Anniversary Night 2

by beatbox9988

Rating: mature
Tags: My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Princess Cadance, Romance, Shining Armor, Sex, Slice of Life, Anthro, Princess Luna
Length: 4023

You, as the Princess of Love, decided that it was only right to repay your husband for what he did on your last anniversary... and what better way than a Princess Party!

This is a sequel to Anniversary Night

It is not needed to have read that one first. Basically, you had a threesome and now you want to repay your husband.

You, as the Princess of Love, decided that it was only right to repay your husband for what he did on your last anniversary... and what better way than a Princess Party!

Warning: Dirty... very dirty... I don't even

Published 2014-04-05 13:20:03 UTC
Last updated 2014-04-05 13:20:03 UTC

Princess Party!

You were twiddling your thumbs nervously as you felt the Lunar Princess’s gaze bore into your very being. All you wanted to do right now was to curl up into a fetal position on the floor and die from shame. Your legs shuffle awkwardly as you felt the silence drag on. The tension was almost palpable.

You chanced a glance, and you looked up, and immediately turned your gaze back to the floor. You couldn’t exactly read her emotions, but you were never too good at that anyway. Still, the silence dragged on, and you were desperately hoping that she would say something, anything. You honestly wished that she would say anything, even if it was to reprimand you, because you didn’t know how much longer you could take before you caved in.

All because you wanted to repay your husband for what he did not more than a year ago. You honestly had the best of intentions! Now it seemed so foolish.

A couple of hours ago, you had set a date “visit” one of your aunties. Since you were so closely related to the princesses, you had no trouble in getting their attention, and they were more than happy to meet you again.

You had done some thinking on who to ask for to help you in this particular “gift of yours to your husband, and only the best would do. You considered asking aunt Celestia at first, but discarded the idea almost immediately. You knew her. She’d never agree to something so… debaucherous.

That only left you with Pri-urm aunt Luna. You’ve never been particularly close to her for fairly obvious reasons, what with the whole banished to the moon for a thousand years or so fiasco, but you didn’t think that there was any harm in asking. Plus, she didn’t look that scary. Well, most of the time.

The conversation began like any other. There was an exchange of pleasantries, and you made a little small talk, stalling for time until you had the courage to make your request known. Unfortunately, your confidence didn’t grow, but did the exact opposite. An invisible knot had formed in your throat and you found yourself forcing to articulate each word that came out of your mouth. You felt parched, and you were about to ask a servant for a glass of water before you heard Luna clear her throat.

“I’m sorry to interrupt you Cadance, but you seem to be a tad bit nervous. Perchance you could tell me what picks at your conscience?” she asked politely with a small smile on her face.

Your eyes finally looked upon her after being fixed on a wall for who knows how long. You blushed and smiled sheepishly. You were probably embarrassing yourself. Luna was as stunning as ever. She was wearing a dress made of many shades of blue and violet, which managed to accentuate her already stunning natural beauty. Her regalia was in place, completing her royal look, her mane billowing in some otherworldly wind.

Usually, you wouldn’t think twice of it, but now, she looked downright intimidating. Her warm smile did nothing to comfort you. Compared to your modest dress, you looked like something someone had dragged off the streets.

You cleared your throat and did your best to compose yourself. “Yes,” you began shakily. “It’s actually a request…” you said, trailing off.

“And what might this request be?” Luna replied without missing a beat.

“It’s…” you trailed off, mumbling incoherently.

“What was that?” Luna said, leaning in a little closer.

Just let it out, Cadance. you told yourself. This is for Shiny…

“W-would you agree to having a threesome with me and Shiny?!” you blurted out, and immediately regretted it. You could feel your cheeks heat up and you could feel your heartbeat drumming in your ears. You knew this idea was stupid! Asking an immortal goddess to partake in something so scandalous!

You clenched your eyes shut, preparing for the worst.

So that brings you to your present predicament. Eyes shut and awaiting judgment.

“Leave.” You hear Luna say suddenly. You didn’t need any other incentive than that. You quickly got off your chair, and made your way to the door.

