A three way marriage.

by Kye Clifford

Rating: mature
Tags:
Length: 5302

Shining and his secret admirer form a bond...But Shining still loves Cadence. What happens when love is present to not only his wife but also admirer?

Cadence always glared at Shining whenever he looked at other mares, but she always knew there was no way for Shining to look at stallions because she wouldn't even think he was bisexual.

However, she was going to find out more about Shining when she finds him with another pony in bed.

Published 1970-01-01 00:00:00 UTC
Last updated 2014-04-03 20:20:01 UTC

A three way marriage.

Many ponies that have joined the royal guard are brave, mentally strong, adventurous ponies. This applies to every stallion and mare of the royal guard of every rank. One of these ponies was Shining Armour, the captain of the royal guard. Shining Armour possessed all three traits but he especially possessed the third. Shining Armour always looked for adventure and many times it sought him when he didn’t. However, being adventurous doesn’t apply to journeys only, it also applies to lifestyle just as much.

Shining isn’t any simple stallion. His life has been very wild and free, sometimes even so that Shining was embarrassed to speak about it. Many believed that Shining’s marriage would put an end to such a free lifestyle, but they were always wrong. However, it was something that Shining never wanted to confess to other’s as much as he’d love to. He feared that if he told others they could sell him out to his wife, Princess Cadence. Although Shining was indeed wild he wasn’t that wild to talk about his deepest secrets. He was honest, but he still knew which secrets to keep and which to reveal.

Shining wasn’t a pig, mind you. He didn’t spend time having sex with other mares, go to strip clubs, or get drunk whenever he possibly could, he was a much better stallion than that, and he perfectly knew not to do such things when in a happy relationship. So what deed could he have done that he didn’t dare speak about?

Was he cheating on Cadence with another mare!?

Not at all.

He was ‘cheating’ on Cadence with another stallion.

I bet you didn’t see that one coming.

So what does ‘cheating’ mean? Whatever ‘cheating’ Shining was doing wasn’t quite cheating exactly. You see, it was also a little bit accidental. Shining would never love another mare other than Cadence and that’s something he promised himself, thus he always controlled his ‘friendliness’ around mares. However, he got very comfortable around his stallion friends. Shining wouldn’t expect that any of the stallions around him were gay or bisexual, thus why.

However, once upon a night Shining was invited for dinner by one of his male friends to hang out. Shining thought it was just a regular friendly invitation for a few beers and a hoofball game. It seemed normal enough to him.

The place, to his surprise, was a restaurant. Perhaps his friend thought there was something nice to eat and drink there…Either way he was unsure.

His friend was sitting on a table for two. There were two wine glasses and a wine bottle. That was a little strange but Shining didn’t let that bother him too much.

The waiter arrived with their food. However it wasn’t some kind of snack food of any sorts like chips or food to go with cider, but the food was instead a set of some of the more expensive items on the menu, from starters to main courses. Shining felt a little odd, but all his friends were straight, so it wasn’t anything of concern.

No matter how long they were eating Shining still didn’t see any sort of TV. Maybe his friend just wanted to chat and maybe even felt lonely?

They chatted about various topics. Shining asked Caramel about work, family, friends, life, and all basic stuff. However, his friendseemed a little odd. He always talked about how great Shining was, how his life with Cadence is, how much he's lonely, and how much he thought Shining was pretty. But Shining still didn't find anything odd about it, his friend just liked to chat.

They ate, drank wine, and talked. They were sharing a moment with each other and Shining though it was just a little strange.

Until that stallion softly and shyly kissed Shining on the lips.

However, Shining wasn’t reluctant at all and kissed him in return. He just felt this stallion was such a great friend that he didn’t hesitate to return the kiss despite being already happily married. Nopony would expect him to kiss the stallion back but yet he did. That was because Shining was actually bi-curious before his marriage and kissed a hoof-full of stallions back in the day, yet he never got to sleep with any of them. The two stallions felt very close to each other ever since that night.

Shining made a little realization though. He didn’t cheat. Cheating is when his attention goes away to another pony, but in his case, he was still happy with Cadence. That was when Shining thought he made some sort of scientific discovery. He loved Cadence and she loved him, and the two have paid each other much attention. But when Shining wasn’t with Cadence, he had time to spend with his little coltfriend. Shining and the stallion have been dating each other oftentimes and Shining still felt love to Cadence as much as the stallion.

