her head hanging backwards as she moved up and down. At first, he thought Rarity was just going to do the same thing, but now he had a change of mind, and with Rarity teasing him constantly, he wasn’t going to last much longer.

“Oooohhhh Button~!…P-please, fill m-me up before I cum agaAaAAahhhh!”

Before she had even finished her sentence, Rarity managed to cum once again, leaking even more liquids onto the bed and Button’s crotch. Button Mash could no longer take how tight Rarity’s walls were getting, and so the pressure finally boiled over as he managed to rapidly shoot four huge loads inside Rarity, filling her up and making her stomach feel nice and warm. The sheer amount of spunk he was filling her with was enough to bring her to another orgasm and she blushed harder than ever before. The flow of cum eventually became too much, and a copious amount burst out of Rarity and coated Button’s crotch and a part of the bed.

Button Mash was the first one to finish cumming. He felt like a huge weight had been lifted off his back, or in actuality, out of his balls. Rarity was still moaning and blushing while the walls of her pussy were still clamped down on Button Mash’s member which, even after shooting off two bucket loads of cum, was still just as hard as when they started. Rarity eventually calmed down and leaned down to rest on Button’s stomach with his cock still embedded into her.

“B-Button…I f-feel, so full…p-please tell me you…you have more for m-me…”

“Rarity…you are a s-sex goddess, I w-will always have plenty f-for you…”

“What about Sweetie Belle though?”

“She…she isn’t nearly as skilled as you are…”

“Mmmmm well, I try my best…even more so for the thick ones~”

Rarity teased him a bit by bouncing on his cock again for a short moment, then after a few seconds she managed to pull herself off Button’s shaft. She sat her haunches behind Button Mash and started to rub his cock with her hooves.

“Hehe…so is my big Button ready to Mash my plot nice and hard?”

“Oooohhhh yes…I’m r-ready Miss Rarity”

“Are you ready to fill me up?”

Rarity started moving her hooves faster and faster, and started talking in a more stern tone, while still being sexy as hell.

“Yes ma’am!”

“Are you ready to shoot the last of your spunk deep inside me?”

“Hell Yes Ma’am!”

“Good.”

And with that, Rarity’s stroking on Button’s cock seized and she jumped off of the bed and started trotting to the nearest wall, shaking her flanks as much as possible. When she was directly facing the wall, she threw her front hooves onto it and started swaying her ass invitingly.

“Now get over here and rut me senseless.”

Button Mash was in no mood to argue. He got off the bed and trotted towards Rarity slowly, his cock swaying back and forth beneath him, throbbing with lust every half second. After what seemed like hours, he finally reached Rarity and began to put his front hooves on her back and began to align his cock with her entrance. Button’s cock poked Rarity in her flanks multiple times before finally reaching its destination. He tried his best to thrust into her backdoor, but even with all the juices covering his dick as lube, it wouldn’t budge. Button Mash was starting to lose hope until Rarity spoke up.

“Come on now darling. It’s rude to keep a lady waiting to be filled up with a large load from a humungous cock such as yours~”

That sentence alone was enough to give Button Mash all the encouragement he needed. He tried once more and finally pushed the head of his cock inside Rarity’s tight plot hole. It wasn’t long before both of the ponies began to groan in pleasure. Button Mash had only a few inches of his cock inside her and it felt as if it was just melting inside of her, it was that tight. Rarity had actually only tried anal a few times before, and Button Mash was so ridiculously thick that she thought she would faint from the amount of stallion cock being thrusted inside of her.

Button Mash wasted no time. He began to thrust and thrust deeper inside Rarity and he eventually made it in all the way, his balls rubbing against her folds down below. Just then, Button Mash leaned his head down farther, and whispered into Rarity’s ear.

“I hope you’re ready for a good fucking, you slut.”

Rarity smiled as she realized that Button was finally going to be the dominate one this time around. She was actually getting tired of doing so but if she figured if he did his own thing she would make him cum just as fast.

Button Mash started to push in and out of Rarity at an extremely fast pace, his balls slapping loudly against her now, feeling all the warm seed that he had yet to release inside of her. With every thrust, he would pull out almost all the way, leaving the tip just barely inside, then he would quickly push it all back in. Rarity was currently on an endless string of moans and pants, to her there was nothing else. The world to her was a big pile of nothingness. All she could do was think about the oversized meat stick pounding her relentlessly, and that it would eventually fill her up with warmth that rivaled a small fire.

“Do you love my cock that much, s-slut? I bet you’d love to be f-filled with it every day, you whore. I bet if…ooohhhh…Sweetie Belle weren’t my marefriend, you’d want to f-fuck with me for the rest of your l-life.”

“Oh yes Button! I would ride it every day for you! I love how thick and long you are! I could never cum with anyone who’s cock is smaller than yours! I’d let you cover me in your jizz whenever you want!”

Rarity’s true thoughts and feeling came out just then. She genuinely wanted nothing more than to be with Button and rut with him for eternity. She no longer cared about fashion. She no longer cared about dress making. All she wanted in life now, was to tend and take care of Button’s large member.

“Hnnnng…Good mare…I’m g-gonna cum soon…tell me h-how…aaahhh….badly you want it.”

“I…I want it bad…I want you t-to shoot it inside me…I want to feel shot after shot fill me up…I want you to never stop cumming! P-please, cum for m-me..”

Button Mash didn’t have any strength left to hold it in. The tightness of her ass and her teasing had caused him to lean his head back and tense up. He started to fill Rarity up, shooting long, thick ropes of cum insider her harder and faster than ever before. Rarity was screaming aloud as she felt like he body temperature had tripled due to the amount of warm seed being shot inside her wanting plot hole.

Button had shot well over twenty times into Rarity and thought that at this point he was done. So he pulled out and was mildly mistaken. He shot five more sizeable loads of jizz onto her back and flanks and his stallionhood finally started to deflate.
Rarity was still in shock and eventually collapsed onto the cum covered floor below her. While she was still panting and blushing, she turned around to look at Button. The first thing she noticed was his balls looked very empty and that his cock was back in its sheath now. She slowly, but surely, sat upright with her legs trembling slightly, and began to speak.

“Y-you were amazing…”

“Thanks…S-Sweetie Belle taught me how to act like I just did a few nights b-back…”

Rarity’s eyes went wide. She just remembered that her sister would probably be home any minute now, and she hadn’t even thought about cleaning up the mess they made down stairs or in Rarity’s Bedroom. Just then, she heard the door open and there stood who else but Sweetie Belle.

“Rarity, I’m Home! What’s with puddle of white paint in the middle of the living room fl—“

Sweetie Belle final surveyed the scene. Rarity’s bed had been covered pretty well in Button’s cum along with hers, while the area around the two was almost the same, except it was more concentrated near Button’s crotch area. Then finally, she saw Rarity and Button Mash. Button Mash was on his back with his genital region exposed and Rarity was close enough to caress the area. Sweetie Belle was horrified. Rarity finally decided to speak up and say the most overused saying ever created and used by anypony.

“Sweetie Bell, I can explain…”

FIN

Chapter 3 [By sbloom85]

Something has gone wrong. We don't seem to have an archived copy of that chapter.