“Wait!”

Dangit! I’m really in for it now!

“I didn’t mean you, Cadance.” She replied in a playful tone. You turned around, your features full of confusion. You realized that her command were not for you, but for her batpony guards… that were still in the room!

You were speechless when you realized that you had forgotten that you weren’t the only two ponies in the room. Great. Word was going to get out, and there’d be a huge scandal. And it’d be all. Your. Fault.

Your ears folded in shame at this revelation, but perked up when you heard Luna laughing. You raised an eyebrow, wondering what was so funny.

“Relax, Cadance. My guards are very loyal, and they know how to keep a secret.” Said Luna. You breath a sigh of relief. “And as for your offer…” she continued. You tense up again, nervous of what she was going to say.

“Okay.”

You blinked. You blinked again.

“Okay…?” you reiterated slowly.

“Okay.” She said again.

“So… I’ll… see you tonight?”

“I’ll be there.” She said matter of factly.

“Okay then…” You say awkwardly. You were working up until this moment the whole week and now when she had agreed to do it, you didn’t know what to do or say. You honestly didn’t think that you would’ve have gotten this far…

“I have thought about it before, you know.” Said Luna, breaking you out of your stupor. “About Shining. He’s such a handsome stallion.”

That caught your attention. You perked your ears up to listen to what Luna had to say. “I’ve seen his dreams before, you know. His more... intimate ones. And some of them did involve either me or my sister. Sometimes both.”

You couldn’t help but smile.

“This is very nice of you, Cadance. I’m sure Shining Armor would appreciate it.”

You smiled easily after that. Everything was going better than expected!

“Plus, I had always wanted a piece of that hunk of a stallion ever since I saw him!” she added with glee, clapping her hands.

Both of you laughed at the little quip. The rest of the afternoon was spent on catching up and light banter.

~

You were both snuggled up in bed, book in hands. It was nice to have company whilst waiting for your husband to arrive. Luna was laying on the bed next to you, her own hands occupied not by a book, but by one of those handheld gaming devices. Soon enough, the book was left lying forgotten on the nightstand as you leaned in closer to her to peer over her shoulder. It definitely beats reading a book, that much you could say.

“Does your husband have a habit of keeping mares waiting?” Luna asked suddenly, eyes not moving from her gaming device.

You opened your mouth to defend him, but was rendered speechless as you realized you couldn’t. You just gave her a non committal response. She rolled her eyes at that, focusing on her video game.

You heard the door knob turn, and you quickly nudged Luna on the shoulder to warn her. She got your message, and her horn lit up, and she teleported to a corner of the room.

The door swung open, and the stallion in question entered the room, looking no worse for wear. He looked tired, but he smiled when he caught sight of you. “Hey, Cady.”

You smiled in response, and you got off the bed and made your way over to him. “Hi, Shiny.” You greeted him before pulling him into a kiss. He returned it happily. Nothing too intimate.

“It’s our anniversary today…” you say as you wrapped your arms around your stud. You could feel him tensing up slightly.

“L-look, Cady,” he began. “I’m sorry, but, I, uh… didn’t exactly plan on doing anything today… but I’ll make it up to you, I promise!” he said, his voice full of regret.

You continued staring at him, feigning disappointment. He looked so cute when he was all flustered! Finally, you decided that he had had enough and you decided to cut the tension.

You smiled, and the gesture proved infectious as Shiny’s ramblings slowly came to a stop and he couldn’t help but smile too.

“That’s okay.” You amended. You held him close, and planted a loving kiss on those lips of his.

“I’ll make it up to you.” He began. “I promise.”

Your smile stretched a little wider upon hearing his words, and you decided that he was due for his surprise.

“Remember our last anniversary?” you asked in a low, sultry voice.

“Um… yes?” he replied unsurely.

“I knew it wasn’t easy for you, and I thought it was very sweet.” You whispered to him. His ear flicked in excitement. “And I thought I’d return the favor.”

His eyes widened at that, evident that he was very much surprised.