Shining went to Canterlot once for guard business, and he felt this was the perfect opportunity to invite his friend over. The stallions spent a lovely evening and it had resulted in something very special. Prior to that very day, the stallions were simply VERY close friends. But on that very day they became much closer. Their evening ended with Shining and that stallion cuddling in bed and falling asleep together, they felt each other’s breathing and each other’s warm embrace.  Shining was happy with the stallion and he was happy with Cadence, it was some kind of Polygamy Shining would never believe he’d see; and the stallion was happy with him.

So who was that stallion?...

“Good morning sleepyhead.” The light brown coated and darker brown mane coloured stallion said. It was Caramel. Caramel was in a relationship with a mare at some point, but she dumped him, causing his sexual orientation to change after the experience.

Shining was sleeping, but he was supposed to wake up early in the morning. Caramel put on the alarm clock and woke up to find Shining still sleeping, thus making it his duty to wake him up. “Come on honey, wake up~…” Caramel hummed and stroked Shining’s blue mane. Shining really liked his horn being touched and Caramel perfectly knew it. Caramel decided to lick Shining’s long, pointy horn. The sudden short, quick, wet lick caused Shining’s horn to release a spark and send a small, slightly orgasmic wave of euphoria and pleasure through Shining’s body. It caused him gently shiver, silently and gently gasp and open his eyes. As he opened his eyes he saw Caramel lying there with a cute smile and a string of saliva connecting his lips and Shining’s horn.

Shining had a blush on his face but soon a smile of his own came into existence. Shining stuck his tongue out and licked Caramel’s muzzle with it. Caramel giggled a little femininely and kissed Shining on the lips. Shining, although he was supposed to wake up at the time, still didn’t get up from bed and remained lying there with his coltfriend. Not that Caramel protested, but he was a little curious. “What about work?” Caramel silently whispered into his ear.

Shining released a short hearty chuckle. “Meeting’s cancelled. I still wanted you to wake me up so we could have a longer while together.” He said. His words were so kind and loving they caused Caramel’s cheeks to turn bright red. Shining still had the feeling that Caramel wasn’t replacing Cadence but was being his ‘other-lover’. Shining had to remind himself this almost every week. He wanted to see himself with Cadence in a happy marriage, but he too wanted to see Caramel with him as a coltfriend. Caramel was perfectly aware that Shining was married, and he was afraid he was somehow damaging it. When Caramel first kissed Shining he planned to run out of the restaurant, but Shining kissing him in return prevented him from doing so. Caramel really supported the marriage of the two and their happy family, but if Shining loved him likewise, what was there to stop him if Shining always insists it didn’t have any negative impact on their happy marriage?

“You’re so nice and cute.” Caramel mused and nuzzled Shining in the neck. Shining was a little ticklish, so it caused him to Shiver and his hind-legs to slightly clench. Shining began to silently laugh and hold Caramel close before he rolled Caramel on top of him. The two stallions laughing heartedly was followed by the two making silent, smiling eye contact. Shining sighed happily after relief from the tickling nuzzle and looked Caramel into his eyes, with Caramel looking into Shining’s.

“I’m really glad you finally took a short break from the crystal empire and came here. It’s not Ponyville, but its close-by.” Caramel said and licked Shining’s lips. Shining didn’t even hesitate to take the opportunity to see his lover for a sleep-over. Shining moved a stray strand of hair out of Caramel’s face so he could see his crystal clear blue eyes again.

“All I did was think of a poor excuse for the guards to have a meeting and then cancel it.” Shining said. This caused Caramel to gasp because Caramel assumed Shining wasn’t the one who organized the meeting. However it changed everything. It made him realize that Shining was ready to do the most silliest of things just to be with him and share a night in the same bed. Caramel, after a short pause, giggled.

However, his giggle was interrupted by Shining leaning in and trapping Caramel’s lower lip with his own lips. It was a sort of small, cute ‘kiss’. After a bashful blush, Caramel pulled Shining’s face into his and kissed him deeply. Shining wrapped his hooves around Caramel’s neck and pushed his tongue into the kiss. His tongue was running through Caramel’s mouth and covering it with his own saliva. Caramel, however, took charge and pushed his tongue down Shining’s throat. It made Shining gasp and blush, not expecting Caramel to take such charge. Caramel’s tongue wasn’t long but it managed to fill Shining’s mouth somewhat. Shining allowed Caramel to take over him and kiss him all he wanted. Shining made another realization; he enjoyed being ‘used’. By that he doesn’t mean used for money, as a sex toy, but Shining loved when ponies did their magic on him while Shining didn’t or couldn’t do anything. It was something he personally took a liking in.

