Chapter 3 ~ The Unforgivable

With another burst of green flames, Chrysalis shed her disguise of Celestia, returning to her true form. As her slitted eyes peeled open, the sticky mess on her face began to glow green.

I backed away, shocked to suddenly see her real self.

“Oh, come now,” her strangely choral voice hummed. “It's not as if you haven't seen me before, and it's not as if you didn't know who I am.” The green-glowing ooze on her face slowly disappeared, as if being absorbed into her chitinous skin. “Ah, now that's what I've been missing!” She giggled, her voice buzzing on every low note.

What had I gotten myself into? I needed to get out of here, now! I rose from my chair and made a rush for the door.

“Oh no you don't!” With a few flaps of her transparent wings, Chrysalis again stood directly in front of me – and between me and the door. “I'm not satisfied yet.”

I winced. “Well, ah, I need time to recover, you know. Maybe we can meet again tomorrow?”

She smiled, and her eyes sharpened. “I don't think you'll need much time. I still have one very special trick in mind for you.”

I slowly backed away, cringing. “I... I've had enough for one day, I think.”

Smirking, she stalked toward me. “Don't forget, Shining, I've been inside your head. I know each and every dirty little secret of yours.” She paused her walk and engulfed herself in green flames again, and the glare forced me to close my eyes.

“There, better?” Twilight Sparkle's voice asked me.

Oh no. It wasn't fair. I'd never told anyone about that! I dared to open my eyes.

'Twilight' stood in front of me, her wings folded, glancing to the side, and with a furious blush burning on her cheeks. “A good friend of mine told me that you actually have a thing for me... and well...” She bit her lip. “Well, I guess it's kinda mutual? I mean, you're my B.B.B.F.F.” She glanced up at me again before shyly glancing back down at the base of the bed. “I'd do anything for my brother.”

I stomped my hoof down. “Chrysalis, this isn't funny!”

She turned toward me, sitting down on her round little rump. She touched her mouth with the tip of her hoof and slowly licked the rim of it. “Who's laughing?” She winked at me. “Come on, brother, we both know you want to.”

“I have absolutely no interest in that!”

“Really?” She glanced slightly downward. “Because a certain part of you says otherwise.”

I winced, feeling my face flush with heat as I crossed my front legs in an effort to hide my raging erection. “That doesn't mean anything!” I shook my head. “And besides, I'd never do that! It's incest! And it's abuse of a young foal! And... and...”

She laughed. “Is it, is it really? I may look like her, but–”

“No!”

Her hind legs shifted uncomfortably, never seeming to be able to stay still, and her tail slowly rose off the floor behind her. “Come on, big brother. I need you!” She stared up at me with those big, wavering eyes.

Those eyes. They would be the death of me someday, I was sure, but I still couldn't turn them down. I took a couple hesitant steps toward her.

She smiled, and the blush returned to her cheeks, more fiercely than ever.

With a few more steps, I closed the distance between us, and she stood up in front of me, face to face. “You're the best, B.B.B.F.F!” she cried, jumping forward and wrapping her hooves around my neck. “I've needed a stallion to rut me hard for a long time now. Thank you so much!” She pulled off the tiny squeal at the end perfectly. I had to admit she made a pretty convincing Twilight.

Leaning in closer, she brought her lips up to me, and her tongue followed just behind, slipping in between my lips. This wasn't the chaste kisses of my wife; this was making out with a sex goddess. Our tongues writhed against each other, exploring each other's mouths.

She pulled away and turned around, presenting her pert little rump to me. Her tail lifted to the side and her smooth violet lips winked long and hard. “Give it to me, brother. Give it to me as hard as you can. I need it!” She leaned backward, splaying her back hooves out as her sex gave a series of uncontrolled winks, flashing her pink folds at me over and over again. A thin rivulet of her juices matted down the fur of her thigh as it trailed downward. “Please?”

There was no point in denying it now. I wanted her. I pressed myself up against her backside, pushing the my chest up against her needy entrance. I could feel it pulsing against my fur, urging me on.

As we touched, her wings splayed out. She gasped. “Yes! Yes, brother! I've waited too long – please give it to me!”

Pushing up and forward, I slid my chest over her nice, round cheeks, pushing her tail even higher as I slid up over it.

Her body melted into mine as I pushed even further forward. She gave a quiet moan.

Finally, I slid up until my forelegs brushed against the base of her wings on either side. The tip of my cock nudged against the soft curve of her flank.

“Oh, Shining, I love you so much! I want you inside me!”