“Turn around, Shining.” You say, and he immediately does so, turning around on his heels as if he was doing a pirouette. You could see his entire form tensing and sweat beginning to bead on his forehead.

“P-Princess Luna?!” he blurted out in a mixture of astonishment and reverence. There, standing in the corner of the room, was Princess Luna herself, looking as radiant as ever. She was wearing nothing but a very skimpy two piece. Her bust was not too big, nor was it too small, but they were round and perky. Her panties hugged her ass so tightly that you could practically see the contours of her vagina. All in all, she looked like a succubus, a true femme fatale that no stallion could resist.

“Hello, Shining Armor.”

He shivered slightly, and he brought his head down to bow. Luna merely rolled her eyes at that, and a smirk etched itself on to her face.

“At ease.” She stated simply.

Shiny brought his head up again, albeit a little nervous. You had already discarded your robe, revealing your lacy black and white underwear, but Shining was still too shocked to notice. You decided to ease the tension a little.

Still standing behind him, you wrapped your arms around him gently, and began undoing his uniform with practised ease. Each button came undone in a light blue hue, and soon enough, he was laid completely bare. You could see him blushing under the gaze of the co-ruler of Equestria, but he kept his cool.

You looked down, and you could see his member was already rock hard, pre cum practically oozing from the tip. You lick your lips in anticipation for what was to come.

“W-wow…” he said in a quivering voice.

“Happy Anniversary, darling.” You purred into his ear.

He turned around, looking more excited but still a little nervous. “A-are you sure?” he said, his usual bravado long gone.

“Yes, Shining. I won’t hold it against you. Just for tonight. You can have both of us.” You reply lovingly as you wrapped his lips in a kiss.

You had planned a little with Luna before he had arrived, and you motioned for Luna to get in position with you. Both of you moved over to the king-sized bed, Shiny’s eyes tracking your every movement, and leaned over it, sticking your butts in the air. Both of you turned your heads around just a little, and fixed him with your most smoldering gazes, your eyes half lidded and your mouth fixed into a small welcoming smile.

“You can do whatever you want with us Shining, just for tonight.” You say seductively.

“And please don’t keep us waiting, dear Shining Armor, your princesses need you.” Chimed in Luna.

That was all the incentive he needed, and he moved closer. You could feel your body heating up with need, and you were sure you were more than a little moist down south. You wriggled your hips a little, and bent a little lower, intent on making your pert ass stick out even more. You swished your tail, wafting your scent over to him.

Luna, not one to be outdone, used her advantage of her fuller, rounder ass than yours. She closed her legs together, her ass jiggling enticingly with each movement of her legs. She arched her back like a cat, her underwear practically squeezing her form to contain her curves.

She smiled knowingly at you, and like you, she too swished her tail, making her arousal apparent.

You could see his nostrils flare, and his dick throbbed even more. He got behind the two of you, and your body shivered in anticipation. Who was he going to pick? You weren’t going to hold anything against him if he chose Luna, of course. It was your idea.

You saw him grab Luna’s ass, and she gave an adorable squeak. You smiled and you couldn’t help but giggle. You never thought the loud and overbearing princess could make such a sound.

You watched him as he moved his face closer to Luna’s nether region, his hands continued to grope and squeeze Luna’s behind. Clearly, he was enjoying himself, if that wide grin was anything to go by.

His face moved closer still, and he wrapped his fingers around her panties, and pulled it over Luna’s butt. His nostrils flared again as he was hit with the full blast of Luna’s scent.

“C’mon, Captain, don’t leave me waiting…” said Luna.

Shining practically buried his face in Luna’s hindquarters, and Luna moaned in approval. He began licking her faster and faster, and you couldn’t help but blush.

You were reminded of your own needs, as you felt your hand subconsciously moved downwards to tend to your own wet pussy. You slipped your hand past your panties, and began fingering yourself to the visual stimulation of your husband’s muzzle buried in Princess Luna’s muff.

You suddenly had an idea. While your husband was eating out one of your fellow princesses, you crawled up on the bed and placed yourself in front of Luna. You grabbed the edges of your already soaked panties, and pulled them down, revealing your pink puffy lips, already slick with arousal.