Shining was a very soft, tender, loving stallion when it comes to romance and love, despite being a brave, tough pony when it comes to doing his captain duties. However, he wasn’t very ‘assertive’ when it came to relationships. He always preferred to allow the pony he loved to make decisions more than he did. It sort of made him a somewhat subordinate stallion but neither he nor Cadence nor Caramel paid it any negative mind.

Cadence was a subordinate or a dominative mare depending on her partner. After all, if she was an Alicorn that had the ability to make ponies love each other she had to be able to understand many different ways that love works in a relationship. However, Cadence was a little bit afraid to experiment at times fearing that if an experiment goes too far it risks a relationship. Shining said many times that he doesn’t mind any experimentation and rather enjoys it. Cadence was trying to do various things in bed with Shining, and other relationship experiments, but even she admitted it wasn’t much. Shining’s and Cadence’s bed experiences only went as far as having sex with the lights on while not being covered in sheets. However, Cadence said that she knows somepony that could help her widen her ‘experience’ and experimentation. Shining never knew much about ‘experimentation’ but he had a very imaginative mind, so he always thought of things to do even if they weren’t already attempted by many ponies. Shining, however, was too embarrassed to reveal them to anypony, so he just hoped at some point his experimentation with Cadence could reach a very high point so that Shining could attempt some of those ideas for experiments he had. And now that Shining also has Caramel with him, he hoped that he could also try some ‘experimental’ things with him. But Shining still wasn’t sure about one thing; Was Caramel a virgin? Shining wasn’t, as he lost his virginity to Cadence before marriage.

Shining noticed that Caramel was and looking away as if there was something he wanted to say. Without a word, Shining booped his muzzle with his hoof and tilted his head. Caramel smiled and blushed before his eyes fell back on Shining. “You know…We’ve been together for a long time, and it’s not everyday Cadence is busy while you’re here…” He said bashfully with a tiny smile. His words were very suggestive to Shining, but Shining still wasn’t sure what it was exactly that Caramel wanted. “I had a marefriend once but we only went as far as kissing…I really wanted to…you know…do the thing lovers do in bed.” Caramel said shyly. It didn’t take long for Shining to realize where he was going at.

“Well…I…didn’t do it with stallions…But we could try…” Shining said just as silently as Caramel. “But…Caramel, honey…Could I ask you something…?” Shining asked as if his question was about to be intimate.

Caramel tilted his head in question and nodded.

“I really did a lot of…’casual’ sex with Cadence and I really wanted to try out some…fetishes.” Shining said, causing Caramel to gently gasp. “W-What are some of your…you know…fetishes?”  Shining asked.

Caramel blushed at this question and licked his lips. “Well, I never had sex, but I really find cock and ball worship sexy…I really like collars and leashes…also crossdressing…and I like to use toys…but uhm…most of all…I may not look like it, but I really like to dominate.” He silently said. “What about you…?” He asked.

This caused Shining’s eyes to brighten up in hope. He liked being a sub and the fetishes Caramel listed were quite also to his liking. “Well…I like all of yours…but also I like being dominated instead of dominating.” He cooed shyly. “Also I like getting big things up my butt and I want to try drinking…well…semen.” He awkwardly said.

Both stallions felt ‘something poking their pokers’. Their cocks were frotting as they had both become erect. Shining blushed and took the covers off… he was surprised. Whereas Shining had a nine inch cock, Caramel had a twelve inch one! Shortly it made Shining realize that it made him much more aroused rather than make him jealous or unhappy. Caramel awkwardly gasped in fear that the notable advantage of his cock’s size over Shining’s could have saddened him or damaged Shining’s ego. “I-I’m so sorry Shining…I-I didn’t know…” Caramel said awkwardly. He couldn’t prevent his cock being bigger than Shining’s, but he still felt he needed to apologize

“Can I call you ‘sir’…?” Shining whispered into Caramel’s ear and gave it a quick lick. He found his own hooves caressing each other’s penises. Caramel remembered that Shining liked to be dominated, so he smiled lustfully and mischievously.

“You will only call me sir, my little bitch.” Caramel rawred after he had the courage to become dominate on his soft, tender lover. Shining gasped but nevertheless he loved that. Caramel put on his most lusty look and looked Shining deep in the eyes. Caramel had never had any experience but he had read a lot of erotica and seen much pornography in his life, so he had some knowledge on what to do during sex. He climbed up so he sat sitting on Shining’s chest, his large member was resting on Shining’s muzzle. Shining looked at the tip that was in-between his eyes, causing him to cross his eyes cutely.