With a slight shift to the side and another nudge forward, my tip kissed her warm, slick entrance.

She gasped. “Yes! Mmn!” The tight lips of her sex returned the kiss, massaging my tip with her clit and nearly opening wide enough to envelop me even without any pressure. “Oh please!”

Slow and sure, I pushed, letting my cock glide into my 'sister'.

Her warm, wet walls caressed the smooth skin of my shaft while her entrance spasmed wildly, milking me and begging for more.

Still, I slid in slowly, progressing inch by moan-inducing inch, spreading her out inside. I reached her tightest point and pushed through smoothly, reveling in the amazing feeling of the velvety-soft flesh pressing against me just beyond.

Finally unwilling to wait any longer, 'Twilight' let her front legs go limp, dropping to the floor and pushing back into me.

My stallionhood buried itself inside her, ramming in all the way to the sheath. I gasped, feeling her warm, wet lips spasm against the very base of my cock. I hadn't felt this since... well, since the last time I rutted Chrysalis, back when she was pretending to be my fiancé.

'Twilight' gave a soft, silky moan – almost a purr – as she squirmed her hips side to side with me buried deep inside her. “Mmn, yes. That's it. That's what I needed.”

I pulled out slightly, just enough to let me ram it home again.

She pressed back against me even more, even forcing a little of my sheath inside of her. “Rut me hard, big brother!”

Rocking my hips back and forth with short jerks, I began thrusting into her in earnest. Already, I could hear the squelching sound of her wetness pressing against me. I grabbed onto her hips, pulling her into me hard and increasing the length of my thrusts.

She gave a wordless moan, drooling onto the crystal floor beneath her and letting her eyes drift shut.

With my completely submissive 'sister' moaning beneath me, I finally lost all of my habitual self-restraint. I rammed into her again and again, shoving my stiff shaft into her as deep as I could every time.

Her inner walls pressed against me harder and harder as I went on, coaxing me to use even more force. With every thrust, a few more drops of her pleasure gushed outward to join a quickly-growing puddle on the floor beneath us.

As her moans rose in pitch, nearly becoming screams, I increased my tempo again, going as fast as I possibly could. I could feel the head of my cock flaring out, filling her completely and stretching out her innermost passage.

With one final shriek, 'Twilight' exploded. Her soft inner walls gripped me so hard I couldn't budge, and her back legs gave out, leaving nothing but my stallionhood holding her up off the floor. A wet spurt squirted out around the base of my cock, coating my balls and thighs in its heat.

It was too much. Even as she gave way underneath me, beginning to fall down, my climax burst into her. Despite the resistance of my flared cock against her still-clenching passage, I slipped out of her in the middle of the second pump. The remainder of the thick strand laid itself out across her entrance, over her ass and onto her back.

She laid flat beneath me, panting and letting out one long moan as more and more spurts of my sticky seed sprayed out over her ass, back, and even her wings.

When my orgasm finally died down, and my stallionhood hung limply beneath me, I backed up a little, admiring the alicorn beneath me as my cum slowly dripped down her back. How long had I secretly longed to do that?

'Twilight' stood up, and another flash of green fire enveloped her, leaving behind the black form of Chrysalis. Again, the thick ropes of cum all over her glowed green before absorbing into her. It left a distinctive smell, sharp and sweet; not unpleasant, but very peculiar.

She stretched herself out, and I could hear the chitin plates in her back popping. As hard as I looked, I couldn't see any sign of a marehood on her now. Did she even have one in this form?

She turned to the door, walking briskly away without even a single word to me.

“Hey!” I called out to her. “What about... um...” A moment ago, I had been very clear on what I wanted to say to her, but now it seemed to slip my mind. Still, it seemed wrong for her to just leave without saying a single thing to me.

“Don't worry,” she said, her voice buzzing. “I'll keep in touch. See you later, B.B.B.F.F!” With a wink, she engulfed herself in green flames, this time emerging as the janitor again, complete with uniform.

I just stood there and blinked, her juices still drying on my softening cock as she stepped through the door and shut it behind her. I gulped. What would this mean for me now? Would she come back for me again? Did I want her to come back again? What would happen if Cadance found out?

Shaking my head, I used my magic to levitate my armor over to the still-pristine bed. The Garnet was a good inn, and the rooms would all have nice, private showers. It would be the perfect place to wash up and think about what just happened.

Author's Note

Stay tuned for my upcoming sequel, to be titled A Gentlemare's Agreement.
Cadance finds out about Shining Armor's activities with Chrysalis... and she wants in on it.