You sat in front of Luna, and spread your legs. Luna was moaning and groaning heavily now and you could tell that she was getting close to her peak.

You grabbed her horn, getting her attention, and guided her to your own cunt. She got the message, and she dove in with gusto. You purred approvingly at the act. Her tongue was sloppy, thanks to Shiny, but her enthusiasm more than made up for it. Her tongue went straight for your pussy, penetrating it and wriggling around like crazy. You moaned in lust, and one of your hands moved up to cup your breast.

Luna stopped, and you opened your eyes to see Luna whining in disappointment as you saw Shining remove his face from in between her ass cheeks. You see Shining lining up his member, using one of his hands to guide it in. Luna’s moans got louder and louder as Shining Armor penetrated her inch by inch.

“Ffffuuuck…” Luna drawled out slowly. “Your husband is huge, Cadance. You’re a very lucky mare…” she said in a husky voice.

You smiled knowingly. You’d never heard one of the other princesses swear before, and it was exciting to hear it. “Thanks. I know…” you cooed as you stroked her cheek.

“How is she, Shining?” you asked your hubby.

“Tight.” Shining said in between grunts.

“Tighter than me?” you asked teasingly.

“U-uh…” he stuttered, to which you merely giggled.

“Don’t worry about it, Shiny.”

He chuckled as he pushed the rest of his length into Luna. He groaned as he finally hilted inside her.

“How is he, Luna?” you ask the mare below you.

“I-I can feel him twitching… inside me… oh by the stars! It feels incredible! What are you waiting for? F-fuck me already!” she breathed impatiently. She punctuated her statement by wriggling her hips, and pushing back into him needily.

Shining pulled himself out slowly, leaving only the tip in, his veiny cock glistening in Luna’s juices, before ramming back in, her ass rippling from the impact.

Luna moaned, louder this time, as Shining repeated his motions with increasing velocity. His pelvis ramming into Luna again and again as Luna’s moans got louder and louder. You grabbed her horn again, as if reminding her that you were still here and also in need of attention. She dived into your muff again with renewed vigor, her tongue working in a frenzy.

You began panting under Luna’s ministrations, your tongue lolling out the side of your mouth as you started to lose yourself in the pleasurable sensations. Your hands began fondling your breasts, and tweaking your already hard nipples.

Your ears pick up the sound of Shiny’s heavy balls slapping into Luna again and again, slowly but surely building up to unleash his heavy load.

The pair of fucking ponies slowly reached their crescendo as you felt Luna’s tongue work got even messier, as she was practically drooling all over your cunt. Still, she did her best despite the haze of pleasure that she was in, kissing and sucking on your clit. You could see Shiny’s face tensing up, teeth barred and completely drenched in sweat as he continued to thrust into her.

He hilted into her suddenly, completely burying his length into her, and pushing her deep inside your own cunt. She practically screamed into your second pair of lips as Shining Armor came inside her. Spurt after spurt, he continued to unload his sticky white goo into her womb.

After what seemed like minutes, he finally stopped. He was breathless but had a goofy grin plastered all over his face. He left his length inside her for a while, relishing in his afterglow. Finally, he pulled out, and his seed seeped out of her abused vagina and on to the floor.

You were really turned on now. Having had to watch your husband fuck someone else, and the fact that you were denied release had attributed to that. Your pussy was absolutely drenched with your arousal and Luna’s saliva, and it was winking like crazy. You could feel the saliva pooling in your mouth and you couldn’t help but drool, and you’re blushing too.

You licked your lips again. You flipped Luna on to her back and leaned down, and came face to face with her spunk-filled pussy. You couldn’t help yourself. You wanted, no, needed to taste his essence. Without any hesitation, you used your mouth to suck, lick, and collect all of the sperm around Luna’s pussy, before diving into her cunt, using your tongue to collect as much of his white goo as you could. It was still warm.