Without hesitating Shining gave the shaft a long juicy, lengthy lick and adjusted himself so that the tip was on his lips. He licked the tip and tasted a little bit of Caramel’s pre-cum. However, before allowing Shining to coat Caramel’s cock with his saliva Caramel got up from bed and looked around. “Wait, do you know where we could get some toys and mare clothes!?” Caramel asked in sheepish excitement. He did say he liked to use toys and was into cross dressing, which is why Shining didn’t ask what for. Shining thought for a second and remembered that one of the maids in the castle was rumored to masturbate during breaks with various toys. It was that maid’s day off. If Shining was right, not only there were some of the mare’s toys, but also her outfit.

“When you leave the room go to the third bedroom to your right!” Shining exclaimed with excitement. Without hesitating Caramel ran out of the room like crazy and into the mare’s bedroom. The bedrooms weren’t locked since the princesses considered there really wasn’t any point putting locks on any doors asides from those that held valuables. Even the private chambers of the princesses didn’t have a lock. Caramel ran in and was lucky enough not to be seen by anypony. He looked around the bedroom and locked his eyes on the wardrobe. He opened it to find not only a maid’s outfit, but also white-and-black stripped stockings. Caramel looked around to find a small chest suspiciously well-hidden. He cracked it open to find a treasure chest of a porn-pirate. Inside were various toys such as dildos, vibrators, leashes and collars! Caramel took the box and carried the outfit back into Shining’s bedroom. As Shining saw Caramel  run back in his eyes began to sparkle in excitement.

“Sir, can I put my new outfit on, pleeease?~” Shining moaned lewdly. Caramel softly smirked and nodded before Shining levitated the outfit from Caramel and put it on. First Shining put the stockings and the maid outfit. The outfit was a little small and tight, but it was only more arousing for Caramel to see and Shining to feel. Caramel opened the chest and looked inside. Without a word Caramel threw a leash and collar on the bed that Shining didn’t hesitate to put on. He tightened the collar around his neck and attached the leash to it. Caramel looked at the toys and decided to use them later.

Caramel jumped back in bed causing the bed to emit a gentle crack due to the sudden weight. Probably one of the wooden supports fell. However neither of the two ponies paid it any mind. Caramel slowly pushed his tongue deep into Shining’s mouth while rubbing his balls with his hoof sensually. Shining decided to please Caramel by massaging his flanks rougly, mushing them together and spreading them apart. However, Caramel pulled out and smirked.

“Oh? You’re the one to touch my ass? ~” Caramel purred and smirked suggestively. He took hold of the leash and tugged it so that it was pulling Shining by his side, gesturing Shining to roll over. Shining obeyed and lied down on his belly. Caramel ran his hoof on Shining’s flank before groping it so hard it was painful, yet pleasing. Shining yelped and gasped. Caramel pulled the collar causing Shining to hang his head back so that it wouldn’t choke him.  Caramel ran his both of his hooves and mushed them hard against each other, massaging  them and kneading them. Cadence had never done any like that to Shining, so a flank massage was something alien yet pleasing for him. Caramel leaned in to give Shining’s anus a quick lick. Since Shining never felt anything make contact with his anus ever it caused his to silently gasp, making him sound like a girl. Caramel leaned in to grab wrap his hooves around Shining’s chest, pull him up and place him back on the bed on his back. Caramel got up on his hind-legs and spread him, his testicles and cock were hanging just above his face before he squatted down. He squatted down so that his balls were resting on his mouth. Shining opened them and took Caramel’s musky balls into his mouth. Shining began fondling them with his tongue causing Caramel to shiver. Caramel didn’t take his time and raised himself up and squatted back down, but this time his cock going straight down his mouth. Shining took all twelve inches of it deep down his throat, covering it in saliva. Caramel got up after that and sat down on a pillow, his balls and cock resting on it while his back was against the wall, sitting there with his legs spread.

Shining leaned in and opened his mouth before Caramel’s meaty cock was in his mouth once again. Caramel put a hoof on the back of Shining’s head and pushed his head in.  Shining pulled back began bobbing his head back and forth. Shining looked up at Caramel and silently moaned. He felt something warm and sticky leak out of it and identified it as Caramel’s pre-cum. Caramel was looking down at Shining with a smile and stroked Shining’s mane while he was being sucked off. Caramel was in ecstasy and felt his cock throbbing in Shining’s throat. Caramel put both of his hooves on Shining’s head and took control of Shining’s movement. Instead of Shining moving back in forth, it was Caramel moving his head.