“Holy fuck, Cadance.” You heard Shiny say in disbelief. You looked up to his stupefied expression. You also noticed that he was rock hard again, no doubt because of your little display. You swirled the mixture of Luna’s juices and Shiny’s cum with your tongue, savoring the taste, before greedily swallowing it all. Your eyes glazed over, and you hummed in contentment.

Suddenly, you felt Luna’s tongue running up your entrance and you moaned again, heavier and huskier this time. You were already close to the edge, so it didn’t take much for Luna to drive you over it.

She plunged into your depths once again, but with a little more control this time as she expertly moved her tongue in all the right places. You couldn’t have warned Luna of your impending climax even if you had wanted too, as you drenched her muzzle with your mare juices.

After being denied release for so long, it was one of the most intense orgasms you had ever experienced. Your face locked into a silent scream as you lost your voice. You felt Luna lapping at your cunny, and nibble your love button slightly to prolong your orgasm. Your body shuddered uncontrollably as your mind went blank.

When you finally came down from your high, you were completely breathless and panting like a dog. You laid there with Luna for a time, catching your breaths’. You propped yourself up, and saw Shiny’s still rock hard dick.

“Ready for round two, Love?” you asked on a low voice and a sultry grin.

He chuckled nervously, no doubt eyeing you a little warily. You grabbed Luna by the arm and got off the bed. You guided her lazily onto her knees in front of Shining, mirroring your own actions. You eyed your husband lustily from your position as you nuzzled his messy cock lovingly, before licking the tip.

His dick twitched. That seemed to have snapped Luna out of her mini trance as she gave Shining’s cock a lick too.

“My husband’s cock is a little dirty from the mess you made on it Luna. Would you help me clean it.” You asked in a sweet voice.

“Gladly.” You heard her pur.

So there you two were, on your knees, licking one of your fellow princess’s juices off your husband’s cock with the aforementioned princess. Your tongues covered each and every inch of Shiny’s throbbing dick, and your tongues would come in contact frequently as you both worked his member.

You brought your hand up, and wrapped it around the base of your husband’s cock, before pointing the tip towards Luna, Which she gratefully accepted it into her mouth.

She began suckling powerfully, using her tongue to lap at the underside of his cock. Meanwhile, you began masturbating him, running your hands up and down from his medial ring to the base with a firm but gentle grip.

“C’mon, Shiny.” You said in a playful voice. “Cum for you princess. Cum into her little mouth. Make her swallow your seed…”

That was all Shining could take as he grunted loudly, and unloaded more of his seed into Luna’s mouth. Luna’s cheeks soon puffed out due to the sheer volume. Seeing this, you took his dick out of her mouth and pointed it towards you while still jerking him off.

You opened your mouth, and let your tongue hang out of your mouth. “Aaaah…” you said cutely with a smile. Thick ropey strands of his cum landed on your face and mane, and you had to close one of your eyes. You caught some in your mouth.

He slowly died down, and the last few spurts drizzled lazily on to your boobs.

You turned to Luna, who was sporting a blush of her own, and brought her in for a kiss, your tongues dancing sloppily as you swapped each others’ seed in your mouths. When you broke apart, multiple strands of spittle and semen connected the two of you, and you were tempted to go in again.

You licked your lips, and you both swallow your respective shares.

You heard the bed creak, and you saw that Shiny had collapsed on to it. You led Luna to your shared bed, and she laid down, exhausted but happy.

Both of you took a place at either side of Shiny, snuggling up to his muscular frame. You used your magic to levitate the covers over everyone.

“Happy Anniversary, Shiny.” You said drowsily. In response to that, he planted a tender kiss on your forehead, right beneath your horn.

“I love you, Cady.” He said.

“I love you too, Shiny.” You said with a soft smile.

“Hey, what about me?” you heard a voice ask.

“And we love you too, Luna.” You said with a smirk.

“That was one of the best sex I’ve ever had. Could we do it again, sometime?” she asked.

Shiny turned to you as if asking the same thing, but you merely replied with, “I’ll think about it.”

All three of you fell asleep in each others’ embraces.

Author's Note

*Takes shelter in a buker*