“Well well~!” A female voice said that Shining recognized instantly; It was Cadence. Caramel look at the door frame which Cadence was leaning on with her forehooves crossed. Caramel gasped and attempted to jump out of the bed…But however, his hooves remained on Shining’s head due to Cadence’s magic that kept it in place. Cadence entered the room and began to circle the bed. Shining’s throat was gagged with Caramel’s cock, not giving him a chance to speak.

Caramel’s eyes were looking everywhere in panic “M-Miss Cadence!!! T-This isn’t what it looks like! I-I swear I was just sitting and Shining fell on m-my…” Caramel sighed, it was too obvious on what was happening. Cadence’s husband was fellating another stallion, how else could it be ‘explained’ as an accident.

“Oh, Oh! It’s so rich.” She purred deviously and approached Shining. Shining’s eyes were pathetically looking at Cadence. “Oh, honey did you really think that an Alicorn such as I didn’t notice my lover loving another pony?” Cadence whispered into Shining’s ear.

“M-Miss Cadence, please, don’t hurt him! It’s my fault, I-I kissed him first back in the restaurant…” Caramel winced and bit his lips.

“Well, Caramel, that’s something I already knew~! But I won’t hurt him, no…because you see…” Cadence stroked Caramel’s mane and looked back at her husband. “If my special somepony ever removes me from their heart, I would feel a painful nudge of negative magic in my soul. But however, I didn't, and yet, here you two are. But I still feel love from him directed to you and vice versa.” She said. “Am I mad? Not at all. If I wasn’t the mare I was I wouldn’t support polygamy, would I?” She asked as she knelled down by the bed and took a closer look at Shining who was currently stuck with his other lover’s cock. “It’s a little heartwarming to me, even so I would love to see more…” Cadence purred and her eyes sparkled. “NO!...I wouldn’t love to see more…”

“I would love to participate in it.” Cadence purred and removed a stray strand of hair from Shining’s face.  Caramel and Shining looked at the Alicorn with widened eyes, both of them rather shocked. Cadence released Caramel’s hooves and they still remained on Shining’s head. “Keep them there for a little bit.” Cadence looked at the chest and smiled, she had found something Caramel did not; a strap-on. Caramel mistook it for a dildo. She levitated it out of the chest. It was a pink, 13 inch rubber dildo on a black harness. Caramel was in shock from seeing the large strap-on and Shining was shocked to see Caramel shocked, because Shining didn’t see what it was that Cadence had found and he couldn’t ask Caramel what he saw. Cadence put it on and got up on her hind-legs. She put her hooves on her hips and stood triumphantly.  “How do I look, Cammy?~” Cadence asked. Caramel was a little shocked.

“Y-You look great Mrs. Cadence…” Caramel silently spoke. Cadence slowly approached the bed and levitated a bottle of lubricant, applying it on in the strap-on. She stroked it with her hoof slowly to spread the lubricant.

“I spoke with Twilight, and she gave me a whole book of how to ‘experiment’. I guess now we’ll see how much I have learned.” She said and mounted Shining. Shining felt something prod against his tight anus and he perfectly knew what it was. His own wife was about to fuck him in the butt. “Fuck his mouth well, honey.” She told Caramel. Caramel hesitantly nodded once and began thrusting his hips and moving Shining’s head. Cadence slowly but steadily pushed the strap-on into Shining. Shining had tried to stimulate himself anally a few times with magic, but this time he had a large strap-on enter his ass. He squirmed and clenched his ass-cheeks. Cadence was pleasing herself with vibrating magic while she fucked her husband. Caramel looked down at Shining and shrugged . Caramel wanted to enjoy himself, since Cadence had nothing against it.

Cadence slowly put her hooves on Shining’s shoulders and massaged them. Slowly began to thrust into Shining, to make sure Shining got used to it and the feeling wasn’t exactly painful.

Shining could feel pleasure from Cadence’s fucking, a tingling sensation in his cock made itself present. He never expected that he’d ever feel orgasmic pleasure from anal stimulation, but he wouldn’t lie if he said he loved it.

Cadence’s thrusts were getting faster, thus rougher and  more aggressive. But she knew Shining enjoyed it, there was no denying it. She knew his husband was an experimental lad and anything alien and new to him was certainly something he’d enjoy. All 13 inches were embedded deeply inside of Shining. Shining was moaning while sucking off Caramel. Shining, from all the anal stimulation, felt his cock throb and twitch, his balls slowly expanding in size due to his semen building up. Caramel likewise began to shuffle a little; indicating that he would be ready to blow anytime soon.  Meanwhile, since Cadence was an Alicorn of love, she could actually feel the two stallions were building their own pleasure up. Just for the purpose of a synchronized ejaculation she used her magic to stimulate herself faster and better. That caused her to moan into Shining’s ear that aroused Shining even furthermore.

With a final thrust from Cadence, she had her orgasm. The two stallions had ejaculated almost at the same time. Caramel came deep into Shining’s throat while Shining came into a magical cup that was made by Cadence. Caramel was panting, himself sweating and his balls musky as ever.

Shining wondered what the deal behind the cup was, until Cadence lifted his head back with magic and moved the cup to his lips. She tilted the cup and allowed it to flow down his throat. Shining felt it as salty and potent. He blushed and moaned deeply while drinking it all.

“Fucking sluts, I’ll lock use you like toys for a few days~. That’s what you’ll get for not telling me about your relationship earlier.” Cadence said with a devious tone to her voice. Caramel and Shining gulped at unison. Cadence wasn’t mad but she thought for the sake of their new ‘three-way-relationship’ she should try out some new things. With that Caramel and Shining were peacefully knocked unconscious by a magical spell.

***

Shining woke up with a stinging and a sore pain haunting his rear, a nagging taste of semen in his mouth, and the sound of moans and gasps revolving around his ears. However he couldn’t see anything, instantly assuming that he was blindfolded. He tried to gasp but air only came through his nose. He was gagged with a ball gag. He attempted to use his magic but it wouldn’t work, it was disarmed with a ring. He finally attempted to move around but his hooves were suspended in the air by magic.

Soon enough he was able to see again as the blindfold was levitated off of his eyes. He was in Cadence’s chambers in Canterlot castle. Cadence proudly stood there with a smirk, wearing a black corset and fishnets. Shining gulped, it was the only thing he could do. “Well well, my bitch husband…Tied up and used like a slut~.” She winked at him. “Now, don’t think this is some kind of forceful punishment. This is roleplay, of-course. However, just because its roleplay doesn’t mean I can’t punish you for not telling me about your affair with Carry~.” She said. A stinging, powerful force suddenly smacked Shining’s flanks with a ‘loud ‘Crack!’; Cadence whipped him with a rather long whip.  Shining squeaked from the sudden surge of pain that went through his body and his eyes began to tear up a little.

Cadence smiled and walked away for a bit. Shining looked where Cadence went and gasped. A group of royal guards was fucking a bound and blindfolded Caramel. Unlike Shining, Caramel was tied with his hooves spread on the ground, not suspended in the air. One guard fucked him into the mouth, and two double-penetrated his ass. Shining already knew why there was a taste of semen in his mouth and the sore pain in his ass. The guards all came into Caramel and pulled out. They all thanked Cadence for allowing them to use her bitch husband. Caramel panted and soon enough Cadence levitated Caramel’s blindfold and Shining’s gag away. Caramel panted and looked up at Cadence who towered above him. He looked at the Alicorn and whimpered at the dominatrix standing tall above him. She smiled and put a hoof on his lips. Caramel, knowing what the gesture was, licked the hoof. Cadence chuckled and pulled her hoof away and turned her head to Shining, and then to Caramel.

“Now, my little sluts. Let’s play a little game. There is no way to win, and there’s no way to lose. But there are ways to get penalized heavily.” She winked and unbound the two and levitated them on the bed. She tied the two together with rope so that their cocks were frotting. She slid in one vibrating buttplug each into the stallion, and tied their heads together so that they were forced into a kiss they couldn’t pull away from. Last but not least she made sure to tie their hind-legs together. Their cocks and balls were touching and their asses were receiving vibrating stimulation.

“Whoever cums overnight is going to get punished tomorrow morning. The more cum, the more punishment.” She purred, as if she perfectly knew that one of them would cum. She lied down with them and moved in to spoon with Shining. Shining moaned out, unable to speak as he was still forced in that long kiss. Shining and Caramel whimpered, looking at each other while Cadence fell asleep.

It was a start of a new kind of romance, one neither Shining, nor Caramel, nor Cadence expected. Two stallions and a mare who loved each other. Cadence would have to get to know Caramel a little more the morning after…

After the punishment he’d receive with Shining due to the dirtied, white stained sheets.

And perhaps Caramel would have to somehow be included into the marriage. As an Alicorn of love Cadence is going to have to find one creative idea for a three-way marriage.